Coaching questions existed last year with player cohesiveness , player development , work ethic etc. Helfrich was considered by Chip as a very smart offensive mind. But he did not provide strong enough leadership among other things. Lubick however was a first year OC smart guy, good receiver coach, But was he the best OC. Hoke as DC , Pellum before that, enough has been said about them. Now we don't doubt Leavitt and his staff can coach, but can they turn it around year one? Likewise Willi Taggart appears to be good at leadership and rebuilding, But can he out scheme and game plan and adjust/ adapt game plans during games at this level and with two new co OCs, all who have not worked together and have not coach a game together yet. Talent is there on Offense, experience is decent on Offense overall. Defense has talent and experience as definite questions. Think if we had linebackers as experienced and talented as our running backs are.
Another point is Chip was crazy smart and innovative, but did other coaches just adapt to playing us, or was Helfrich not able to adapt and continue to innovate. And finally is it more about Xs and Os or more about MOs and JOs. On the recruiting front they have been stellar so far compared to previous staff and coming off our worst season in years makes them amazing.
So in summary this year may be a rebuilding year, but with better incoming talent we will have high expectations of the coaching over the next years.
Confident and Concered, Pre-Season Edition
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
-
soduck
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 601
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:33 pm
Re: Confident and Concered, Pre-Season Edition
Last edited by soduck on Sun Sep 03, 2017 9:40 pm, edited 1 time in total.

-
Duck24
- Senior
- Posts: 4744
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: Confident and Concered, Pre-Season Edition
You should change your name to MDMA because you must be high but I like the optimism.mdm0302 wrote:im so confident in the ducks this year. We are going to suffer one heartbreaking loss and will be back in the playoffs. Back to the glory days we come
Like Greenblood said above, the OL and running game could be the X factor for Oregon this year. With a young and what we all believe will be an improved but still underwhelming D, having an offense that could put together clock churning and demoralizing 'shove it down your throat' drives could win them a few of those toss up games and maybe one or two some of us are already throwing in the L column. The W/L record for this team is going to come down to health, development of the younger/less experienced guys and some luck. If we don't lose any key players at thin positions, see the young guys step up quick and get a few lucky bounces, maybe 9 wins is possible. If Herbie goes down, the young guys hit a wall and those bounces go against Oregon, they could be looking at 5 wins.
I'd say I'm cautiously optimistic. While I wouldn't be ecstatic if this team won 6-7 games, if we see a team that plays like it actually gives a crap, show signs of life and on field development, I could live with a Las Vegas bowl or some low level bowl like that. Anything more is money in the bank and anything less would be disappointing, barring extenuating injury circumstances.
-
dthomas=ddixon
- Moderator

- Posts: 8822
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
- Location: McMinnville, Oregon
Re: Confident and Concered, Pre-Season Edition
Nice post. I share your sentiment.Greenblood wrote:There's the ideal and there's the realistic. We all want the Ducks to go 15-0 every year. But realistically, about 8-5, maybe 9-4, including a bowl game, seems about right. Too much new, too many unknowns, and too thin and/or young in certain positions to feel confident about anything better. And I'm just not sure if it can be fully appreciated how much it takes to turn a program around from how low the Ducks had fallen (not even sure the Ducks themselves fully realize what it will take). On the other hand, unless there are significant injury issues, 6-6 feels like a disappointment right now.
One area that makes me think we could squeak out an upset or two is our running game. The quality depth we have at RB and the OL could be pretty lethal at controlling games and perhaps forcing opposing offenses out of their game plan. And I don't think it can be easily overestimated how important it was that Freeman decided to return.
Another issue simply gets back to overall talent. I'm really curious to see if it will in fact appear that the Ducks were just severely "under-coached" last season. If you were to look, for instance, at the Rivals recruiting rankings, the Ducks have out-recruited the Huskies each year since 2014 -- and fairly decisively in 2014 and 2015 -- though obviously that didn't seem to mean much in last year's Husky pummeling of the Ducks. I know that recruiting rankings don't necessarily mean all that much all the time, but there's enough there for me to at least view last year's mauling as probably very misleading as to the overall talent of the two programs.
Questions begin to be answered tomorrow! Go Ducks!
I don't think people realize, especially those outside the program, just how good our running game will be. Our OL is going to be really good and we have arguably the best RB in the nation backed up by two dynamic players, who if made starters could easily run for 1,000 yards. If you can run the ball like I expect us to, you're going to give yourself a chance to win most games. I expect a lot of close games with teams we shouldn't be able to compete with on paper.
As far as the talent issue goes, I think a convincing argument can be made both ways but I always reference our first two losses last year as an indicator of where we were/are talent wise; both the Nebraska and Colorado games were games I feel we should have won.
The Nebraska game was without a doubt a win that Helf gave away by refusing to kick PATs. That game shouldn't have even been close but I won't get into that. Regardless, that's a game on the road against a top 25 team that we should have won. The game against CU had it's own set of circumstances but again, a game against what turned out to be a really good team that was easily winnable.
So despite a real lack of talent on D and an incompetent coaching staff we were THIS close to beating two really good teams and being 4-0 to start the year. That alone leads to believe that a competent staff who doesn't give games away and is able to put together effective game plans will put us over the edge in those types of games. 8-9 wins is absolutely doable and who knows, as our defense gels we may close the year really strong and gets some wins we never expected.

- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: Confident and Concered, Pre-Season Edition
Let's not overthink this stuff, okay. I haven't forgotten how putrid our defense looked at times under Alliotti and we still balled out because of the offense and that approach still works in college. I still believe that what JH did last season was more impressive than what MM did as a RS FR and I think this team plays with the same confidence that their coach has which is to say that just because its Year 1 doesn't mean we don't have the talent to compete and beat anyone in our league.
I think we go 4-1 in the North with a loss to Stanford but the Farm eats it late and we win the tiebreaker.
I think we go 4-1 in the North with a loss to Stanford but the Farm eats it late and we win the tiebreaker.

-
mdm0302
- Freshman
- Posts: 1349
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:38 pm
- Location: Eugene O
Re: Confident and Concered, Pre-Season Edition
HahaDuck24 wrote:You should change your name to MDMA because you must be high but I like the optimism.mdm0302 wrote:im so confident in the ducks this year. We are going to suffer one heartbreaking loss and will be back in the playoffs. Back to the glory days we come![]()
Like Greenblood said above, the OL and running game could be the X factor for Oregon this year. With a young and what we all believe will be an improved but still underwhelming D, having an offense that could put together clock churning and demoralizing 'shove it down your throat' drives could win them a few of those toss up games and maybe one or two some of us are already throwing in the L column. The W/L record for this team is going to come down to health, development of the younger/less experienced guys and some luck. If we don't lose any key players at thin positions, see the young guys step up quick and get a few lucky bounces, maybe 9 wins is possible. If Herbie goes down, the young guys hit a wall and those bounces go against Oregon, they could be looking at 5 wins.
I'd say I'm cautiously optimistic. While I wouldn't be ecstatic if this team won 6-7 games, if we see a team that plays like it actually gives a crap, show signs of life and on field development, I could live with a Las Vegas bowl or some low level bowl like that. Anything more is money in the bank and anything less would be disappointing, barring extenuating injury circumstances.