A Dose Of College Football Reality For Oregon Fans
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
-
SuperDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 4671
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
- Location: Arizona, USA
- Contact:
A Dose Of College Football Reality For Oregon Fans
I've read, and participated in, a few threads of frustration over the past few days since our stunning loss to Colorado. Hey, I like for my Ducks to win, too!!!
Like many others here (and elsewhere), I had high expectations for this season. Why I don't know. No one was picking Oregon to win the Pac-12 North and MOST experts had them picked 3rd, behind Stanford and UW.
Still, I couldn't help but fantasize about another national championship run, a chance for redemption after a horrendous loss at "The Alamo" and an opportunity to shut down the naysayers who were talking about how my beloved Ducks had regressed. Unfortunately, that's not how things have turned out, and it may get worse before it gets better.
That being said, I still believe that Mark Helfrich is the right guy for the job.
I understand that expectations have become high at Oregon. Chip Kelly built upon what Mike Bellotti had begun (many of those players were recruited to Oregon under Bellotti).
The thing that most fans don't understand is that winning 10 games every year is both uncommon and unrealistic. I've had to remind myself of this recently, too.
I assure you that if Chip had stayed at Oregon, he would have had down years, too.
Look at this list of coaches who have a .750 winning percentage each year or better. Notice that only 5 are FBS level who are active. Those are Urban Meyer, Chris Petersen, Bob Stoops, Nick Saban and Gary Patterson.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_c ... percentage
Urban Meyer has won apx 85% of his games. That's an average of 10.2 wins per year at Bowling Green, Utah, Florida and Ohio State. That is an amazing feat that may never again be matched in this era of parity.
Chris Petersen has a .817 winning percentage at Boise State and UW. That means that he's averaging 9.8 wins per year. However, as good of a coach as I believe he is, you have to look at the competition he played while at Boise State and the fact that a string of other coaches had winning records there before he became head coach including Houston Nutt, Dirk Koetter and Dan Hawkins.
Bob Stoops has a .796 winning percentage but has had his share of down years, as well. That's an average of 9.5 wins per year. I do give kudos to Stoops for having won all of his games while at Oklahoma and also for not being afraid to schedule tough non-conference opponents.
Nick Saban is next at .760 percent with stops at Toledo (one year), Michigan State, LSU and Alabama. Even the great Nick Saban has only averaged just over 9 wins per season throughout his coaching career.
Gary Patterson rounds out the list at .753, all at TCU. Like Boise State, TCU wasn't in a Power-5 conference until just a few years ago, so many of Patterson's wins came vs non-Power-5 opponents. Still, his record is very respectable, but even he has only won 75% of his games! That's an average of 9 wins per season. That would be like a 9-3 season with a Bowl loss or an 8-4 season with a Bowl win.
Once again, I think that Mark Helfrich is a very good coach and that the Ducks WILL see greatness again, as long as he's given the time to right the ship.
Yes, there've been issues with developing QBs. Part of that problem, Scott Frost, is gone. Yes, there've been coaching gaffes this year that haven't been present in the past. Way too many penalties and a couple of "winnable" losses.
On the other hand, we also have 2 new coordinators, a new defensive scheme and right now have 11 freshman in the 2-deep.
My point is that we need to ease our expectations and be more realistic. As I said before in another thread, if we can challenge for the conference championship most years and make it to to the college football playoffs a couple times each decade, most people would consider that to be a fantastic coaching job. So would I and so should everyone else.
The numbers don't lie.
Like many others here (and elsewhere), I had high expectations for this season. Why I don't know. No one was picking Oregon to win the Pac-12 North and MOST experts had them picked 3rd, behind Stanford and UW.
Still, I couldn't help but fantasize about another national championship run, a chance for redemption after a horrendous loss at "The Alamo" and an opportunity to shut down the naysayers who were talking about how my beloved Ducks had regressed. Unfortunately, that's not how things have turned out, and it may get worse before it gets better.
That being said, I still believe that Mark Helfrich is the right guy for the job.
I understand that expectations have become high at Oregon. Chip Kelly built upon what Mike Bellotti had begun (many of those players were recruited to Oregon under Bellotti).
The thing that most fans don't understand is that winning 10 games every year is both uncommon and unrealistic. I've had to remind myself of this recently, too.
I assure you that if Chip had stayed at Oregon, he would have had down years, too.
Look at this list of coaches who have a .750 winning percentage each year or better. Notice that only 5 are FBS level who are active. Those are Urban Meyer, Chris Petersen, Bob Stoops, Nick Saban and Gary Patterson.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_c ... percentage
Urban Meyer has won apx 85% of his games. That's an average of 10.2 wins per year at Bowling Green, Utah, Florida and Ohio State. That is an amazing feat that may never again be matched in this era of parity.
Chris Petersen has a .817 winning percentage at Boise State and UW. That means that he's averaging 9.8 wins per year. However, as good of a coach as I believe he is, you have to look at the competition he played while at Boise State and the fact that a string of other coaches had winning records there before he became head coach including Houston Nutt, Dirk Koetter and Dan Hawkins.
Bob Stoops has a .796 winning percentage but has had his share of down years, as well. That's an average of 9.5 wins per year. I do give kudos to Stoops for having won all of his games while at Oklahoma and also for not being afraid to schedule tough non-conference opponents.
Nick Saban is next at .760 percent with stops at Toledo (one year), Michigan State, LSU and Alabama. Even the great Nick Saban has only averaged just over 9 wins per season throughout his coaching career.
Gary Patterson rounds out the list at .753, all at TCU. Like Boise State, TCU wasn't in a Power-5 conference until just a few years ago, so many of Patterson's wins came vs non-Power-5 opponents. Still, his record is very respectable, but even he has only won 75% of his games! That's an average of 9 wins per season. That would be like a 9-3 season with a Bowl loss or an 8-4 season with a Bowl win.
Once again, I think that Mark Helfrich is a very good coach and that the Ducks WILL see greatness again, as long as he's given the time to right the ship.
Yes, there've been issues with developing QBs. Part of that problem, Scott Frost, is gone. Yes, there've been coaching gaffes this year that haven't been present in the past. Way too many penalties and a couple of "winnable" losses.
On the other hand, we also have 2 new coordinators, a new defensive scheme and right now have 11 freshman in the 2-deep.
My point is that we need to ease our expectations and be more realistic. As I said before in another thread, if we can challenge for the conference championship most years and make it to to the college football playoffs a couple times each decade, most people would consider that to be a fantastic coaching job. So would I and so should everyone else.
The numbers don't lie.
John 3:36
- QuackininBama
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5741
- Joined: Sat Sep 10, 2011 8:55 am
Re: A Dose Of College Football Reality For Oregon Fans
I think what most people are observing is Helf without the benefit of CK's staff/players/scheme and its not pretty.
This is kinda the point. WHY? Why is his decision making so poor? Why are we on our 3rd defensive coordinator in 4 years? Why do we HAVE to start so many freshman? Why weren't the kids ready to step in when our seniors stepped out? Marcus stepped in when DT stepped out, smooth transition right? Why weren't we recruiting linebackers the year we went to the championship. I recall many of the fans here panicking in the "War Room" because they saw this year coming 2 years ago because we were recruiting so poorly. This is ALL on Helf. Its not about what you do THIS YEAR, its about what your doing for this year, AND the next two years and Helf is simply unprepared and hasn't shown much for the next two years either.On the other hand, we also have 2 new coordinators, a new defensive scheme and right now have 11 freshman in the 2-deep.
- QuackininBama
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5741
- Joined: Sat Sep 10, 2011 8:55 am
Re: A Dose Of College Football Reality For Oregon Fans
Let me put it this way. Michigan is recruiting terribly and they are being coached poorly. They end the 2014 season 5-7. Harbaugh steps in and in ONE YEAR takes the team to 10-3 beating Florida in the Citrus bowl and currently has them undefeated and ranked 4th in the nation. No excuses about "he needs to recruit his guys" or "his coordinators need time for the kids to develop in his system" or "he needs to change the culture of the program", none of that crap, his teams just win games.
Now you can say, "hey, Harbaugh is a great coach, its unfair to expect Helf to be the same kind of coach as Harbaugh". Ok fair enough, I don't. But I did want Helf to at least be able to keep the ship going in the right direction. I think its fair to say David Shaw is sure as hell no Harbaugh, but look what hes done. 57-14, 3 Rose Bowls, without checking it, 3 Pac-12 titles and currently ranked 7th in the nation with a Heisman candidate. Yea, that's how you do it when your left a Ferrari. You just keep it in 6th gear and don't downshift. I expected that and thus far, Helf is failing to maintain any momentum at all and we are heading back to the Rich Brooks era of Ducks football where 8 wins and the Holiday bowl was a great season. I just expected more.
Now you can say, "hey, Harbaugh is a great coach, its unfair to expect Helf to be the same kind of coach as Harbaugh". Ok fair enough, I don't. But I did want Helf to at least be able to keep the ship going in the right direction. I think its fair to say David Shaw is sure as hell no Harbaugh, but look what hes done. 57-14, 3 Rose Bowls, without checking it, 3 Pac-12 titles and currently ranked 7th in the nation with a Heisman candidate. Yea, that's how you do it when your left a Ferrari. You just keep it in 6th gear and don't downshift. I expected that and thus far, Helf is failing to maintain any momentum at all and we are heading back to the Rich Brooks era of Ducks football where 8 wins and the Holiday bowl was a great season. I just expected more.
- OregonFan4Life
- All-American
- Posts: 15450
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm
Re: A Dose Of College Football Reality For Oregon Fans
I get your point, but most people aren't asking for Helf to be Saban or Meyer, but we're asking to not lose to Colorado at home with their backup QB. Say Colorado is improved all you want, maybe it's true, but coming into this season, you all would've laughed at anyone who said Colorado would beat Oregon in Autzen with their freshman backup QB, and here we are and suddenly we're being unrealistic for wanting better. Whatever happens happens and I'll always support this team, but simply from watching this team, this is not the Oregon team we should be seeing.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6490
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: A Dose Of College Football Reality For Oregon Fans
I'd say keep our expectations high, but be more realistic in how we pursue them.My point is that we need to ease our expectations and be more realistic.
Quackinbama, you do bring up some good points (most people here do) but a couple quick counterpoints:
DT wasn't a once-in-a-generation Heisman-winning QB who recruits had to fear. Also, Mariota was a relative unknown, not being competed for by the big-name schools. It has been beaten to death here, but it's just much more difficult for a non-Alabama school to get top-tier recruits to sit behind a Heisman winner, which is why most teams that lose Heisman QBs only win nine games the next year.Marcus stepped in when DT stepped out
Helfrich doesn't get the props he deserves for trying to prevent that letdown by snagging VA and Prukop. If VA stays healthy, Oregon wins the Pac-12 last season and makes the playoffs for the second-consecutive season (and then Helf and Shaw are tied for conference titles, and maybe THIS is the first and only "down" year).
Yeah, I know. Woulda coulda shoulda. But the logic can't be ignored. Helfrich blazed a trail by bringing VA and Prukop up here. It was a FANTASTIC move. Sucks that VA got hurt, but that's life.
We were -- and whiffing. I follow the War Room chat, and that was a frustrating recruiting period. In hindsight, part of the issue may have been that everyone knew Nick Aliotti was about to retire, creating uncertainty at the position. But that whiffing started near the end of the Chip era, and our efforts certainly weren't helped by the ongoing Lyles investigation or the resulting sanctions, or constant questions of when (not if) Chip would bolt for the NFL. He was never an Oregon man.Why weren't we recruiting linebackers the year we went to the championship.
And regarding your general example about Michigan, which is definitely a valuable point... but we're talking apples and oranges. Helfrich inherited a team that was already weak in certain positions, and the transition of Chip to Helfrich did NOT help our recruiting. That was largely seen as a step down -- a once-in-a-program coach being replaced by some dude who isn't that guy. Michigan, on the other hand, transitioned from a coach that didn't have much respect to Jim Harbaugh, one of the most proven commodities money can buy. Not to mention, it's freaking Michigan, always loaded with talent and HUGE name recognition with staying power that vastly overwhelms Oregon's -- simply no denying that.
Here's a great read I just happened to find while writing this post: http://www.espn.com/college-football/st ... once-again
Harbaugh returning to Michigan is a lightning-in-a-bottle scenario, kind of like Chip coming to Oregon and pioneering the blur offense. It's not really realistic to expect Helfrich's time here to launch in the same way.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
-
dthomas=ddixon
- Moderator

- Posts: 8829
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
- Location: McMinnville, Oregon
Re: A Dose Of College Football Reality For Oregon Fans
We get it, he has a really good record over four years of coaching. What's his record going to look like after this season? That's important because his record is supporting for your entire argument.
How many fans actually want him fired because we aren't challenging for a national title every year? The vast majority of people who you've thrown into the panicking fan pile aren't upset just because we're losing games. It's HOW we are losing them.
I understand the massive amount over turnover that he's had to manage. It's the main reason I'm not to the point of wanting him fired. There's more to our struggles than coaching turnover though. How much coaching turnover and youth does it take for it to be acceptable for a top 10-15 program to have one of the very worst defenses on the nation? With, other than some wishful thinking, no real signs of improvement so far this season?
If you have an explanation for Helfrich folding in on himself in big moments, players calling each other out through the media for not caring/trying, a defense that is completely lost out on the field and for two years running, one of the worst in college football, leading the country in penalties, then let's hear it. But please, stop with throwing out Helf's declining winning percentage. The numbers are lying to you. And just because you won't acknowledge any of these issues for what they are doesn't mean the rest of us are spoiled fans in need of a "dose of college football reality."
You're a great member here and I'm sure you don't mean to come off this way but man, some of you Helf defenders need to get over yourselves. The condescending, pretentious nature of your posts is becoming nauseating.
How many fans actually want him fired because we aren't challenging for a national title every year? The vast majority of people who you've thrown into the panicking fan pile aren't upset just because we're losing games. It's HOW we are losing them.
I understand the massive amount over turnover that he's had to manage. It's the main reason I'm not to the point of wanting him fired. There's more to our struggles than coaching turnover though. How much coaching turnover and youth does it take for it to be acceptable for a top 10-15 program to have one of the very worst defenses on the nation? With, other than some wishful thinking, no real signs of improvement so far this season?
If you have an explanation for Helfrich folding in on himself in big moments, players calling each other out through the media for not caring/trying, a defense that is completely lost out on the field and for two years running, one of the worst in college football, leading the country in penalties, then let's hear it. But please, stop with throwing out Helf's declining winning percentage. The numbers are lying to you. And just because you won't acknowledge any of these issues for what they are doesn't mean the rest of us are spoiled fans in need of a "dose of college football reality."
You're a great member here and I'm sure you don't mean to come off this way but man, some of you Helf defenders need to get over yourselves. The condescending, pretentious nature of your posts is becoming nauseating.

- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: A Dose Of College Football Reality For Oregon Fans
Helfrich is an offensive coach who doesn't call plays, so the game plan each week should be spot on. We're back to playing checkers on offense as it doesn't appear early on that were running plays designed to have the defense reveal their game plan.
I understand the growing pains on Defense, but we also retained a coach in Pellum who has failed to put an average group out there, that's on Helf.
The film don't lie.
I understand the growing pains on Defense, but we also retained a coach in Pellum who has failed to put an average group out there, that's on Helf.
The film don't lie.

-
maxduck
- Senior
- Posts: 3763
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:37 pm
Re: A Dose Of College Football Reality For Oregon Fans
David Shaw finished 8-5 in his 4th year as head coach at Stanford, 5-4 in Pac-12 play. Only three victories against teams that finished their season with a winning record.QuackininBama wrote:Let me put it this way. Michigan is recruiting terribly and they are being coached poorly. They end the 2014 season 5-7. Harbaugh steps in and in ONE YEAR takes the team to 10-3 beating Florida in the Citrus bowl and currently has them undefeated and ranked 4th in the nation. No excuses about "he needs to recruit his guys" or "his coordinators need time for the kids to develop in his system" or "he needs to change the culture of the program", none of that crap, his teams just win games.
Now you can say, "hey, Harbaugh is a great coach, its unfair to expect Helf to be the same kind of coach as Harbaugh". Ok fair enough, I don't. But I did want Helf to at least be able to keep the ship going in the right direction. I think its fair to say David Shaw is sure as hell no Harbaugh, but look what hes done. 57-14, 3 Rose Bowls, without checking it, 3 Pac-12 titles and currently ranked 7th in the nation with a Heisman candidate. Yea, that's how you do it when your left a Ferrari. You just keep it in 6th gear and don't downshift. I expected that and thus far, Helf is failing to maintain any momentum at all and we are heading back to the Rich Brooks era of Ducks football where 8 wins and the Holiday bowl was a great season. I just expected more.
- QuackininBama
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5741
- Joined: Sat Sep 10, 2011 8:55 am
Re: A Dose Of College Football Reality For Oregon Fans
That was already accounted for in the overall win/loss record. But I will post the complete record here to make sure I am being as transparent as possible:maxduck wrote: David Shaw finished 8-5 in his 4th year as head coach at Stanford, 5-4 in Pac-12 play. Only three victories against teams that finished their season with a winning record.

- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6490
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: A Dose Of College Football Reality For Oregon Fans
So we're a VA broken finger away from Helfrich being Shaw's mirror image.
That's why I'm not panicking. Last year didn't end up like we'd hoped, but it wasn't a true "down" year in the sense that this year could be.
I don't like the term "Helf defender." I'm not defending the play of our defense or our stupid penalties. A better (but less palatable) term is I'm "accepting" them -- for now. I simply can't ignore the massive amount of transition that Helfrich inherited with this job, including not just his coaching moves but also the decisions of other coaches to leave (and Chip's actions which landed us with sanctions).
For me, next season is make-or-break. I'm not defending Helf as much as I'm withholding my judgement until a point which I feel is more logical for drawing conclusions. I want to see Hoke with a full year to recruit and install his D, I want to see Lubick develop as a playcaller, I want to see which players develop into playmakers and I want to see the QB who Helfrich entrusts with the keys for the next two or three years.
We're positioned to be dominant. If we're not, then we'll have a problem.
That's why I'm not panicking. Last year didn't end up like we'd hoped, but it wasn't a true "down" year in the sense that this year could be.
I don't like the term "Helf defender." I'm not defending the play of our defense or our stupid penalties. A better (but less palatable) term is I'm "accepting" them -- for now. I simply can't ignore the massive amount of transition that Helfrich inherited with this job, including not just his coaching moves but also the decisions of other coaches to leave (and Chip's actions which landed us with sanctions).
For me, next season is make-or-break. I'm not defending Helf as much as I'm withholding my judgement until a point which I feel is more logical for drawing conclusions. I want to see Hoke with a full year to recruit and install his D, I want to see Lubick develop as a playcaller, I want to see which players develop into playmakers and I want to see the QB who Helfrich entrusts with the keys for the next two or three years.
We're positioned to be dominant. If we're not, then we'll have a problem.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
-
SuperDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 4671
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
- Location: Arizona, USA
- Contact:
Re: A Dose Of College Football Reality For Oregon Fans
+1pezsez1 wrote:So we're a VA broken finger away from Helfrich being Shaw's mirror image.
That's why I'm not panicking. Last year didn't end up like we'd hoped, but it wasn't a true "down" year in the sense that this year could be.
I don't like the term "Helf defender." I'm not defending the play of our defense or our stupid penalties. A better (but less palatable) term is I'm "accepting" them -- for now. I simply can't ignore the massive amount of transition that Helfrich inherited with this job, including not just his coaching moves but also the decisions of other coaches to leave (and Chip's actions which landed us with sanctions).
For me, next season is make-or-break. I'm not defending Helf as much as I'm withholding my judgement until a point which I feel is more logical for drawing conclusions. I want to see Hoke with a full year to recruit and install his D, I want to see Lubick develop as a playcaller, I want to see which players develop into playmakers and I want to see the QB who Helfrich entrusts with the keys for the next two or three years.
We're positioned to be dominant. If we're not, then we'll have a problem.
I don't even necessarily see next year as "make or break". I just want to see significant improvement in all areas.
By the way, when I started the original post it was meant in reply to "Lukeyrid" who said in a different thread that "he'd be okay with 10-2 every year". That's why I brought up the stats, to show that there's only ONE active coach in FBS (who has a decent amount of tenure) who's averaging 10 wins per year.
John 3:36
-
dthomas=ddixon
- Moderator

- Posts: 8829
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
- Location: McMinnville, Oregon
Re: A Dose Of College Football Reality For Oregon Fans
Last year is actually the reason I have remaining faith in Helfrich. He weathered the awful start to the year (Even with Lockie at QB we had a top 10 offense statistically) and when VA was healthy our offense was never more potent. And while Pellum was his hire, he made a change and we I think we owe it to the program to let that play out.pezsez1 wrote:So we're a VA broken finger away from Helfrich being Shaw's mirror image.
That's why I'm not panicking. Last year didn't end up like we'd hoped, but it wasn't a true "down" year in the sense that this year could be.
I don't like the term "Helf defender." I'm not defending the play of our defense or our stupid penalties. A better (but less palatable) term is I'm "accepting" them -- for now. I simply can't ignore the massive amount of transition that Helfrich inherited with this job, including not just his coaching moves but also the decisions of other coaches to leave (and Chip's actions which landed us with sanctions).
For me, next season is make-or-break. I'm not defending Helf as much as I'm withholding my judgement until a point which I feel is more logical for drawing conclusions. I want to see Hoke with a full year to recruit and install his D, I want to see Lubick develop as a playcaller, I want to see which players develop into playmakers and I want to see the QB who Helfrich entrusts with the keys for the next two or three years.
We're positioned to be dominant. If we're not, then we'll have a problem.
I completely agree regarding next year. Short of a complete meltdown this season I want to see what they do next year. We'll have another mariota-esque Helfrich find at QB that could potentially be another program changer (sustain-er?).

-
picksix
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 354
- Joined: Sun Sep 27, 2009 10:00 am
Re: A Dose Of College Football Reality For Oregon Fans
If Chip stayed here... we'd at least have 9 wins every year Imo.
- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6490
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: A Dose Of College Football Reality For Oregon Fans
You are probably right. But Chip staying means less upheaval within the program and fewer whiffs in recruiting. We'd most likely be in a better place now.If Chip stayed here... we'd at least have 9 wins every year Imo.
We still would have had to deal with life after Marcus Mariota, and the rest of the country would have still adapted to our tempo, so hard to say, really.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40738
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: A Dose Of College Football Reality For Oregon Fans
Agreed. Unless a serious injury to a QB when down or something super extreme. But with the roster Oregon has right now, I'd like to think Chip would have em undefeated at this point.picksix wrote:If Chip stayed here... we'd at least have 9 wins every year Imo.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13