Coach Taggart Needs Someone to call the plays

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Coach Taggart Needs Someone to call the plays

Post by Duck07 »

OregonFan4Life wrote: How about the 3rd down conversion rate, is that not a reason to question the playcalling?
Go back and tell me how many drops were on third down. It's not like we were playing a ghost out there, give credit to ASU. You just want something to overreact to which is why even in wins you tend to always find something negative to go on about. Once again, we're also just putting all the blame on the offense and not special teams or defense for the times they messed up. Go make a list of everything that contributed to the loss and then compare it to play-calling. This isn't "analysis" that's being brought up, it's just whining because we lost. "They should have run something different because obviously it would have succeeded."
Image
User avatar
OregonFan4Life
All-American
Posts: 15433
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm

Re: Coach Taggart Needs Someone to call the plays

Post by OregonFan4Life »

Duck07 wrote:
OregonFan4Life wrote: How about the 3rd down conversion rate, is that not a reason to question the playcalling?
Go back and tell me how many drops were on third down. It's not like we were playing a ghost out there, give credit to ASU. You just want something to overreact to which is why even in wins you tend to always find something negative to go on about. Once again, we're also just putting all the blame on the offense and not special teams or defense for the times they messed up. Go make a list of everything that contributed to the loss and then compare it to play-calling. This isn't "analysis" that's being brought up, it's just whining because we lost. "They should have run something different because obviously it would have succeeded."
I never blamed the loss on one thing, multiple things caused the loss, and I gave credit to ASU and even said they deserved to win the game and had great preparation and energy and they certainly looked better than I expected. I don't know what you and other posters are expecting, for us to be all "hooray" after a bad loss? In addition last time I checked this is an Oregon forum and not an ASU forum, so I'm going to talk about Oregon on here a lot more than ASU, so me talking about the negatives from Oregon rather than the positives from ASU is in no way an overreaction. Another funny thing is you mentioned the drops, yes there were drops on 3rd down plays, never denied that, but you and others are comical to me in that you get all upset at people blaming coaches then start blaming players, how is that any better?

And yes, the 3rd down playcalling did not work, and while there were other factors the conversion rate is a huge indicator that the playcalling on 3rd down did not help.

Just curious, to you and so many other posters getting on my case for asking about the coaches and if we should lower expectations, what do you think this forum is for?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Image
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Coach Taggart Needs Someone to call the plays

Post by Duck07 »

OregonFan4Life wrote:Just curious, to you and so many other posters getting on my case for asking about the coaches and if we should lower expectations, what do you think this forum is for?
The only reason to be upset about this loss is because your expectations are overblown. After a loss you always want someone to give you some specific reason to why we lost rather than simply accepting that so many of these things are just part of football. Yes, guys drop passes and misses blocks and commit penalties and they all help contribute to a loss, just as all the catches and blocks and tackles they make contribute to the win. Right now this isn't a team worth getting upset at over a 1 score loss.

Nobody pulled a Sherman in the game and committed some egregious act, it's a mix of a few great players with young ones. Reset your expectations and just enjoy watching a team that for all of it's flaws, has given some exciting and competitive games.

If you need something to feel better about going forward, go look at our recruiting class and rankings.
Image
User avatar
OregonFan4Life
All-American
Posts: 15433
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm

Re: Coach Taggart Needs Someone to call the plays

Post by OregonFan4Life »

Duck07 wrote:
OregonFan4Life wrote:Just curious, to you and so many other posters getting on my case for asking about the coaches and if we should lower expectations, what do you think this forum is for?
The only reason to be upset about this loss is because your expectations are overblown. After a loss you always want someone to give you some specific reason to why we lost rather than simply accepting that so many of these things are just part of football. Yes, guys drop passes and misses blocks and commit penalties and they all help contribute to a loss, just as all the catches and blocks and tackles they make contribute to the win. Right now this isn't a team worth getting upset at over a 1 score loss.

Nobody pulled a Sherman in the game and committed some egregious act, it's a mix of a few great players with young ones. Reset your expectations and just enjoy watching a team that for all of it's flaws, has given some exciting and competitive games.

If you need something to feel better about going forward, go look at our recruiting class and rankings.
Our my expectations that overblown for expecting them to beat ASU? And yeah, I always enjoy talking about Oregon football, losses and wins. I enjoy analyzing with other duck fans why they lost or why they won. It seems awfully boring for me as a fan on a forum to see a loss and just say "well, that's football for you. Let's just talk about nothing now." I know none of us will have an impact on Oregon football, but for me, I particularly enjoy talking with other fans what went wrong and where we hope to see improvement from this team, and I particularly enjoy it from more knowledgeable fans. And as someone who wants Oregon to win every game forever, I will get upset over a 1 score loss in a very very very winnable game, part of being a fan.
Image
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: Coach Taggart Needs Someone to call the plays

Post by buckmarkduck »

I went through and re watched the game, and really there was a lot of well designed plays that got missed ether because of a missed throw, drops, or something lots of people aren't talking about, the OL just missing key blocks. Honestly Hanson had at least 3 missed blocks, that if he makes them all 3 plays go for 20+ yds. On the play where ASU DL hits Herbert just as he's about to throw it, if Crosby even chipped the guy as he goes by, Taj might score.

I'd challenge anyone who says the play calling was bad, we had the right calls to score at least 14 more points, it just wasn't executed. Oh and our very young DBs, played a great game despite giving up some yards. They had some Freshman moments, but if they improve the way other DB at UO have over the years, our pass d will be unbeatable in 2 years. I'm talking out on tape of LSU most years, and that will be UO in 2019.
User avatar
OregonFan4Life
All-American
Posts: 15433
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm

Re: Coach Taggart Needs Someone to call the plays

Post by OregonFan4Life »

buckmarkduck wrote:I went through and re watched the game, and really there was a lot of well designed plays that got missed ether because of a missed throw, drops, or something lots of people aren't talking about, the OL just missing key blocks. Honestly Hanson had at least 3 missed blocks, that if he makes them all 3 plays go for 20+ yds. On the play where ASU DL hits Herbert just as he's about to throw it, if Crosby even chipped the guy as he goes by, Taj might score.

I'd challenge anyone who says the play calling was bad, we had the right calls to score at least 14 more points, it just wasn't executed. Oh and our very young DBs, played a great game despite giving up some yards. They had some Freshman moments, but if they improve the way other DB at UO have over the years, our pass d will be unbeatable in 2 years. I'm talking out on tape of LSU most years, and that will be UO in 2019.
Damn, that's brave of you to watch that game! Thanks for doing that on behalf of all of us, cause no way I'd wanna watch that game again. That's good information and good to know. So basically scheme wasn't the problem but lack of preparation was resulting in poor execution? If that's the case, I'm wondering how much of that is cause of the players vs the coaches. I've always wondered that, cause I hear some say it's on the players themselves to prepare but I hear others say it's on the coaches to prepare the players. I'm wondering what people on here think.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Image
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: Coach Taggart Needs Someone to call the plays

Post by buckmarkduck »

Most of the issues is youth, not coaching or preparation. A team that's decided doesn't fight back down 31-14. The team is buying in, but you see things like the fumble by Benoit, and it looks like guys may not totally know the playbook yet. Again it's brand new, and you have 3 srs on O, one who has no business starting at guard, and on d you have 2-3 srs starting. Im expecting these errors to start to go away by the last 3-4 games of the year.
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: Coach Taggart Needs Someone to call the plays

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

Some of the third down problems were because of the previous downs. You have receivers dropping the ball or Herbert missing them combined with penalties and you fix those the third downs become more manageable. Yes the 3rd down conversions were bad but when are trying to overcome bad plays on the first two downs it leaves you in 3rd and long. Even pro teams do not win games if they are in 3rd and long most the game. Odds of converting them on a regular basis is nearly impossible. There is enough blame for this loss on anyone on offense to go around. That goes for the coaches on down to the players.
GrantDuck
Senior
Posts: 2629
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm

Re: Coach Taggart Needs Someone to call the plays

Post by GrantDuck »

Duck07 wrote:
OregonFan4Life wrote: How about the 3rd down conversion rate, is that not a reason to question the playcalling?
Go back and tell me how many drops were on third down. It's not like we were playing a ghost out there, give credit to ASU. You just want something to overreact to which is why even in wins you tend to always find something negative to go on about. Once again, we're also just putting all the blame on the offense and not special teams or defense for the times they messed up. Go make a list of everything that contributed to the loss and then compare it to play-calling. This isn't "analysis" that's being brought up, it's just whining because we lost. "They should have run something different because obviously it would have succeeded."
There's 2 valid counterpoints here:

1. We didn't see a single WR screen or HB screen or ANY screen or draw on 3rd down....that's simply terrible playcalling at ANY level against what ASU was doing. It would have worked a lot better than 1 for 10.

2. We lost to an significantly inferior team talent wise, never happened under chip, VERY rarely under Mike B.
karlhungis
All Pac-12
Posts: 7990
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:08 am

Re: Coach Taggart Needs Someone to call the plays

Post by karlhungis »

GrantDuck wrote:
Duck07 wrote:
OregonFan4Life wrote: How about the 3rd down conversion rate, is that not a reason to question the playcalling?
Go back and tell me how many drops were on third down. It's not like we were playing a ghost out there, give credit to ASU. You just want something to overreact to which is why even in wins you tend to always find something negative to go on about. Once again, we're also just putting all the blame on the offense and not special teams or defense for the times they messed up. Go make a list of everything that contributed to the loss and then compare it to play-calling. This isn't "analysis" that's being brought up, it's just whining because we lost. "They should have run something different because obviously it would have succeeded."
There's 2 valid counterpoints here:

1. We didn't see a single WR screen or HB screen or ANY screen or draw on 3rd down....that's simply terrible playcalling at ANY level against what ASU was doing. It would have worked a lot better than 1 for 10.

2. We lost to an significantly inferior team talent wise, never happened under chip, VERY rarely under Mike B.
They didn't appear to be "significantly inferior" talent wise.
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
Groundswell
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 753
Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm

Re: Coach Taggart Needs Someone to call the plays

Post by Groundswell »

buckmarkduck wrote:Most of the issues is youth, not coaching or preparation. A team that's decided doesn't fight back down 31-14. The team is buying in, but you see things like the fumble by Benoit, and it looks like guys may not totally know the playbook yet. Again it's brand new, and you have 3 srs on O, one who has no business starting at guard, and on d you have 2-3 srs starting. Im expecting these errors to start to go away by the last 3-4 games of the year.
I think guys not knowing the playbook, or at least being able to execute the playbook is something to talk about. Since Nebraska, there have been a few series in each game where the coaches tried to trot out new formations or throw a wrinkle play in there and the play just looks out of sorts. Bad timing. Bad execution.

For me, it's not about saying "this is just bad play calling in that situation". The issue for me is the team seems to be running the same plays without any adjustments being made. For ASU, the consistent throwing the ball 20+ yards downfield when we couldn't hit got a bit frustrating. I don't know that I've ever seen a team throw that deep that often...at least a team without V. Adams at the helm. Situationally, those may be the right call. But not when you're 0 for 10ish, even if ASU is challenging you to do it. I'm not saying the coaches don't know how to call plays. I'm saying I'm not sure what they want for an identity. I guess it's power run game with deep throws over the top. But I haven't seen the team find an answer for when those two things are working. Clearly we're putting up points and yards, and when everything is clicking we look awesome. When things aren't clicking, we don't seem to adjust. I think that is something that's going to take some time for both the players and the coaches to figure out. We can't even run a screen play reliably. That's weird to me.
GrantDuck
Senior
Posts: 2629
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm

Re: Coach Taggart Needs Someone to call the plays

Post by GrantDuck »

karlhungis wrote:
GrantDuck wrote:
Duck07 wrote:
OregonFan4Life wrote: How about the 3rd down conversion rate, is that not a reason to question the playcalling?
Go back and tell me how many drops were on third down. It's not like we were playing a ghost out there, give credit to ASU. You just want something to overreact to which is why even in wins you tend to always find something negative to go on about. Once again, we're also just putting all the blame on the offense and not special teams or defense for the times they messed up. Go make a list of everything that contributed to the loss and then compare it to play-calling. This isn't "analysis" that's being brought up, it's just whining because we lost. "They should have run something different because obviously it would have succeeded."
There's 2 valid counterpoints here:

1. We didn't see a single WR screen or HB screen or ANY screen or draw on 3rd down....that's simply terrible playcalling at ANY level against what ASU was doing. It would have worked a lot better than 1 for 10.

2. We lost to an significantly inferior team talent wise, never happened under chip, VERY rarely under Mike B.
They didn't appear to be "significantly inferior" talent wise.
Disagreed. I do think Harry is a heck of a WR and I think if you look at their offense vs our offense, there's a fair bit of even talent...however their defense?!

They got run by Texas Tech..and their best defender then was out for the Oregon game.... not a single NFL player on that defense...it's bad, real bad, and we were 1 for 10 against it bc they just sold out to stop the run and blitz and Willie didn't adjust..went braindead..I don't know...
GrantDuck
Senior
Posts: 2629
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm

Re: Coach Taggart Needs Someone to call the plays

Post by GrantDuck »

ifuwant2 wrote:
buckmarkduck wrote:Most of the issues is youth, not coaching or preparation. A team that's decided doesn't fight back down 31-14. The team is buying in, but you see things like the fumble by Benoit, and it looks like guys may not totally know the playbook yet. Again it's brand new, and you have 3 srs on O, one who has no business starting at guard, and on d you have 2-3 srs starting. Im expecting these errors to start to go away by the last 3-4 games of the year.
I think guys not knowing the playbook, or at least being able to execute the playbook is something to talk about. Since Nebraska, there have been a few series in each game where the coaches tried to trot out new formations or throw a wrinkle play in there and the play just looks out of sorts. Bad timing. Bad execution.

For me, it's not about saying "this is just bad play calling in that situation". The issue for me is the team seems to be running the same plays without any adjustments being made. For ASU, the consistent throwing the ball 20+ yards downfield when we couldn't hit got a bit frustrating. I don't know that I've ever seen a team throw that deep that often...at least a team without V. Adams at the helm. Situationally, those may be the right call. But not when you're 0 for 10ish, even if ASU is challenging you to do it. I'm not saying the coaches don't know how to call plays. I'm saying I'm not sure what they want for an identity. I guess it's power run game with deep throws over the top. But I haven't seen the team find an answer for when those two things are working. Clearly we're putting up points and yards, and when everything is clicking we look awesome. When things aren't clicking, we don't seem to adjust. I think that is something that's going to take some time for both the players and the coaches to figure out. We can't even run a screen play reliably. That's weird to me.
Really wish one of the reporters asked Willie about the playcalling, but nobody did. It's also possible we're just really lousy at screen passes in practice or something like that, so we haven't run them in games much, but gosh, they've GOT to practice that against a Graham defense to at least have 2 reliable different screen passes they can execute with Taj or TBJ.
User avatar
Duckenstein
Freshman
Posts: 1433
Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2016 7:43 pm

Re: Coach Taggart Needs Someone to call the plays

Post by Duckenstein »

New coaches have room to grow, lots of freshman showing flashes but also making mistakes, a limited playbook because of a new system.

It all seems acceptable to me, I didn't expect a pac12 title this year.
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8820
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Coach Taggart Needs Someone to call the plays

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

ifuwant2 wrote:
buckmarkduck wrote:Most of the issues is youth, not coaching or preparation. A team that's decided doesn't fight back down 31-14. The team is buying in, but you see things like the fumble by Benoit, and it looks like guys may not totally know the playbook yet. Again it's brand new, and you have 3 srs on O, one who has no business starting at guard, and on d you have 2-3 srs starting. Im expecting these errors to start to go away by the last 3-4 games of the year.
I think guys not knowing the playbook, or at least being able to execute the playbook is something to talk about. Since Nebraska, there have been a few series in each game where the coaches tried to trot out new formations or throw a wrinkle play in there and the play just looks out of sorts. Bad timing. Bad execution.

For me, it's not about saying "this is just bad play calling in that situation". The issue for me is the team seems to be running the same plays without any adjustments being made. For ASU, the consistent throwing the ball 20+ yards downfield when we couldn't hit got a bit frustrating. I don't know that I've ever seen a team throw that deep that often...at least a team without V. Adams at the helm. Situationally, those may be the right call. But not when you're 0 for 10ish, even if ASU is challenging you to do it. I'm not saying the coaches don't know how to call plays. I'm saying I'm not sure what they want for an identity. I guess it's power run game with deep throws over the top. But I haven't seen the team find an answer for when those two things are working. Clearly we're putting up points and yards, and when everything is clicking we look awesome. When things aren't clicking, we don't seem to adjust. I think that is something that's going to take some time for both the players and the coaches to figure out. We can't even run a screen play reliably. That's weird to me.
These are pretty much my thoughts exactly. The lack of discernible identity on offense is concerning. And the seeming refusal to make any sort of adjustments when the offense isn't moving the ball or converting 3rd downs has to give you some pause. It's not like it's happened in one game. There's been LONG stretches in almost every game where the offense stagnates and no discernible adjustment is made. Not even game to game. Someone correct me if I'm wrong but it looks like we're running basically the same stuff we have been since the SUU game.

Also, I miss VA. Dude threw an incredible deep ball and made it look routine.
Image
Post Reply