Mullens needs to act ASAP

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by buckmarkduck »

pezsez1 wrote:
All realistic fans have expected a post-Chip Kelly decline. I think Helfrich has done a great job in limiting that decline, especially on offense, even while he had difficulty for a few years finding quarterbacks. We lost Aliotti and still haven't found our defensive footing. People wanted to fire him too, and now they are starting to realize what a tough job he had and how well he actually did it.
I didn't expect much of a post-Chip decline as much as I expected a post-Mariota decline, which is happening. But the big reason why I highlighted the above quote is because the Aliotti segment is right on. People here wanted his head served on a platter, despite the fact he was always ahead of the curve in slowing the spread offenses that today are so common. This year's Oregon team with Aliotti as DC would be undefeated and bound for the playoffs (although I'm sure people would still be begging for him to be fired).

I'm not sold on Hoke yet, but I won't start criticizing him until he's had reasonable time to do what he's trying to do. One observation about Hoke, though... his defensive units often seem disorganized trying to get on and off the field. I never saw remotely this much confusion under either Aliotti or Pellum. A small part of me wonders whether Hoke is in over his head in trying to deal with Pac-12 offenses.
Aliotti was never ahead of any curve, it was entirely coach Azz. I'm sorry you still can't grasp that.
User avatar
Phalanx
All Pac-12
Posts: 5347
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by Phalanx »

StevensTechU wrote:
Frank Solich of 82-63 Ohio Bobcat fame? lol. If anything, Frank Solich is yet another point for my side of the argument. He was promoted to head coach of Nebraska in the 90s, a huge job at the time, because he did well as a coordinator under Osborne. But how good was his actual ability to be a head coach? 82-63 at Ohio after Nebraska let him go. Very mediocre, yet he, at one time, had one of the biggest jobs in college football. Letting go of Solich wasn't the problem, it was promoting him in the first place because Nebraska wasn't willing to look outside of Nebraska.
Aside from the fact that you elect to completely ignore Solich's 58-19 record at Nebraska, which is the only relevant record in this discussion, I'm not even sure what 'your argument' is. Are you saying that Helfrich should never have been promoted? That's incredibly helpful, thanks. Helfrich is 35-10 as a head coach at Oregon. He beat the snot out of a Florida State team that had the #1 player in the very next NFL draft. In a non playoff year, that would have been enough to claim a national championship. If he hadn't lost his two starting receivers, he might have won even in the playoff.

The reason for bringing up Solich is not how awesome he was as a coach in other contexts, but what his firing did to the program. They went from Alamo Bowl champs at 10-3 in year six of his tenure to 5-6 the next year with the newly-installed west coast offense. They have never lost less than four games since then, and have had several losing seasons, including just last year. Firing Solich cemented Nebraska as a second-tier program. Following that example would be idiocy for Oregon.

Helfrich has been a great coach that has spoiled us such that we freak out when we lose two games by a field goal. It would be one thing if the cupboard was bare at Oregon, but with injuries and having to play a crazy amount of underclassmen, I'm willing to wait until they rebuild before I start looking around for a Bill Callahan to scrap the program and start over. The defense is clearly dragging the team down, but that is why Helfrich brought Hoke in. People need to give him time to do his job.
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by StevensTechU »

Phalanx wrote:
Aside from the fact that you elect to completely ignore Solich's 58-19 record at Nebraska, which is the only relevant record in this discussion, I'm not even sure what 'your argument' is. Are you saying that Helfrich should never have been promoted? That's incredibly helpful, thanks. Helfrich is 35-10 as a head coach at Oregon. He beat the snot out of a Florida State team that had the #1 player in the very next NFL draft. In a non playoff year, that would have been enough to claim a national championship. If he hadn't lost his two starting receivers, he might have won even in the playoff.

The reason for bringing up Solich is not how awesome he was as a coach in other contexts, but what his firing did to the program. They went from Alamo Bowl champs at 10-3 in year six of his tenure to 5-6 the next year with the newly-installed west coast offense. They have never lost less than four games since then, and have had several losing seasons, including just last year. Firing Solich cemented Nebraska as a second-tier program. Following that example would be idiocy for Oregon.

Helfrich has been a great coach that has spoiled us such that we freak out when we lose two games by a field goal. It would be one thing if the cupboard was bare at Oregon, but with injuries and having to play a crazy amount of underclassmen, I'm willing to wait until they rebuild before I start looking around for a Bill Callahan to scrap the program and start over. The defense is clearly dragging the team down, but that is why Helfrich brought Hoke in. People need to give him time to do his job.
Weak sarcasm isn't really going to earn you respect. I'll respect your opinion when you make valid, irrefutable arguments (or at minimum, ones that aren't really easy to refute).

Your point: Don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. The grass isn't always greener.
My point: Don't hang onto a mistake just because you spent a lot of time making it.

Record alone doesn't tell you much about a coach's abilities. Going 10-3 at Washington State is completely different than 10-3 at Alabama. So for context, Frank Solich took over a national powerhouse that went 69-6 in the six seasons before took over, and he led them to a record of 58-19. Not awful, not great. Further cementing his status as a mediocre coach (not a champion, not a trainwreck) is that he moved down to a midmajor conference and managed a record of 82-63.

Now let's say it was reversed, that he actually was the Ohio coach before he was the Nebraska coach. Would Nebraska, coming off six seasons with a 69-6 record, hire a guy who is 82-63 in the Mid-Atlantic Conference? The answer is probably 'no.' You'd go and get a guy who's proven to be better, because you're Nebraska in 1997 and you can. But instead they went with Solich because he was already on the staff, and they rode him into mediocrity. Then they hired a failed NFL coach, cut ties with their Texas recruiting base by switching to the Big 10, held onto another mediocre coach in Bo Pelini who has since went a whopping 7-7 in the Missouri Valley Conference.

Oregon has ascended to a level where it can take the best coach from approximately 100-105 other FBS schools, plus all of those currently coaching FCS or lower, and currently coordinators at any level of football. I guarantee that out of all of those options, the best man for the Oregon job isn't the one currently coaching the team.

There is no 'lunacy' or 'hysteria' in my post. Just cold, hard facts. If there is something to learn from the Nebraska example that you gave, it's probably that Mike Nolan shouldn't be the next guy. Instead, go get any of Whittingham, Macintyre, Dino Babers or Dave Clawson, because what they've been able to do at their respective institutions is more impressive than what Helfrich has done when you take into consideration the circumstances each was dealt.
User avatar
Phalanx
All Pac-12
Posts: 5347
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by Phalanx »

StevensTechU wrote:
Weak sarcasm isn't really going to earn you respect. I'll respect your opinion when you make valid, irrefutable arguments (or at minimum, ones that aren't really easy to refute).

Your point: Don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. The grass isn't always greener.
My point: Don't hang onto a mistake just because you spent a lot of time making it.

Record alone doesn't tell you much about a coach's abilities. Going 10-3 at Washington State is completely different than 10-3 at Alabama. So for context, Frank Solich took over a national powerhouse that went 69-6 in the six seasons before took over, and he led them to a record of 58-19. Not awful, not great. Further cementing his status as a mediocre coach (not a champion, not a trainwreck) is that he moved down to a midmajor conference and managed a record of 82-63.

Now let's say it was reversed, that he actually was the Ohio coach before he was the Nebraska coach. Would Nebraska, coming off six seasons with a 69-6 record, hire a guy who is 82-63 in the Mid-Atlantic Conference? The answer is probably 'no.' You'd go and get a guy who's proven to be better, because you're Nebraska in 1997 and you can. But instead they went with Solich because he was already on the staff, and they rode him into mediocrity. Then they hired a failed NFL coach, cut ties with their Texas recruiting base by switching to the Big 10, held onto another mediocre coach in Bo Pelini who has since went a whopping 7-7 in the Missouri Valley Conference.

Oregon has ascended to a level where it can take the best coach from approximately 100-105 other FBS schools, plus all of those currently coaching FCS or lower, and currently coordinators at any level of football. I guarantee that out of all of those options, the best man for the Oregon job isn't the one currently coaching the team.

There is no 'lunacy' or 'hysteria' in my post. Just cold, hard facts. If there is something to learn from the Nebraska example that you gave, it's probably that Mike Nolan shouldn't be the next guy. Instead, go get any of Whittingham, Macintyre, Dino Babers or Dave Clawson, because what they've been able to do at their respective institutions is more impressive than what Helfrich has done when you take into consideration the circumstances each was dealt.
I'm not all that worried about getting the respect of a dude on the internet who thinks we should fire our coach because we lost a couple of close games. You may not remember this, but there were a lot of people calling for Rich Brooks to get fired in 1994 after the ducks started 3-3 as well. Just for the record, I wasn't worried about obtaining their respect either. You don't have cold, hard facts, you have opinions based on your current whim, just like everybody else.

Solich took Nebraska into mediocrity? I think you and I define mediocrity a little differently. The guy won over 75% of his games. He had a Heisman winner in his 4th year, and he took them to the National Championship game. The year he got fired, they won the Alamo Bowl the very next game. We should all be so mediocre. No doubt you are an incredibly accomplished fellow in your field and can look down your nose at Solich and Helfrich, but the reality is that most of the coaches you mentioned have never sniffed a national championship game or a Rose Bowl victory, and likely never will. Mark Helfrich has on his resume the single biggest victory in Oregon football history. THAT is a cold hard fact.

I'm not going to spend a lot of time arguing about this. Helfrich is a good coach who is dealing with a lot of crap right now, a lot like Altman did early in his tenure at Oregon. The team will be better going forward, and this will be a memory, just like Chip losing to Boise State. Stuff happens. That's what makes football fun, you don't win every year.
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by StevensTechU »

Phalanx wrote:
I'm not all that worried about getting the respect...
Addressing someone else's points isn't your strong suit. Got it - debate over.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6490
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by pezsez1 »

Aliotti was never ahead of any curve, it was entirely coach Azz. I'm sorry you still can't grasp that.
Coach Azz only coached the D-line... and he did a great job! But NA fielded good defenses for years with and without coach Azz. Having a great D-line was a nice asset, but Azz had nothing to do with our linebackers and secondary -- and you can go back many years and find play-making leaders who thrived in those positions.

The strength of NA's D was never focused on the D-line, but on CBs and LBs either blitzing or excelling in one-on-one coverage while everyone else ganged up on the run.

The "it was all coach Azz" nonsense needs to stop.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
Phalanx
All Pac-12
Posts: 5347
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by Phalanx »

StevensTechU wrote:
Addressing someone else's points isn't your strong suit. Got it - debate over.
Yeah, I'm just here drowning in my own mediocrity, just like Mark Helfrich. Good thing there are such self-actualized people like you around to point these things out. :lol:
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by StevensTechU »

Phalanx wrote:
Yeah, I'm just here drowning in my own mediocrity, just like Mark Helfrich. Good thing there are such self-actualized people like you around to point these things out. :lol:
I really have no idea why you're making this a personal matter.
User avatar
Phalanx
All Pac-12
Posts: 5347
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm

Re: Mullens needs to act ASAP

Post by Phalanx »

StevensTechU wrote:
Phalanx wrote:
Yeah, I'm just here drowning in my own mediocrity, just like Mark Helfrich. Good thing there are such self-actualized people like you around to point these things out. :lol:
I really have no idea why you're making this a personal matter.
I'm so confused...are we still talking about things that aren't my strong suit? I guess you meant that in the impersonal sense...?
:roll:

I'll tell you what...you go back to spending your day slavering over new coaching prospects, and I will get back to work and wait for the next game. Have a great day.
Post Reply