Talent level on "defense"
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
-
karlhungis
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7990
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:08 am
Talent level on "defense"
I hear the excuse thrown out a lot that we can't be expected to have any success on defense because we simply don't have the talent for it. So I decided that I would take a look. Below is the 2 deep on defense with the recruiting star rating next to each player. It is true that our talent level is fairly low but I don't think that it is low enough to be used as a scapegoat for the performance that we have seen thus far.
Overall average star rating for our 2 deep is 3.0 stars.
Our team is on the younger side with an average of 2.65 out of 4 (1pt for FR, 2 for SO, 3 for JR and 4 for SR), so essentially the average would be a red shirt sophomore.
DE 92 Mondeaux, Henry JR *** 45 Daniel, T.J. RS SR **
DT 47 Manu, Rex SO *** 74 George, Elijah RS JR **
DT 50 Maloata, Austin JR *** 99 Kaumatule, Canton SO **** 71 Tei-Kirby, Wayne FR ***
DE 11 Hollins, Justin RS SO *** 97 Jelks, Jalen RS SO ***
WLB 28 Ragin III, Johnny SR *** 54 McDowell, De'Quan SR N/A
MLB 55 Hotchkins, A.J. JR *** 46 Mattingly, Danny RS JR ***
SLB 35 Dye, Troy FR *** 3 Moi, Jonah RS JR ***
CB 2 Robinson, Tyree JR *** 14 Amadi, Ugo SO ****
S 43 Schooler, Brenden FR ** 17 Williams, Juwaan RS JR ***
S 26 Oliver, Khalil RS SO ** 8 Daniels, Reggie RS SR ***
CB 1 Springs, Arrion JR **** 23 Lovette, Malik RS FR ****
So we clearly have a relatively young team that doesn't have a ton of talent. I think that youth and talent would be a perfectly valid excuse of why we aren't a top 25 defense, maybe even top 50. You couldn't expect that type of play from this group of players. However, there is no excuse for this group to be outside of the top 100. There isn't THAT much youth and there is enough talent that a top 50 defense should be a realistic expectation.
If our coaches and fans accept that the talent level and or youth on this defense is the excuse for our abysmal performances, we are going to be doomed for a long time going forward.
Overall average star rating for our 2 deep is 3.0 stars.
Our team is on the younger side with an average of 2.65 out of 4 (1pt for FR, 2 for SO, 3 for JR and 4 for SR), so essentially the average would be a red shirt sophomore.
DE 92 Mondeaux, Henry JR *** 45 Daniel, T.J. RS SR **
DT 47 Manu, Rex SO *** 74 George, Elijah RS JR **
DT 50 Maloata, Austin JR *** 99 Kaumatule, Canton SO **** 71 Tei-Kirby, Wayne FR ***
DE 11 Hollins, Justin RS SO *** 97 Jelks, Jalen RS SO ***
WLB 28 Ragin III, Johnny SR *** 54 McDowell, De'Quan SR N/A
MLB 55 Hotchkins, A.J. JR *** 46 Mattingly, Danny RS JR ***
SLB 35 Dye, Troy FR *** 3 Moi, Jonah RS JR ***
CB 2 Robinson, Tyree JR *** 14 Amadi, Ugo SO ****
S 43 Schooler, Brenden FR ** 17 Williams, Juwaan RS JR ***
S 26 Oliver, Khalil RS SO ** 8 Daniels, Reggie RS SR ***
CB 1 Springs, Arrion JR **** 23 Lovette, Malik RS FR ****
So we clearly have a relatively young team that doesn't have a ton of talent. I think that youth and talent would be a perfectly valid excuse of why we aren't a top 25 defense, maybe even top 50. You couldn't expect that type of play from this group of players. However, there is no excuse for this group to be outside of the top 100. There isn't THAT much youth and there is enough talent that a top 50 defense should be a realistic expectation.
If our coaches and fans accept that the talent level and or youth on this defense is the excuse for our abysmal performances, we are going to be doomed for a long time going forward.
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
- QuackininBama
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5741
- Joined: Sat Sep 10, 2011 8:55 am
Re: Talent level on "defense"
I really thought Hoke would have this defense top 50 by midseason. I am literally SHOCKED they are so bad.QuackininBama wrote:WOW, couldn't be happier with this hire! WOW, GREAT news for the Ducks!!!!

This is just.............there are no words for it. How does a top level program even field such a bad defense? Literally, STATISTICALLY its nearly impossible with the recruits we are getting to be this bad. If you intentionally tried to field a defense this bad it would be difficult one would think???
-
rockthief
- Senior
- Posts: 4876
- Joined: Sun Nov 27, 2011 11:52 am
- Location: Stand By Me
Re: Talent level on "defense"
There is often a three star who kills it when he plays. Jelks and Dye are those guys. They did not play yesterday. Three star players are absolutely good enough to give us a D rated at least in the sixties or seventies with two or three guys like Jelks and Dye. We are one of the worst, however. I ache.
-
karlhungis
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7990
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:08 am
Re: Talent level on "defense"
Why didn't Dye make the trip?rockthief wrote:There is often a three star who kills it when he plays. Jelks and Dye are those guys. They did not play yesterday. Three star players are absolutely good enough to give us a D rated at least in the sixties or seventies with two or three guys like Jelks and Dye. We are one of the worst, however. I ache.
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
-
rockthief
- Senior
- Posts: 4876
- Joined: Sun Nov 27, 2011 11:52 am
- Location: Stand By Me
Re: Talent level on "defense"
There is a Dye rumor that he comes late to practice. He is a great player, but if this is true perhaps the decision will get him thinking straight. Love watching him play. I'd love to spend a couple of hours with him talking, walking, listening. He needs energetic guidance.
-
shoparound
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 791
- Joined: Sat Mar 19, 2016 1:56 am
Re: Talent level on "defense"
I am even more shocked that we aren't the worst in the Pac-12. I don't know how that's even possible.
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: Talent level on "defense"
That's more talent than the Gang Green D had coming out of HS. Probably more 4-5* on that depth chart than the 2000 or 2001 teams had. We have plenty of talent.karlhungis wrote:I hear the excuse thrown out a lot that we can't be expected to have any success on defense because we simply don't have the talent for it. So I decided that I would take a look. Below is the 2 deep on defense with the recruiting star rating next to each player. It is true that our talent level is fairly low but I don't think that it is low enough to be used as a scapegoat for the performance that we have seen thus far.
Overall average star rating for our 2 deep is 3.0 stars.
Our team is on the younger side with an average of 2.65 out of 4 (1pt for FR, 2 for SO, 3 for JR and 4 for SR), so essentially the average would be a red shirt sophomore.
DE 92 Mondeaux, Henry JR *** 45 Daniel, T.J. RS SR **
DT 47 Manu, Rex SO *** 74 George, Elijah RS JR **
DT 50 Maloata, Austin JR *** 99 Kaumatule, Canton SO **** 71 Tei-Kirby, Wayne FR ***
DE 11 Hollins, Justin RS SO *** 97 Jelks, Jalen RS SO ***
WLB 28 Ragin III, Johnny SR *** 54 McDowell, De'Quan SR N/A
MLB 55 Hotchkins, A.J. JR *** 46 Mattingly, Danny RS JR ***
SLB 35 Dye, Troy FR *** 3 Moi, Jonah RS JR ***
CB 2 Robinson, Tyree JR *** 14 Amadi, Ugo SO ****
S 43 Schooler, Brenden FR ** 17 Williams, Juwaan RS JR ***
S 26 Oliver, Khalil RS SO ** 8 Daniels, Reggie RS SR ***
CB 1 Springs, Arrion JR **** 23 Lovette, Malik RS FR ****
So we clearly have a relatively young team that doesn't have a ton of talent. I think that youth and talent would be a perfectly valid excuse of why we aren't a top 25 defense, maybe even top 50. You couldn't expect that type of play from this group of players. However, there is no excuse for this group to be outside of the top 100. There isn't THAT much youth and there is enough talent that a top 50 defense should be a realistic expectation.
If our coaches and fans accept that the talent level and or youth on this defense is the excuse for our abysmal performances, we are going to be doomed for a long time going forward.
-
duck541
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 531
- Joined: Wed Jan 12, 2011 3:05 pm
Re: Talent level on "defense"
Part of the problem (but not to excuse how terrible we've been) is that a lot of that talent doesn't seem to fit into what Hoke wants to do on D. He needs a good edge rusher and a penetrating DT. With Prevot gone and Jelks hurt Hollins is the only guy who really threatens as a pass rusher. Manu and Maloata were better suited for our previous scheme. And outside of Dye our LBs are either too small to shed blockers or just terrible on pass coverage. McDowell seems to be around the ball a lot, but he may be the worst tackler I've ever seen at this level. Somehow our secondary seems to be the strongest unit on D, and that should tell you all you need to know.
-
rockthief
- Senior
- Posts: 4876
- Joined: Sun Nov 27, 2011 11:52 am
- Location: Stand By Me
Re: Talent level on "defense"
duck451 I get what you are saying. I believe that a good player is one who can and will adjust to a given scheme. None of them are doing that. I don't get it. I'd think two or three would embrace Hoke's D.
- DmoneyDuck
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1587
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:18 pm
- Location: Portland, OR
- Contact:
Re: Talent level on "defense"
Is it time to put Nelson back at Safety? We have way too many playmakers at WR and not enough talent at Safety ... I know Nelson may not want to move, but this move makes too much sense, yeah?
-
Duck24
- Senior
- Posts: 4744
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: Talent level on "defense"
Making the switch from a 3-4 to a 4-3 is tough. You are recruiting two different types of players in the front 7 with those two schemes. That isn't an excuse for Hoke and the D, it's just a fact. Struggles were expected but this goes beyond struggles. It is a matter of being inept. If I never see a rush 3, drop 8 with 10 yard cushions on 3rd and 8 again, I can die a happy man.rockthief wrote:duck451 I get what you are saying. I believe that a good player is one who can and will adjust to a given scheme. None of them are doing that. I don't get it. I'd think two or three would embrace Hoke's D.
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: Talent level on "defense"
Another of a shockingly long list of bad decisions on D, by Helf. Why switch to a 4-3? Why hire a guy who's never been a DC? Helf had lots of options, and he made this hire. Helf can't blame anyone but himself.Duck24 wrote:Making the switch from a 3-4 to a 4-3 is tough. You are recruiting two different types of players in the front 7 with those two schemes. That isn't an excuse for Hoke and the D, it's just a fact. Struggles were expected but this goes beyond struggles. It is a matter of being inept. If I never see a rush 3, drop 8 with 10 yard cushions on 3rd and 8 again, I can die a happy man.rockthief wrote:duck451 I get what you are saying. I believe that a good player is one who can and will adjust to a given scheme. None of them are doing that. I don't get it. I'd think two or three would embrace Hoke's D.
5 teams in the conference hired new DC last season, and UO made the worst move of the 5. Id rather have seen it go to Chins, who I'm told was going to get the job, until the meltdown vs TCU. Then Helfrich was "encouraged" to go outside and make a hire.
-
Duck24
- Senior
- Posts: 4744
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: Talent level on "defense"
Completely agree, not letting anyone off the hook. He is paid a lot of money to make the right choices. It's been an unmitigated disaster thus far but Helf had to know there would be a transition period. My hope would be that with another recruiting class, we see drastic improvement next season, assuming he gets a second season.buckmarkduck wrote:Another of a shockingly long list of bad decisions on D, by Helf. Why switch to a 4-3? Why hire a guy who's never been a DC? Helf had lots of options, and he made this hire. Helf can't blame anyone but himself.Duck24 wrote:Making the switch from a 3-4 to a 4-3 is tough. You are recruiting two different types of players in the front 7 with those two schemes. That isn't an excuse for Hoke and the D, it's just a fact. Struggles were expected but this goes beyond struggles. It is a matter of being inept. If I never see a rush 3, drop 8 with 10 yard cushions on 3rd and 8 again, I can die a happy man.rockthief wrote:duck451 I get what you are saying. I believe that a good player is one who can and will adjust to a given scheme. None of them are doing that. I don't get it. I'd think two or three would embrace Hoke's D.
-
jimmy12
- Senior
- Posts: 2823
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:38 am
Re: Talent level on "defense"
OK-- If recruiting to the 4-3 is different than the 3-4 (which I believe it is), why am I not seeing a change in our recruiting strategy? What's the difference between last year and this in terms of targeted recruits? I am all for excuses of personnel, but what has changed in terms of targeted?
To me these are just excuses of why we are so bad. Also, why not break in some of these LB recruits from last year? It can't be any worse and they are playing special teams, let them get their feet wet while we are getting crushed.
To me these are just excuses of why we are so bad. Also, why not break in some of these LB recruits from last year? It can't be any worse and they are playing special teams, let them get their feet wet while we are getting crushed.
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: Talent level on "defense"
Fire Hoke today. Give Neal the DC job the rest of the year, and let the chips fall where they fall.