Most over and under appreciated Ducks in recent history
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
- Alan
- Senior
- Posts: 4359
- Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm
Most over and under appreciated Ducks in recent history
I have to give credit to Stevetech for this subject, he asked the question on another thread, I thought it was good enough question it deserved it own thread.
In recent history, since 1990 or so, who is the most under-appreciated and the most over-appreciated duck? I have mine but why start a shyt storm right away. In the other thread someone said Joey was the most over-appreciated. For the record I completely disagree. It was a great time with Joey at the helm to be a Duck fan.
In recent history, since 1990 or so, who is the most under-appreciated and the most over-appreciated duck? I have mine but why start a shyt storm right away. In the other thread someone said Joey was the most over-appreciated. For the record I completely disagree. It was a great time with Joey at the helm to be a Duck fan.
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: Most over and under appreciated Ducks in recent history
Since 2007:
Under- Byron Marshall (1,000 yard seasons receiving and rushing)
Over- Keanon Lowe (kind of your classic 'BUT HIS INTANGIBLES WERE INCREDIBLE' guy who didn't actually contribute much)
runners up
Under- Darron Thomas
Over- De'Anthony Thomas
Under- Byron Marshall (1,000 yard seasons receiving and rushing)
Over- Keanon Lowe (kind of your classic 'BUT HIS INTANGIBLES WERE INCREDIBLE' guy who didn't actually contribute much)
runners up
Under- Darron Thomas
Over- De'Anthony Thomas
-
duckfan22
- Senior
- Posts: 2698
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm
Re: Most over and under appreciated Ducks in recent history
Under- Darron Thomas as well all he did was win.
over- Arik Armstead A lot of hype but seemed to dissappear at times
over- Arik Armstead A lot of hype but seemed to dissappear at times
- Alan
- Senior
- Posts: 4359
- Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Most over and under appreciated Ducks in recent history
I won't use the word "most" with him but before his "we smoked it all" days Cliff Harris was under appreciated. Exciting on punt returns and a ball hawk on D. Plus he installed terms that are still used today nationally.
- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6489
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: Most over and under appreciated Ducks in recent history
Wow, great topic!
Under: I'm going to dig back to my years at UofO and say fullback Josh Line, a local walk-on who ended up starting for our 2001 Fiesta Bowl team, paving the way for Maurice Morris and Onterrio Smith.
Over: Pains me to say this, but Thomas Tyner. Home-grown kid who had the size and skill to be the best in the country... but between issues of injury and desire, he never came close to reaching his potential. Having Royce Freeman helped stem Tyner's bust, but man... what might have been.
Under: I'm going to dig back to my years at UofO and say fullback Josh Line, a local walk-on who ended up starting for our 2001 Fiesta Bowl team, paving the way for Maurice Morris and Onterrio Smith.
Over: Pains me to say this, but Thomas Tyner. Home-grown kid who had the size and skill to be the best in the country... but between issues of injury and desire, he never came close to reaching his potential. Having Royce Freeman helped stem Tyner's bust, but man... what might have been.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
-
BTJ201
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 253
- Joined: Sat Apr 02, 2016 7:12 pm
Re: Most over and under appreciated Ducks in recent history
Under: JJ Jerimiah Johnson was a absolute beast but seemed like J. stew got all the love.
Over: Colt Lyerla expected the world from him and was always hurt or in trouble seemed like
Over: Colt Lyerla expected the world from him and was always hurt or in trouble seemed like
Last edited by BTJ201 on Tue Jan 03, 2017 10:48 am, edited 1 time in total.
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: Most over and under appreciated Ducks in recent history
I think there's a difference between over-hyped and over-appreciated. Definitely agree that Tyner (though affected by injuries) and Colt were over-hyped. I don't know how many people look back fondly at their careers, though.
-
BTJ201
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 253
- Joined: Sat Apr 02, 2016 7:12 pm
Re: Most over and under appreciated Ducks in recent history
Over-hyped may be the wrong word for those 2, but they certainly didn't live up to the General hype surrounding them.StevensTechU wrote:I think there's a difference between over-hyped and over-appreciated. Definitely agree that Tyner (though affected by injuries) and Colt were over-hyped. I don't know how many people look back fondly at their careers, though.
- Alan
- Senior
- Posts: 4359
- Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: Most over and under appreciated Ducks in recent history
While I love the topic it does leave room for grey area. For example DAT, he did great thing while a Duck, exciting to watch, I still remember the looks on the faces of the Kansas St fans when DAT returned to opening kick off for a TD. But without a doubt he shut it down a bunch his last year here, he wasn't the same DAT, should tha play a factor in his over or under rating? Same,with Arik and some others.BTJ201 wrote:Over-hyped may be the wrong word for those 2, but they certainly didn't live up to the General hype surrounding them.StevensTechU wrote:I think there's a difference between over-hyped and over-appreciated. Definitely agree that Tyner (though affected by injuries) and Colt were over-hyped. I don't know how many people look back fondly at their careers, though.
- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6489
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: Most over and under appreciated Ducks in recent history
Good point.I think there's a difference between over-hyped and over-appreciated. Definitely agree that Tyner (though affected by injuries) and Colt were over-hyped. I don't know how many people look back fondly at their careers, though.
I'd probably say Arik Armstead then.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
-
dthomas=ddixon
- Moderator

- Posts: 8826
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
- Location: McMinnville, Oregon
Re: Most over and under appreciated Ducks in recent history
I would never have thought it but after seeing these responses I may have to include DAT on my under appreciated list ha. He was such a big part of what made Oregon "cool" during that run; he was a STAR in the college football world and brought a lot of attention to the program that it wouldn't have gotten otherwise. His final year was a dud but it didn't change what he did the previous two years.
Over: Nick Aliotti. I like NA but the awful post-NA years have caused people to look back on his tenure more positively than they should. He was always behind the curve and only fielded very average defenses until Chip took over and brought in Azz.
Under: Vernon Adams. I thought this before the debacle of last season and it's only more true after we saw how bad the team was without him. Without him I think we would have had a season similar to this past years; we certainly saw glimpses of it when he was hurt. With his ability to evade pass rushers and throw the deep ball he had our offense more dynamic than I've ever seen it before. If he had been a 2-3 year play I believe we would hold him in as high regard as we do guys like Mariota, DT, DD, Joey, etc.
Over: Nick Aliotti. I like NA but the awful post-NA years have caused people to look back on his tenure more positively than they should. He was always behind the curve and only fielded very average defenses until Chip took over and brought in Azz.
Under: Vernon Adams. I thought this before the debacle of last season and it's only more true after we saw how bad the team was without him. Without him I think we would have had a season similar to this past years; we certainly saw glimpses of it when he was hurt. With his ability to evade pass rushers and throw the deep ball he had our offense more dynamic than I've ever seen it before. If he had been a 2-3 year play I believe we would hold him in as high regard as we do guys like Mariota, DT, DD, Joey, etc.

- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6489
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: Most over and under appreciated Ducks in recent history
Over: Nick Aliotti. I like NA but the awful post-NA years have caused people to look back on his tenure more positively than they should. He was always behind the curve and only fielded very average defenses until Chip took over and brought in Azz.
Hahaha, I actually had him as my "under" Duck, but deleted it because I didn't want to start up the same-old arguments. (Our Gang Green defense and Harrington-era defenses were pretty damn good, too... he consistently did more with less... and he was ahead of the curve with his hockey-style substitutions and development of depth to accommodate the blur... and now, many defenses employ those principles to deal with uptempo teams).
Also, for the record, I haven't seen anyone who wanted NA fired suddenly come back around and say, "You know, I was wrong, he was a good DC." People seem pretty entrenched in their beliefs. It's just harder now to portray him as a lesser DC given the context of the past few years.
One thing we might all agree on... I think NA needs his own special category as the most divisive Duck ever. I definitely wouldn't call him over-appreciated though. Arik Armstead was regarded as a good, above-average player who most fans appreciated, even though we all knew he never reached his potential. Nick Aliotti hardly received that same level of appreciation from Duck fans, even when his defenses were killing it.
Last edited by pezsez1 on Tue Jan 03, 2017 12:26 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
- QuackininBama
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5740
- Joined: Sat Sep 10, 2011 8:55 am
Re: Most over and under appreciated Ducks in recent history
Under-Michael Clay Under sized but play with smarts, heart and intensity. After seeing our linebacking corps after he left you realize just what he brought to the team.
Over-gotta jump on the Arik Armstead bandwagon. Lots of hype, and had the potential to be All-World but felt like he was going half speed to save himself for the NFL most of the time.
Over-gotta jump on the Arik Armstead bandwagon. Lots of hype, and had the potential to be All-World but felt like he was going half speed to save himself for the NFL most of the time.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: Most over and under appreciated Ducks in recent history
Terrance Whitehead is one that comes to mind. Enoka Lucas another on Offense and I think Kellen Clemens would have excelled in all of the offenses we've run.
Defensively Kevin Mitchell stands out to me as another guy that probably doesn't get the level of recognition he deserves.
Defensively Kevin Mitchell stands out to me as another guy that probably doesn't get the level of recognition he deserves.

-
Wildcat-Duck
- One Star Recruit
- Posts: 51
- Joined: Mon Jan 03, 2011 3:41 pm
Re: Most over and under appreciated Ducks in recent history
Under: D. Thomas, Jeremiah Johnson.
Over: pains me to say...DAT
Over: pains me to say...DAT