The Argument For Helfrich

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: The Argument For Helfrich

Post by SuperDuck »

nogerO wrote:And what do you suppose MH's record would be if he hadn't inherited one Marcus Mariota? Guy is not too bright.

What would you say it would have been last year if Vernon Adams hadn't gotten hurt? The system still works as long as there's a capable QB plugged in, though Mariota was special.
John 3:36
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: The Argument For Helfrich

Post by SuperDuck »

nogerO wrote:And what do you suppose MH's record would be if he hadn't inherited one Marcus Mariota? Guy is not too bright.

Who's not too bright?

Actually, it was Helfrich who discovered Mariota in the first place, asked Chip to take a look at him and convinced him to give him a scholarship.
John 3:36
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: The Argument For Helfrich

Post by buckmarkduck »

And what if Kelly had to roll with Bennett instead of inheriting Thomas at the last minute? I can promise you with BB, we never play in a title game.
User avatar
lukeyrid13
All-American
Posts: 10475
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
GM: Portland TrailBlazers

Re: The Argument For Helfrich

Post by lukeyrid13 »

I think the fact that we are in season four with Helf and have more questions than answers is telling.
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: The Argument For Helfrich

Post by SuperDuck »

buckmarkduck wrote:And what if Kelly had to roll with Bennett instead of inheriting Thomas at the last minute? I can promise you with BB, we never play in a title game.
Agreed.
John 3:36
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: The Argument For Helfrich

Post by SuperDuck »

lukeyrid13 wrote:I think the fact that we are in season four with Helf and have more questions than answers is telling.
I agree. Still, he only lost 4 games, won the Alamo Bowl and went to the NCG in his first two seasons. He lost 4 games last year due to VAs injuries and poor QB recruiting and development, which IS on him and Scott Frost. However, they're not the first coaches to ever whiff on recruits. I can assure everyone that it won't be the last time either. I think it was Rob Moseley that said only around 50% of recruits ever really pan out in college.

One thing I can give Helf kudos for is recognizing the problem, bringing in VA last year and Prukop this year as temporary fixes, and recruiting more QBs. Now, if the next set of QB recruits all suck, then I'll start to question the staff, too, but until then I just don't see the point.

The Ducks are in rebuilding mode this year and next. I know that everyone has high hopes, and they may just have a great season, but they're still very young and next year they'll have a new QB again.

My only point has been that Oregon is not going to the playoffs every year and they're not going to with the conference every year. It's just a fact and to expect it is completely unrealistic.
John 3:36
User avatar
fpsduck
Senior
Posts: 2862
Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 11:10 am

Re: The Argument For Helfrich

Post by fpsduck »

lukeyrid13 wrote:I think the fact that we are in season four with Helf and have more questions than answers is telling.
^This
User avatar
UofDuck
Senior
Posts: 3976
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:51 pm

The Argument For Helfrich

Post by UofDuck »

lukeyrid13 wrote:I think the fact that we are in season four with Helf and have more questions than answers is telling.
. Not to be flippant, but what are the questions? Program is so much cleaner with Helf vs the Bellotti years. We have been averaging 10 wins a year. This is Helf's first HC job. There is a lot to learn. But it is widely recognized that he is very, very smart. He'll improve and learn and he runs a tight ship.

Regarding the penalty issue, the vaunted and seemingly mild mannered Chris Peterson (very much like Helf in mannerism) was the king of BSU teams that played borderline dirty and were heavily penalized. It's the price of playing to the whistle. Like someone else said, a mean streak comes at a cost. Jake Fisher was a prime example of that. As was Long. The guys will figure it out.

If Herbert is legit, I think Helf and Hoke will get this team back to the playoffs next year. Our D is rapidly improving and that loss yesterday pails in comparison to the AZ loss in 14.
User avatar
FlDuckFan
All Pac-12
Posts: 5068
Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:45 am
GM: Orlando Magic GM
Location: Florida

Re: The Argument For Helfrich

Post by FlDuckFan »

UofDuck wrote:
lukeyrid13 wrote:I think the fact that we are in season four with Helf and have more questions than answers is telling.
. Not to be flippant, but what are the questions? Program is so much cleaner with Helf vs the Bellotti years. We have been averaging 10 wins a year. This is Helf's first HC job. There is a lot to learn. But it is widely recognized that he is very, very smart. He'll improve and learn and he runs a tight ship.

Regarding the penalty issue, the vaunted and seemingly mild mannered Chris Peterson (very much like Helf in mannerism) was the king of BSU teams that played borderline dirty and were heavily penalized. It's the price of playing to the whistle. Like someone else said, a mean streak comes at a cost. Jake Fisher was a prime example of that. As was Long. The guys will figure it out.

If Herbert is legit, I think Helf and Hoke will get this team back to the playoffs next year. Our D is rapidly improving and that loss yesterday pails in comparison to the AZ loss in 14.
+1 The thing I'm most scared of is Hoke leaving after 2 years, that would kill our defense for years. I'm solid on Helfrich, there's always going to be questions for any Coach even Bama fans question Saban at times.
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: The Argument For Helfrich

Post by SuperDuck »

FlDuckFan wrote:
UofDuck wrote:
lukeyrid13 wrote:I think the fact that we are in season four with Helf and have more questions than answers is telling.
. Not to be flippant, but what are the questions? Program is so much cleaner with Helf vs the Bellotti years. We have been averaging 10 wins a year. This is Helf's first HC job. There is a lot to learn. But it is widely recognized that he is very, very smart. He'll improve and learn and he runs a tight ship.

Regarding the penalty issue, the vaunted and seemingly mild mannered Chris Peterson (very much like Helf in mannerism) was the king of BSU teams that played borderline dirty and were heavily penalized. It's the price of playing to the whistle. Like someone else said, a mean streak comes at a cost. Jake Fisher was a prime example of that. As was Long. The guys will figure it out.

If Herbert is legit, I think Helf and Hoke will get this team back to the playoffs next year. Our D is rapidly improving and that loss yesterday pails in comparison to the AZ loss in 14.
+1 The thing I'm most scared of is Hoke leaving after 2 years, that would kill our defense for years. I'm solid on Helfrich, there's always going to be questions for any Coach even Bama fans question Saban at times.
I'm not sure about that. I thought the same thing at first, but after giving it some thought, I think we'd be okay, depending on who we brought in to replace him.

Hoke is an excellent recruiter and if we can have him on staff for at least 2-3 recruiting classes there's a strong chance that our defense could be loaded with talent, if and when he chooses to leave. Then it would be much more enticing for another proven defensive coordinator to come on board, because the cupboard would be full and they wouldn't be inheriting a rebuilding job.
John 3:36
maxduck
Senior
Posts: 3763
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:37 pm

Re: The Argument For Helfrich

Post by maxduck »

+1 The thing I'm most scared of is Hoke leaving after 2 years, that would kill our defense for years. I'm solid on Helfrich, there's always going to be questions for any Coach even Bama fans question Saban at times.[/quote]

Hoke is in his late 50's. Probably wouldn't be hired by a Power 5 program, is a lower division HC job that much better than a coordinator position at Oregon at his age?
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6490
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: The Argument For Helfrich

Post by pezsez1 »

I also take issue with the comment about "how can he be the guy if there are already so many questions?"

Helfrich has provided more answers than questions.

He has won nearly as many games as Chip Kelly during roughly the same time period, and -- like Chip -- also took us to a national championship game.

He plugged holes at the QB position that almost always occur on teams with tenured, Heisman-caliber quarterbacks... by bringing in VA and Prukop, we've remained contenders for the conference/national championships in what would have otherwise been big-time rebuilding years.

- And, to build on the above point... Helfrich was a trendsetter here! That's right, he didn't walk in anyone else's footsteps... he went out and solved the effing problem.

Helfrich has proven his ability to find good QBs. He found Mariota, he recognized VA's skillset, and then he got Prukop... and next year, we'll probably be hailing Herbert as our next great QB.

He made the necessary coaching changes while keeping intact what makes Oregon a special program.

- And, to add on the above point, anyone who thinks Chip Kelly wouldn't have bowed to Phil Knight's wishes needs to take off their visors and come to their senses. Nobody in the history of Oregon athletics has been, and may ever be, as important as Phil Knight. Chip Kelly is just a dude. Phil Knight built the planet he coached on. Long after Chip and Uncle Phil are dead and gone, the University will probably still get regular donations from some kind of Knight family trust.

Helfrich recruits quality players. No Colts or Cliff Harris types.

No coach is ever perfect. Chip wasn't perfect. Chip landed us in trouble with the NCAA, got us sanctioned and hamstrung our recruiting (and we're just NOW finally out from those sanctions). Chip was incredibly stubborn, and his playcalling cost us a very winnable national championship as well as a berth to the natty a year later. Chip also took some crazy risks with the football. Go ahead and scream about Helfrich over 2-pt conversions... I'll raise you Chip Kelly refusing to kick field goals even when we were way ahead in games, thus taking away valuable reps that could have given Maldonado more confidence in big moments.

I loved Chip -- most Oregon fans did -- but we're fortunate to have Helfrich. He has already beaten all the other coaches in the Pac-12. He is putting together a great recruiting class (again). He totally restocked the QB cupboard. He saved us from having to endure a true down year. He took us to a natty already, and has us poised to be playoff contenders for at least the next few years. And he has done this while bringing in quality guys, keeping his nose clean, setting an example and not putting the program in danger.

He's also done this despite the immense pressure of following Chip Kelly -- a time when fanbase expectations are unreasonably (and sometimes hilariously) high.

I know everyone wants a national championship, but firing a quality guy who has already proven he can take us there isn't the way to get it done.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
Surging Chaos
One Star Recruit
Posts: 17
Joined: Sun Jun 26, 2016 12:13 am
Location: Happy Valley, OR

Re: The Argument For Helfrich

Post by Surging Chaos »

Yeah Chip's stubbornness was a big weakness of his. He had no plan B when he was up against NFL-caliber D-lines (2010 Rose Bowl, 2011 Natty, LSU). Just run the ball into the teeth of future first-round draft picks and hope for the best.

Also another thing I should bring up is that during Chip's reign the Pac-12 was a down conference. The only team we had to worry about was Stanford. USC was hammered with sanctions. Wazzu, Colorado, and others were bottom-feeders. ASU/UCLA/Uw were stuck with bad coaches. Those teams were easy to blow out. Once the TV money started to come in for 2012 the Pac-12 got really good really fast. Suddenly all the "bad" programs were able to afford to make big-name hires, build new shiny facilities and stadiums.
User avatar
jBeavertonduck
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 187
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:34 pm

Re: The Argument For Helfrich

Post by jBeavertonduck »

pezsez1 wrote:I also take issue with the comment about "how can he be the guy if there are already so many questions?"

Helfrich has provided more answers than questions.

He has won nearly as many games as Chip Kelly during roughly the same time period, and -- like Chip -- also took us to a national championship game.

He plugged holes at the QB position that almost always occur on teams with tenured, Heisman-caliber quarterbacks... by bringing in VA and Prukop, we've remained contenders for the conference/national championships in what would have otherwise been big-time rebuilding years.

- And, to build on the above point... Helfrich was a trendsetter here! That's right, he didn't walk in anyone else's footsteps... he went out and solved the effing problem.

Helfrich has proven his ability to find good QBs. He found Mariota, he recognized VA's skillset, and then he got Prukop... and next year, we'll probably be hailing Herbert as our next great QB.

He made the necessary coaching changes while keeping intact what makes Oregon a special program.

- And, to add on the above point, anyone who thinks Chip Kelly wouldn't have bowed to Phil Knight's wishes needs to take off their visors and come to their senses. Nobody in the history of Oregon athletics has been, and may ever be, as important as Phil Knight. Chip Kelly is just a dude. Phil Knight built the planet he coached on. Long after Chip and Uncle Phil are dead and gone, the University will probably still get regular donations from some kind of Knight family trust.

Helfrich recruits quality players. No Colts or Cliff Harris types.

No coach is ever perfect. Chip wasn't perfect. Chip landed us in trouble with the NCAA, got us sanctioned and hamstrung our recruiting (and we're just NOW finally out from those sanctions). Chip was incredibly stubborn, and his playcalling cost us a very winnable national championship as well as a berth to the natty a year later. Chip also took some crazy risks with the football. Go ahead and scream about Helfrich over 2-pt conversions... I'll raise you Chip Kelly refusing to kick field goals even when we were way ahead in games, thus taking away valuable reps that could have given Maldonado more confidence in big moments.

I loved Chip -- most Oregon fans did -- but we're fortunate to have Helfrich. He has already beaten all the other coaches in the Pac-12. He is putting together a great recruiting class (again). He totally restocked the QB cupboard. He saved us from having to endure a true down year. He took us to a natty already, and has us poised to be playoff contenders for at least the next few years. And he has done this while bringing in quality guys, keeping his nose clean, setting an example and not putting the program in danger.

He's also done this despite the immense pressure of following Chip Kelly -- a time when fanbase expectations are unreasonably (and sometimes hilariously) high.

I know everyone wants a national championship, but firing a quality guy who has already proven he can take us there isn't the way to get it done.

This
QuackAttack92
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 328
Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2016 9:01 pm

Re: The Argument For Helfrich

Post by QuackAttack92 »

I can see the argument both ways...honestly the best option is to let the season play out...there's no reason we shouldn't win double digit games with our talent

Another 9-3 season or worse without a conference championship game appearance and Helf should get the ax
"F***** score points. What's your plan?"- Chipper
Post Reply