DAT_man_again wrote:Some of the BS I've read on this board and others after this game is absolutely pathetic. One two point loss on the road when we played terrible and suddenly we will be stuck in PAC 12 mediocrity for years to come? Can you guys hear yourselves?!?!
We went 4-8 last year! Most of the players we have this year were on that sorry team. Taggart comes in and wins his first three games by an average of 33 points and he loses one game and you start questioning the coaching staff? Are. You. Kidding. Me.
We are averaging 44 points a game. The defense is one of the best in the country on 3rd down. Those stats right there are INCREDIBLE after a 4-8 season. The offense had a terrible game and still put up 35. I am sorry but when you have the worst defense in the country one year, and all that's different the next year are 5 freshman and one grad transfer... yeah you are going to give up 30 points a lot of games. And if your offense has hiccups you are going to lose. That is the way it goes when you are rebuilding. We just needed to see IMPROVEMENT on defense this year. And we have. And next year, when Lenoir, Graham, Pickett, Scott and Faoilu are sophomores combined with Malcolm Lamar, Isaiah Bolden, Adrian Jackson, Steve Stephens and Holland? Let alone the returning seniors. That defense is going to be GOOD. Year 3? When all our freshman now are upper classmen and all of the 4*s we have recruited are sophomores in year 3 of Leavitt? Mark my words.. we will have one of the best defenses in the country.
I'll finish with this. Our recruiting class for 2018 is #5 in the country, and we could conceivably add two 5*s. That sort of recruiting has never happened before. Not even under Chip. So for those of you questioning the coaching staff and saying we are trapped in mediocrity because of ONE road loss by two points after a 4-8 season. Yeah that's about as dumb as it gets.
Woah, take a chill pill and a half man. You are blowing what I and others have said way way way out of proportion. We are analyzing what we've seen. Never communicated any lack of support for the coaches or desire for them to be fired, we simply are analyzing what we've seen and I've asked regarding what realistic expectations are. People were saying this team would compete in the PAC-12 and Herbert is the next Mariota and I was simply asking people what they thought about the coaching staff and what are reasonable expectations. It certainly didn't warrant a reaction like this.
Clearly you're obsessed with stats, but anyone will tell you there is also an eye test. What I saw yesterday were things slightly concerning, Herbert didn't progress through his reads, dropped passes, but also an insane amount of penalties, playcalls that did not adjust to the fact that ASU blitzed heavily every third down, and an overall lack of preparation. During a short period in the second quarter it seemed like the team struggled just to get a clean snap and play off! You can 100% blame those on the players, but how is that better than blaming the coaches? Seeing these issues that resulted in a loss to a below average PAC-12 team absolutely caused questions and discussions about the coaches. I fail to see how that warrants the type of reaction you had at all.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I don’t think any reasonable fan was expecting more than 7-8 wins nor calling Herbert the next Mariota. There’s a whole lot of over analyzing going on to what is a simple answer to what happened. Oregon is only a decent team this year and relying on a whole bunch of unproven young guys to contribute in key positions. People’s pants got a little tight when they beat up on three sorry teams and looked past some glaring obvious holes. The OL couldn’t get a consistent push up the middle against a team not named Southern Utah and struggles to give Herbert consistent time to throw, even when the opponents don’t blitz. Herbert will make a throw that only a handful of guys in the country can make on one play and then overthrow wide open guys on 9 routes the next play. The D, while vastly improved, is still a work in progress with five true freshman playing regularly and a walk-on 200# MLB.
If you’re questioning this team after one loss that was, in hindsight, kind of predictable, what are you gonna do if they lose four of five to Wazzu, Stanford, UCLA, Utah and UW, which is a distinct possibility? As I said in a previous post, you’re going to find out a lot about this team and coaching staff on Saturday. They’re all saying the right things but let’s see it in action Saturday night against a Cal team that will be looking to rebound too. I think Oregon is in for a dogfight.
DAT_man_again wrote:Some of the BS I've read on this board and others after this game is absolutely pathetic. One two point loss on the road when we played terrible and suddenly we will be stuck in PAC 12 mediocrity for years to come? Can you guys hear yourselves?!?!
We went 4-8 last year! Most of the players we have this year were on that sorry team. Taggart comes in and wins his first three games by an average of 33 points and he loses one game and you start questioning the coaching staff? Are. You. Kidding. Me.
We are averaging 44 points a game. The defense is one of the best in the country on 3rd down. Those stats right there are INCREDIBLE after a 4-8 season. The offense had a terrible game and still put up 35. I am sorry but when you have the worst defense in the country one year, and all that's different the next year are 5 freshman and one grad transfer... yeah you are going to give up 30 points a lot of games. And if your offense has hiccups you are going to lose. That is the way it goes when you are rebuilding. We just needed to see IMPROVEMENT on defense this year. And we have. And next year, when Lenoir, Graham, Pickett, Scott and Faoilu are sophomores combined with Malcolm Lamar, Isaiah Bolden, Adrian Jackson, Steve Stephens and Holland? Let alone the returning seniors. That defense is going to be GOOD. Year 3? When all our freshman now are upper classmen and all of the 4*s we have recruited are sophomores in year 3 of Leavitt? Mark my words.. we will have one of the best defenses in the country.
I'll finish with this. Our recruiting class for 2018 is #5 in the country, and we could conceivably add two 5*s. That sort of recruiting has never happened before. Not even under Chip. So for those of you questioning the coaching staff and saying we are trapped in mediocrity because of ONE road loss by two points after a 4-8 season. Yeah that's about as dumb as it gets.
Woah, take a chill pill and a half man. You are blowing what I and others have said way way way out of proportion. We are analyzing what we've seen. Never communicated any lack of support for the coaches or desire for them to be fired, we simply are analyzing what we've seen and I've asked regarding what realistic expectations are. People were saying this team would compete in the PAC-12 and Herbert is the next Mariota and I was simply asking people what they thought about the coaching staff and what are reasonable expectations. It certainly didn't warrant a reaction like this.
Clearly you're obsessed with stats, but anyone will tell you there is also an eye test. What I saw yesterday were things slightly concerning, Herbert didn't progress through his reads, dropped passes, but also an insane amount of penalties, playcalls that did not adjust to the fact that ASU blitzed heavily every third down, and an overall lack of preparation. During a short period in the second quarter it seemed like the team struggled just to get a clean snap and play off! You can 100% blame those on the players, but how is that better than blaming the coaches? Seeing these issues that resulted in a loss to a below average PAC-12 team absolutely caused questions and discussions about the coaches. I fail to see how that warrants the type of reaction you had at all.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I don’t think any reasonable fan was expecting more than 7-8 wins nor calling Herbert the next Mariota. There’s a whole lot of over analyzing going on to what is a simple answer to what happened. Oregon is only a decent team this year and relying on a whole bunch of unproven young guys to contribute in key positions. People’s pants got a little tight when they beat up on three sorry teams and looked past some glaring obvious holes. The OL couldn’t get a consistent push up the middle against a team not named Southern Utah and struggles to give Herbert consistent time to throw, even when the opponents don’t blitz. Herbert will make a throw that only a handful of guys in the country can make on one play and then overthrow wide open guys on 9 routes the next play. The D, while vastly improved, is still a work in progress with five true freshman playing regularly and a walk-on 200# MLB.
If you’re questioning this team after one loss that was, in hindsight, kind of predictable, what are you gonna do if they lose four of five to Wazzu, Stanford, UCLA, Utah and UW, which is a distinct possibility? As I said in a previous post, you’re going to find out a lot about this team and coaching staff on Saturday. They’re all saying the right things but let’s see it in action Saturday night against a Cal team that will be looking to rebound too. I think Oregon is in for a dogfight.
This is a very good post and I agree, though I will say the ASU loss wasn't predictable to me, I was expecting that win, and even after the game, I believe Oregon should beat ASU. Granted ASU had killer mistakes, but Oregon just seemed lost so much and like they were not ready for PAC-12 play at all. I started the season expecting 7-5 and after going 3-0 I moved to 8-4, but I did not expect this to be one of those 4 losses.
And maybe it was just me, but I heard a lot of fans talking about Herbert being the next Mariota and this team competing for the conference. Heck even Jerry Allen compared Herbert to Mariota! Hopefully this loss gives us reasonable expectations which will allow us all to enjoy this season much more for what it will be.
Most Herbert-Mariota comparisons I've seen (from teammates, coaches, and analysts) have to do with his humbleness, quiet demeanor, and leadership style more than his actual playing style.
A few years ago we lost to an AZ team in embarrassing fashion early in the season and this same board was saying the same things. The sky is falling. That team nutted up and did amazing things. Will happen again? Maybe, but prolly not, but let's not overreact to a loss (or two). The key for a young team is to keep improving every week.
UofDuck wrote:A few years ago we lost to an AZ team in embarrassing fashion early in the season and this same board was saying the same things. The sky is falling. That team nutted up and did amazing things. Will happen again? Maybe, but prolly not, but let's not overreact to a loss (or two). The key for a young team is to keep improving every week.
I haven't really seen anybody saying the sky is falling, nor have I seen anybody proclaiming we have crappy coaches. Rather people just questioning things from what we've seen and I simply asked what are reasonable expectations for the coaching staff also from what we've seen.
UofDuck wrote:A few years ago we lost to an AZ team in embarrassing fashion early in the season and this same board was saying the same things. The sky is falling. That team nutted up and did amazing things. Will happen again? Maybe, but prolly not, but let's not overreact to a loss (or two). The key for a young team is to keep improving every week.
I haven't really seen anybody saying the sky is falling, nor have I seen anybody proclaiming we have crappy coaches. Rather people just questioning things from what we've seen and I simply asked what are reasonable expectations for the coaching staff also from what we've seen.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I agree here. Sure, there's a few boors who think unreasonable thoughts, but I do think there are a lot of fair questions being asked. A lot of it has to do with the fans not knowing what to expect and trying to dial in this team, and coaching staffs', tendencies. The staff is probably still trying to figure that out. This season for me is an experiment, and let's see where we're at going into next year.
ifuwant2 wrote:Anyone who thinks this is a supremely talented team on both sides of the football that has just been let down by bad coaching the past 20 or so games just needs to watch Alabama's second string offense and defense. Almost none of our guys would be in the the first or second team rotation at Alabama.
90% of college football teams fall into that category