The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the aisle

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Locked
User avatar
Tray Dub
Senior
Posts: 4994
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:31 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Tray Dub »

lukeyrid13 wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:
They said they'd protest the disparity between what America says it is and what it actually is.
I didn't say that, either. I'm not protesting anything. But I'm firmly behind the protesters. If pressed, I'd rather kneel with them than pretend racism is dead and that everything is tremendous and beautiful.

You know who I have zero respect for? The hypocritical idiots who boo the national anthem protesters. You can't be against anthem protests and then protest them during the anthem. That's not how life works.
As I said before, I don't want to start a vitriolic argument but instead a civil discussion....but in what ways is the gov't racist and where do we see systemic racism? I am fully against racism, but outside of a few nut jobs in Charlottesville, where is all this racism affecting the average American?
According to a lot of black people*, policing in poor black neighborhoods is often pretty bad. From what I understand, they say they feel targeted by police more than protected. And hell, if I was a cop in a high-crime area, I might view the people who live there suspiciously. But that can foster bad relationships with the community and lead to this cycle of escalating mistrust and contempt between the police and the people they're supposed to be serving.

I'm not black, I don't live in a neighborhood like that, so I don't know. But a lot of black people do genuinely have experiences like that, and while I understand being cautious about throwing cops under the bus I also think it's important for people outside those black communities to take what they're reporting seriously.

*I know I know, that's not exactly an authoritative source.
Last edited by Tray Dub on Wed Sep 27, 2017 9:48 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Phenom
All Pac-12
Posts: 9914
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:49 am

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Phenom »

Image
Handsome Dan
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 688
Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 3:04 am

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Handsome Dan »

lukeyrid13 wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:
They said they'd protest the disparity between what America says it is and what it actually is.
I didn't say that, either. I'm not protesting anything. But I'm firmly behind the protesters. If pressed, I'd rather kneel with them than pretend racism is dead and that everything is tremendous and beautiful.

You know who I have zero respect for? The hypocritical idiots who boo the national anthem protesters. You can't be against anthem protests and then protest them during the anthem. That's not how life works.
As I said before, I don't want to start a vitriolic argument but instead a civil discussion....but in what ways is the gov't racist and where do we see systemic racism? I am fully against racism, but outside of a few nut jobs in Charlottesville, where is all this racism affecting the average American?
I don't have time to write a response right now but I'd be happy to help address this when I can.
User avatar
Phenom
All Pac-12
Posts: 9914
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:49 am

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Phenom »

lukeyrid13 wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:
They said they'd protest the disparity between what America says it is and what it actually is.
I didn't say that, either. I'm not protesting anything. But I'm firmly behind the protesters. If pressed, I'd rather kneel with them than pretend racism is dead and that everything is tremendous and beautiful.

You know who I have zero respect for? The hypocritical idiots who boo the national anthem protesters. You can't be against anthem protests and then protest them during the anthem. That's not how life works.
As I said before, I don't want to start a vitriolic argument but instead a civil discussion....but in what ways is the gov't racist and where do we see systemic racism? I am fully against racism, but outside of a few nut jobs in Charlottesville, where is all this racism affecting the average American?
Just because it doesn't affect you that doesn't mean it's not happening. That's the definition of white privilege.

Anyways, here's some evidence:
http://www.rootcausecoalition.org/wp-co ... ntions.pdf
https://www.usnews.com/news/blogs/at-th ... ay-of-life
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/bla ... b8000d687f
https://www.aclu.org/sites/default/file ... sion_0.pdf
Groundswell
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 753
Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Groundswell »

lukeyrid13 wrote:http://www.dailywire.com/news/8638/what ... n-shapiro#


I am going off of Ben Shapiro's definition of the Alt-Right because he is way smarter than I pertain to be.
The article I linked to is actually somewhat similar to this in defining the Alt-Right. Of course we could disagree in many ways, but I will grant you that true conservatism isn't inherently racist. It's the political party that uses race to win elections. And to an extent both parties are guilty...to what extent is up for every American to consider soberly, and with an earnest heart.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6487
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by pezsez1 »

As I said before, I don't want to start a vitriolic argument but instead a civil discussion....but in what ways is the gov't racist and where do we see systemic racism? I am fully against racism, but outside of a few nut jobs in Charlottesville, where is all this racism affecting the average American?
I'm not sure characterizing this as the government being racist is the best way to illustrate the issue.

Rather, the first step is accepting that everyone is, to some degree, racist. This doesn't mean we're all terrible people -- it just means that racism is a natural, instinctive thing. It's everywhere, and the best we can do is be aware of it and try to minimize its influence.

That said...
where is all this racism affecting the average American?
Disclaimer: When I use the word racism, I'm not always using it in the context of "OMG, that's like KKK-level racism!" I'm mainly using it in the sense of "racism is a natural thing, it is what it is, and everyone's racist by human nature." So it's not necessarily "bad." It just is what it is. OK, that being said....

If by "average" American you mean white American, then I'm not surprised you struggle to understand the systemic racism in American culture. White Americans have it pretty good. Most politicians are white, most cops are white, most college administrators are white, most employers are white, most people who live in middle- and upper-class neighborhoods are white. Most white people (especially in the state of Oregon) are incredibly sheltered in terms of racism and race relations in general.

But how do African Americans and other ethnic minorities experience racism on a daily basis? Man oh man.

I'll just give you one example -- Trump's wall.

I'm using this example BECAUSE I've seen so many Trump supporters say this isn't racist. However, the whole desire for the wall is built on a premise that illegal immigrants are spilling over our borders and committing all kinds of crime. (They're rapists, they're bad people, blah blah blah.) However, that entire train of thought isn't backed by facts... it's powerful, though, because of a perception that brown people commit more crimes, and brown people are immigrants, and many immigrants are "illegals," therefore illegals are dangerous... and we need a wall to keep them out!

Reality is that less than 3 percent of all illegal immigrants have ever committed either a misdemeanor or a felony. Most are homeowners. I believe most have been here for more than 10 years. Many (or most) don't come spilling over the border -- they come here legally but then do things like overstay their work visas. But they hold jobs, pay taxes, go to school and contribute to our communities. They don't freeload. As much as the average documented American, they make our country a decent place to live.

Now... imagine being a Mexican American and having to constantly listen to Trump and Republicans in general rant about this wall and how Mexicans are criminals and blah blah blah blah blah (mainly amplified by social media, where people talk without conscious or filters). Imagine how that changes the way you feel when you're out and about in the community. Imagine how you might feel when you're alone and surrounded by white people. Imagine how they feel when people then make racist comments to them.

But this isn't just about feelings. This racism-based sentiment toward immigrants can influence groups of white people to discriminate against Mexican Americans in various ways. Renting out a room or home, and need to choose a tenant? Hiring someone for a job at your work? Thinking of calling the cops on a suspicious door-to-door salesman who might be an illegal? Step back and think about how prevailing attitudes can affect all kinds of human interactions and transactions, and you begin to see the very real impacts of systemic/institutional racism.

(To a more insignificant degree, these narratives also build racism among other groups toward whites, but the nature of institutional racism is generally driven by the majority/most privileged demographic.)

These collective attitudes fall like dominos to impact lives in other ways. For example, Dreamer kids. These young people -- whose only home is the United States -- are now at risk of deportation for no real reasons other than race-driven myths about immigrants. This IS systemic racism. Most people don't think of something as racist unless it involves white-hooded figures, the N word or people swinging from trees. Systemic racism is far more pervasive and much more insidious. And it can be harder to accept when doing so challenges one's personal opinions.

I could go on and on and on talking about different examples of institutional racism.... but doing so isn't nearly as important as simply coming to understand the entirety of racism. And it's definitely not easy. Just remember though that everyone's at least a little bit racist, and we can't help it, so nobody should feel defensive when trying to understand how racism manifests itself in their views.
Last edited by pezsez1 on Wed Sep 27, 2017 10:31 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
lukeyrid13
All-American
Posts: 10475
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
GM: Portland TrailBlazers

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by lukeyrid13 »

Phenom wrote:
lukeyrid13 wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:
They said they'd protest the disparity between what America says it is and what it actually is.
I didn't say that, either. I'm not protesting anything. But I'm firmly behind the protesters. If pressed, I'd rather kneel with them than pretend racism is dead and that everything is tremendous and beautiful.

You know who I have zero respect for? The hypocritical idiots who boo the national anthem protesters. You can't be against anthem protests and then protest them during the anthem. That's not how life works.
As I said before, I don't want to start a vitriolic argument but instead a civil discussion....but in what ways is the gov't racist and where do we see systemic racism? I am fully against racism, but outside of a few nut jobs in Charlottesville, where is all this racism affecting the average American?
Just because it doesn't affect you that doesn't mean it's not happening. That's the definition of white privilege.

Anyways, here's some evidence:
http://www.rootcausecoalition.org/wp-co ... ntions.pdf
https://www.usnews.com/news/blogs/at-th ... ay-of-life
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/bla ... b8000d687f
https://www.aclu.org/sites/default/file ... sion_0.pdf
I scanned the first article(very long) and read the second and will go through the rest completely in the morning.

Solely in response to the second article, I think it all comes down to a matter of opinion and perspective(basically the entirety of this thread) but the stats they throw out are counter intuitive IMO. Stating that black kids are 3x as likely to get suspended than whites, 73% of whites own homes compared to 43%, 40% of expelled students are black and that 50% of violent crimes are commit by blacks. I think everyone can agree that those aren't flattering numbers but I suppose the debate is HOW we get to those numbers. I would argue that it's the fact that 72% of black kids grow up in a single family home in comparison to say only 18% in the Asian community.

If we really wanted to boil it down though, I think we have a class problem more than a race problem. Poor neighborhoods have exponentially higher crime rates and also get way less benefit of the doubt in pretty much all facets of life. Now, because of segregation a lot of communities still see a race disparity geographically( ie Harlem, Miami/Little Haiti, Chicago North/South etc) and what is now a matter of class could very easily be conceived as being a matter of race.
Groundswell
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 753
Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Groundswell »

lukeyrid13 wrote:
Phenom wrote:
lukeyrid13 wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:
They said they'd protest the disparity between what America says it is and what it actually is.
I didn't say that, either. I'm not protesting anything. But I'm firmly behind the protesters. If pressed, I'd rather kneel with them than pretend racism is dead and that everything is tremendous and beautiful.

You know who I have zero respect for? The hypocritical idiots who boo the national anthem protesters. You can't be against anthem protests and then protest them during the anthem. That's not how life works.
As I said before, I don't want to start a vitriolic argument but instead a civil discussion....but in what ways is the gov't racist and where do we see systemic racism? I am fully against racism, but outside of a few nut jobs in Charlottesville, where is all this racism affecting the average American?
Just because it doesn't affect you that doesn't mean it's not happening. That's the definition of white privilege.

Anyways, here's some evidence:
http://www.rootcausecoalition.org/wp-co ... ntions.pdf
https://www.usnews.com/news/blogs/at-th ... ay-of-life
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/bla ... b8000d687f
https://www.aclu.org/sites/default/file ... sion_0.pdf
I scanned the first article(very long) and read the second and will go through the rest completely in the morning.

Solely in response to the second article, I think it all comes down to a matter of opinion and perspective(basically the entirety of this thread) but the stats they throw out are counter intuitive IMO. Stating that black kids are 3x as likely to get suspended than whites, 73% of whites own homes compared to 43%, 40% of expelled students are black and that 50% of violent crimes are commit by blacks. I think everyone can agree that those aren't flattering numbers but I suppose the debate is HOW we get to those numbers. I would argue that it's the fact that 72% of black kids grow up in a single family home in comparison to say only 18% in the Asian community.

If we really wanted to boil it down though, I think we have a class problem more than a race problem. Poor neighborhoods have exponentially higher crime rates and also get way less benefit of the doubt in pretty much all facets of life. Now, because of segregation a lot of communities still see a race disparity geographically( ie Harlem, Miami/Little Haiti, Chicago North/South etc) and what is now a matter of class could very easily be conceived as being a matter of race.
Sincere question: Do you think brown skinned people are mistaking race for class?
Handsome Dan
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 688
Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 3:04 am

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Handsome Dan »

You are right that there is a class problem in addition to a race problem. Indeed, a sizeable portion of the racism exhibited by the less educated white people who vote conservatively is encouraged and validated by the dishonest wealthy in control of conservative media, because it distracts those less educated white people from the primary role that those dishonest wealthy people have in the problems (such as poverty) that are commonly experienced by less educated white people. Of course, because racism is used (and has been used for a long time) as a tool to divide people in the country, the race issue is very real as well.
I would argue that it's the fact that 72% of black kids grow up in a single family home in comparison to say only 18% in the Asian community.
That definitely has some effect, but then you need to ask the follow up question, namely "why are black communities so shattered in the first place?" And that turns right back to the historical systemic racism directed at them, such as denying them equal rights, segregating from them, and denying them the opportunity for the economic advancement necessary to avoid being devastated by desperation.
New Duck
One Star Recruit
Posts: 15
Joined: Thu Aug 24, 2017 7:22 am

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by New Duck »

I only wish those opposed could legitimately say they have felt what the people who protest feel. It is so easy to stand behind the perfect ideals of the unknowing or unaware. The fact of the matter is if everyone had always stood for equality and the rights of those who are treated unjustly there would be no kneeling or sitting today. Anyone who sidesteps the issue simply because they have not personally felt or seen it in their lives is why the problem still exists.

As someone who has lost a half dozen in several branches fighting for a freedom they would not have enjoyed had they returned, I sympathize with all who express their rights in the most peaceful and non threatening way possible. Our anthem and our flag do not stand for who fought for it, they stand for the freedoms not being afforded to all of its citizens.....this is not a new thing. People fought for all of US in every war that no one could possibly say were equal. Not before, not during, not after.

The fact that it has turned political and has lost the meaning is sickening as it only silences the underlying issue. Claiming this protest is about the flag or the anthem is akin to saying Rosa Parkd was protesting public transportation. The unoppressed are burying the lead........as to continue to hold the power.
New Duck
One Star Recruit
Posts: 15
Joined: Thu Aug 24, 2017 7:22 am

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by New Duck »

ifuwant2 wrote:
lukeyrid13 wrote:
Phenom wrote:
lukeyrid13 wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:
They said they'd protest the disparity between what America says it is and what it actually is.
I didn't say that, either. I'm not protesting anything. But I'm firmly behind the protesters. If pressed, I'd rather kneel with them than pretend racism is dead and that everything is tremendous and beautiful.

You know who I have zero respect for? The hypocritical idiots who boo the national anthem protesters. You can't be against anthem protests and then protest them during the anthem. That's not how life works.
As I said before, I don't want to start a vitriolic argument but instead a civil discussion....but in what ways is the gov't racist and where do we see systemic racism? I am fully against racism, but outside of a few nut jobs in Charlottesville, where is all this racism affecting the average American?
Just because it doesn't affect you that doesn't mean it's not happening. That's the definition of white privilege.

Anyways, here's some evidence:
http://www.rootcausecoalition.org/wp-co ... ntions.pdf
https://www.usnews.com/news/blogs/at-th ... ay-of-life
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/bla ... b8000d687f
https://www.aclu.org/sites/default/file ... sion_0.pdf
I scanned the first article(very long) and read the second and will go through the rest completely in the morning.

Solely in response to the second article, I think it all comes down to a matter of opinion and perspective(basically the entirety of this thread) but the stats they throw out are counter intuitive IMO. Stating that black kids are 3x as likely to get suspended than whites, 73% of whites own homes compared to 43%, 40% of expelled students are black and that 50% of violent crimes are commit by blacks. I think everyone can agree that those aren't flattering numbers but I suppose the debate is HOW we get to those numbers. I would argue that it's the fact that 72% of black kids grow up in a single family home in comparison to say only 18% in the Asian community.

If we really wanted to boil it down though, I think we have a class problem more than a race problem. Poor neighborhoods have exponentially higher crime rates and also get way less benefit of the doubt in pretty much all facets of life. Now, because of segregation a lot of communities still see a race disparity geographically( ie Harlem, Miami/Little Haiti, Chicago North/South etc) and what is now a matter of class could very easily be conceived as being a matter of race.
Sincere question: Do you think brown skinned people are mistaking race for class?
Only if u believe "brown skinned" people are poor and feeling oppressed. I refuse to be too much on a really friendly board......will simply say I need more time to look through the thread. This statement screams unaware and unaffected though.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Duck07 »

Claudette Colvin is so underappreciated in this thread right now.
Image
Handsome Dan
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 688
Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 3:04 am

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Handsome Dan »

New Duck wrote:I only wish those opposed could legitimately say they have felt what the people who protest feel. It is so easy to stand behind the perfect ideals of the unknowing or unaware. The fact of the matter is if everyone had always stood for equality and the rights of those who are treated unjustly there would be no kneeling or sitting today. Anyone who sidesteps the issue simply because they have not personally felt or seen it in their lives is why the problem still exists.

As someone who has lost a half dozen in several branches fighting for a freedom they would not have enjoyed had they returned, I sympathize with all who express their rights in the most peaceful and non threatening way possible. Our anthem and our flag do not stand for who fought for it, they stand for the freedoms not being afforded to all of its citizens.....this is not a new thing. People fought for all of US in every war that no one could possibly say were equal. Not before, not during, not after.

The fact that it has turned political and has lost the meaning is sickening as it only silences the underlying issue. Claiming this protest is about the flag or the anthem is akin to saying Rosa Parkd was protesting public transportation. The unoppressed are burying the lead........as to continue to hold the power.
For the record, I think it's spelled 'lede' in that phrase. You on point though.
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

I highly doubt the wall will ever be built. I would be fine if it is. It is not because I think they are criminals per se... I just think they need to come into the country legally. I can pretty much assure you that if I entered another country illegally I would promptly be escorted out of the country. Somehow in the USA there are people who think is ok to enter a country illegally. I am also concerned that the next terrorist attack on the USA the people carrying it out will enter the country through Mexico. When and if that happens wonder what people will say then. I have always been a law abiding citizen and do not see that just because they are foreigners that they somehow should be granted immunity if came into the country illegally. For to many years we have allowed anyone into the country and government did nothing if they came here illegally. Maybe when the terrorist come in through Mexico the wall will be built. I highly doubt it will be done before then. This is a long ways off the main topic of the thread and I apologize. I was just responding to the wall comment. There are many who feel the exact same as I do.. Want to come to the USA fine... but do it through legal matters. I would still gladly stand for the anthem... it is a no brainer to me.
New Duck
One Star Recruit
Posts: 15
Joined: Thu Aug 24, 2017 7:22 am

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by New Duck »

GoDucksIn09 wrote:I highly doubt the wall will ever be built. I would be fine if it is. It is not because I think they are criminals per se... I just think they need to come into the country legally. I can pretty much assure you that if I entered another country illegally I would promptly be escorted out of the country. Somehow in the USA there are people who think is ok to enter a country illegally. I am also concerned that the next terrorist attack on the USA the people carrying it out will enter the country through Mexico. When and if that happens wonder what people will say then. I have always been a law abiding citizen and do not see that just because they are foreigners that they somehow should be granted immunity if came into the country illegally. For to many years we have allowed anyone into the country and government did nothing if they came here illegally. Maybe when the terrorist come in through Mexico the wall will be built. I highly doubt it will be done before then. This is a long ways off the main topic of the thread and I apologize. I was just responding to the wall comment. There are many who feel the exact same as I do.. Want to come to the USA fine... but do it through legal matters. I would still gladly stand for the anthem... it is a no brainer to me.
If u tell me the wall between us and Canada is next then we are on to something. If you proclaim that illegals are not entering fron the north you are delusional. To pretend all of our borders are not penetrable is idiocracy.....are we ok with Canada because it is the "Great White North"? How bout we finish that wall first?
Locked