Q:
karlhungis wrote:Why change to a 4-3 of you don't have the bodies for it? Why not make it a 2-3 year plan but make the switch once you have the bodies?
A:
pezsez1 wrote:That's a great question that might be better answered by the many folks on this forum who were begging for this change to happen
Remember rushing three on third and long, playing zone pass D, and constantly giving up third down conversions?
Now we rush four, play zone pass D, and still give up long third down conversions.
Although I started the season as an admitted homer for the defense (which was sorta fun until Nebraska), I'm no Hoke apologist, but let me tell you why he gets more than just this year before I'm putting fault on his shoulders:
1. Oregon decided to move away from the 3-4 and hired a coach to implement a 4-3 defense. Presumably, the idea was field a more effective defense.
2. Although Oregon decided to field a 4-3 defense, part of the agreement with Coach Hoke (one must similarly presume), was that Oregon was going to retain its existing system. Coach Hoke brought none of his own assistants. He inherited the former demoted DC, Coaches Aiken and Neal, as well as their various sub assistants and GAs.
3. Out of a roster recruited for a 3-4 Coach Hoke is expected to field an effective 4-3 this year. Have a look at our roster and try and put together a starting front seven for a good 3-4. Mondeaux, Manu, and Daniel as the front three? Maybe Prevot, Hotchkins, Ragin, and Dye as linebackers. Ignoring for the moment that Prevot, Ragin and Dye are not currently available, does anyone think we have the pieces for a good 3-4 this year? I don't.
I'm not bagging on the kids so much as Oregon's system. I wondered prior to Fall Camp whether Oregon would adjust its practices in any way to focus on making the defense a priority. Perhaps to put a defense on the field that can save a faltering offense and finish a game if necessary. Recall Coach Hoke saying that practicing against spread offenses makes defenses soft? Pepridge Farms does.
The defense just isn't going to be pretty this year. If the AD wants to scrap Coach Hoke after one year, or even midseason this year, that's fine. But if that is decision is made can we at least go big and hire a defensive specialist who can bring in his own staff and just clear house on the entire defensive side? I'm not in favor of that approach but canning Coach Hoke to promote Coach Neal is the sort of interbreeding that got us to Coach Hoke in the first place.