Which of the young defensive players are significant pieces?

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8822
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Which of the young defensive players are significant pie

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

I don't think it's fair to make a final judgement on our defensive players, especially the young ones, just yet. It will be really interesting to see what the new staff can do with what is supposed to be a talent void defense. We'll see but I suspect people will be surprised.
Image
polyduck
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 533
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2009 9:26 pm
Location: Vancouver. WA

Re: Which of the young defensive players are significant pie

Post by polyduck »

ifuwant2 wrote:
polyduck wrote:Let's not HATE on last years defensive squad now. Hate on the system and who implemented it! Let the new staff do their job and evaluate the existing roster. I honestly believe that some of these kids that you're hating on will "rise to the occasion" and respond accordingly to the new coaching staff and be major contributors this upcoming season!
Thanks Poly for the reminder. I think most of us fans really want these kids to succeed. Most importantly we want them to get their degrees and go out into the world and be difference makers. The problem for these kids is they've had 2 straight years of really bad defense. Maybe the worst in the history of major college football over a 2 year span. We can blame a lot of that on the coaches. But there's also a lot of film with kids just getting killed head-to-head, and too much film of kids running away from contact and making basic mistakes. If these kids want to be taken seriously, they are going to have to go out there and prove it. Sure, fans shouldn't be so rough on them. The kids put in a lot of hours. Respect to them for that. However, until this defensive group proves something on Saturdays, they are what they are.
I-2....point taken. That's where we as fans need to take a step back.....BREATH.....let the coaching staff assess what they have to work with and watch and see who competes, works their A$$ off & steps up. If those same kids that were starting last year can't keep up....step aside, and NEXT MAN UP!

#lezdodisDucks!
Groundswell
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 753
Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm

Re: Which of the young defensive players are significant pie

Post by Groundswell »

dthomas=ddixon wrote:I don't think it's fair to make a final judgement on our defensive players, especially the young ones, just yet. It will be really interesting to see what the new staff can do with what is supposed to be a talent void defense. We'll see but I suspect people will be surprised.
This is my hope. But I'm heading into season #3 of hope. At some point reality is reality. The juniors and seniors are pretty much on tape and are what they are. I'm sure some of them will have better years, but I don't know how many of them have the chance to bust-out and be flat-out studs. Maybe Jelks? Maybe Springs puts it all together for a full season? It's the 2015, 16, and 17 class who we really have to hope can turn the ship around. And we've seen enough of the 2015 class to have doubts.

Edit: Looking at the 2015 Defensive commits, we have Amadi, Baker, Manu, Carlberg, Moi and Cumberlaner. That's it. Not many guys.

I do hope to be surprised. We certainly have really good coaches. We just have a long ways to go.
Last edited by Groundswell on Fri Feb 03, 2017 2:35 pm, edited 1 time in total.
ttrag2418
One Star Recruit
Posts: 87
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2017 10:44 pm

Re: Which of the young defensive players are significant pie

Post by ttrag2418 »

polyduck wrote:
ifuwant2 wrote:
polyduck wrote:Let's not HATE on last years defensive squad now. Hate on the system and who implemented it! Let the new staff do their job and evaluate the existing roster. I honestly believe that some of these kids that you're hating on will "rise to the occasion" and respond accordingly to the new coaching staff and be major contributors this upcoming season!
Thanks Poly for the reminder. I think most of us fans really want these kids to succeed. Most importantly we want them to get their degrees and go out into the world and be difference makers. The problem for these kids is they've had 2 straight years of really bad defense. Maybe the worst in the history of major college football over a 2 year span. We can blame a lot of that on the coaches. But there's also a lot of film with kids just getting killed head-to-head, and too much film of kids running away from contact and making basic mistakes. If these kids want to be taken seriously, they are going to have to go out there and prove it. Sure, fans shouldn't be so rough on them. The kids put in a lot of hours. Respect to them for that. However, until this defensive group proves something on Saturdays, they are what they are.
I-2....point taken. That's where we as fans need to take a step back.....BREATH.....let the coaching staff assess what they have to work with and watch and see who competes, works their A$$ off & steps up. If those same kids that were starting last year can't keep up....step aside, and NEXT MAN UP!

#lezdodisDucks!

Keep in mind that Leavitt just took a Colorado D that was nearly ranked last in the nation to #8 over a 2 year time frame. I'm guessing that when he came in to Colorado there was not a lot to work with and he got them turned around pretty quick. I'm thinking that at the minimum he is inheriting a better cast this time around. Very hopeful that we will see significant progress defensively over the next two seasons.
duckfan22
Senior
Posts: 2698
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm

Re: Which of the young defensive players are significant pie

Post by duckfan22 »

one thing we wont hear is excuses from this staff.. We wont have to hear how there working harder
and its part of the process what ever that was. Willie T and staff are pretty up front and no excuse type
coaches. I hoped last year at this time of year that the defense would be fixed and better... I was wrong.
Not going to get excited just yet. That is one side of the ball i need to see it happen.
Everythingsducky
Senior
Posts: 2821
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 2:40 pm

Re: Which of the young defensive players are significant pie

Post by Everythingsducky »

ttrag2418 wrote:
polyduck wrote:
ifuwant2 wrote:
polyduck wrote:Let's not HATE on last years defensive squad now. Hate on the system and who implemented it! Let the new staff do their job and evaluate the existing roster. I honestly believe that some of these kids that you're hating on will "rise to the occasion" and respond accordingly to the new coaching staff and be major contributors this upcoming season!
Thanks Poly for the reminder. I think most of us fans really want these kids to succeed. Most importantly we want them to get their degrees and go out into the world and be difference makers. The problem for these kids is they've had 2 straight years of really bad defense. Maybe the worst in the history of major college football over a 2 year span. We can blame a lot of that on the coaches. But there's also a lot of film with kids just getting killed head-to-head, and too much film of kids running away from contact and making basic mistakes. If these kids want to be taken seriously, they are going to have to go out there and prove it. Sure, fans shouldn't be so rough on them. The kids put in a lot of hours. Respect to them for that. However, until this defensive group proves something on Saturdays, they are what they are.
I-2....point taken. That's where we as fans need to take a step back.....BREATH.....let the coaching staff assess what they have to work with and watch and see who competes, works their A$$ off & steps up. If those same kids that were starting last year can't keep up....step aside, and NEXT MAN UP!

#lezdodisDucks!

Keep in mind that Leavitt just took a Colorado D that was nearly ranked last in the nation to #8 over a 2 year time frame. I'm guessing that when he came in to Colorado there was not a lot to work with and he got them turned around pretty quick. I'm thinking that at the minimum he is inheriting a better cast this time around. Very hopeful that we will see significant progress defensively over the next two seasons.
Agree, to an extent. That Colorado team, supposedly was senior heavy, and had a lot of experience (yes, at losing). He will be rebuilding, and working in a ton of young players. I hope his enthusiasm, and hopefully knowledge, translates to a positive, but just not sure with what he has to work with. Were the players AND coaches that bad? If so, it could take some time. Hopefully he is a miracle worker. Can't be any worse than I has been.
User avatar
DuckedOut
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 292
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2017 12:05 pm

Re: Which of the young defensive players are significant pie

Post by DuckedOut »

dthomas=ddixon wrote:I don't think it's fair to make a final judgement on our defensive players, especially the young ones, just yet. It will be really interesting to see what the new staff can do with what is supposed to be a talent void defense. We'll see but I suspect people will be surprised.
Yeah, the ideology that there's no talent on our defense and that our players on that side of the ball are garbage is just false. Most of them are talented kids who suffered from receiving incredibly poor coaching and working in flawed defensive schemes. Granted there are some players that I question why they are on the field, especially a veteran or two, but some of these young guys can become really good players if they get coached up...and they will get coached up.

I don't see our defense being a top 50 unit next year, but they will get stops and they will play better. Leavitt will make sure of that.
Groundswell
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 753
Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm

Re: Which of the young defensive players are significant pie

Post by Groundswell »

DuckedOut wrote:
dthomas=ddixon wrote:I don't think it's fair to make a final judgement on our defensive players, especially the young ones, just yet. It will be really interesting to see what the new staff can do with what is supposed to be a talent void defense. We'll see but I suspect people will be surprised.
Yeah, the ideology that there's no talent on our defense and that our players on that side of the ball are garbage is just false. Most of them are talented kids who suffered from receiving incredibly poor coaching and working in flawed defensive schemes. Granted there are some players that I question why they are on the field, especially a veteran or two, but some of these young guys can become really good players if they get coached up...and they will get coached up.

I don't see our defense being a top 50 unit next year, but they will get stops and they will play better. Leavitt will make sure of that.
I think it'll have to be the 2016 & 2017 guys. We have to have a lot of those 2016 guys pan out since we already lost Kirby and Franklin. Maybe Briscoe too if he's not coming to work-outs. Means we can't afford busts. The problem for the 2015 class is guys like Baker, Carlberg, and Manu are going to have to really come on or they are going to get passed up on the depth chart. Amadi is a nice corner. And Cumberlaner really needs to break out soon. Yes, our defense should make a nice jump next year. But I think 2018 is when things start coming together a bit.
Post Reply