I think one of the largest misconceptions I have seen is that, for the long-time Duck fans calling for change at the top is as follows:
No one is saying Helfrich is a bad person, no one is saying he is stupid, no one is saying he is a bad father, husband, sibling, son, etc. I really have yet to see one PERSONAL insult aimed at him in any article or post. We know the man was going to be a surgeon, he was in student council in HS and at SOU and he was a great QB at an NAIA school. FishDuck and most of you on here who know more about football than I have noted the slight changes he has made to our vertical passing game to bring it more to the forefront than Charles S. Kelly did. Look at what the man did with Hendricks (sp?) at BSU, Walter at ASU and he took the Buff offense under Hawkins from absolutely God-awful to only slightly terrible ("Go play intramurals brother!")
What I believe most of us are questioning is along these lines...is Mark Helfrich wired to lead 105 completely different teenagers from various parts of the country and all walks of life into a collective, focused unit with 100% total and absolute buy-in?
I do not believe there are 128 men in the country that can do that on a regular basis, and there are 128 HC positions at the FBS/CFPB level. The few that can do it are the elite coaches.
A few examples:
Why does Harbough turn teams around so quickly? He inspires total buy-in. He's a goofy SOB who wears adminsitrators out, but the guy has proven at USD, LjS,Jr., 49ers and now UM that he can get teens and grown men to immediately buy-in.
PJ Fleck - its corny, but "row the boat" is a simple mantra and implies all 105 and all the staffers get together and get in the same direction.
Chris Peterson - He had a young team in 2014, 2015 and still has mostly Sark's guys, but he has inspird 100% buy-in through a very quiet, calm confident-in-his-ways swagger.
Urban Meyer and Nick Saban - don't necesarliy do anything better X and O's wise (and yes they have recruiting advantages in geography and allegedly "questionable" practices) but I guaruntee you that if you were at a cocktail party with Urbs and Nicky, you'd know where they were in a room, even without them saying a word.
Not everyone has this trait. It can be gained many ways. Out of love, out of fear, out of confidence, out of loyalty...however it is gained, the point is that the buy-in is there.
I am not calling for the dismisal of Helf and the return of Chip or Frost, but relating closer to home as Ducks you can find many comments written and tales told from Chip's former players (some settled here in the Portland area) that you just "felt a different energy" when Chip, Frost, Azz or Aliotti walked into a room. Aliotti's guys would jump off the Mo for him, same with Azz.
Frost has a quiet confidence in himself and his personal faith, that when combined with his physical size and looks many people misinterpret as "cockiness" (listen to the man speak at a chuch sometime, he's actually quite humble, but he is 100% true to his beliefs and doesn't waver...I digress due to my #Frostmancrush).
With Chip, even the kids who "didn't like him" fell in line and bought in because they knew he was no BS, he unconditionally cared about them as people and he treated every player equal. You had expectations and if you didn't meet them, you were disciplined, #1-#105. Kids buy-in to a leader like that. You want a confident swagger? Look at the way Erin Andrews looked at Chip whenever she interviewed him. Look at his cute girlfriend now. I believe dude was voted "biggest flirt" (or something like that) in his HS Yearbook in NH. I have had female friends who were servers at the PDX airport who have served him before. They told me that even though he isn't in the greatest shape there was just something magnetic about him that draws you to the guy.
It is not an easy task. Few are up to it, but that trait, above all else is what I think separates the Top 30 teams in the country. Buy-in can even keep a team in games with physically superior opponents (see: Boise State BCS wins). Buy-in also can fade from year to year. Some coaches have it one year, some coaches lose it the next, some get it every other year, but the elite coaches have it every year, and in the down/young team/poor recruiting/rebuliding years, their buy-in yields a 7-5 record instead of 10-2 or 11-1.
Anyway, if you made it this far, thanks for reading my glorious novel. The point of this is that I believe Helf is smart and has talent, but those talents might not include leading a105 dudes at Top 25 Program.


