After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
- DAT_man_again
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1569
- Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 7:26 pm
After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?
Okay, I don't want this to sound like I'm throwing in the towel on this season, because I'm totally not. I still think we will contend for a PAC 12 title. However, this Saturday we are going to start 5 freshman on the offensive line.
Next year, we are going to return all five starters obviously, and at running back, we will return TBJ, Taj and Kani Benoit. At wideout we will have Nelson, Mitchell and Allen. Tight end Mundt. We will still be loaded at the skill positions is what I'm saying.
We could have a chance to be a top five team next year as we return the ENTIRE defense pretty much, and the entire offensive line and a loaded running back corps. Do we really want to be breaking in a new QB yet again when we could very well have a chance to make a playoff run?
I don't think it is throwing the towel this season to start Herbert. Based on what we've seen from Prukop, we are gonna have at least one more loss anyway. Is it negligent for the coaches to NOT start Herbert, whom is getting almost as much behind-the-scenes hype as Marcus was? Especially since we already burned his redshirt.
The coaches are smarter than I am, but could someone explain the benefit of still starting Prukop?
Next year, we are going to return all five starters obviously, and at running back, we will return TBJ, Taj and Kani Benoit. At wideout we will have Nelson, Mitchell and Allen. Tight end Mundt. We will still be loaded at the skill positions is what I'm saying.
We could have a chance to be a top five team next year as we return the ENTIRE defense pretty much, and the entire offensive line and a loaded running back corps. Do we really want to be breaking in a new QB yet again when we could very well have a chance to make a playoff run?
I don't think it is throwing the towel this season to start Herbert. Based on what we've seen from Prukop, we are gonna have at least one more loss anyway. Is it negligent for the coaches to NOT start Herbert, whom is getting almost as much behind-the-scenes hype as Marcus was? Especially since we already burned his redshirt.
The coaches are smarter than I am, but could someone explain the benefit of still starting Prukop?
"You know we the big brother." - Cliff Harris
"Y'all know what time it is." -Damian Lillard
"Y'all know what time it is." -Damian Lillard
-
lmduck
Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?
DAT Man- do you really think Allen comes back next year? I think it is highly doubtful and Nelson may declare for the draft and Mundt is gone after this year as well. Baylis, Mundt and Brown are done. Not saying Nelson declaring for the draft is a good or bad idea just saying that I would not be surprised to see him do that.
Depending how the DUCKS end this year which has a long way to go, them being considered a Top 5 team next year is questionable.
Depending how the DUCKS end this year which has a long way to go, them being considered a Top 5 team next year is questionable.
- DAT_man_again
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1569
- Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 7:26 pm
Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?
Until Allen says otherwise, yes, I think he comes back next year.lmduck wrote:DAT Man- do you really think Allen comes back next year? I think it is highly doubtful and Nelson may declare for the draft and Mundt is gone after this year as well. Baylis, Mundt and Brown are done. Not saying Nelson declaring for the draft is a good or bad idea just saying that I would not be surprised to see him do that.
Depending how the DUCKS end this year which has a long way to go, them being considered a Top 5 team next year is questionable.
Nelson won't declare. If he does it is foolish. I didn't realize Mundt was a senior. That sucks, but we are still going to be loaded at RB, and have some young studs at WR. And like I said, we will return the entire offensive line and defense.
"You know we the big brother." - Cliff Harris
"Y'all know what time it is." -Damian Lillard
"Y'all know what time it is." -Damian Lillard
-
dthomas=ddixon
- Moderator

- Posts: 8830
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
- Location: McMinnville, Oregon
Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?
If the coaches believe he's the better QB and gives us a better chance to win then yes. Otherwise, how do explain to a guy like Pharoah Brown that, after his incredible effort come back and play one more year, we're going to play for next season?

- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6490
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?
Not only would I not start Herbert, but now I have more reasons not to start him.
My main reason for sticking with Prukop is that he's clearly more capable for the job at this point -- otherwise, he wouldn't have been named the starter. And Oregon is still in great shape to make a run for the Pac-12 title. Our conference schedule starts this weekend, and we get all of our toughest Pac-12 North games at home.
In other words, the best QB should start until we're no longer in the running.
Now, my second reason -- our O line just took a huge hit. Our line is already insanely young. Yes, they're playing great all things considered, but I wouldn't want to throw a true freshman QB into the pressure cooker behind a developing line that just lost its senior anchor.
Of course, if Herbert surpasses Prukop in practice as the team's best QB, then by all means put him on the field. But that doesn't seem to be the case, and Oregon has an excellent chance to win a Pac-12 title this season. This isn't the full-on rebuilding year it would have been without Prukop. We have a big chance to do something special.
My main reason for sticking with Prukop is that he's clearly more capable for the job at this point -- otherwise, he wouldn't have been named the starter. And Oregon is still in great shape to make a run for the Pac-12 title. Our conference schedule starts this weekend, and we get all of our toughest Pac-12 North games at home.
In other words, the best QB should start until we're no longer in the running.
Now, my second reason -- our O line just took a huge hit. Our line is already insanely young. Yes, they're playing great all things considered, but I wouldn't want to throw a true freshman QB into the pressure cooker behind a developing line that just lost its senior anchor.
Of course, if Herbert surpasses Prukop in practice as the team's best QB, then by all means put him on the field. But that doesn't seem to be the case, and Oregon has an excellent chance to win a Pac-12 title this season. This isn't the full-on rebuilding year it would have been without Prukop. We have a big chance to do something special.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
- DAT_man_again
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1569
- Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 7:26 pm
Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?
Do you think it would be playing for next season though? With Prukop, we will likely still lose to Stanford and possibly Washington (gross). We should still beat Colorado, Wazzu, ASU, USC and OSU (Cal and Utah might be tough.)dthomas=ddixon wrote:If the coaches believe he's the better QB and gives us a better chance to win then yes. Otherwise, how do explain to a guy like Pharoah Brown that, after his incredible effort come back and play one more year, we're going to play for next season?
So if I were a betting man, we should be around 9-3 with Prukop. Does that really change that much with Herbert?
"You know we the big brother." - Cliff Harris
"Y'all know what time it is." -Damian Lillard
"Y'all know what time it is." -Damian Lillard
-
Duck24
- Senior
- Posts: 4744
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?
No, stop with this "go young the season is over" crap. They lost by 3 on the road to a power 5 team, with one of the best home field advantages (take note Duck fans, that's how you cheer and play host to visiting teams), playing without Royce and Crosby for a majority of the game, with over 100 yards in penalties etc etc etc. At the end of the day, they were one play away from winning that game. Would all of you "go young" fanboys be clamoring for this if Oregon won the game and Crosby was out for the season? No. One loss doesn't define the team, how they rebound does. The knee jerk/sky is falling reactions are absurd.
- DAT_man_again
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1569
- Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 7:26 pm
Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?
Wow, good job reading my post. I literally said I am not throwing in the towel on the season, and if you read through all of the threads, you will see I have said the EXACT SAME THING. I predicted that we would go 10-2. And I said "we lost to a good team on the road by 3 in one of the toughest places to play in CFB when we were missing our best player." I was saying I think we could probably still have a chance to be good this year with Herbert. I am real tired of you posting snarky crap in response to everything I say, especially when out of the two of us, you are the only one who apparently can't read.Duck24 wrote:No, stop with this "go young the season is over" crap. They lost by 3 on the road to a power 5 team, with one of the best home field advantages (take note Duck fans, that's how you cheer and play host to visiting teams), playing without Royce and Crosby for a majority of the game, with over 100 yards in penalties etc etc etc. At the end of the day, they were one play away from winning that game. Would all of you "go young" fanboys be clamoring for this if Oregon won the game and Crosby was out for the season? No. One loss doesn't define the team, how they rebound does. The knee jerk/sky is falling reactions are absurd.
Last edited by DAT_man_again on Tue Sep 20, 2016 9:50 am, edited 1 time in total.
"You know we the big brother." - Cliff Harris
"Y'all know what time it is." -Damian Lillard
"Y'all know what time it is." -Damian Lillard
- DAT_man_again
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1569
- Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 7:26 pm
Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?
Like literally, I have been the one saying the OPPOSITE of "the season is over" in every thread. And don't call me "fanboy" like I am somehow lesser of a fan than you are because I suggested we could have a chance to be a top 5 team next year while also being good this year. Geez.
"You know we the big brother." - Cliff Harris
"Y'all know what time it is." -Damian Lillard
"Y'all know what time it is." -Damian Lillard
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?
Do you think that possibility goes away if Herbert doesn't start for the rest of the year?DAT_man_again wrote:Like literally, I have been the one saying the OPPOSITE of "the season is over" in every thread. And don't call me "fanboy" like I am somehow lesser of a fan than you are because I suggested we could have a chance to be a top 5 team next year while also being good this year. Geez.
Redshirt freshmen QBs have done pretty well in the last few years -- Mariota, Winston, Manziel. Not starting as a true freshman doesn't appear to be any kind of death sentence.
I wouldn't mind seeing Herbert gets snaps, though, just to get comfortable on the field. Yost has made comments that he knows that plenty well, and expects to get to a chance to play him this season. I will be watching each game with anticipation.
-
Duck24
- Senior
- Posts: 4744
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?
It wasn't a reply directly to you, hence why I didn't quote your original post or otherwise call you out. Half the posts on this board are "the sky is falling, we won't make a bowl game, Helf is terrible blah blah blah". My post was a reaction to those, not you.DAT_man_again wrote:Wow, good job reading my post, moron. I literally said I am not throwing in the towel on the season, and if you read through all of the threads, you will see I have said the EXACT SAME THING. I predicted that we would go 10-2. And I said "we lost to a good team on the road by 3 in one of the toughest places to play in CFB when we were missing our best player." I was saying I think we could probably still have a chance to be good this year with Herbert. I am real tired of you posting snarky crap in response to everything I say, especially when out of the two of us, you are the only one who apparently can't read.Duck24 wrote:No, stop with this "go young the season is over" crap. They lost by 3 on the road to a power 5 team, with one of the best home field advantages (take note Duck fans, that's how you cheer and play host to visiting teams), playing without Royce and Crosby for a majority of the game, with over 100 yards in penalties etc etc etc. At the end of the day, they were one play away from winning that game. Would all of you "go young" fanboys be clamoring for this if Oregon won the game and Crosby was out for the season? No. One loss doesn't define the team, how they rebound does. The knee jerk/sky is falling reactions are absurd.
- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6490
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?
Chip Kelly established Oregon as a meritocracy, and that's something I'd like to see continue. Benching Prukop for reasons not relevant to the here and now just seems... not Oregon-esque.
Herbert will get his chance. At some point this year, we'll probably see some packages drawn up for him. And there's no way Prukop makes it through every down of every game -- not with this young O-line, not with how long he stands in the packet, and not with how he sometimes dives head-first for extra yards.
Herbert will get his chance. At some point this year, we'll probably see some packages drawn up for him. And there's no way Prukop makes it through every down of every game -- not with this young O-line, not with how long he stands in the packet, and not with how he sometimes dives head-first for extra yards.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
-
QuackAttack92
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 328
- Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2016 9:01 pm
Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?
I really wish this thread was sarcastic but the sad thing is is that it isnt...this isn't the NFL...there's no playing for a draft pick in college football...put the winners into the games
"F***** score points. What's your plan?"- Chipper
- DAT_man_again
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1569
- Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 7:26 pm
Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?
This comment is so dumb that I am now confused.QuackAttack92 wrote:I really wish this thread was sarcastic but the sad thing is is that it isnt...this isn't the NFL...there's no playing for a draft pick in college football...put the winners into the games
"You know we the big brother." - Cliff Harris
"Y'all know what time it is." -Damian Lillard
"Y'all know what time it is." -Damian Lillard
-
duckfan22
- Senior
- Posts: 2698
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm
Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?
That would be an interesting conversation.. Helfrich calls in Prukup and tells him even tho you
earned the starting spot were going to play for next year so you will be watching from the sidelines.
Teams play there best players, If Herbert was our best option he would be the starter. Freshman will
play at Oregon if they earn it. We will be fine. Herbert will have the play book down going into fall workouts
and the spring.
earned the starting spot were going to play for next year so you will be watching from the sidelines.
Teams play there best players, If Herbert was our best option he would be the starter. Freshman will
play at Oregon if they earn it. We will be fine. Herbert will have the play book down going into fall workouts
and the spring.