Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Yes
39
60%
NO
26
40%
 
Total votes: 65
User avatar
lukeyrid13
All-American
Posts: 10475
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
GM: Portland TrailBlazers

Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Post by lukeyrid13 »

pezsez1 wrote:
Instead, one should take a glimpse at he overall picture of helf
This is so hard to do with Helfrich. No other coach in Oregon's FB program history has had to overcome such massive transitions, including following behind a once-in-a-generation coach (made possibly by the moment as much as the man) and also the loss of a Heisman QB. Throw in sanctions from the previous coach, recruiting whiffs, coordinator changes and this year's unfortunate rash of injuries, and you have... well, three winning seasons and a losing season. Not all bad.

I recently hopped on the "Fire Helf" bandwagon because of how we got embarrassed at home against Stanford. We just seemed to look too discombobulated to have decent coaching, and after awhile the excuses of youth/injuries/new schemes start getting old. But then we win a game like this, which proves the coaches have control and the players haven't quit, and suddenly it seems injuries/youth might really be a big part of the problem.

As I said above, I'm glad I'm not the one getting paid big bucks to make this decision, and I trust that those who do have far more information than we do. If Helfrich stays, then he'll deserve another chance. If he's fired, then he'll deserve that too. We just don't know.

Hell of a game today, though. Helfrich and his staff must be doing something right. Is it enough? We'll find out soon, I'm sure.
How many games do you think we have played above our potential in the last 4 years vs how many games have we vastly underachieved?

I would say that Arizona in 14 and Florida state in 14, Stanford 15 and Utah this year we overachieved and I felt our coaching staff was outstanding.

In contrast, these are the games I feel like we underachieved: Stanford 13, Arizona 13, Oregon state 13, wazzu 14, Arizona 14, wazzu 15, Utah 15, Eastern Washington 15, OSU 15, TCU 15(1st half was exceptional though) Colorado 16, wazzu 16, Washington 16, uc Davis and Virginia 16.

Just my opinion but there is a far greater track record of coming in unprepared and being out coached.
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

I certainly would hope one game does not give Helfrich a pass, regardless of what happens against the Beavers. They could put 80 on them and would still want Helfrich fired. The losses and the way Oregon lost falls on the coaches. Prior to last year we had not lost a game at Autzen by 42... we follow it up with a loss by more than that to Washington this year. A win against Utah should not salvage Helfrich from being fired. The excuses about injuries or being young are the same excuses the Huskies used for many years and they were stuck being mediocre. Is that what we want out of coach. They also don't talk about winning... well that is probably good... they have won 4 games so why talk about winning when are 4-7. Injuries and graduations are part of college football. You don't hear the coaches who have won championships complain about being young or injuries. We have gone the graduation route when it comes to a starting quarterback the last 2 years because could not develop a quarterback after Mariotta left. These are all things the head coach is responsible for. Chip never lost a game by 42 at home or on the road for that matter. Helfrich has lost multiple games by that the last 2 years. How many fans will not renew their season tickets if Helfrich still the coach in 2017. I think will be lots who will not renew. I had tickets for 16 years. The product on the field this year... and last year against Utah not worth the money the university is charging their season ticket holders.
Lightning Strikes
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 251
Joined: Sat Nov 27, 2010 10:07 am

Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Post by Lightning Strikes »

Bearing an absolute ass kicking in the Civil War, Helfrich won't be fired. The buyout is too big, and there isn't a coach out there who could do much better with the team and staff transition he's had this year.

I'll still say that Helfrich is a very good football coach, I just question his ability to motivate a lot of these kids. This team has lacked passion too many times this season for my liking, and I think that usually starts on the defensive side of the ball.
User avatar
QuackininBama
All Pac-12
Posts: 5741
Joined: Sat Sep 10, 2011 8:55 am

Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Post by QuackininBama »

No, hes as good as gone. I'm betting Knight has been working behind the scenes for over a month to search for a new coach and we will hear something when the season is over. Hopefully we can Row The Boat, we will see.
User avatar
Duckenstein
Freshman
Posts: 1433
Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2016 7:43 pm

Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Post by Duckenstein »

Fire him regardless.

One last second victory and another over an equally hapless opponent would be uplifting but shouldn't save his job.
karlhungis
All Pac-12
Posts: 7990
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:08 am

Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Post by karlhungis »

Lightning Strikes wrote: there isn't a coach out there who could do much better with the team and staff transition he's had this year.
I wholeheartedly disagree with this statement.
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Post by buckmarkduck »

Lightning Strikes wrote:Bearing an absolute ass kicking in the Civil War, Helfrich won't be fired. The buyout is too big, and there isn't a coach out there who could do much better with the team and staff transition he's had this year.

I'll still say that Helfrich is a very good football coach, I just question his ability to motivate a lot of these kids. This team has lacked passion too many times this season for my liking, and I think that usually starts on the defensive side of the ball.
You saw that team yesterday right? If that team had had a coach who inspired them all year, they beat Nebraska, CU and cal. We don't give up 70, or even 50 to UW, there's a good chance we make a game of it in Pullman and we don't make Stanford look like a top ten team.
ducksrock
Senior
Posts: 2739
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 8:08 am

Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Post by ducksrock »

buckmarkduck wrote:
Lightning Strikes wrote:Bearing an absolute ass kicking in the Civil War, Helfrich won't be fired. The buyout is too big, and there isn't a coach out there who could do much better with the team and staff transition he's had this year.

I'll still say that Helfrich is a very good football coach, I just question his ability to motivate a lot of these kids. This team has lacked passion too many times this season for my liking, and I think that usually starts on the defensive side of the ball.
You saw that team yesterday right? If that team had had a coach who inspired them all year, they beat Nebraska, CU and cal. We don't give up 70, or even 50 to UW, there's a good chance we make a game of it in Pullman and we don't make Stanford look like a top ten team.

Spot on... truer words have never been spoken
Duck24
Senior
Posts: 4744
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Post by Duck24 »

buckmarkduck wrote:
Lightning Strikes wrote:Bearing an absolute ass kicking in the Civil War, Helfrich won't be fired. The buyout is too big, and there isn't a coach out there who could do much better with the team and staff transition he's had this year.

I'll still say that Helfrich is a very good football coach, I just question his ability to motivate a lot of these kids. This team has lacked passion too many times this season for my liking, and I think that usually starts on the defensive side of the ball.
You saw that team yesterday right? If that team had had a coach who inspired them all year, they beat Nebraska, CU and cal. We don't give up 70, or even 50 to UW, there's a good chance we make a game of it in Pullman and we don't make Stanford look like a top ten team.
If Oregon was 7-4, beating Nebrask/Colorado/Cal and was respectable in their losses to Wazzu/Stanford/USC/UW, wouldn't everyone still be clamoring for Helf's head?
User avatar
OregonFan4Life
All-American
Posts: 15450
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm

Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Post by OregonFan4Life »

Duck24 wrote:
buckmarkduck wrote:
Lightning Strikes wrote:Bearing an absolute ass kicking in the Civil War, Helfrich won't be fired. The buyout is too big, and there isn't a coach out there who could do much better with the team and staff transition he's had this year.

I'll still say that Helfrich is a very good football coach, I just question his ability to motivate a lot of these kids. This team has lacked passion too many times this season for my liking, and I think that usually starts on the defensive side of the ball.
You saw that team yesterday right? If that team had had a coach who inspired them all year, they beat Nebraska, CU and cal. We don't give up 70, or even 50 to UW, there's a good chance we make a game of it in Pullman and we don't make Stanford look like a top ten team.
If Oregon was 7-4, beating Nebrask/Colorado/Cal and was respectable in their losses to Wazzu/Stanford/USC/UW, wouldn't everyone still be clamoring for Helf's head?
Not at all maybe some would but I certainly wouldn't, cause 7-4 is drastically different than 4-7 and we wouldn't have as many losses due to poor coaching. I said before the season Helf only should be fired if we have a losing season and here we are.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Image
pdxduck2013
Freshman
Posts: 1431
Joined: Sun Jul 28, 2013 5:20 pm

Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Post by pdxduck2013 »

Since the question posed was whether we think a Civil War win keeps him from getting fired, rather than do we as fans think he should keep his job:

I think it does, with the team finishing with a 5-7 record. As has been said, the buyout is large this year and much smaller after next season (I think the "Phil hates Helf and will put up all the money himself" narrative is overblown, unless anyone knows Phil personally and has heard him say this). They'll also likely take the 3 9+ win seasons (regardless of what Chip did before) and the one losing season into consideration together. (I get the "regression" narrative so I don't need to hear it again). Generally coaches don't get fired after one losing season.

On top of that, there are the major injuries and the young team components that they'll likely consider as well. I think the combination of everything leads them to keep him for one more year.

From an availability of coaches standpoint, this is a bad year to be looking for a head coach, with openings at LSU and likely both Texas and Notre Dame. UCLA might have an opening too.

I could see an assistant coach or two getting canned though...maybe Pellum retires? If Ron Gould gets fired as HC at UC Davis, I could see Campbell retiring and Gould coming in to replace him.
karlhungis
All Pac-12
Posts: 7990
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:08 am

Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Post by karlhungis »

pdxduck2013 wrote:Since the question posed was whether we think a Civil War win keeps him from getting fired, rather than do we as fans think he should keep his job:

I think it does, with the team finishing with a 5-7 record. As has been said, the buyout is large this year and much smaller after next season (I think the "Phil hates Helf and will put up all the money himself" narrative is overblown, unless anyone knows Phil personally and has heard him say this). They'll also likely take the 3 9+ win seasons (regardless of what Chip did before) and the one losing season into consideration together. (I get the "regression" narrative so I don't need to hear it again). Generally coaches don't get fired after one losing season.

On top of that, there are the major injuries and the young team components that they'll likely consider as well. I think the combination of everything leads them to keep him for one more year.

From an availability of coaches standpoint, this is a bad year to be looking for a head coach, with openings at LSU and likely both Texas and Notre Dame. UCLA might have an opening too.

I could see an assistant coach or two getting canned though...maybe Pellum retires? If Ron Gould gets fired as HC at UC Davis, I could see Campbell retiring and Gould coming in to replace him.
Mora and Brian Kelly aren't going anywhere. I don't think the coach hunt will be any worse this year than any other year.
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
cesame
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 102
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:47 pm

Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Post by cesame »

I question how great of a win it is. Utah had no business being ranked that high. Just look at their schedule.

Wins are against

Southern Utah
BYU
San Jose St
USC (record below .500 at the time)
Arizona
Oregon State
UCLA
Arizona State

If beating an overrated Utah team saves his job then well......
User avatar
Alan
Senior
Posts: 4359
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Post by Alan »

Without a doubt it was the Ducks best performance of the season and has many second guessing their screams for Helf's head. The Ducks certainly lost games this season do to poor coaching decisions, repeated 2point tries for example. Myself, I still leaning toward replacing him, but I liked what I saw yesterday and I know a new coach could also be a step backwards. Hoke is a big name coach, who failed at Michigan but still a big name, this years D is worse than last years. Also, as reported yesterday, the Ducks have 22 players in the two deep who are freshman and sophomores..... that's young. I'll hold my own decision until after the civil war, my foremost thought is a new coach is not a guarantee of better days.......the Huskies post Don James, Nebraska post Tom Osborn, USC post Pete Carroll (yes they had sanctions).
cesame
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 102
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:47 pm

Re: Will a civil war victory save Helfrich's job?

Post by cesame »

And Utah also lost to Cal.....

How do you lose to both Oregon and Cal, who are statistically the two worst ranked defenses in the entire country?
Post Reply