And yet Alie again, with them having halftime to decide and make a decision, started the 2nd half. I just don't understand people sometimes.ifuwant2 wrote:Not necessarily. When that decision was made, the coaches could still be hoping Herbert is going to come back out from the locker room. Herbert was telling the coaches he was fine right up until they took him back. Then they have to run tests and get a scan. Coaches probably didn't know Herbert out for multiple games until later in the second half. Maybe half-time they know he's not coming back in.Duck07 wrote:BB would have come into the game before Alie did.
It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
- pudgejeff
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:21 am
- GM: Sacramento Kings GM
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
- midwestduck82
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 319
- Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 8:35 pm
- Location: Michigan
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
I was surprised to see Alie as the quarterback after halftime as well.
BB looks good in the highlights on YouTube. He throws a very catch-able ball. Hopefully he has kept watching film and learning the playbook. Taggart said he caught him in the QBs meeting room by himself watching film in the spring. I would rather give the ball to the future star than to the reserve scout team QB. I'm at least excited to see what BB can do with the offense. I think we know how a game would go with Alie as QB.
BB looks good in the highlights on YouTube. He throws a very catch-able ball. Hopefully he has kept watching film and learning the playbook. Taggart said he caught him in the QBs meeting room by himself watching film in the spring. I would rather give the ball to the future star than to the reserve scout team QB. I'm at least excited to see what BB can do with the offense. I think we know how a game would go with Alie as QB.
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
Alie completed 7 passes that went 1 yard or less downfield. So did he complete passes, yes, but the extent of what the coaches trust him to throw it is 5 yards or so. Anything more than that, and it's probably 1/3 of the time incomplete, 1/3 INT and being optimistic 1/3 completion.GrantDuck wrote:Kinda don't get all the Taylor Allie bashing. He made a handful of solid throws against Cal and can manage the game well.
Maybe people forgot the Colorado game 2 years ago where he made a great deep throw?
He's not a great college QB, he doesn't have a big arm, many of his throws look shaky...but the bashing on him constantly is pretty lame. (Not saying all of you are doing this, but some are, especially on Twitter and some here.)
So for the OP, no it does not HAVE to be Burmeister unless he's the best QB that can execute the offense, make good decisions, AND throw the ball downfield. I trust the coaches know the answer to that better than us, but like many of you I'd wager it's BB this weekend.
-
GrandpaDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 3314
- Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
buckmarkduck wrote:Alie completed 7 passes that went 1 yard or less downfield. So did he complete passes, yes, but the extent of what the coaches trust him to throw it is 5 yards or so. Anything more than that, and it's probably 1/3 of the time incomplete, 1/3 INT and being optimistic 1/3 completion.GrantDuck wrote:Kinda don't get all the Taylor Allie bashing. He made a handful of solid throws against Cal and can manage the game well.
Maybe people forgot the Colorado game 2 years ago where he made a great deep throw?
He's not a great college QB, he doesn't have a big arm, many of his throws look shaky...but the bashing on him constantly is pretty lame. (Not saying all of you are doing this, but some are, especially on Twitter and some here.)
So for the OP, no it does not HAVE to be Burmeister unless he's the best QB that can execute the offense, make good decisions, AND throw the ball downfield. I trust the coaches know the answer to that better than us, but like many of you I'd wager it's BB this weekend.
And Burmeister tried 11 passes in the Spring Game, was sacked 4 times, Intercepted once, and had 3 completions. Against Cal he was 1/1 for 4 yards. Obviously he will get better than that, but really only the coaches know how he looks in practice and nobody including the coaches know how he'll do in a Pac-12 game.
I wont second guess who they choose to start. I'll save that for not making a change if the starter pulls a Chris Harper.
-
GrantDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 2629
- Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
He also had no fumbles and got the ball in the right spots to the running backs and properly carried out fakes. He also had 2 nice plays in the passing game, with the outside slant to JJ and the naked bootleg play to Bay. It just depends what you're asking him to do and what we need to do to score points this week and not have turnovers. He has 1 INT in 34 career passing attempts.buckmarkduck wrote:Alie completed 7 passes that went 1 yard or less downfield. So did he complete passes, yes, but the extent of what the coaches trust him to throw it is 5 yards or so. Anything more than that, and it's probably 1/3 of the time incomplete, 1/3 INT and being optimistic 1/3 completion.GrantDuck wrote:Kinda don't get all the Taylor Allie bashing. He made a handful of solid throws against Cal and can manage the game well.
Maybe people forgot the Colorado game 2 years ago where he made a great deep throw?
He's not a great college QB, he doesn't have a big arm, many of his throws look shaky...but the bashing on him constantly is pretty lame. (Not saying all of you are doing this, but some are, especially on Twitter and some here.)
So for the OP, no it does not HAVE to be Burmeister unless he's the best QB that can execute the offense, make good decisions, AND throw the ball downfield. I trust the coaches know the answer to that better than us, but like many of you I'd wager it's BB this weekend.
He's not going to be a downfield passer throwing 15+ yard outs and crosses, but he can make the basic throws and take care of the ball. I'm all for BB if he's the better option, but the "TAYLOR ALIE SUUckkks" crowd is too much...
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
And we've seen this movie before. A QB who can't push the ball down the field, who can only handoff the ball or maybe run it himself. If you don't remember it, I've got a recording of the UCLA game 07, and the second half of the TCU game, if you need to be reminded of what we can expect Saturday from Alie. Now I'd love, LOVE to be wrong, but I don't think I am. Is BB better, I don't know, but I know he's improved a ton from the Spring game when he was still a HS Sr.GrantDuck wrote:He also had no fumbles and got the ball in the right spots to the running backs and properly carried out fakes. He also had 2 nice plays in the passing game, with the outside slant to JJ and the naked bootleg play to Bay. It just depends what you're asking him to do and what we need to do to score points this week and not have turnovers. He has 1 INT in 34 career passing attempts.buckmarkduck wrote:Alie completed 7 passes that went 1 yard or less downfield. So did he complete passes, yes, but the extent of what the coaches trust him to throw it is 5 yards or so. Anything more than that, and it's probably 1/3 of the time incomplete, 1/3 INT and being optimistic 1/3 completion.GrantDuck wrote:Kinda don't get all the Taylor Allie bashing. He made a handful of solid throws against Cal and can manage the game well.
Maybe people forgot the Colorado game 2 years ago where he made a great deep throw?
He's not a great college QB, he doesn't have a big arm, many of his throws look shaky...but the bashing on him constantly is pretty lame. (Not saying all of you are doing this, but some are, especially on Twitter and some here.)
So for the OP, no it does not HAVE to be Burmeister unless he's the best QB that can execute the offense, make good decisions, AND throw the ball downfield. I trust the coaches know the answer to that better than us, but like many of you I'd wager it's BB this weekend.
He's not going to be a downfield passer throwing 15+ yard outs and crosses, but he can make the basic throws and take care of the ball. I'm all for BB if he's the better option, but the "TAYLOR ALIE SUUckkks" crowd is too much...
-
Groundswell
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 753
- Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
But this doesn't mean the coaches were ready to pull a kid's redshirt, especially if they were dead set on holding it. Maybe they got to get final word on how long Herbert is out. Maybe they aren't sure he isn't going to be back the next week. When word started leaking about the broken collar bone, weren't we well into the second half and the team is playing well, and we're moving the ball? You don't pull a kid in that situation, and you don't burn a redshirt in that situation.pudgejeff wrote:And yet Alie again, with them having halftime to decide and make a decision, started the 2nd half. I just don't understand people sometimes.ifuwant2 wrote:Not necessarily. When that decision was made, the coaches could still be hoping Herbert is going to come back out from the locker room. Herbert was telling the coaches he was fine right up until they took him back. Then they have to run tests and get a scan. Coaches probably didn't know Herbert out for multiple games until later in the second half. Maybe half-time they know he's not coming back in.Duck07 wrote:BB would have come into the game before Alie did.
Alie may be the best player to help us win. I haven't seen enough of Burmeister to have an opinion on that. However, I'm not making that decision based on who came trotting out for the second half of the Cal game. Now that the redshirt is pulled, we'll see what happens. That changes things.
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
Give me some facts of why you are arguing so hard for Alie? What have you seen that makes you think we can win with him? Because I fully believe there's just .001% chance we can win with him at QB. Greatwood literally told Cal players that Alie can't throw a ball over 8 yds, and to no respect him as a throwing threat. And that's a guy who saw him for 4 years everyday.pudgejeff wrote:And yet Alie again, with them having halftime to decide and make a decision, started the 2nd half. I just don't understand people sometimes.ifuwant2 wrote:Not necessarily. When that decision was made, the coaches could still be hoping Herbert is going to come back out from the locker room. Herbert was telling the coaches he was fine right up until they took him back. Then they have to run tests and get a scan. Coaches probably didn't know Herbert out for multiple games until later in the second half. Maybe half-time they know he's not coming back in.Duck07 wrote:BB would have come into the game before Alie did.
- pudgejeff
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:21 am
- GM: Sacramento Kings GM
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
I'm not arguing for Alie, I'm trusting that the coaches want to win and they are making decision's based on that. They saw the competition, they see them in practice every week. If he is the player they put in then I fully believe they deem he is the best option to help the team win. My thought is, what does that say about Braxton's ability to do so?buckmarkduck wrote:Give me some facts of why you are arguing so hard for Alie? What have you seen that makes you think we can win with him? Because I fully believe there's just .001% chance we can win with him at QB. Greatwood literally told Cal players that Alie can't throw a ball over 8 yds, and to no respect him as a throwing threat. And that's a guy who saw him for 4 years everyday.pudgejeff wrote:And yet Alie again, with them having halftime to decide and make a decision, started the 2nd half. I just don't understand people sometimes.ifuwant2 wrote:Not necessarily. When that decision was made, the coaches could still be hoping Herbert is going to come back out from the locker room. Herbert was telling the coaches he was fine right up until they took him back. Then they have to run tests and get a scan. Coaches probably didn't know Herbert out for multiple games until later in the second half. Maybe half-time they know he's not coming back in.Duck07 wrote:BB would have come into the game before Alie did.
-
Groundswell
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 753
- Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
I think we'll see what they think of BB's ability at this point. He was never really an option until some point in the second half of the Cal game. Maybe we see both guys in the game too. I don't know. I do know that Alie shouldn't be that hard to beat out, and if BB can't win the job over Alie during this stretch where Herbert is out, then ouch for BB. I think you're putting too much stock on who came out for the second half of the Cal game. Maybe the coaches had already told Burmeister they weren't going to burn his redshirt unless they had to. When the kid was recruited, there was a deep line of kids ahead of him. Maybe BB expected to redshirt. Maybe he doesn't want to use up all his eligibility behind Herbert? Lots of moving parts here.pudgejeff wrote:I'm not arguing for Alie, I'm trusting that the coaches want to win and they are making decision's based on that. They saw the competition, they see them in practice every week. If he is the player they put in then I fully believe they deem he is the best option to help the team win. My thought is, what does that say about Braxton's ability to do so?buckmarkduck wrote:Give me some facts of why you are arguing so hard for Alie? What have you seen that makes you think we can win with him? Because I fully believe there's just .001% chance we can win with him at QB. Greatwood literally told Cal players that Alie can't throw a ball over 8 yds, and to no respect him as a throwing threat. And that's a guy who saw him for 4 years everyday.pudgejeff wrote:And yet Alie again, with them having halftime to decide and make a decision, started the 2nd half. I just don't understand people sometimes.ifuwant2 wrote:Not necessarily. When that decision was made, the coaches could still be hoping Herbert is going to come back out from the locker room. Herbert was telling the coaches he was fine right up until they took him back. Then they have to run tests and get a scan. Coaches probably didn't know Herbert out for multiple games until later in the second half. Maybe half-time they know he's not coming back in.Duck07 wrote:BB would have come into the game before Alie did.
-
QuackAttack89
- One Star Recruit
- Posts: 69
- Joined: Thu Oct 05, 2017 10:00 am
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
Jeff Locke fanboys all over again in favor of Taylor Allie? I can promise you BB will be the guy Saturday and beyond
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
First post and this guy is claiming BB will take Herbert's job. I don't know whether to congratulate you or just laugh.QuackAttack89 wrote:Jeff Locke fanboys all over again in favor of Taylor Allie? I can promise you BB will be the guy Saturday and beyond

- Juice
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 685
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:19 am
- Location: Seattle
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
Duck07 wrote:First post and this guy is claiming BB will take Herbert's job. I don't know whether to congratulate you or just laugh.QuackAttack89 wrote:Jeff Locke fanboys all over again in favor of Taylor Allie? I can promise you BB will be the guy Saturday and beyond
I think that answers that.
-
QuackAttack89
- One Star Recruit
- Posts: 69
- Joined: Thu Oct 05, 2017 10:00 am
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
I meant of the rest of the season don't get cute
-
QuackAttack89
- One Star Recruit
- Posts: 69
- Joined: Thu Oct 05, 2017 10:00 am
Re: It has to be Burmeister. Right? Right?
Don't sleep on Jeff Lockie his experience gives us the best chance to win !!!