I think what's needed is a giant step back when evaluating the Herbert situation.I find this sort of amusing. People were calling for helfrich to start Herbert cause Prukop was/is no good. Rumors make it sound like that will be the case and now some of y'all are saying it's a desperate move. Which is it. Anyone ever stop to think that Herbert got to Oregon late and it may have taken him some time to learn playbook etc? Maybe he is now fully up to speed and helfrich think he gives Oregon best shot to compete? Crazy I know
Imagine for second that VA didn't break his finger last season. Oregon probably loses one game, wins the Pac-12 and goes to the CFP. Now, here we are this year at 2-3, but Oregon fans are pretty happy with the program so Helfrich isn't getting any heat.
Does he still start Herbert on Saturday?
I think he does, given that our offense has regressed and Prukop's ceiling isn't high enough to compensate for our horrid defense. That, and it has been pretty clear that Herbert is the more skilled player who only needed time to develop. Now, several weeks after arriving for fall camp, Herbert seems ready to make that leap.
This move is only desperate if it doesn't make sense. Sure, the move isn't ideal -- I'd rather start a less-talented Prukop if the offense were humming a bit more predictably -- but it definitely makes sense.

