The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the aisle

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Locked
User avatar
Duckenstein
Freshman
Posts: 1433
Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2016 7:43 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Duckenstein »

greenyellow wrote:
Duckenstein wrote:
wlduck wrote:
GrantDuck wrote:
GoDucksIn09 wrote:I would always stand for the anthem... I don't get involved in politics... this is our country and way to many veterans who have fought for our freedom to take a knee is in my opinion disrespectful of them. No question in my mind. There are way better venues to stand up and make a stand for injustices than to sit or kneel during national anthem. As a very conservative person been way to many times media or culture tries to tell me I should shut up or sit down and not say a word. . Everyone has a right to voice their opinion.. even those who are conservative. Standing for the anthem is just the right thing to do no matter what. Too many veterans fought for our freedoms for everyone to sit.
The thing for me is that the flag/anthem don't represent "troops". They represent the ideals the United States stands for and that the troops fought for. If the anthem/flag no longer stand for those ideals, then I can't in good conscience stand for ideals so starkly and drastically opposed to that. Ideals that undermine who we are as a people, who I am as a person, and what so many fought and died for.

What you convey and what a lot of people convey, is what makes it more difficult for me to do so, because I respect service members and don't want to be seen as disrespecting them in any way. That's why I'm adding the support the troops ribbon while doing so. I realize not all people will see it that way and that's unfortunate, but doesn't change my choice.

I also agree with you and understand that there are a lot of conservative people in this country that feel and continue to feel that media and others suppress their voice. In many cases those concerns are valid so I hope that you continue to express your conservative voice.
The idea that conservative voices are "suppressed" is laughable. Conservatives hold the White House, the Supreme Court and both houses of congress. Talk radio is a sea of right wing lunatics. Fox News is one large right wing propaganda machine. Even MSNBC feels compelled to add more conservative commenters. The whole "suppression" narrative is part of the GOP Culture War plan (see the "War On Christmas" nonsense) to make lower and middle class white people feel like victims so that they will support GOP policy that is largely opposed to their interests.
I'm Left on the scale, and I'd be inclined to say most MSM is Center Right. They allow for some social freedom, but are extremely regressive on matters of money and also very hawkish. They generally support corporate ideology.

The coocoo right wing outlets like Breitbart make up a tiny fraction of the media.
Much of that seeming center-rightness likely comes from the corporate interests of most news corporations but for a lot of social and even some foreign policy stuff, they are really to the left. A look at campaign contributions from media members would show that a vast majority (60=705) of it goes to Democratic candidates versus Republicans. Then you look at who major media outlets (namely magazines and newspapers) endorse for president and other political offices, which most of the time are the Democratic candidates.
Definitely, media seems to favor Democrats over Republicans but one can make a good argument that the Democratic Party is center right on most issues. Which issues are the Democrats to the left? Yes, they talk a good game, but they don't generally pursue leftist policy
User avatar
Duckenstein
Freshman
Posts: 1433
Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2016 7:43 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Duckenstein »

pdxmallard wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:Whether he exercises his right to vote really has no bearing on him exercising his right to peaceful protest. I agree, it's dumb for anyone to not vote -- and Kaep has been not voting since long before last year's election -- but for some recent perspective, I can think of 3 million reasons why people might think their votes don't matter.

Now, combine that with the apathy many non-white Americans feel as a result from institutionalized bias/racism/privilege that usually banks against them, and I can't honestly blame people who perceive voting as an exercise in futility.
I absolutely agree with this. There has never (for the last 2000+ years anyway) been a meaningful protest without an established group finding fault with the methods/messenger in order to avoid the message.
Nail on the head.

When you see the establishment attack the messenger, you know the message has some truth to it
Groundswell
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 753
Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Groundswell »

Duckenstein wrote:
greenyellow wrote:
Duckenstein wrote:
wlduck wrote:
GrantDuck wrote:
GoDucksIn09 wrote:I would always stand for the anthem... I don't get involved in politics... this is our country and way to many veterans who have fought for our freedom to take a knee is in my opinion disrespectful of them. No question in my mind. There are way better venues to stand up and make a stand for injustices than to sit or kneel during national anthem. As a very conservative person been way to many times media or culture tries to tell me I should shut up or sit down and not say a word. . Everyone has a right to voice their opinion.. even those who are conservative. Standing for the anthem is just the right thing to do no matter what. Too many veterans fought for our freedoms for everyone to sit.
The thing for me is that the flag/anthem don't represent "troops". They represent the ideals the United States stands for and that the troops fought for. If the anthem/flag no longer stand for those ideals, then I can't in good conscience stand for ideals so starkly and drastically opposed to that. Ideals that undermine who we are as a people, who I am as a person, and what so many fought and died for.

What you convey and what a lot of people convey, is what makes it more difficult for me to do so, because I respect service members and don't want to be seen as disrespecting them in any way. That's why I'm adding the support the troops ribbon while doing so. I realize not all people will see it that way and that's unfortunate, but doesn't change my choice.

I also agree with you and understand that there are a lot of conservative people in this country that feel and continue to feel that media and others suppress their voice. In many cases those concerns are valid so I hope that you continue to express your conservative voice.
The idea that conservative voices are "suppressed" is laughable. Conservatives hold the White House, the Supreme Court and both houses of congress. Talk radio is a sea of right wing lunatics. Fox News is one large right wing propaganda machine. Even MSNBC feels compelled to add more conservative commenters. The whole "suppression" narrative is part of the GOP Culture War plan (see the "War On Christmas" nonsense) to make lower and middle class white people feel like victims so that they will support GOP policy that is largely opposed to their interests.
I'm Left on the scale, and I'd be inclined to say most MSM is Center Right. They allow for some social freedom, but are extremely regressive on matters of money and also very hawkish. They generally support corporate ideology.

The coocoo right wing outlets like Breitbart make up a tiny fraction of the media.
Much of that seeming center-rightness likely comes from the corporate interests of most news corporations but for a lot of social and even some foreign policy stuff, they are really to the left. A look at campaign contributions from media members would show that a vast majority (60=705) of it goes to Democratic candidates versus Republicans. Then you look at who major media outlets (namely magazines and newspapers) endorse for president and other political offices, which most of the time are the Democratic candidates.
Definitely, media seems to favor Democrats over Republicans but one can make a good argument that the Democratic Party is center right on most issues. Which issues are the Democrats to the left? Yes, they talk a good game, but they don't generally pursue leftist policy
This. Mainstream Dems are not really Liberal at all. The Party is Neo-Liberal, which protects the status quo and serves corporate interests both at home and abroad. They want stability. They only go hard on social changes if corporations sign off on it. CNN and most mags and newspapers are merely the arm or leg of a much larger conglomerate who wants security. This is why the Sanders folks are fed up. The only see moderate Republicans in the mainstream media. And by Leftist standards, it's true.

BTW, I lived in Austin, TX, years ago when Alex Jones used to be a street ranter. He'd stand on the side of the road with a megaphone shouting about UFO's and Owl Gods and the New World Order. Then the internet came along. Now he has a direct line to the White House.
TualatinDuck
Senior
Posts: 2439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:23 am
Location: Tualatin

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by TualatinDuck »

That's freaking scary!
"And I can be the warrior for those who are frail and weak,
And I can be the compass for those that search and seek." ~Lem Absher
User avatar
Tray Dub
Senior
Posts: 4994
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:31 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Tray Dub »

Duckenstein wrote:
pdxmallard wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:Whether he exercises his right to vote really has no bearing on him exercising his right to peaceful protest. I agree, it's dumb for anyone to not vote -- and Kaep has been not voting since long before last year's election -- but for some recent perspective, I can think of 3 million reasons why people might think their votes don't matter.

Now, combine that with the apathy many non-white Americans feel as a result from institutionalized bias/racism/privilege that usually banks against them, and I can't honestly blame people who perceive voting as an exercise in futility.
I absolutely agree with this. There has never (for the last 2000+ years anyway) been a meaningful protest without an established group finding fault with the methods/messenger in order to avoid the message.
Nail on the head.

When you see the establishment attack the messenger, you know the message has some truth to it
The establishment Boogeymen were pretty upset with Charlottesville protesters, no?
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Duck07 »

The easiest way to explain the differences at the Federal level is that a Democratic POTUS favors abortion while a Republican POTUS does not. Every single issue they all agree on except that one.

Why does Alex Jones' conspiracy stuff bother people? Is the Iran/Contra affair not a prime example of conspiracies being true? Hell my original post mentions the Gulf of Tonkin, how many people even know that story? Jeremy Renner's movie Kill The Messenger documented the truth of our CIA operations and how forces conspired against the real messenger to quiet the story. Now we've got a new Tom Cruise movie openly glorifying the operation from another side. WTC 7 is still to this day the only steel building in history to collapse because of fire and Flight 93 is still the only plane crash to have no substantive wreckage at the crash site, same with the Pentagon.
Image
Groundswell
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 753
Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Groundswell »

Duck07 wrote:The easiest way to explain the differences at the Federal level is that a Democratic POTUS favors abortion while a Republican POTUS does not. Every single issue they all agree on except that one.

Why does Alex Jones' conspiracy stuff bother people? Is the Iran/Contra affair not a prime example of conspiracies being true? Hell my original post mentions the Gulf of Tonkin, how many people even know that story? Jeremy Renner's movie Kill The Messenger documented the truth of our CIA operations and how forces conspired against the real messenger to quiet the story. Now we've got a new Tom Cruise movie openly glorifying the operation from another side. WTC 7 is still to this day the only steel building in history to collapse because of fire and Flight 93 is still the only plane crash to have no substantive wreckage at the crash site, same with the Pentagon.
I guess I would say there's a difference between there being examples of conspiracy and being a lunatic. Jones is a lunatic. I've seen him up close in person. He was doing this schtick 25 years ago on the street. He's made a business out of it. Good for him. He shouldn't be anywhere near the presidential office.
TualatinDuck
Senior
Posts: 2439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:23 am
Location: Tualatin

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by TualatinDuck »

Duck07 wrote:The easiest way to explain the differences at the Federal level is that a Democratic POTUS favors abortion while a Republican POTUS does not. Every single issue they all agree on except that one.

Why does Alex Jones' conspiracy stuff bother people? Is the Iran/Contra affair not a prime example of conspiracies being true? Hell my original post mentions the Gulf of Tonkin, how many people even know that story? Jeremy Renner's movie Kill The Messenger documented the truth of our CIA operations and how forces conspired against the real messenger to quiet the story. Now we've got a new Tom Cruise movie openly glorifying the operation from another side. WTC 7 is still to this day the only steel building in history to collapse because of fire and Flight 93 is still the only plane crash to have no substantive wreckage at the crash site, same with the Pentagon.
Major history buff so yes I know the Tonkin story from both sides. After that you lost me. Alex Jones is a joke and I'm a conservative! He just spouts ridiculous conspiracy like its truth and is far worse than Clive Lewis. Hard to listen to someone who thinks aliens have infiltrated our government.
"And I can be the warrior for those who are frail and weak,
And I can be the compass for those that search and seek." ~Lem Absher
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Duck07 »

For those who do feel upset about showing any respect or positive sentiment towards the flag or the country, did you have those feelings prior to Kaepernick and if not, what changed with his kneeling?

Are the issues that they and others protesting getting worse or have they been increasing over time and relative to each generation?
Image
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6488
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by pezsez1 »

The easiest way to explain the differences at the Federal level is that a Democratic POTUS favors abortion while a Republican POTUS does not. Every single issue they all agree on except that one.
They're not quite THAT close. Other big differences include how to tax the wealthiest Americans, whether all citizens should be entitled to healthcare, gun control, whether the federal minimum wage should be lifted, subsidies for education, investment in social services, attitudes toward immigration (hello Dreamers), support for religious freedom laws, investments in alternative energy and curbing man-made climate change.... those are just off the top of my head.

I'd even argue that liberals don't really focus on abortion as much as they do preserving access for women to receive healthcare... and conservatives often threaten that with a scorched-earth approach to abortion access. Each side frames the argument based on what they value most.

I think Democrats and Republicans used to be closer than they are currently, but the influence of the alt-right within the GOP has really pushed the party to the right. And now, perhaps as a reaction, you have the Berniecrats making noise and trying to take Democrats farther left. So far, though, the left's progressive wing hasn't had nearly the same impact as the right's Tea Party/alt-right wing. (Though I highly doubt Trump would have won had the GOP's "establishment" voters not been split among so many candidates during the primaries.)
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
lukeyrid13
All-American
Posts: 10475
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
GM: Portland TrailBlazers

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by lukeyrid13 »

pezsez1 wrote:
The easiest way to explain the differences at the Federal level is that a Democratic POTUS favors abortion while a Republican POTUS does not. Every single issue they all agree on except that one.
They're not quite THAT close. Other big differences include how to tax the wealthiest Americans, whether all citizens should be entitled to healthcare, gun control, whether the federal minimum wage should be lifted, subsidies for education, investment in social services, attitudes toward immigration (hello Dreamers), support for religious freedom laws, investments in alternative energy and curbing man-made climate change.... those are just off the top of my head.

I'd even argue that liberals don't really focus on abortion as much as they do preserving access for women to receive healthcare... and conservatives often threaten that with a scorched-earth approach to abortion access. Each side frames the argument based on what they value most.

I think Democrats and Republicans used to be closer than they are currently, but the influence of the alt-right within the GOP has really pushed the party to the right. And now, perhaps as a reaction, you have the Berniecrats making noise and trying to take Democrats farther left. So far, though, the left's progressive wing hasn't had nearly the same impact as the right's Tea Party/alt-right wing. (Though I highly doubt Trump would have won had the GOP's "establishment" voters not been split among so many candidates during the primaries.)
I'm gonna have to disagree with this. There is a bit of an alt-right movement, but they have numbers in the thousands, maybe tens of thousands. They make up such a small percentage of the conservative right that without the media spotlighting them and giving guys like Milo Y and David Duke an outlet they'd essentially go unnoticed(Charlotesville not withstanding). I'm of the opinion that the left has shifted more than the right who has stayed grounded in their ideals(calling card of the right) while the left has changed their opinions on: Gay marriage, transgender laws, healthcare, relaxing on immigration, free speech etc just in the past decade. There has been a shift and the sides are certainly further apart, we can at least agree on that and it's just a matter of perspective I suppose.
Handsome Dan
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 688
Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 3:04 am

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Handsome Dan »

TualatinDuck wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:
But it shows that he's not the best conduit for discussing said issues.
Whether he exercises his right to vote really has no bearing on him exercising his right to peaceful protest. I agree, it's dumb for anyone to not vote -- and Kaep has been not voting since long before last year's election -- but for some recent perspective, I can think of 3 million reasons why people might think their votes don't matter.

Now, combine that with the apathy many non-white Americans feel as a result from institutionalized bias/racism/privilege that usually banks against them, and I can't honestly blame people who perceive voting as an exercise in futility. (Add in the fact that most people who make the ballot don't often represent the views and issues of non-white Americans, all the more reasons for voting to be met with a shrug.)

To get more on topic... sit or stand...

I didn't want to answer this earlier, but Duck24 is right... this thread is pretty civil. So here's my honest answer.

I didn't go to any Duck games last year, and I probably won't go to any this year. Part of the reason is money -- I could justify a couple games, but the budget would get tight -- but part of the reason is honestly the national anthem. It would take a lot to make me sit. For now, though, standing through it makes me feel ill. Had to do it the other night at a high school football game, and honestly I felt like a fraud. I'd rather stay in the locker room than go anywhere near the flag or the anthem. In other words, best for me to stay home and barbecue where I can sit in peace.
Very well said! I also agree his not voting does not decrease his right to protest, it just weakens his argument from a personal perspective point. When I have a d1 player tell me it never crossed his mind until I asked, that to me was telling. I stand by my previous comment, this last weekend was a reaction to Trump and not about the actual issue.
Trump and what Trump represents is the same issue.
User avatar
Phenom
All Pac-12
Posts: 9914
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:49 am

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Phenom »

lukeyrid13 wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:
The easiest way to explain the differences at the Federal level is that a Democratic POTUS favors abortion while a Republican POTUS does not. Every single issue they all agree on except that one.
They're not quite THAT close. Other big differences include how to tax the wealthiest Americans, whether all citizens should be entitled to healthcare, gun control, whether the federal minimum wage should be lifted, subsidies for education, investment in social services, attitudes toward immigration (hello Dreamers), support for religious freedom laws, investments in alternative energy and curbing man-made climate change.... those are just off the top of my head.

I'd even argue that liberals don't really focus on abortion as much as they do preserving access for women to receive healthcare... and conservatives often threaten that with a scorched-earth approach to abortion access. Each side frames the argument based on what they value most.

I think Democrats and Republicans used to be closer than they are currently, but the influence of the alt-right within the GOP has really pushed the party to the right. And now, perhaps as a reaction, you have the Berniecrats making noise and trying to take Democrats farther left. So far, though, the left's progressive wing hasn't had nearly the same impact as the right's Tea Party/alt-right wing. (Though I highly doubt Trump would have won had the GOP's "establishment" voters not been split among so many candidates during the primaries.)
I'm gonna have to disagree with this. There is a bit of an alt-right movement, but they have numbers in the thousands, maybe tens of thousands. They make up such a small percentage of the conservative right that without the media spotlighting them and giving guys like Milo Y and David Duke an outlet they'd essentially go unnoticed(Charlotesville not withstanding). I'm of the opinion that the left has shifted more than the right who has stayed grounded in their ideals(calling card of the right) while the left has changed their opinions on: Gay marriage, transgender laws, healthcare, relaxing on immigration, free speech etc just in the past decade. There has been a shift and the sides are certainly further apart, we can at least agree on that and it's just a matter of perspective I suppose.
Alt right is way bigger than "thousands".
User avatar
lukeyrid13
All-American
Posts: 10475
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
GM: Portland TrailBlazers

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by lukeyrid13 »

Phenom wrote:
lukeyrid13 wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:
The easiest way to explain the differences at the Federal level is that a Democratic POTUS favors abortion while a Republican POTUS does not. Every single issue they all agree on except that one.
They're not quite THAT close. Other big differences include how to tax the wealthiest Americans, whether all citizens should be entitled to healthcare, gun control, whether the federal minimum wage should be lifted, subsidies for education, investment in social services, attitudes toward immigration (hello Dreamers), support for religious freedom laws, investments in alternative energy and curbing man-made climate change.... those are just off the top of my head.

I'd even argue that liberals don't really focus on abortion as much as they do preserving access for women to receive healthcare... and conservatives often threaten that with a scorched-earth approach to abortion access. Each side frames the argument based on what they value most.

I think Democrats and Republicans used to be closer than they are currently, but the influence of the alt-right within the GOP has really pushed the party to the right. And now, perhaps as a reaction, you have the Berniecrats making noise and trying to take Democrats farther left. So far, though, the left's progressive wing hasn't had nearly the same impact as the right's Tea Party/alt-right wing. (Though I highly doubt Trump would have won had the GOP's "establishment" voters not been split among so many candidates during the primaries.)
I'm gonna have to disagree with this. There is a bit of an alt-right movement, but they have numbers in the thousands, maybe tens of thousands. They make up such a small percentage of the conservative right that without the media spotlighting them and giving guys like Milo Y and David Duke an outlet they'd essentially go unnoticed(Charlotesville not withstanding). I'm of the opinion that the left has shifted more than the right who has stayed grounded in their ideals(calling card of the right) while the left has changed their opinions on: Gay marriage, transgender laws, healthcare, relaxing on immigration, free speech etc just in the past decade. There has been a shift and the sides are certainly further apart, we can at least agree on that and it's just a matter of perspective I suppose.
Alt right is way bigger than "thousands".
I looked it up and there is no concrete number but KKK membership is around 7,000. There are obviously other radicals out there and I saw one estimate that around 140,000 right wing extremists/Alt-Right were out there. Definitely too large but not incredibly alarming. Now, I will say that if Trump had denounced them in primaries, and after Charlotesville things would presumably be very different. He needs PR help desperately, and by my and most estimates the voters/support he might lose by losing the Alt-Right wouldn't even affect his numbers. That's the only explanation I have for him not denouncing them whenever he can, is that he's afraid of losing some votes but he would be incredibly wise to bite the bullet on that front.
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by buckmarkduck »

Duck07 wrote:For those who do feel upset about showing any respect or positive sentiment towards the flag or the country, did you have those feelings prior to Kaepernick and if not, what changed with his kneeling?

Are the issues that they and others protesting getting worse or have they been increasing over time and relative to each generation?
I really wasnt mad or even giving it much thought when Kaep did it. My problem is players doing it to protest the President, who cares what he said? I liked how Seattle and Tennessee did it, not everyone wants to kneel and not everyone wants to stand, so go back to how the nfl used to do it until 2001 or whatever, and stay in the locker room. And my argument is and will continue to be the flag doesn't represent any president. I'm all for everyone having equal rights and I'd bet most here are for that.
Locked