Mullens needs to act ASAP

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6490
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by pezsez1 »

All realistic fans have expected a post-Chip Kelly decline. I think Helfrich has done a great job in limiting that decline, especially on offense, even while he had difficulty for a few years finding quarterbacks. We lost Aliotti and still haven't found our defensive footing. People wanted to fire him too, and now they are starting to realize what a tough job he had and how well he actually did it.
I didn't expect much of a post-Chip decline as much as I expected a post-Mariota decline, which is happening. But the big reason why I highlighted the above quote is because the Aliotti segment is right on. People here wanted his head served on a platter, despite the fact he was always ahead of the curve in slowing the spread offenses that today are so common. This year's Oregon team with Aliotti as DC would be undefeated and bound for the playoffs (although I'm sure people would still be begging for him to be fired).

I'm not sold on Hoke yet, but I won't start criticizing him until he's had reasonable time to do what he's trying to do. One observation about Hoke, though... his defensive units often seem disorganized trying to get on and off the field. I never saw remotely this much confusion under either Aliotti or Pellum. A small part of me wonders whether Hoke is in over his head in trying to deal with Pac-12 offenses.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
Tray Dub
Senior
Posts: 4994
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:31 pm

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by Tray Dub »

pezsez1 wrote:
All realistic fans have expected a post-Chip Kelly decline. I think Helfrich has done a great job in limiting that decline, especially on offense, even while he had difficulty for a few years finding quarterbacks. We lost Aliotti and still haven't found our defensive footing. People wanted to fire him too, and now they are starting to realize what a tough job he had and how well he actually did it.
I didn't expect much of a post-Chip decline as much as I expected a post-Mariota decline, which is happening. But the big reason why I highlighted the above quote is because the Aliotti segment is right on. People here wanted his head served on a platter, despite the fact he was always ahead of the curve in slowing the spread offenses that today are so common. This year's Oregon team with Aliotti as DC would be undefeated and bound for the playoffs (although I'm sure people would still be begging for him to be fired).

I'm not sold on Hoke yet, but I won't start criticizing him until he's had reasonable time to do what he's trying to do. One observation about Hoke, though... his defensive units often seem disorganized trying to get on and off the field. I never saw remotely this much confusion under either Aliotti or Pellum. A small part of me wonders whether Hoke is in over his head in trying to deal with Pac-12 offenses.
I do not think we would be bound for the playoffs. Our o-line is not good enough, our quarterback is probably the worst we've had since before Dennis Dixon (I don't think he's bad mind you, just not better than an average Pace 12 qb), our defense is generally crazy young and our front seven is weak. We could MAYBE eke out ten wins with a well-coached D and some luck, but no way in hell this is a playoff-caliber team.
User avatar
justducky0
Senior
Posts: 2012
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:02 pm
Location: The Real World

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by justducky0 »

This is something I have wondered about.. Would Hoke be able to keep up in the Pac12, who's offense are much more advanced than the Big10. So far that answer is no.

He was fired from Michigan for a reason. Yes he made an improvement, but how good are the Big10 teams? Going to a 4-3 was a mistake in my mind. You are literally taking speed off the field and putting in muscle. Which works against slower moving teams but in the Pac12 with all of the offensive firepower you have to wonder if that was the right choice.
Image
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by StevensTechU »

SuperDuck wrote: Well, although I'm not quite ready to show Helfrich the door, at least, not "yet", if the Ducks were to hire one of the guys on that list, the 2 guys I'd prefer would be Mike Macintyre or Kyle Whittingham, though I think both will be strong candidates for the USC job, and maybe UCLA, after the season.

Kyle Whittingham is a good coach that's been pretty consistent. He's also won some big time Bowl games.

Mike Macintyre is also a very good coach. Both have had their struggles, especially Macintyre, who will likely be eager to jump from Colorado because of their unwillingness to modernize their facilities. The guy is building a winner at CU while being at a disadvantage to most, if not all, other teams in the conference. I think he's smart enough to leave to greener pastures once he's shown that he can build a winner under the disadvantages he's had at Colorado.

Something to keep in mind, this year there may be several jobs available at high profile schools. The LSU job is already open. I can see the USC job being open, as well as UCLA unless Mora wins out. Oklahoma is also a strong candidate for a new coach, as the Stoops era seems to be coming to a close. Notre Dame is another job that may very well be available. Brian Kelly would do well at any of the schools mentioned because he wouldn't have the same restrictions elsewhere that he has at Notre Dame.
This is why I think going with the lesser-known, just-as-good coach is the play. When you don't have the same resources, you just have to outwit your opponents.

I agree that Macintyre and Whittingham are good options, hence why I listed them #2 and #3. But put side-by-side in terms of overall ability, I think Dino Babers is the one I'd most like to build the program around.
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by SuperDuck »

StevensTechU wrote:
SuperDuck wrote: Well, although I'm not quite ready to show Helfrich the door, at least, not "yet", if the Ducks were to hire one of the guys on that list, the 2 guys I'd prefer would be Mike Macintyre or Kyle Whittingham, though I think both will be strong candidates for the USC job, and maybe UCLA, after the season.

Kyle Whittingham is a good coach that's been pretty consistent. He's also won some big time Bowl games.

Mike Macintyre is also a very good coach. Both have had their struggles, especially Macintyre, who will likely be eager to jump from Colorado because of their unwillingness to modernize their facilities. The guy is building a winner at CU while being at a disadvantage to most, if not all, other teams in the conference. I think he's smart enough to leave to greener pastures once he's shown that he can build a winner under the disadvantages he's had at Colorado.

Something to keep in mind, this year there may be several jobs available at high profile schools. The LSU job is already open. I can see the USC job being open, as well as UCLA unless Mora wins out. Oklahoma is also a strong candidate for a new coach, as the Stoops era seems to be coming to a close. Notre Dame is another job that may very well be available. Brian Kelly would do well at any of the schools mentioned because he wouldn't have the same restrictions elsewhere that he has at Notre Dame.
This is why I think going with the lesser-known, just-as-good coach is the play. When you don't have the same resources, you just have to outwit your opponents.

I agree that Macintyre and Whittingham are good options, hence why I listed them #2 and #3. But put side-by-side in terms of overall ability, I think Dino Babers is the one I'd most like to build the program around.

Hmmm...the main reason I preferred Macintyre and Whittingham was because of their familiarity with the west coast recruiting grounds, but after looking at Dino Babers resume, I can see that he not only has Pac-12 roots, but also ties to Texas, Chicago and the east coast.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dino_Babe ... ing_career

My concern with him is that he's a coach on the rising star list and it would be unlikely that he'd stay at Oregon long term. I think we'd have a better chance of keeping the other two for more than a few years.
John 3:36
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by SuperDuck »

Alan wrote:
SuperDuck wrote:
Phalanx wrote:It appears that we have allowed the lunacy and hysteria that normally is confined to the in-game threads to bleed into the rest of the week. People need to get a grip. A couple of losses by a field goal in an obvious rebuilding year are not grounds for scrapping the whole program. Golly, but we are spoiled here. The season is already ruined? Really? We need to play for a NC every year or have the coach's head?

These results were obvious for anyone who paid attention to the last two years of recruiting, especially on the defensive end, and the quarterback situation. I agree that there have been mistakes. Elevating Pellum to DC was a huge one. But you have to give the fix some time. Changing defensive philosophy (especially while using the same coaches) isn't going to bring instant results, especially when the new DC doesn't even have the full year to recruit the right guys.

Someone brought up the Coker comparison. There is another obvious comparison, and that is Frank Solich. Recall what happened to Nebraska after they fired him in 2003. That year, Solich's team finished 10-3. If I'm not mistaken, they have still never finished with that high of a winning percentage since.

All realistic fans have expected a post-Chip Kelly decline. I think Helfrich has done a great job in limiting that decline, especially on offense, even while he had difficulty for a few years finding quarterbacks. We lost Aliotti and still haven't found our defensive footing. People wanted to fire him too, and now they are starting to realize what a tough job he had and how well he actually did it.

I don't like watching my team lose tight games either, but I also see light at the end of the tunnel. The quarterback pipeline is obviously improving. The defense is young and will get better. I think fans just need to be a little patient.

+1000
X2, very well written opinion.

Another thing, what if we brought in another coach and he ended up being no better than Helfrich? With the talent that Oregon has on its roster it wouldn't be too hard to bring in a good coach and have them go 9-3 or 10-2 for the next 2-3 years before the program began to regress even further.

At least Helfrich has much of the blueprint that he and Chip Kelly put together, plus the continuity of the staff.
John 3:36
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6490
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by pezsez1 »

I do not think we would be bound for the playoffs.
We've lost two games by a combined six points. I guarantee we'd be undefeated right now with NA at the helm of the defense. And while this isn't a "down" year for the Pac-12 like we've seen in past years, this is also a season where we're not at all top-heavy. There isn't a single unbeatable juggernaut anywhere in this conference.

UW barely beat Arizona. Stanford needed a last-second play to beat UCLA. USC sucks. Utah isn't impressive either.

With an average defense, I'd have a hard time seeing anyone beating us, even with our other problems.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
Tray Dub
Senior
Posts: 4994
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:31 pm

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by Tray Dub »

pezsez1 wrote:
I do not think we would be bound for the playoffs.
We've lost two games by a combined six points. I guarantee we'd be undefeated right now with NA at the helm of the defense. And while this isn't a "down" year for the Pac-12 like we've seen in past years, this is also a season where we're not at all top-heavy. There isn't a single unbeatable juggernaut anywhere in this conference.

UW barely beat Arizona. Stanford needed a last-second play to beat UCLA. USC sucks. Utah isn't impressive either.

With an average defense, I'd have a hard time seeing anyone beating us, even with our other problems.
Two pet peeves I gotta air: first, respond to my actual argument, not just the headline of my post. Second, you can't guarantee a hypothetical. I generally like you but yeah, if you're gonna engage you shouldn't just ignore what the other person replied to you with.

I agree, there's no unbeatable juggernaut this year. There hardly ever is. Yet Duck teams much better than this one, even in a world where Allioti is still the coordinator, have lost games during the season. Being unable to imagine us losing to Stanford or the Dawgs is frankly kind of ridiculous. You can say you think we'd win, but you can't even entertain a situation in which we lost? Beyond that, just because you can't see a team we should lose to does not mean you should predict that we'd go undefeated. Almost every single elite team in any given season will lose a game to a team they're better than. That's the nature of the game: if you'd win nine times out of ten and you play twelve games in a season, your odds are pretty good that you won't win at least one of those times. And again, that's all bizarrely ignoring this team's obvious weaknesses, which even a really good defensive coordinator (which NA probably isn't but whatever) could not single-handedly fix. Predicting the playoffs for this current group of players, given any group of coaches, is nuts.
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by StevensTechU »

SuperDuck wrote: My concern with him is that he's a coach on the rising star list and it would be unlikely that he'd stay at Oregon long term. I think we'd have a better chance of keeping the other two for more than a few years.
I think Oregon has a better shot at retaining a coach than going to the market place to get an established big name. I think there's a lot to learn from hiring Altman in basketball -- sometimes there are guys who don't have their name attached to marquee programs but who could do amazing things with the right resources.

Tray Dub, don't worry, I'm far too ugly to ever feel flattered by anything. But to answer your question seriously, I work a comfortable job that I'm often under-utilized mentally, giving me too much time to let my mind wander to other things (like conservation, ethics, politics and college football). Between social media, raw videos of interviews, a little bit of networking, and a pinch of intuition you can formulate a lot on your own about what's going on, at least with your favorite teams. Edit: Maybe worth noting, but I watch literally no ESPN or Fox Sports. Like absolutely zero. As an information source, that's the worst, least efficient means.
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39390
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by greenyellow »

Phalanx wrote:It appears that we have allowed the lunacy and hysteria that normally is confined to the in-game threads to bleed into the rest of the week. People need to get a grip. A couple of losses by a field goal in an obvious rebuilding year are not grounds for scrapping the whole program. Golly, but we are spoiled here. The season is already ruined? Really? We need to play for a NC every year or have the coach's head?

These results were obvious for anyone who paid attention to the last two years of recruiting, especially on the defensive end, and the quarterback situation. I agree that there have been mistakes. Elevating Pellum to DC was a huge one. But you have to give the fix some time. Changing defensive philosophy (especially while using the same coaches) isn't going to bring instant results, especially when the new DC doesn't even have the full year to recruit the right guys.

Someone brought up the Coker comparison. There is another obvious comparison, and that is Frank Solich. Recall what happened to Nebraska after they fired him in 2003. That year, Solich's team finished 10-3. If I'm not mistaken, they have still never finished with that high of a winning percentage since.

All realistic fans have expected a post-Chip Kelly decline. I think Helfrich has done a great job in limiting that decline, especially on offense, even while he had difficulty for a few years finding quarterbacks. We lost Aliotti and still haven't found our defensive footing. People wanted to fire him too, and now they are starting to realize what a tough job he had and how well he actually did it.

I don't like watching my team lose tight games either, but I also see light at the end of the tunnel. The quarterback pipeline is obviously improving. The defense is young and will get better. I think fans just need to be a little patient.
Couldn't agree more. With how much change there's been on the coaching staff under Helfrich, I'd say he's still trying to find the best combination for the long-term. Couple that with the fact that they also had to deal with recruiting sanctions the past 3 years, I do think Helfrich has not had as easy a time as Kelly did.
Image
User avatar
Phalanx
All Pac-12
Posts: 5347
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by Phalanx »

greenyellow wrote: Couldn't agree more. With how much change there's been on the coaching staff under Helfrich, I'd say he's still trying to find the best combination for the long-term. Couple that with the fact that they also had to deal with recruiting sanctions the past 3 years, I do think Helfrich has not had as easy a time as Kelly did.
Great point about the recruiting sanctions. Even the most die-hard Chip fan (of which I am one) has to make an entry on Chip's ledger for the increased difficulty in recruiting for the last few years. In particular, I think we suffered at linebacker in terms of recruiting because of less available visits. So moving forward, fixing that problem perhaps gets a little easier.

I admit to being amused watching guys on here plowing ahead with the 'fire Helfrich' narrative. I don't think we are anywhere close to that point, and throwing out names of new coaches just seems to add to the comic nature of these threads.
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by StevensTechU »

greenyellow wrote:
Phalanx wrote:It appears that we have allowed the lunacy and hysteria that normally is confined to the in-game threads to bleed into the rest of the week. People need to get a grip. A couple of losses by a field goal in an obvious rebuilding year are not grounds for scrapping the whole program. Golly, but we are spoiled here. The season is already ruined? Really? We need to play for a NC every year or have the coach's head?

These results were obvious for anyone who paid attention to the last two years of recruiting, especially on the defensive end, and the quarterback situation. I agree that there have been mistakes. Elevating Pellum to DC was a huge one. But you have to give the fix some time. Changing defensive philosophy (especially while using the same coaches) isn't going to bring instant results, especially when the new DC doesn't even have the full year to recruit the right guys.

Someone brought up the Coker comparison. There is another obvious comparison, and that is Frank Solich. Recall what happened to Nebraska after they fired him in 2003. That year, Solich's team finished 10-3. If I'm not mistaken, they have still never finished with that high of a winning percentage since.

All realistic fans have expected a post-Chip Kelly decline. I think Helfrich has done a great job in limiting that decline, especially on offense, even while he had difficulty for a few years finding quarterbacks. We lost Aliotti and still haven't found our defensive footing. People wanted to fire him too, and now they are starting to realize what a tough job he had and how well he actually did it.

I don't like watching my team lose tight games either, but I also see light at the end of the tunnel. The quarterback pipeline is obviously improving. The defense is young and will get better. I think fans just need to be a little patient.
Couldn't agree more. With how much change there's been on the coaching staff under Helfrich, I'd say he's still trying to find the best combination for the long-term. Couple that with the fact that they also had to deal with recruiting sanctions the past 3 years, I do think Helfrich has not had as easy a time as Kelly did.
Frank Solich of 82-63 Ohio Bobcat fame? lol. If anything, Frank Solich is yet another point for my side of the argument. He was promoted to head coach of Nebraska in the 90s, a huge job at the time, because he did well as a coordinator under Osborne. But how good was his actual ability to be a head coach? 82-63 at Ohio after Nebraska let him go. Very mediocre, yet he, at one time, had one of the biggest jobs in college football. Letting go of Solich wasn't the problem, it was promoting him in the first place because Nebraska wasn't willing to look outside of Nebraska.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6490
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by pezsez1 »

I admit to being amused watching guys on here plowing ahead with the 'fire Helfrich' narrative. I don't think we are anywhere close to that point, and throwing out names of new coaches just seems to add to the comic nature of these threads.
+1. This just seems... pointless and desperate. It's not happening this year, whether you want it to or not.

Also, I agree (and I've said before) that Helfrich has dealt with an insane amount of transition. First, the departure of Chip. Second, the departure of Mariota. Now, the replacement of his OC and DC.

And there's one in there I'd left out... the departure of NA, who by now is hopefully more appreciated for his ability to always field a dangerous defense.

I agree a lot with this piece: http://www.csnnw.com/oregon-ducks/ducks ... nce-makers

This defense needs playmakers. It needs personnel. We usually have some playmakers on D... Buckner, Ifo, Armstead are a few recent examples. But right now, the cupboard is pretty bare. Yeah, we have talented players, but who doesn't? What we don't have are leaders on the field on the defensive side of the ball. That's not the thing that can be "coached up." You're either a leader or you're not.

And how did we get to this point? Over the past four years, the program has gone through a head coaching change and two defensive coordinator changes. I follow recruiting, and I've seen how that instability (along with sanctions) has hamstrung our efforts. Now, we're paying the price.

Will the cost be worth it in the long run? We'll see. But there's always a price.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6490
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by pezsez1 »

I do not think we would be bound for the playoffs. Our o-line is not good enough, our quarterback is probably the worst we've had since before Dennis Dixon (I don't think he's bad mind you, just not better than an average Pace 12 qb), our defense is generally crazy young and our front seven is weak. We could MAYBE eke out ten wins with a well-coached D and some luck, but no way in hell this is a playoff-caliber team.
You requested that I argue all of your points, so here we go.

To say Prukop is the worst we've had since "before" Dennis Dixon implies that you're comparing him to the likes of Brady Leaf, which simply wouldn't be accurate or fair. With a sample size of just two games, I'd agree Prukop is on par with the average Pac-12 QB. He has completed 67 percent of his passes while throwing 8 TDs to 1 INT. He's no scrub, but he's also no Mariota. He struggles with the deep ball and is too indecisive at times; bad combination for late-game scenarios without having a ball-control offense.

So we mostly agree on QB play, if not agree completely.

As per our defense, if NA were still here we wouldn't have switched to a 4-3 without having the correct personnel to do so. And our guys wouldn't be constantly lost or confused about where to go. Even during a few years when our D was super young under Aliotti -- and even during that post-Harrington year where our freshman corners got routinely lit up like Christmas trees -- we simply didn't see the flat-out confusion we've seen under Pellum and now Hoke. Love him or hate him, NA could flat-out recruit and coach. He was also a master of halftime adjustments and laying down the hammer in the second half.

In a regular year, upgrading our offense from "sad!" to "average" probably wouldn't be good enough... this year's offense just isn't quite potent enough to carry such a big load. But the Pac-12 this year isn't top heavy -- we're going to lose more close games. I say we'd win them with an average defense.

Then again, this is all kind of nonsense because NA isn't coming back and there's no such thing as time travel. But I wanted to do you the courtesy of responding to your whole argument, and not just the top.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
Quietduck
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 623
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:43 pm

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by Quietduck »

I'm an old school Duck fan so the record so many are trembling about will only be disappointment to me, but I see a silver lining. Maybe all the band wagon fans will break their ankles jumping off and we can have some peace. To those who believe we can get a "Saban" type coach with enough money I say " only if we get him before he becomes a star" money isn't enough to bring a great coach to Oregon as we live in a recruiting desert with no Oasis to draw in the athletes. Even "Mike" alone wasn't enough to win championships alone, he needed resources and we don't have those other resources.
Post Reply