It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
- DAT_man_again
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1569
- Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 7:26 pm
It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
The debate of the week. A 4 * true freshman All-American or a walk-on who has shown he can't throw the ball?
If you take any stock in Moseley's practice report, he seemed to insinuate that Braxton really came alive with the extra reps today. Said he threw an awesome deep ball at one point (that Schooler dropped).
I just can't believe the coaches would start Allie. I know we will not beat the #11 team in the country being totally one-dimensional. And did you see the offense against Cal when Alie was in? All runs with some screen passes sprinkled in. That. Will. Not. Cut. It.
I have faith in the coaches to make the right decision, and surely they know more than me. But if I see #12 jogging out there this weekend with the 1's I am going to die a little on the inside.
If you take any stock in Moseley's practice report, he seemed to insinuate that Braxton really came alive with the extra reps today. Said he threw an awesome deep ball at one point (that Schooler dropped).
I just can't believe the coaches would start Allie. I know we will not beat the #11 team in the country being totally one-dimensional. And did you see the offense against Cal when Alie was in? All runs with some screen passes sprinkled in. That. Will. Not. Cut. It.
I have faith in the coaches to make the right decision, and surely they know more than me. But if I see #12 jogging out there this weekend with the 1's I am going to die a little on the inside.
"You know we the big brother." - Cliff Harris
"Y'all know what time it is." -Damian Lillard
"Y'all know what time it is." -Damian Lillard
-
ducksrock
- Senior
- Posts: 2739
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 8:08 am
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
no argument here
-
Sooth
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 593
- Joined: Mon Oct 19, 2009 9:34 am
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
Yup. It's obvious if what we've been told about both Alie and Burmeister being currently even is true. We know that Alie, in his current form, does not give Oregon a good chance of winning, so we can assume the same in the case of Burmeister. However, Alie has been in the program five years and has most assuredly piqued in terms of his talent. Whereas Burmeister hasn't even begun to reach his potential and will, in theory, only get better. Therefor, Burmeister is the guy going forward.
For me the formula is simple. I've seen a lot of media members saying the most important component is experience and thus are anointing Alie. But in a situation with an older guy and younger guy are even, you go with the younger guy every time.
For me the formula is simple. I've seen a lot of media members saying the most important component is experience and thus are anointing Alie. But in a situation with an older guy and younger guy are even, you go with the younger guy every time.
-
rsbgduck
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 672
- Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2009 9:42 am
- Location: Roseburg, OR
- Contact:
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
Didn’t Allie throw his first pass late over the middle for his first completion
to the Defense? Couldn’t agree more, has to be the true fresh who at least gives you the added dimension of a runner/scrambler. I’m also an all or nothing kinda person, put your best talent on the field and go with it, win or lose. Sure he will probably have a pic or two but you go on the field and you run your O at a 100% and if you’re going to lose then you lose throwing tyoir entire offense at he opponent, not with conservative/predictable play calling. I honestly believe that if our Ducks limit the penalties on offense we have an opportunity to keep this game close, even with a couple TO’s. I’m more concerned about our young cornerback play than our fresh. QB. As always IMHO
GO DUCKS !!!!
GO DUCKS !!!!
-
Everythingsducky
- Senior
- Posts: 2820
- Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 2:40 pm
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
Have to believe the Ducks were praying Herbert would stay healthy this year, and able to redshirt Braxton. Now that that is out the window, might as well get him experience moving forward, especially with his shirt burned. I'm excited to see him play, and what he has to offer.
-
Groundswell
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 753
- Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
Only guessing here:
I figure Moseley spent most this first part of the season saying Alie was well ahead of Burmeister because the coaches were hoping to redshirt BB. Makes sense. No reason to burn potentially 3 years of the kid's eligibility as a Herbert back-up. But now that the redshirt is burnt, Moseley is saying BB grew a ton in one practice and was like a new player. All the sudden there's a real competition going on between Alie and BB...like, one practice sudden.
I've assumed BB was going to start, but that's when I thought Alie had a concussion. And he may. He was moving at a slower speed than the other quarterbacks in the practice videos I saw from today. But he's also taking first team reps. Not sure what to make of that.
I'm pretty sure BB is going to get the start. Like, 70-75 percent sure. I agree with other posters: if it's even close, you have to go with BB. But if Alie trots out there, the coaches gotta live with the decision, and they think that's the way to go, I won't get too worked up. I haven't seen BB outside scrimmage/practice stuff so I'm not gonna argue with them. Also won't be surprised to see them both out there maybe running slightly different packages. But, unless Alie wasn't really concussed at all, something tells me he's not playing unless it's an emergency.
I figure Moseley spent most this first part of the season saying Alie was well ahead of Burmeister because the coaches were hoping to redshirt BB. Makes sense. No reason to burn potentially 3 years of the kid's eligibility as a Herbert back-up. But now that the redshirt is burnt, Moseley is saying BB grew a ton in one practice and was like a new player. All the sudden there's a real competition going on between Alie and BB...like, one practice sudden.
I've assumed BB was going to start, but that's when I thought Alie had a concussion. And he may. He was moving at a slower speed than the other quarterbacks in the practice videos I saw from today. But he's also taking first team reps. Not sure what to make of that.
I'm pretty sure BB is going to get the start. Like, 70-75 percent sure. I agree with other posters: if it's even close, you have to go with BB. But if Alie trots out there, the coaches gotta live with the decision, and they think that's the way to go, I won't get too worked up. I haven't seen BB outside scrimmage/practice stuff so I'm not gonna argue with them. Also won't be surprised to see them both out there maybe running slightly different packages. But, unless Alie wasn't really concussed at all, something tells me he's not playing unless it's an emergency.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
If he is then someone will be fired. That would be far worse than the Rhadbo incident and the only way for him to be on the field is that he left the game for his tooth and nothing more. If he failed a concussion protocol at any point he's not practicing this soon.ifuwant2 wrote: I've assumed BB was going to start, but that's when I thought Alie had a concussion. And he may. He was moving at a slower speed than the other quarterbacks in the practice videos I saw from today.
The decision on who to play comes down to this: who gives you the best chance to win. BB doesn't deserve the #1 spot just because he's younger unless he can outplay Alie for it. Now if the game gets out of hand, then it's pointless to keep playing Alie and give BB the reps, but while the game is still a contest you play the QB that gives you the best chance to win.

-
rsbgduck
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 672
- Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2009 9:42 am
- Location: Roseburg, OR
- Contact:
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
Duck07 wrote:If he is then someone will be fired. That would be far worse than the Rhadbo incident and the only way for him to be on the field is that he left the game for his tooth and nothing more. If he failed a concussion protocol at any point he's not practicing this soon.ifuwant2 wrote: I've assumed BB was going to start, but that's when I thought Alie had a concussion. And he may. He was moving at a slower speed than the other quarterbacks in the practice videos I saw from today.
The decision on who to play comes down to this: who gives you the best chance to win. BB doesn't deserve the #1 spot just because he's younger unless he can outplay Alie for it. Now if the game gets out of hand, then it's pointless to keep playing Alie and give BB the reps, but while the game is still a contest you play the QB that gives you the best chance to win.
Who ever said to give him the #1 spot just because he was younger? Everyone with the opinion that he should start has said they believe BB gives us the best chance to win. Has nothing to do with age.
- nogerO
- Senior
- Posts: 4517
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:48 pm
- Location: Wyoming
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
rsbgduck wrote:Duck07 wrote:If he is then someone will be fired. That would be far worse than the Rhadbo incident and the only way for him to be on the field is that he left the game for his tooth and nothing more. If he failed a concussion protocol at any point he's not practicing this soon.ifuwant2 wrote: I've assumed BB was going to start, but that's when I thought Alie had a concussion. And he may. He was moving at a slower speed than the other quarterbacks in the practice videos I saw from today.
The decision on who to play comes down to this: who gives you the best chance to win. BB doesn't deserve the #1 spot just because he's younger unless he can outplay Alie for it. Now if the game gets out of hand, then it's pointless to keep playing Alie and give BB the reps, but while the game is still a contest you play the QB that gives you the best chance to win.
Who ever said to give him the #1 spot just because he was younger? Everyone with the opinion that he should start has said they believe BB gives us the best chance to win. Has nothing to do with age.
Yep. Time to get him in the games and learn/grow just like Herbert did last year. Going to be some interesting competition for QB in the near future if BB is as advertised...
"To give anything less than your best, is to sacrifice the gift." - Steve Prefontaine
-
Groundswell
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 753
- Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
Moseley reporting that BB is QB1 in Wednesday's drills.
-
Groundswell
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 753
- Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
Well, there are levels of severity with concussions. And Alie's injury was listed as a wrist so he wouldn't have to go through concussion protocol. There had been some speculation that he had a concussion. Maybe he passed protocol? Maybe he didn't have to go through protocol? Lots we don't know.Duck07 wrote:If he is then someone will be fired. That would be far worse than the Rhadbo incident and the only way for him to be on the field is that he left the game for his tooth and nothing more. If he failed a concussion protocol at any point he's not practicing this soon.ifuwant2 wrote: I've assumed BB was going to start, but that's when I thought Alie had a concussion. And he may. He was moving at a slower speed than the other quarterbacks in the practice videos I saw from today.
The decision on who to play comes down to this: who gives you the best chance to win. BB doesn't deserve the #1 spot just because he's younger unless he can outplay Alie for it. Now if the game gets out of hand, then it's pointless to keep playing Alie and give BB the reps, but while the game is still a contest you play the QB that gives you the best chance to win.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
1 - just about everyone has said to give him the spot because "experience."rsbgduck wrote:Who ever said to give him the #1 spot just because he was younger? Everyone with the opinion that he should start has said they believe BB gives us the best chance to win. Has nothing to do with age.
2 - nobody knows that for sure, we're all just guessing (hoping) that BB is better than Alie but if it was that obvious, BB would have come into the game before Alie did.

-
Groundswell
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 753
- Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
Not necessarily. When that decision was made, the coaches could still be hoping Herbert is going to come back out from the locker room. Herbert was telling the coaches he was fine right up until they took him back. Then they have to run tests and get a scan. Coaches probably didn't know Herbert out for multiple games until later in the second half. Maybe half-time they know he's not coming back in.Duck07 wrote:BB would have come into the game before Alie did.
-
GrandpaDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 3314
- Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
I agree with all this.Duck07 wrote: .....
The decision on who to play comes down to this: who gives you the best chance to win. BB doesn't deserve the #1 spot just because he's younger unless he can outplay Alie for it. Now if the game gets out of hand, then it's pointless to keep playing Alie and give BB the reps, but while the game is still a contest you play the QB that gives you the best chance to win.
I have no opinion on which one is better at this point. I would have a quick hook for real and/or near turnovers while the game is still in doubt if the decision is close.
-
GrantDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 2629
- Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
Kinda don't get all the Taylor Allie bashing. He made a handful of solid throws against Cal and can manage the game well.
Maybe people forgot the Colorado game 2 years ago where he made a great deep throw?
He's not a great college QB, he doesn't have a big arm, many of his throws look shaky...but the bashing on him constantly is pretty lame. (Not saying all of you are doing this, but some are, especially on Twitter and some here.)
So for the OP, no it does not HAVE to be Burmeister unless he's the best QB that can execute the offense, make good decisions, AND throw the ball downfield. I trust the coaches know the answer to that better than us, but like many of you I'd wager it's BB this weekend.
Maybe people forgot the Colorado game 2 years ago where he made a great deep throw?
He's not a great college QB, he doesn't have a big arm, many of his throws look shaky...but the bashing on him constantly is pretty lame. (Not saying all of you are doing this, but some are, especially on Twitter and some here.)
So for the OP, no it does not HAVE to be Burmeister unless he's the best QB that can execute the offense, make good decisions, AND throw the ball downfield. I trust the coaches know the answer to that better than us, but like many of you I'd wager it's BB this weekend.