After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

QuackAttack92
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 328
Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2016 9:01 pm

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by QuackAttack92 »

StevensTechU wrote:
QuackAttack92 wrote:
Absolutely right on...Prukop is a tough sonofabitch to carry the mail...he doesnt have an off the charts skill set like Mariota or Adams, but he's done fine so far
I was probably my most obnoxious of the whole game at Memorial Stadium when Dakota trucked that safety.
And then the refs f***** us on the very next play and I wanted to break my remote
"F***** score points. What's your plan?"- Chipper
User avatar
Alan
Senior
Posts: 4359
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by Alan »

I kinda read the three pages, Herbert has one snap in a live game, zero pass attempts. We start Prukop but If Herbert is the future get him some live reps. Like I said earlier, one hand off in three games just to burn his redshirt.... There may be more to the story.
User avatar
nogerO
Senior
Posts: 4517
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:48 pm
Location: Wyoming

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by nogerO »

DAT_man_again wrote:Okay, I don't want this to sound like I'm throwing in the towel on this season, because I'm totally not. I still think we will contend for a PAC 12 title. However, this Saturday we are going to start 5 freshman on the offensive line.

Next year, we are going to return all five starters obviously, and at running back, we will return TBJ, Taj and Kani Benoit. At wideout we will have Nelson, Mitchell and Allen. Tight end Mundt. We will still be loaded at the skill positions is what I'm saying.

We could have a chance to be a top five team next year as we return the ENTIRE defense pretty much, and the entire offensive line and a loaded running back corps. Do we really want to be breaking in a new QB yet again when we could very well have a chance to make a playoff run?

I don't think it is throwing the towel this season to start Herbert. Based on what we've seen from Prukop, we are gonna have at least one more loss anyway. Is it negligent for the coaches to NOT start Herbert, whom is getting almost as much behind-the-scenes hype as Marcus was? Especially since we already burned his redshirt.

The coaches are smarter than I am, but could someone explain the benefit of still starting Prukop?
The good news is, we return the entire defense. The bad news? We return the entire defense.
"To give anything less than your best, is to sacrifice the gift." - Steve Prefontaine
User avatar
Alan
Senior
Posts: 4359
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by Alan »

nogerO wrote:The good news is, we return the entire defense. The bad news? We return the entire defense.
Now that's funny, I needed the chuckle! :lol:
vegasdom
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 233
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2015 11:22 pm

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by vegasdom »

DAT_man_again wrote:Okay, I don't want this to sound like I'm throwing in the towel on this season, because I'm totally not. I still think we will contend for a PAC 12 title. However, this Saturday we are going to start 5 freshman on the offensive line.

Next year, we are going to return all five starters obviously, and at running back, we will return TBJ, Taj and Kani Benoit. At wideout we will have Nelson, Mitchell and Allen. Tight end Mundt. We will still be loaded at the skill positions is what I'm saying.

We could have a chance to be a top five team next year as we return the ENTIRE defense pretty much, and the entire offensive line and a loaded running back corps. Do we really want to be breaking in a new QB yet again when we could very well have a chance to make a playoff run?

I don't think it is throwing the towel this season to start Herbert. Based on what we've seen from Prukop, we are gonna have at least one more loss anyway. Is it negligent for the coaches to NOT start Herbert, whom is getting almost as much behind-the-scenes hype as Marcus was? Especially since we already burned his redshirt.

The coaches are smarter than I am, but could someone explain the benefit of still starting Prukop?
I believe they are all red shirt freshmen and they looked good vs Nebraska. They are going to play Prukop till he is injured or royally screws up in a game or the Ducks are leading by 30 going into the 4th quarter. His stats are pretty good and he was 1 foot away from hitting Nelson late in the Nebraska game for a TD. Mr. Hype is going to just sit there and wait.
User avatar
FlDuckFan
All Pac-12
Posts: 5068
Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:45 am
GM: Orlando Magic GM
Location: Florida

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by FlDuckFan »

Alan wrote:I kinda read the three pages, Herbert has one snap in a live game, zero pass attempts. We start Prukop but If Herbert is the future get him some live reps. Like I said earlier, one hand off in three games just to burn his redshirt.... There may be more to the story.
My guess that the "more to the story" is that the coaches were over confident at the end of the game thinking we were going to blow out both Virginia and Nebraska and that he'd only get 1 play against Davis but would get a lot of time in the next two games.
gofightingducks
All Pac-12
Posts: 5533
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:08 pm
Location: Portland, OR

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by gofightingducks »

FlDuckFan wrote:
Alan wrote:I kinda read the three pages, Herbert has one snap in a live game, zero pass attempts. We start Prukop but If Herbert is the future get him some live reps. Like I said earlier, one hand off in three games just to burn his redshirt.... There may be more to the story.
My guess that the "more to the story" is that the coaches were over confident at the end of the game thinking we were going to blow out both Virginia and Nebraska and that he'd only get 1 play against Davis but would get a lot of time in the next two games.

Yes that was completely stupid to burn his redshirt that way. The Ducks are not going to blow anyone out, including the Beavers, there are no easy games left on the schedule, he is likely not going to play unless Prukop gets injured. He should have been put in earlier against UC Davis and should have got a series or two against Virginia.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6490
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by pezsez1 »

My guess that the "more to the story" is that the coaches were over confident at the end of the game thinking we were going to blow out both Virginia and Nebraska and that he'd only get 1 play against Davis but would get a lot of time in the next two games.
I highly doubt that's what happened. Even if coaches suspected we'd beat Virginia, I doubt they were planning on a five- or six-TD lead, or whatever they felt they'd need to put Herbert in the game. And there's no way they'd have planned on blowing out Nebraska... that's just not a possibility. I get that some people here dislike the coaches, but these guys aren't idiots.

I think it's a mental/confidence thing. They wanted to remove all doubt in Herbert's mind that he's the #2 guy. It sends a message to him and the rest of the team to "be ready." Burning his redshirt undeniably gives him more motivation because he doesn't have to wonder, "well maybe they'll hold me out in certain situations just to save my redshirt."

Nope, he's playing. I guarantee the coaches will find ways to get him in the game plan.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
QuackAttack92
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 328
Joined: Sun Sep 18, 2016 9:01 pm

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by QuackAttack92 »

gofightingducks wrote:
FlDuckFan wrote:
Alan wrote:I kinda read the three pages, Herbert has one snap in a live game, zero pass attempts. We start Prukop but If Herbert is the future get him some live reps. Like I said earlier, one hand off in three games just to burn his redshirt.... There may be more to the story.
My guess that the "more to the story" is that the coaches were over confident at the end of the game thinking we were going to blow out both Virginia and Nebraska and that he'd only get 1 play against Davis but would get a lot of time in the next two games.

Yes that was completely stupid to burn his redshirt that way. The Ducks are not going to blow anyone out, including the Beavers, there are no easy games left on the schedule, he is likely not going to play unless Prukop gets injured. He should have been put in earlier against UC Davis and should have got a series or two against Virginia.
what does it matter? If he really is that good he's not gonna be here for longer than 3 years anyway
"F***** score points. What's your plan?"- Chipper
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by Duck07 »

QuackAttack92 wrote:
gofightingducks wrote:
FlDuckFan wrote:
Alan wrote:I kinda read the three pages, Herbert has one snap in a live game, zero pass attempts. We start Prukop but If Herbert is the future get him some live reps. Like I said earlier, one hand off in three games just to burn his redshirt.... There may be more to the story.
My guess that the "more to the story" is that the coaches were over confident at the end of the game thinking we were going to blow out both Virginia and Nebraska and that he'd only get 1 play against Davis but would get a lot of time in the next two games.

Yes that was completely stupid to burn his redshirt that way. The Ducks are not going to blow anyone out, including the Beavers, there are no easy games left on the schedule, he is likely not going to play unless Prukop gets injured. He should have been put in earlier against UC Davis and should have got a series or two against Virginia.
what does it matter? If he really is that good he's not gonna be here for longer than 3 years anyway
Stuff happens. You're telling me you wouldn't have wanted an extra year of Dennis Dixon?
Image
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

One look at the depth chart on the offensive line and can not imagine Prukop staying healthy all year I hope I am wrong but I think we lose a couple of quarterbacks this year. I would be extremely nervous as a qb playing behind them all year.
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8830
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

Duck07 wrote:
QuackAttack92 wrote:
gofightingducks wrote:
FlDuckFan wrote:
Alan wrote:I kinda read the three pages, Herbert has one snap in a live game, zero pass attempts. We start Prukop but If Herbert is the future get him some live reps. Like I said earlier, one hand off in three games just to burn his redshirt.... There may be more to the story.
My guess that the "more to the story" is that the coaches were over confident at the end of the game thinking we were going to blow out both Virginia and Nebraska and that he'd only get 1 play against Davis but would get a lot of time in the next two games.

Yes that was completely stupid to burn his redshirt that way. The Ducks are not going to blow anyone out, including the Beavers, there are no easy games left on the schedule, he is likely not going to play unless Prukop gets injured. He should have been put in earlier against UC Davis and should have got a series or two against Virginia.
what does it matter? If he really is that good he's not gonna be here for longer than 3 years anyway
Stuff happens. You're telling me you wouldn't have wanted an extra year of Dennis Dixon?
Sure but wouldn't you have wanted an extra year of all the guys who left after their RS-JR years? If they're that good let them play because they're probably going to leave early regardless.
Image
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by Duck07 »

That's not the issue when it comes to eligibility. It's a numbers game, like the decision to go for 2, up 4 late. By wasting a year for a few plays, if a player gets hurt later on its harder to get the exemption from the NCAA. Sometimes it wouldn't matter, other times like with Dennis it would.
Image
Duck24
Senior
Posts: 4744
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by Duck24 »

Duck07 wrote:That's not the issue when it comes to eligibility. It's a numbers game, like the decision to go for 2, up 4 late. By wasting a year for a few plays, if a player gets hurt later on its harder to get the exemption from the NCAA. Sometimes it wouldn't matter, other times like with Dennis it would.
I remember you ranting and raving when they burned his RS in 2004. Don't forget though, Dixon had already grayshirted. He was class of 2003 but didn't enroll until Winter 2004 so that may have had something to do with it. Point stands though, having the option to have him back in 2008 would have been nice.
odux
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 240
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 10:02 pm

Re: After the injury to Crosby, should we start Herbert?

Post by odux »

Hey guys, remember how well it worked out last year when the coaching staff finally listened to the armchair quarterbacks. And finally put Lockie in for Adams, or when we went real deep and wanted Allie for Lockie? Yeah, it worked out so well, lets do it again this year. Also, we will not be starting 5 freshman OL. Even if Hunt doesn't start. Brenner will.
Post Reply