The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the aisle
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
-
duckfan96
- Senior
- Posts: 2717
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:58 pm
Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a
Don't watch the NFL anyways, but I'd stand.
-
wlduck
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1722
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:19 pm
Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a
The idea that conservative voices are "suppressed" is laughable. Conservatives hold the White House, the Supreme Court and both houses of congress. Talk radio is a sea of right wing lunatics. Fox News is one large right wing propaganda machine. Even MSNBC feels compelled to add more conservative commenters. The whole "suppression" narrative is part of the GOP Culture War plan (see the "War On Christmas" nonsense) to make lower and middle class white people feel like victims so that they will support GOP policy that is largely opposed to their interests.GrantDuck wrote:The thing for me is that the flag/anthem don't represent "troops". They represent the ideals the United States stands for and that the troops fought for. If the anthem/flag no longer stand for those ideals, then I can't in good conscience stand for ideals so starkly and drastically opposed to that. Ideals that undermine who we are as a people, who I am as a person, and what so many fought and died for.GoDucksIn09 wrote:I would always stand for the anthem... I don't get involved in politics... this is our country and way to many veterans who have fought for our freedom to take a knee is in my opinion disrespectful of them. No question in my mind. There are way better venues to stand up and make a stand for injustices than to sit or kneel during national anthem. As a very conservative person been way to many times media or culture tries to tell me I should shut up or sit down and not say a word. . Everyone has a right to voice their opinion.. even those who are conservative. Standing for the anthem is just the right thing to do no matter what. Too many veterans fought for our freedoms for everyone to sit.
What you convey and what a lot of people convey, is what makes it more difficult for me to do so, because I respect service members and don't want to be seen as disrespecting them in any way. That's why I'm adding the support the troops ribbon while doing so. I realize not all people will see it that way and that's unfortunate, but doesn't change my choice.
I also agree with you and understand that there are a lot of conservative people in this country that feel and continue to feel that media and others suppress their voice. In many cases those concerns are valid so I hope that you continue to express your conservative voice.
-
wlduck
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1722
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:19 pm
Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a
There is much more to it than that. The battle he was watching included rebellious slaves battling with the British. The original song included verses supporting slavery (Key was a slave holder with a complicated history himself). It's an easy Google search for those who want the whole story. We have sanitized it to fit our comfortable version of American History.Duck07 wrote:The Star Spangled Banner is about the Battle of Fort Henry during the Battle of Baltimore. Francis Scott Key was on board a British ship and watched from afar as the city was shelled. People can have whatever feelings the want, but there is an actual history to it which cannot be disputed. This thread needs some kids who went to school in Seattle, its too quiet.
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a
Agree. He could have taken the time to get to know each candidate for sheriff, voted the one in he thought would be the fairest. Unlike us, if Kaep, or Mike Bennett picked up the phone and called a local candidate for office, sheriff, major or probably even governor, they would be able to get a face to face with them. How much easier would it be to vote if you actually got to talk with the people running? Kaep could have done that, figured out which people he thought would best represent what he's fighting for, and vote for them. If you publicly take a stand, you have to be willing to do your part even when millions aren't watching you. And regardless of anyone's thoughts on the electoral process for president, the fact is the President doesn't have near as much effect on local laws as local governments do. If you want to see real changes in your community, that's where it starts.FlDuckFan wrote:There were more things than just the president for him to vote on. Local elections are just as important if not more. The very things he's trying to bring attention to can be effected by local and state appointments. That's the flaw in his argument, let him bring attention to the injustices he's aware of but let him also tell people how to fix them. Many people have said that the shooting of unarmed civilians by the police need to stop and the officers who commit these acts need to face a consequence well if you elect a sheriff or police chief who runs on that guess what will happen. I'm not saying voting is the only answer and is an immediate fix but it has been used in this country to enact change since the beginning and some people seem to have forgotten about that.Duck24 wrote:He’s right, it doesn’t make a difference. The Electoral college gives voters in swing state exponentially more power than voters in states that are solid red or blue. I didn’t vote for president for this exact reason. I knew regardless of my vote, Clinton would clean up in Oregon. If it was a popular vote, I would have pinched my nose, closed my eyes and asked my wife to guide my hand to the Clinton box.FlDuckFan wrote:Duck07 wrote:I lost a lot of respect for Colin Kaepernick and what he purported to stand for when he said that he doesn't vote because it doesn't make a difference. Apathy doesn't make a difference (in a positive way).buckmarkduck wrote: If you have a problem with him, maybe you should vote.
Agreed, for a guy who wants to get his message out he didn't even participate in the most effective way to enact it.
But like I always say when getting into these types of conversations there is a possibility that I could be completely wrong and welcome any coherent opposing point of view.
-
Groundswell
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 753
- Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm
Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a
Since people are bringing up voting, I think it's important in the context of protest to bring up that many of the Trump votes were protest votes. Many people pulled the lever for him knowing full well he was a nincompoop. They just wanted to destroy government institutions they felt were oppressing them. That is their right. But it's not a very patriotic thing to do, and I'd rather they had taken a knee in peaceful protest. Obviously, a person's vote is extremely important, and his/hers' ownership stake in our country. And I defend each right to vote for whomever they choose, but my heart aches for the people who I grew up with--family, friends, fellow countrymen--who sold out every value they believed in and taught me about to make that protest.
- duckduckgoose
- Five Star Recruit
- Posts: 1117
- Joined: Mon Feb 23, 2009 6:45 pm
Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a
Can we also just admit that the Star Spangled Banner is not that great of a song? I was at a sporting event many years ago and America the Beautiful was sung, it brought a lump to my throat.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
- Phalanx
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5324
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm
Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a
I'm old enough to remember when we used to sing America the Beautiful and My Country 'Tis of Thee as often or more often than the 1812 song, which was my least favorite. I'm sure that people from the Howard Zinn school will find something wrong with those songs too, but maybe it's time for a switch.duckduckgoose wrote:Can we also just admit that the Star Spangled Banner is not that great of a song? I was at a sporting event many years ago and America the Beautiful was sung, it brought a lump to my throat.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
P.S. There is some disagreement about what Francis Scott Key is saying in verse three (of the poem, not the song, which may have never actually gone past the second verse). People who rush to cry 'Pro-Slavery' forget that one of the major causes of the war of 1812 was the fondness on the part of the crown to impress men to serve on ships.
Last edited by Phalanx on Wed Sep 27, 2017 9:30 am, edited 1 time in total.
- Bud Lee
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5541
- Joined: Wed Jun 29, 2011 7:03 am
- Location: Da Boot
Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a
I'm surprised I haven't gotten any notifications on this one getting out of hand. Seems like y'all have been able to keep a topic that triggers the crazy to come out in people civil, great job.
A little off topic but what amazes me about this issue is that you have some so angry over it. If these folks actually cared and respected veterans as much as they claim we would't have so many living on the streets.
A little off topic but what amazes me about this issue is that you have some so angry over it. If these folks actually cared and respected veterans as much as they claim we would't have so many living on the streets.
-
Groundswell
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 753
- Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm
Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a
I seem to remember a time in my youth where people barely noticed the National Anthem at public events. Half wouldn't bother with their hats. Lot of folks just remained seated and went about their business. Headed for the concessions and whatnot. I mean "barely" maybe too strong a word, but I definitely remember a solid portion of the crowd not really paying attention and nobody getting too worked up about it. Is my memory wrong here?
-
Handsome Dan
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 688
- Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 3:04 am
Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a
Sadly this is generally true.wlduck wrote:The idea that conservative voices are "suppressed" is laughable. Conservatives hold the White House, the Supreme Court and both houses of congress. Talk radio is a sea of right wing lunatics. Fox News is one large right wing propaganda machine. Even MSNBC feels compelled to add more conservative commenters. The whole "suppression" narrative is part of the GOP Culture War plan (see the "War On Christmas" nonsense) to make lower and middle class white people feel like victims so that they will support GOP policy that is largely opposed to their interests.GrantDuck wrote:The thing for me is that the flag/anthem don't represent "troops". They represent the ideals the United States stands for and that the troops fought for. If the anthem/flag no longer stand for those ideals, then I can't in good conscience stand for ideals so starkly and drastically opposed to that. Ideals that undermine who we are as a people, who I am as a person, and what so many fought and died for.GoDucksIn09 wrote:I would always stand for the anthem... I don't get involved in politics... this is our country and way to many veterans who have fought for our freedom to take a knee is in my opinion disrespectful of them. No question in my mind. There are way better venues to stand up and make a stand for injustices than to sit or kneel during national anthem. As a very conservative person been way to many times media or culture tries to tell me I should shut up or sit down and not say a word. . Everyone has a right to voice their opinion.. even those who are conservative. Standing for the anthem is just the right thing to do no matter what. Too many veterans fought for our freedoms for everyone to sit.
What you convey and what a lot of people convey, is what makes it more difficult for me to do so, because I respect service members and don't want to be seen as disrespecting them in any way. That's why I'm adding the support the troops ribbon while doing so. I realize not all people will see it that way and that's unfortunate, but doesn't change my choice.
I also agree with you and understand that there are a lot of conservative people in this country that feel and continue to feel that media and others suppress their voice. In many cases those concerns are valid so I hope that you continue to express your conservative voice.
- Bud Lee
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5541
- Joined: Wed Jun 29, 2011 7:03 am
- Location: Da Boot
Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a
I remember like that too. I also remember a time when people didn't call each other idiots and dismiss each other simply because one belongs to another political party.ifuwant2 wrote:I seem to remember a time in my youth where people barely noticed the National Anthem at public events. Half wouldn't bother with their hats. Lot of folks just remained seated and went about their business. Headed for the concessions and whatnot. I mean "barely" maybe too strong a word, but I definitely remember a solid portion of the crowd not really paying attention and nobody getting too worked up about it. Is my memory wrong here?
- Phalanx
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5324
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm
Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a
This post betrays a startling lack of understanding of the political landscape in the U.S, and probably what the word 'conservative' means. Trump has never been thought of as a 'conservative' - the man was a Democrat until only a few years ago. He is completely on his own program. The conservative element in the House and Senate is constantly at odds with the leadership in both parties - they aren't close to a majority in either. Moreover, if conservatives held the Supreme Court, murdering babies would definitely be illegal by now.wlduck wrote:
The idea that conservative voices are "suppressed" is laughable. Conservatives hold the White House, the Supreme Court and both houses of congress. Talk radio is a sea of right wing lunatics. Fox News is one large right wing propaganda machine. Even MSNBC feels compelled to add more conservative commenters. The whole "suppression" narrative is part of the GOP Culture War plan (see the "War On Christmas" nonsense) to make lower and middle class white people feel like victims so that they will support GOP policy that is largely opposed to their interests.
The truth is that every facet of our system is being run by fans of big government, heavy spending, and massive and frequent interventionist foreign policy. It has been this way my whole life, with the possible exception of the Reagan years, and there is no end to it in sight. None of that program could ever reasonably be considered 'conservative'.
- lukeyrid13
- All-American
- Posts: 10475
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
- GM: Portland TrailBlazers
Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a
I think the notion is more about misperception than anything else. If you were to listen to say: Dennis Prager, been Shapiro, Tucker Carlson or even say Adam carolla, they have rational valid points. You can disagree and that's fine but every single one is labeled a biggot, racist etc and shot down immediately in attempts to nullify and drown out their voices.Handsome Dan wrote:Sadly this is generally true.wlduck wrote:The idea that conservative voices are "suppressed" is laughable. Conservatives hold the White House, the Supreme Court and both houses of congress. Talk radio is a sea of right wing lunatics. Fox News is one large right wing propaganda machine. Even MSNBC feels compelled to add more conservative commenters. The whole "suppression" narrative is part of the GOP Culture War plan (see the "War On Christmas" nonsense) to make lower and middle class white people feel like victims so that they will support GOP policy that is largely opposed to their interests.GrantDuck wrote:The thing for me is that the flag/anthem don't represent "troops". They represent the ideals the United States stands for and that the troops fought for. If the anthem/flag no longer stand for those ideals, then I can't in good conscience stand for ideals so starkly and drastically opposed to that. Ideals that undermine who we are as a people, who I am as a person, and what so many fought and died for.GoDucksIn09 wrote:I would always stand for the anthem... I don't get involved in politics... this is our country and way to many veterans who have fought for our freedom to take a knee is in my opinion disrespectful of them. No question in my mind. There are way better venues to stand up and make a stand for injustices than to sit or kneel during national anthem. As a very conservative person been way to many times media or culture tries to tell me I should shut up or sit down and not say a word. . Everyone has a right to voice their opinion.. even those who are conservative. Standing for the anthem is just the right thing to do no matter what. Too many veterans fought for our freedoms for everyone to sit.
What you convey and what a lot of people convey, is what makes it more difficult for me to do so, because I respect service members and don't want to be seen as disrespecting them in any way. That's why I'm adding the support the troops ribbon while doing so. I realize not all people will see it that way and that's unfortunate, but doesn't change my choice.
I also agree with you and understand that there are a lot of conservative people in this country that feel and continue to feel that media and others suppress their voice. In many cases those concerns are valid so I hope that you continue to express your conservative voice.
- justducky0
- Senior
- Posts: 2012
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:02 pm
- Location: The Real World
Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a
Most of America talking about this...

Our community talking about this


Our community talking about this


-
Handsome Dan
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 688
- Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 3:04 am
Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a
I don't think most people label any of those commentators "bigots" or "racists" when attempting to criticize what they say. While those commentators do raise valid points sometimes, the work they produce is typically rife with misleading statements and intellectual dishonesty, and that is usually where the criticism would focus. If asked to give a quick complaint on Ben Shapiro, for example, I'd focus on his inconsistency, disingenuity, and hypocrisy, rather than calling him a bigot or a racist.lukeyrid13 wrote:I think the notion is more about misperception than anything else. If you were to listen to say: Dennis Prager, been Shapiro, Tucker Carlson or even say Adam carolla, they have rational valid points. You can disagree and that's fine but every single one is labeled a biggot, racist etc and shot down immediately in attempts to nullify and drown out their voices.Handsome Dan wrote:Sadly this is generally true.wlduck wrote:The idea that conservative voices are "suppressed" is laughable. Conservatives hold the White House, the Supreme Court and both houses of congress. Talk radio is a sea of right wing lunatics. Fox News is one large right wing propaganda machine. Even MSNBC feels compelled to add more conservative commenters. The whole "suppression" narrative is part of the GOP Culture War plan (see the "War On Christmas" nonsense) to make lower and middle class white people feel like victims so that they will support GOP policy that is largely opposed to their interests.GrantDuck wrote:The thing for me is that the flag/anthem don't represent "troops". They represent the ideals the United States stands for and that the troops fought for. If the anthem/flag no longer stand for those ideals, then I can't in good conscience stand for ideals so starkly and drastically opposed to that. Ideals that undermine who we are as a people, who I am as a person, and what so many fought and died for.GoDucksIn09 wrote:I would always stand for the anthem... I don't get involved in politics... this is our country and way to many veterans who have fought for our freedom to take a knee is in my opinion disrespectful of them. No question in my mind. There are way better venues to stand up and make a stand for injustices than to sit or kneel during national anthem. As a very conservative person been way to many times media or culture tries to tell me I should shut up or sit down and not say a word. . Everyone has a right to voice their opinion.. even those who are conservative. Standing for the anthem is just the right thing to do no matter what. Too many veterans fought for our freedoms for everyone to sit.
What you convey and what a lot of people convey, is what makes it more difficult for me to do so, because I respect service members and don't want to be seen as disrespecting them in any way. That's why I'm adding the support the troops ribbon while doing so. I realize not all people will see it that way and that's unfortunate, but doesn't change my choice.
I also agree with you and understand that there are a lot of conservative people in this country that feel and continue to feel that media and others suppress their voice. In many cases those concerns are valid so I hope that you continue to express your conservative voice.
I do agree that people are sometimes too quick to jump to using this labels when they hear opinions that are displeasing to them, and that even if people express opinions that do indicate some level of bigotry or racism, they aren't necessarily actual bigots or racists. But that doesn't mean that there is some concerted effort to suppress conservative voices; it just means that some liberals aren't very good at understanding the nuance there.