Did we get the right 3 stars?

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Post Reply
Groundswell
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 753
Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm

Did we get the right 3 stars?

Post by Groundswell »

I found this article that's a fun read. I haven't seen it on the forums yet, so forgive me if I've missed it. I don't think all the logic is sound, but it's interesting and fun. So after reading it, if you feel like it, who do you think are our 3 stars that could be major gets under the ideas promoted in this article:

http://www.footballstudyhall.com/2017/2 ... g-rankings
srsmiley007
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 745
Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2013 11:26 am

Re: Did we get the right 3 stars?

Post by srsmiley007 »

ifuwant2 wrote:I found this article that's a fun read. I haven't seen it on the forums yet, so forgive me if I've missed it. I don't think all the logic is sound, but it's interesting and fun. So after reading it, if you feel like it, who do you think are our 3 stars that could be major gets under the ideas promoted in this article:

http://www.footballstudyhall.com/2017/2 ... g-rankings
Thanks. Interesting read. The QB to LB take is wonkie because of the physical difference in playing LB, taking on OL, instinct, etc. but the rest has some merit. The safety to LB take is also off. I used to look for those kids as a hard hitting safety is often the best athlete and capable of playing many positions based upon size.

Anyway, here's my take for best 3 stars, I removed any of the players that had 4 stars on any of the services. IMPACT PLAYERS ARE IN BOLD.


CONTRIBUTORS IN 2017:
Austin Faoliu, DL, 6-3, 285, Santa Ana, Calif. (Mater Dei HS) 3*
- Will likely see minutes at NT this season. Eventual Starter or see's significant minutes at NT, DE in 3-4, impact player.

Jordon Scott, DT, 6-1, 350, Largo, Fla. (Pinellas Park Senior HS) 3*
- Eventual starter at NT, will be elite if controls weight. See him starting at some point this season. IMPACT PLAYER

Johnny Johnson III, WR, 6-0, 194, Chandler, Ariz. (Chandler HS) 3*
- See's minutes this season at WR. Runs excellent routes. Think Keenon Lowe but faster, better body control & hands. His route consistency and ability vs press make him a solid contributor.

Adam Stack, K, 6-2, 175, Honolulu, Hawaii (Kamehameha) 2*
- Starts in 2017 and changes our punt game. No more 25-30 yd punts. Flips the field for us, helps our D instantly! IMPACT PLAYER.

Darrian McNeal, WR, 5-9, 160, Seffner, Fla. (Armwood HS) 3*
- Possible ST player, plays significant snaps at slot in 2018. Reminds me of DAT. IMPACT PLAYER

REDSHIRTS:
Billy Gibson, S, 6-1, 185, Hialeah, Fla. (Miami Southridge HS) 3*
- RS, Role player, likely bust.

Nick Pickett, S, 6-1, 187, Los Angeles, Calif. (Salesian HS) 3*
- RS, Role player.

Popo Aumavae, OL, 6-4, 315, Stockton, Calif. (St. Mary's HS) 3*
- RS, plays/starts in 2-3 years at guard.

Daewood Davis, WR, 6-2, 175, Hollywood, Fla. (Deerfield Beach HS) 3*
- RS likely, plays in 2018 unless we get a ton of injuries this season at WR. IMPACT PLAYER

Darrian Felix, RB, 5-11, 194, Fort Myers, Fla. (Fort Myers HS) 3*
- RS, Significant contributor in 2018, etc. See him playing slot and RB. IMPACT PLAYER

Cody Shear, OL, 6-4, 285, Eugene, Ore. (Sheldon HS) 3*
- RS, plays OG or OC in 3rd/4th year unless Hanson gets injured. Could start in 2018 as our long-snapper. Switch to Center and his ability to long snap poses some real possibilities. I think he'll surprise us in 3years, excellent athlete. Project player.

CJ Verdell, RB, 5-9, 195, Chula Vista, Calif. (Mater Dei Catholic HS) 3*
- RS, 2018 Starter or Gets Significant Time. IMPACT PLAYER

Demetri Burch, ATH, 5-11, 181, Apopka, Fla. (Apopka HS) 3*
- RS, Decent role player, (at issue is number of possible players at slot/wr - Redd, McNeal, Mitchell, Ofodile, etc.) doesn't see time except on special teams until.
Likely bust or just role player.

Cyrus Habibi-Likio, ATH, 6-1, 211, Mountain View, Calif. (St. Francis HS) 3*
- RS, Good get, eventually contributes at either SS or LB, my bet is at LB depending upon depth. Starter in 2-3 years.
Groundswell
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 753
Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm

Re: Did we get the right 3 stars?

Post by Groundswell »

The article does have some interesting logic at work that I don't necessarily agree with, but a couple things stuck out at me: 1. Recruiting athletes at qb with an eye towards moving them elsewhere. 2. Finding run stopping defensive lineman and not getting wrapped up in pass rushing. 3. Looking for kids who blow-up during their senior year. Anthony Pandy would be a great example of this.

Now, the PAC throws the ball a lot, so you do need pass rushers, but I do buy into finding guys who can't be moved off the line of scrimmage, even if they don't have gaudy statistics. Gotta stop the run. A dude who can tie up a couple blockers and separate with the hands may be more valuable than a mobile kid who moves around but can't beat blocks once the OL gets into him. The late bloomer thing makes sense, but the question is how do you get to those kids early enough so that it doesn't look like you were slow-playing them at the last minute. Almost all the athletes we recruited this year played quarterback in high school, or at least took a lot of snaps at qb. Unfortunately, I can't see any of them transitioning to any other position besides slot/rb. Maybe Burch could play db?
User avatar
Duckenstein
Freshman
Posts: 1433
Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2016 7:43 pm

Re: Did we get the right 3 stars?

Post by Duckenstein »

srsmiley007 wrote:
ifuwant2 wrote:I found this article that's a fun read. I haven't seen it on the forums yet, so forgive me if I've missed it. I don't think all the logic is sound, but it's interesting and fun. So after reading it, if you feel like it, who do you think are our 3 stars that could be major gets under the ideas promoted in this article:

http://www.footballstudyhall.com/2017/2 ... g-rankings
Thanks. Interesting read. The QB to LB take is wonkie because of the physical difference in playing LB, taking on OL, instinct, etc. but the rest has some merit. The safety to LB take is also off. I used to look for those kids as a hard hitting safety is often the best athlete and capable of playing many positions based upon size.

Anyway, here's my take for best 3 stars, I removed any of the players that had 4 stars on any of the services. IMPACT PLAYERS ARE IN BOLD.


CONTRIBUTORS IN 2017:
Austin Faoliu, DL, 6-3, 285, Santa Ana, Calif. (Mater Dei HS) 3*
- Will likely see minutes at NT this season. Eventual Starter or see's significant minutes at NT, DE in 3-4, impact player.

Jordon Scott, DT, 6-1, 350, Largo, Fla. (Pinellas Park Senior HS) 3*
- Eventual starter at NT, will be elite if controls weight. See him starting at some point this season. IMPACT PLAYER

Johnny Johnson III, WR, 6-0, 194, Chandler, Ariz. (Chandler HS) 3*
- See's minutes this season at WR. Runs excellent routes. Think Keenon Lowe but faster, better body control & hands. His route consistency and ability vs press make him a solid contributor.

Adam Stack, K, 6-2, 175, Honolulu, Hawaii (Kamehameha) 2*
- Starts in 2017 and changes our punt game. No more 25-30 yd punts. Flips the field for us, helps our D instantly! IMPACT PLAYER.

Darrian McNeal, WR, 5-9, 160, Seffner, Fla. (Armwood HS) 3*
- Possible ST player, plays significant snaps at slot in 2018. Reminds me of DAT. IMPACT PLAYER

REDSHIRTS:
Billy Gibson, S, 6-1, 185, Hialeah, Fla. (Miami Southridge HS) 3*
- RS, Role player, likely bust.

Nick Pickett, S, 6-1, 187, Los Angeles, Calif. (Salesian HS) 3*
- RS, Role player.

Popo Aumavae, OL, 6-4, 315, Stockton, Calif. (St. Mary's HS) 3*
- RS, plays/starts in 2-3 years at guard.

Daewood Davis, WR, 6-2, 175, Hollywood, Fla. (Deerfield Beach HS) 3*
- RS likely, plays in 2018 unless we get a ton of injuries this season at WR. IMPACT PLAYER

Darrian Felix, RB, 5-11, 194, Fort Myers, Fla. (Fort Myers HS) 3*
- RS, Significant contributor in 2018, etc. See him playing slot and RB. IMPACT PLAYER

Cody Shear, OL, 6-4, 285, Eugene, Ore. (Sheldon HS) 3*
- RS, plays OG or OC in 3rd/4th year unless Hanson gets injured. Could start in 2018 as our long-snapper. Switch to Center and his ability to long snap poses some real possibilities. I think he'll surprise us in 3years, excellent athlete. Project player.

CJ Verdell, RB, 5-9, 195, Chula Vista, Calif. (Mater Dei Catholic HS) 3*
- RS, 2018 Starter or Gets Significant Time. IMPACT PLAYER

Demetri Burch, ATH, 5-11, 181, Apopka, Fla. (Apopka HS) 3*
- RS, Decent role player, (at issue is number of possible players at slot/wr - Redd, McNeal, Mitchell, Ofodile, etc.) doesn't see time except on special teams until.
Likely bust or just role player.

Cyrus Habibi-Likio, ATH, 6-1, 211, Mountain View, Calif. (St. Francis HS) 3*
- RS, Good get, eventually contributes at either SS or LB, my bet is at LB depending upon depth. Starter in 2-3 years.
A lot of those guys are 4*s

Sent from my Nexus 6P using Tapatalk
srsmiley007
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 745
Joined: Tue Oct 29, 2013 11:26 am

Re: Did we get the right 3 stars?

Post by srsmiley007 »

Duckenstein wrote:
srsmiley007 wrote:
ifuwant2 wrote:I found this article that's a fun read. I haven't seen it on the forums yet, so forgive me if I've missed it. I don't think all the logic is sound, but it's interesting and fun. So after reading it, if you feel like it, who do you think are our 3 stars that could be major gets under the ideas promoted in this article:

http://www.footballstudyhall.com/2017/2 ... g-rankings
Thanks. Interesting read. The QB to LB take is wonkie because of the physical difference in playing LB, taking on OL, instinct, etc. but the rest has some merit. The safety to LB take is also off. I used to look for those kids as a hard hitting safety is often the best athlete and capable of playing many positions based upon size.

Anyway, here's my take for best 3 stars, I removed any of the players that had 4 stars on any of the services. IMPACT PLAYERS ARE IN BOLD.


CONTRIBUTORS IN 2017:
Austin Faoliu, DL, 6-3, 285, Santa Ana, Calif. (Mater Dei HS) 3*
- Will likely see minutes at NT this season. Eventual Starter or see's significant minutes at NT, DE in 3-4, impact player.

Jordon Scott, DT, 6-1, 350, Largo, Fla. (Pinellas Park Senior HS) 3*
- Eventual starter at NT, will be elite if controls weight. See him starting at some point this season. IMPACT PLAYER

Johnny Johnson III, WR, 6-0, 194, Chandler, Ariz. (Chandler HS) 3*
- See's minutes this season at WR. Runs excellent routes. Think Keenon Lowe but faster, better body control & hands. His route consistency and ability vs press make him a solid contributor.

Adam Stack, K, 6-2, 175, Honolulu, Hawaii (Kamehameha) 2*
- Starts in 2017 and changes our punt game. No more 25-30 yd punts. Flips the field for us, helps our D instantly! IMPACT PLAYER.

Darrian McNeal, WR, 5-9, 160, Seffner, Fla. (Armwood HS) 3*
- Possible ST player, plays significant snaps at slot in 2018. Reminds me of DAT. IMPACT PLAYER

REDSHIRTS:
Billy Gibson, S, 6-1, 185, Hialeah, Fla. (Miami Southridge HS) 3*
- RS, Role player, likely bust.

Nick Pickett, S, 6-1, 187, Los Angeles, Calif. (Salesian HS) 3*
- RS, Role player.

Popo Aumavae, OL, 6-4, 315, Stockton, Calif. (St. Mary's HS) 3*
- RS, plays/starts in 2-3 years at guard.

Daewood Davis, WR, 6-2, 175, Hollywood, Fla. (Deerfield Beach HS) 3*
- RS likely, plays in 2018 unless we get a ton of injuries this season at WR. IMPACT PLAYER

Darrian Felix, RB, 5-11, 194, Fort Myers, Fla. (Fort Myers HS) 3*
- RS, Significant contributor in 2018, etc. See him playing slot and RB. IMPACT PLAYER

Cody Shear, OL, 6-4, 285, Eugene, Ore. (Sheldon HS) 3*
- RS, plays OG or OC in 3rd/4th year unless Hanson gets injured. Could start in 2018 as our long-snapper. Switch to Center and his ability to long snap poses some real possibilities. I think he'll surprise us in 3years, excellent athlete. Project player.

CJ Verdell, RB, 5-9, 195, Chula Vista, Calif. (Mater Dei Catholic HS) 3*
- RS, 2018 Starter or Gets Significant Time. IMPACT PLAYER

Demetri Burch, ATH, 5-11, 181, Apopka, Fla. (Apopka HS) 3*
- RS, Decent role player, (at issue is number of possible players at slot/wr - Redd, McNeal, Mitchell, Ofodile, etc.) doesn't see time except on special teams until.
Likely bust or just role player.

Cyrus Habibi-Likio, ATH, 6-1, 211, Mountain View, Calif. (St. Francis HS) 3*
- RS, Good get, eventually contributes at either SS or LB, my bet is at LB depending upon depth. Starter in 2-3 years.
A lot of those guys are 4*s

Sent from my Nexus 6P using Tapatalk
Umm, sorry? I overlooked Scout on some of these. They are the only one to give Popo, Cyrus and Felix a 4th star.
User avatar
Duckenstein
Freshman
Posts: 1433
Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2016 7:43 pm

Re: Did we get the right 3 stars?

Post by Duckenstein »

srsmiley007 wrote:
Duckenstein wrote:
srsmiley007 wrote:
ifuwant2 wrote:I found this article that's a fun read. I haven't seen it on the forums yet, so forgive me if I've missed it. I don't think all the logic is sound, but it's interesting and fun. So after reading it, if you feel like it, who do you think are our 3 stars that could be major gets under the ideas promoted in this article:

http://www.footballstudyhall.com/2017/2 ... g-rankings
Thanks. Interesting read. The QB to LB take is wonkie because of the physical difference in playing LB, taking on OL, instinct, etc. but the rest has some merit. The safety to LB take is also off. I used to look for those kids as a hard hitting safety is often the best athlete and capable of playing many positions based upon size.

Anyway, here's my take for best 3 stars, I removed any of the players that had 4 stars on any of the services. IMPACT PLAYERS ARE IN BOLD.


CONTRIBUTORS IN 2017:
Austin Faoliu, DL, 6-3, 285, Santa Ana, Calif. (Mater Dei HS) 3*
- Will likely see minutes at NT this season. Eventual Starter or see's significant minutes at NT, DE in 3-4, impact player.

Jordon Scott, DT, 6-1, 350, Largo, Fla. (Pinellas Park Senior HS) 3*
- Eventual starter at NT, will be elite if controls weight. See him starting at some point this season. IMPACT PLAYER

Johnny Johnson III, WR, 6-0, 194, Chandler, Ariz. (Chandler HS) 3*
- See's minutes this season at WR. Runs excellent routes. Think Keenon Lowe but faster, better body control & hands. His route consistency and ability vs press make him a solid contributor.

Adam Stack, K, 6-2, 175, Honolulu, Hawaii (Kamehameha) 2*
- Starts in 2017 and changes our punt game. No more 25-30 yd punts. Flips the field for us, helps our D instantly! IMPACT PLAYER.

Darrian McNeal, WR, 5-9, 160, Seffner, Fla. (Armwood HS) 3*
- Possible ST player, plays significant snaps at slot in 2018. Reminds me of DAT. IMPACT PLAYER

REDSHIRTS:
Billy Gibson, S, 6-1, 185, Hialeah, Fla. (Miami Southridge HS) 3*
- RS, Role player, likely bust.

Nick Pickett, S, 6-1, 187, Los Angeles, Calif. (Salesian HS) 3*
- RS, Role player.

Popo Aumavae, OL, 6-4, 315, Stockton, Calif. (St. Mary's HS) 3*
- RS, plays/starts in 2-3 years at guard.

Daewood Davis, WR, 6-2, 175, Hollywood, Fla. (Deerfield Beach HS) 3*
- RS likely, plays in 2018 unless we get a ton of injuries this season at WR. IMPACT PLAYER

Darrian Felix, RB, 5-11, 194, Fort Myers, Fla. (Fort Myers HS) 3*
- RS, Significant contributor in 2018, etc. See him playing slot and RB. IMPACT PLAYER

Cody Shear, OL, 6-4, 285, Eugene, Ore. (Sheldon HS) 3*
- RS, plays OG or OC in 3rd/4th year unless Hanson gets injured. Could start in 2018 as our long-snapper. Switch to Center and his ability to long snap poses some real possibilities. I think he'll surprise us in 3years, excellent athlete. Project player.

CJ Verdell, RB, 5-9, 195, Chula Vista, Calif. (Mater Dei Catholic HS) 3*
- RS, 2018 Starter or Gets Significant Time. IMPACT PLAYER

Demetri Burch, ATH, 5-11, 181, Apopka, Fla. (Apopka HS) 3*
- RS, Decent role player, (at issue is number of possible players at slot/wr - Redd, McNeal, Mitchell, Ofodile, etc.) doesn't see time except on special teams until.
Likely bust or just role player.

Cyrus Habibi-Likio, ATH, 6-1, 211, Mountain View, Calif. (St. Francis HS) 3*
- RS, Good get, eventually contributes at either SS or LB, my bet is at LB depending upon depth. Starter in 2-3 years.
A lot of those guys are 4*s

Sent from my Nexus 6P using Tapatalk
Umm, sorry? I overlooked Scout on some of these. They are the only one to give Popo, Cyrus and Felix a 4th star.
Don't take the brevity the wrong way.

Just a note that a few of those guys didn't meet your definition
srsmiley007 wrote:
Duckenstein wrote:
srsmiley007 wrote:
ifuwant2 wrote:I found this article that's a fun read. I haven't seen it on the forums yet, so forgive me if I've missed it. I don't think all the logic is sound, but it's interesting and fun. So after reading it, if you feel like it, who do you think are our 3 stars that could be major gets under the ideas promoted in this article:

http://www.footballstudyhall.com/2017/2 ... g-rankings
Thanks. Interesting read. The QB to LB take is wonkie because of the physical difference in playing LB, taking on OL, instinct, etc. but the rest has some merit. The safety to LB take is also off. I used to look for those kids as a hard hitting safety is often the best athlete and capable of playing many positions based upon size.

Anyway, here's my take for best 3 stars, I removed any of the players that had 4 stars on any of the services. IMPACT PLAYERS ARE IN BOLD.


CONTRIBUTORS IN 2017:
Austin Faoliu, DL, 6-3, 285, Santa Ana, Calif. (Mater Dei HS) 3*
- Will likely see minutes at NT this season. Eventual Starter or see's significant minutes at NT, DE in 3-4, impact player.

Jordon Scott, DT, 6-1, 350, Largo, Fla. (Pinellas Park Senior HS) 3*
- Eventual starter at NT, will be elite if controls weight. See him starting at some point this season. IMPACT PLAYER

Johnny Johnson III, WR, 6-0, 194, Chandler, Ariz. (Chandler HS) 3*
- See's minutes this season at WR. Runs excellent routes. Think Keenon Lowe but faster, better body control & hands. His route consistency and ability vs press make him a solid contributor.

Adam Stack, K, 6-2, 175, Honolulu, Hawaii (Kamehameha) 2*
- Starts in 2017 and changes our punt game. No more 25-30 yd punts. Flips the field for us, helps our D instantly! IMPACT PLAYER.

Darrian McNeal, WR, 5-9, 160, Seffner, Fla. (Armwood HS) 3*
- Possible ST player, plays significant snaps at slot in 2018. Reminds me of DAT. IMPACT PLAYER

REDSHIRTS:
Billy Gibson, S, 6-1, 185, Hialeah, Fla. (Miami Southridge HS) 3*
- RS, Role player, likely bust.

Nick Pickett, S, 6-1, 187, Los Angeles, Calif. (Salesian HS) 3*
- RS, Role player.

Popo Aumavae, OL, 6-4, 315, Stockton, Calif. (St. Mary's HS) 3*
- RS, plays/starts in 2-3 years at guard.

Daewood Davis, WR, 6-2, 175, Hollywood, Fla. (Deerfield Beach HS) 3*
- RS likely, plays in 2018 unless we get a ton of injuries this season at WR. IMPACT PLAYER

Darrian Felix, RB, 5-11, 194, Fort Myers, Fla. (Fort Myers HS) 3*
- RS, Significant contributor in 2018, etc. See him playing slot and RB. IMPACT PLAYER

Cody Shear, OL, 6-4, 285, Eugene, Ore. (Sheldon HS) 3*
- RS, plays OG or OC in 3rd/4th year unless Hanson gets injured. Could start in 2018 as our long-snapper. Switch to Center and his ability to long snap poses some real possibilities. I think he'll surprise us in 3years, excellent athlete. Project player.

CJ Verdell, RB, 5-9, 195, Chula Vista, Calif. (Mater Dei Catholic HS) 3*
- RS, 2018 Starter or Gets Significant Time. IMPACT PLAYER

Demetri Burch, ATH, 5-11, 181, Apopka, Fla. (Apopka HS) 3*
- RS, Decent role player, (at issue is number of possible players at slot/wr - Redd, McNeal, Mitchell, Ofodile, etc.) doesn't see time except on special teams until.
Likely bust or just role player.

Cyrus Habibi-Likio, ATH, 6-1, 211, Mountain View, Calif. (St. Francis HS) 3*
- RS, Good get, eventually contributes at either SS or LB, my bet is at LB depending upon depth. Starter in 2-3 years.
A lot of those guys are 4*s

Sent from my Nexus 6P using Tapatalk
Umm, sorry? I overlooked Scout on some of these. They are the only one to give Popo, Cyrus and Felix a 4th star.

Sent from my Nexus 6P using Tapatalk
Post Reply