Pretty Sobering Account of What Transpired Last Season

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Post Reply
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6489
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Pretty Sobering Account of What Transpired Last Season

Post by pezsez1 »

Helfrich's incoherent ramblings where lots of words were spoken, but nothing was said were infuriating. Would be pretty hard for the players to rally behind someone who lacks the kind of mental clarity to express even simple ideas. Taggart seems like a big improvement in that department. I will not miss the classic Helf lines like "We don't talk about winning", and "We are winning most of the days".
I also take issue with this... seems like an attempt to insult Helf's intelligence. Mental clarity has absolutely nothing to do with the ability to communicate.

Like all things, communication is a skill. Some people suck at it, others don't. Different people are often stronger in conveying different kinds of messages. During my time in journalism, I was gifted in quickly absorbing large, complex documents and breaking it down in ways grade-school kids could understand -- but that doesn't mean I'd be good in a corporate communications role.

Anyway, let's keep it real and focus on football. I get what the poster here was trying to say -- that young players might struggle to get fired up by a guy who doesn't necessarily have a magnetic personality -- but let's please try to avoid the inadvertent (and inaccurate) insults.

All that said... wow, I was wrong about Helf. He wasn't a good head coach for our program, and another year could have been disastrous. I'm glad we let him go. And once again I'm thankful to have been exposed to other Duck fans with contradictory positions.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
z99clark11
One Star Recruit
Posts: 26
Joined: Thu Jan 12, 2017 2:08 pm

Re: Pretty Sobering Account of What Transpired Last Season

Post by z99clark11 »

Duck07 wrote:GTFO on Aiken. His unit was by far the best on Defense during his time here and attacking him for not being a Dog is a stupid pot shot that doesn't hold weight, especially with all of the other problems we had. Pellum, Neal and Hoke all deserve far more blame on the defense than Aiken does.

He was out a place in the 43 but nothing was wrong with the DL by and large when we were 1 gapping. Mark could have had an all star cast of coaches but we know now that he couldn't have led them. Don't blame a Major for the General's problems.
I have to respectfully disagree with you here. His unit was great early on because he had great players recruited by his predecessor. You and I could get out there and put together a solid unit if 2/3 guys we coach are first round freaks. But what happens when Azz's guys are gone? Aiken didn't recruit. China has to recruit linebackers and d line. The one "stud" Oregon got on the d line after Azz was recruited by Chins and not Aiken, and he's now retired. Pellum wasn't a good promotion. Neal is still a good coach. His guys are always going to look bad back there when your d line can't get any pressure on the quarterback.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Pretty Sobering Account of What Transpired Last Season

Post by Duck07 »

z99clark11 wrote:
Duck07 wrote:GTFO on Aiken. His unit was by far the best on Defense during his time here and attacking him for not being a Dog is a stupid pot shot that doesn't hold weight, especially with all of the other problems we had. Pellum, Neal and Hoke all deserve far more blame on the defense than Aiken does.

He was out a place in the 43 but nothing was wrong with the DL by and large when we were 1 gapping. Mark could have had an all star cast of coaches but we know now that he couldn't have led them. Don't blame a Major for the General's problems.
I have to respectfully disagree with you here. His unit was great early on because he had great players recruited by his predecessor. You and I could get out there and put together a solid unit if 2/3 guys we coach are first round freaks. But what happens when Azz's guys are gone? Aiken didn't recruit. China has to recruit linebackers and d line. The one "stud" Oregon got on the d line after Azz was recruited by Chins and not Aiken, and he's now retired. Pellum wasn't a good promotion. Neal is still a good coach. His guys are always going to look bad back there when your d line can't get any pressure on the quarterback.
You haven't sold me one iota that Aiken is A-the single worst hire that Helfrich made and B- that the DL was our worst unit during his time. I'm done defending Neal as his Dbs quit defending themselves on the field.
Image
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40738
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Pretty Sobering Account of What Transpired Last Season

Post by UOducksTK1 »

Duck07 wrote:
z99clark11 wrote:
Duck07 wrote:GTFO on Aiken. His unit was by far the best on Defense during his time here and attacking him for not being a Dog is a stupid pot shot that doesn't hold weight, especially with all of the other problems we had. Pellum, Neal and Hoke all deserve far more blame on the defense than Aiken does.

He was out a place in the 43 but nothing was wrong with the DL by and large when we were 1 gapping. Mark could have had an all star cast of coaches but we know now that he couldn't have led them. Don't blame a Major for the General's problems.
I have to respectfully disagree with you here. His unit was great early on because he had great players recruited by his predecessor. You and I could get out there and put together a solid unit if 2/3 guys we coach are first round freaks. But what happens when Azz's guys are gone? Aiken didn't recruit. China has to recruit linebackers and d line. The one "stud" Oregon got on the d line after Azz was recruited by Chins and not Aiken, and he's now retired. Pellum wasn't a good promotion. Neal is still a good coach. His guys are always going to look bad back there when your d line can't get any pressure on the quarterback.
You haven't sold me one iota that Aiken is A-the single worst hire that Helfrich made and B- that the DL was our worst unit during his time. I'm done defending Neal as his Dbs quit defending themselves on the field.
I've always thought Neal did a good job recruiting and developing players. He's pumped a good share of guys into the NFL. Like Zac said, our DB group had the most stress on them in general due to our lack of a dominant front 7 (with the exception of a few good years in the late NA days).

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Pretty Sobering Account of What Transpired Last Season

Post by Duck07 »

Meh, the DB technique the last few years became very porous, like Neal checked in once Pellum was promoted. At some point the 10 yards off combined with abysmal tackling or coverage isn't on Pellum and Hokes play calls but what's going on in positional work. I'd also argue the DL got just as much of a raw deal in our schemes the last few seasons as any other. How often were we all screaming for rushing 4 or even bringing a blitz in game threads and it never came? Expecting a one gap odd front to rush the passer without bringing four or more but talking about how difficult it is for the DBs and blaming the DL is disingenuous at best.
Image
User avatar
FlDuckFan
All Pac-12
Posts: 5068
Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:45 am
GM: Orlando Magic GM
Location: Florida

Re: Pretty Sobering Account of What Transpired Last Season

Post by FlDuckFan »

Duck07 wrote:Meh, the DB technique the last few years became very porous, like Neal checked in once Pellum was promoted. At some point the 10 yards off combined with abysmal tackling or coverage isn't on Pellum and Hokes play calls but what's going on in positional work. I'd also argue the DL got just as much of a raw deal in our schemes the last few seasons as any other. How often were we all screaming for rushing 4 or even bringing a blitz in game threads and it never came? Expecting a one gap odd front to rush the passer without bringing four or more but talking about how difficult it is for the DBs and blaming the DL is disingenuous at best.
While I agree with you , DL play was just a poor as the rest of the defense. Guys were constantly getting pushed back into the linebackers laps, along with sloppy technique .
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Pretty Sobering Account of What Transpired Last Season

Post by Duck07 »

FlDuckFan wrote:
Duck07 wrote:Meh, the DB technique the last few years became very porous, like Neal checked in once Pellum was promoted. At some point the 10 yards off combined with abysmal tackling or coverage isn't on Pellum and Hokes play calls but what's going on in positional work. I'd also argue the DL got just as much of a raw deal in our schemes the last few seasons as any other. How often were we all screaming for rushing 4 or even bringing a blitz in game threads and it never came? Expecting a one gap odd front to rush the passer without bringing four or more but talking about how difficult it is for the DBs and blaming the DL is disingenuous at best.
While I agree with you , DL play was just a poor as the rest of the defense. Guys were constantly getting pushed back into the linebackers laps, along with sloppy technique .
I agree they weren't a great unit, I just took offense to the notion that they and their coach were the worst group.
Image
z99clark11
One Star Recruit
Posts: 26
Joined: Thu Jan 12, 2017 2:08 pm

Re: Pretty Sobering Account of What Transpired Last Season

Post by z99clark11 »

Duck07 wrote:Meh, the DB technique the last few years became very porous, like Neal checked in once Pellum was promoted. At some point the 10 yards off combined with abysmal tackling or coverage isn't on Pellum and Hokes play calls but what's going on in positional work. I'd also argue the DL got just as much of a raw deal in our schemes the last few seasons as any other. How often were we all screaming for rushing 4 or even bringing a blitz in game threads and it never came? Expecting a one gap odd front to rush the passer without bringing four or more but talking about how difficult it is for the DBs and blaming the DL is disingenuous at best.
I do blame the d line. Part of running a four man, one gapping front is to get pressure on the qb. Before this year the last time that we really ran a 4 man front was the 2010 season. That year the starting front four combined for 17 sacks. This year the entire d line (not just the starting front four, but every single guy that took a snap on the d line) combined for 13.5 sacks. Now you say that you don't blame the coach? Why not? These guys either had terrible knowledge, technique, or skill to only have 13.5 sacks on the year. And all three of those things fall on the coach. The d line had the least amount of talent on the defense (outside of McDowell) and it showed in their play. They were by far the worst unit on the defense. It starts up front and trickles back. I don't care how good your linebackers are if your d line sucks. They will suck. That's why big guys are drafted first. Teams know where you have to build from.
z99clark11
One Star Recruit
Posts: 26
Joined: Thu Jan 12, 2017 2:08 pm

Re: Pretty Sobering Account of What Transpired Last Season

Post by z99clark11 »

Duck07 wrote:
FlDuckFan wrote:
Duck07 wrote:Meh, the DB technique the last few years became very porous, like Neal checked in once Pellum was promoted. At some point the 10 yards off combined with abysmal tackling or coverage isn't on Pellum and Hokes play calls but what's going on in positional work. I'd also argue the DL got just as much of a raw deal in our schemes the last few seasons as any other. How often were we all screaming for rushing 4 or even bringing a blitz in game threads and it never came? Expecting a one gap odd front to rush the passer without bringing four or more but talking about how difficult it is for the DBs and blaming the DL is disingenuous at best.
While I agree with you , DL play was just a poor as the rest of the defense. Guys were constantly getting pushed back into the linebackers laps, along with sloppy technique .
I agree they weren't a great unit, I just took offense to the notion that they and their coach were the worst group.
Idk why you would take offense to it. They were the worst group. Aiken, as a whole was the worst coach we had defensively. He should be as embarrassed by the product that he put on the field as I was for having to watch those guys wear the Oregon uniform.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Pretty Sobering Account of What Transpired Last Season

Post by Duck07 »

z99clark11 wrote:
Duck07 wrote:
FlDuckFan wrote:
Duck07 wrote:Meh, the DB technique the last few years became very porous, like Neal checked in once Pellum was promoted. At some point the 10 yards off combined with abysmal tackling or coverage isn't on Pellum and Hokes play calls but what's going on in positional work. I'd also argue the DL got just as much of a raw deal in our schemes the last few seasons as any other. How often were we all screaming for rushing 4 or even bringing a blitz in game threads and it never came? Expecting a one gap odd front to rush the passer without bringing four or more but talking about how difficult it is for the DBs and blaming the DL is disingenuous at best.
While I agree with you , DL play was just a poor as the rest of the defense. Guys were constantly getting pushed back into the linebackers laps, along with sloppy technique .
I agree they weren't a great unit, I just took offense to the notion that they and their coach were the worst group.
Idk why you would take offense to it. They were the worst group. Aiken, as a whole was the worst coach we had defensively. He should be as embarrassed by the product that he put on the field as I was for having to watch those guys wear the Oregon uniform.
Worse than the LBs? You for real?
Image
User avatar
UofO8
Senior
Posts: 2538
Joined: Wed Nov 04, 2009 3:41 pm

Re: Pretty Sobering Account of What Transpired Last Season

Post by UofO8 »

Anyone that thinks Aiken was worse than Pellum is delusional. Our LB's have been our worse part of defense by far and it's not even close.
Image
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Pretty Sobering Account of What Transpired Last Season

Post by Duck07 »

z99clark11 wrote:
Duck07 wrote:Meh, the DB technique the last few years became very porous, like Neal checked in once Pellum was promoted. At some point the 10 yards off combined with abysmal tackling or coverage isn't on Pellum and Hokes play calls but what's going on in positional work. I'd also argue the DL got just as much of a raw deal in our schemes the last few seasons as any other. How often were we all screaming for rushing 4 or even bringing a blitz in game threads and it never came? Expecting a one gap odd front to rush the passer without bringing four or more but talking about how difficult it is for the DBs and blaming the DL is disingenuous at best.
I do blame the d line. Part of running a four man, one gapping front is to get pressure on the qb. Before this year the last time that we really ran a 4 man front was the 2010 season. That year the starting front four combined for 17 sacks. This year the entire d line (not just the starting front four, but every single guy that took a snap on the d line) combined for 13.5 sacks. Now you say that you don't blame the coach? Why not? These guys either had terrible knowledge, technique, or skill to only have 13.5 sacks on the year. And all three of those things fall on the coach. The d line had the least amount of talent on the defense (outside of McDowell) and it showed in their play. They were by far the worst unit on the defense. It starts up front and trickles back. I don't care how good your linebackers are if your d line sucks. They will suck. That's why big guys are drafted first. Teams know where you have to build from.
Why is it that Aiken gets all of the blame for our DL and not Hoke in your opinion? I don't believe our 34 years under Aiken saw terrible DL play but you believe otherwise. You seem to have a bone to pick with Aiken alone for our defensive problems. I don't think 3 DL are going to win against 5 or 6 pass blockers all game and that was largely our scheme for bringing pressure until this year when we started to see just 2.

I'm not crying that Aiken is gone and should still be here, but I think it was clear that our play calls and lack of a defensive mindset hurt our DL more than Aiken did. For example I can already guess that when the DL is the best unit defensively next year you will say that is proof Aiken sucked, Joe is amazing and ignore the schematic differences between the two.
Image
z99clark11
One Star Recruit
Posts: 26
Joined: Thu Jan 12, 2017 2:08 pm

Re: Pretty Sobering Account of What Transpired Last Season

Post by z99clark11 »

Duck07 wrote:
z99clark11 wrote:
Duck07 wrote:
FlDuckFan wrote:
Duck07 wrote:Meh, the DB technique the last few years became very porous, like Neal checked in once Pellum was promoted. At some point the 10 yards off combined with abysmal tackling or coverage isn't on Pellum and Hokes play calls but what's going on in positional work. I'd also argue the DL got just as much of a raw deal in our schemes the last few seasons as any other. How often were we all screaming for rushing 4 or even bringing a blitz in game threads and it never came? Expecting a one gap odd front to rush the passer without bringing four or more but talking about how difficult it is for the DBs and blaming the DL is disingenuous at best.
While I agree with you , DL play was just a poor as the rest of the defense. Guys were constantly getting pushed back into the linebackers laps, along with sloppy technique .
I agree they weren't a great unit, I just took offense to the notion that they and their coach were the worst group.
Idk why you would take offense to it. They were the worst group. Aiken, as a whole was the worst coach we had defensively. He should be as embarrassed by the product that he put on the field as I was for having to watch those guys wear the Oregon uniform.
Worse than the LBs? You for real?
I guess agree to disagree on this one. I'm a d line guy so I'm harder on them. Our linebackers were bad but at least there was a bright spot or two. Our d line was pitiful and there were absolutely no bright spots.
z99clark11
One Star Recruit
Posts: 26
Joined: Thu Jan 12, 2017 2:08 pm

Re: Pretty Sobering Account of What Transpired Last Season

Post by z99clark11 »

Duck07 wrote:
z99clark11 wrote:
Duck07 wrote:Meh, the DB technique the last few years became very porous, like Neal checked in once Pellum was promoted. At some point the 10 yards off combined with abysmal tackling or coverage isn't on Pellum and Hokes play calls but what's going on in positional work. I'd also argue the DL got just as much of a raw deal in our schemes the last few seasons as any other. How often were we all screaming for rushing 4 or even bringing a blitz in game threads and it never came? Expecting a one gap odd front to rush the passer without bringing four or more but talking about how difficult it is for the DBs and blaming the DL is disingenuous at best.
I do blame the d line. Part of running a four man, one gapping front is to get pressure on the qb. Before this year the last time that we really ran a 4 man front was the 2010 season. That year the starting front four combined for 17 sacks. This year the entire d line (not just the starting front four, but every single guy that took a snap on the d line) combined for 13.5 sacks. Now you say that you don't blame the coach? Why not? These guys either had terrible knowledge, technique, or skill to only have 13.5 sacks on the year. And all three of those things fall on the coach. The d line had the least amount of talent on the defense (outside of McDowell) and it showed in their play. They were by far the worst unit on the defense. It starts up front and trickles back. I don't care how good your linebackers are if your d line sucks. They will suck. That's why big guys are drafted first. Teams know where you have to build from.
Why is it that Aiken gets all of the blame for our DL and not Hoke in your opinion? I don't believe our 34 years under Aiken saw terrible DL play but you believe otherwise. You seem to have a bone to pick with Aiken alone for our defensive problems. I don't think 3 DL are going to win against 5 or 6 pass blockers all game and that was largely our scheme for bringing pressure until this year when we started to see just 2.

I'm not crying that Aiken is gone and should still be here, but I think it was clear that our play calls and lack of a defensive mindset hurt our DL more than Aiken did. For example I can already guess that when the DL is the best unit defensively next year you will say that is proof Aiken sucked, Joe is amazing and ignore the schematic differences between the two.
I'm an equal opportunity hater. The scheme has not been good. I do blame hoke and then Pellum for that. But still, when it comes down to it this game is all about talent. Aiken was supposed to be the primary recruiter for the defensive line. its not that he couldn't recruit, it's that he didn't recruit. Some of the guys that saw the field should never have gotten the opportunity to wear the green (and black and white and yellow and blue and etc).
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Pretty Sobering Account of What Transpired Last Season

Post by Duck07 »

z99clark11 wrote:
Duck07 wrote:
z99clark11 wrote:
Duck07 wrote:
FlDuckFan wrote:
Duck07 wrote:Meh, the DB technique the last few years became very porous, like Neal checked in once Pellum was promoted. At some point the 10 yards off combined with abysmal tackling or coverage isn't on Pellum and Hokes play calls but what's going on in positional work. I'd also argue the DL got just as much of a raw deal in our schemes the last few seasons as any other. How often were we all screaming for rushing 4 or even bringing a blitz in game threads and it never came? Expecting a one gap odd front to rush the passer without bringing four or more but talking about how difficult it is for the DBs and blaming the DL is disingenuous at best.
While I agree with you , DL play was just a poor as the rest of the defense. Guys were constantly getting pushed back into the linebackers laps, along with sloppy technique .
I agree they weren't a great unit, I just took offense to the notion that they and their coach were the worst group.
Idk why you would take offense to it. They were the worst group. Aiken, as a whole was the worst coach we had defensively. He should be as embarrassed by the product that he put on the field as I was for having to watch those guys wear the Oregon uniform.
Worse than the LBs? You for real?
I guess agree to disagree on this one. I'm a d line guy so I'm harder on them. Our linebackers were bad but at least there was a bright spot or two. Our d line was pitiful and there were absolutely no bright spots.
Two years ago Mondeaux and Jelks looked like two bright young DEs. I'm hopeful they go back to that in our new scheme and that we can get decent NT play. We do need to get better in the trenches defensively and I think we just picked up a great coach in Joe, but there wasn't much any DL coach could have done with those schemes.
Image
Post Reply