Cute is my middle name and I have a pulchritudinous disposition.QuackAttack89 wrote:I meant of the rest of the season don't get cute

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
Cute is my middle name and I have a pulchritudinous disposition.QuackAttack89 wrote:I meant of the rest of the season don't get cute



Fair, it's easier to get more excited about BB than Allie. At least there's some potential hope and an unknown about BB that makes him the more desired starting QB.QuackAttack89 wrote:I'm excited to see Braxton you guys he's got the dual threat ability to add another dimension to our offense

I know it's a snap judgement, and kids improve, but I'd have to bet he doesn't play another meaningful minute at Oregon again after this year. Unless we have a bunch of injuries again next year.karlhungis wrote:Well, he looked like a freshman. I am not impressed with his accuracy when throwing anything other than sideline screen passes. I am sure he will improve but it feels like it will be a while.
Why the F was he practicing then? If this is true I'm pissed and somebody F'ed up.ifuwant2 wrote:Sounds like Alie didn't pass concussion protocol. BB is the only quarterback available if so.



Was Alie ruled out for the game though? He did practice during the week so if he wasn't suited up because of a tooth it doesn't make sense why he wouldn't be available.greenyellow wrote:I don't think anyone ever confirmed he had a concussion even though many assumed he did because of the way his head hit the turf against Cal. I saw it posted on a couple other places that he broke a tooth or two from that hit and that may be why could fully go on Saturday but those were never confirmed either. Taggart did confirm Mitchell had a concussion so it's not like he won't state certain injuries.


Could also have been a bit of gamesmanship by Taggart so it wasn't a completely obvious choice, forcing WSU to have to prepare for both. Don't think it would have mattered since they're both similar players except Alie has a tad more experience.Duck07 wrote:Was Alie ruled out for the game though? He did practice during the week so if he wasn't suited up because of a tooth it doesn't make sense why he wouldn't be available.greenyellow wrote:I don't think anyone ever confirmed he had a concussion even though many assumed he did because of the way his head hit the turf against Cal. I saw it posted on a couple other places that he broke a tooth or two from that hit and that may be why could fully go on Saturday but those were never confirmed either. Taggart did confirm Mitchell had a concussion so it's not like he won't state certain injuries.

The problem though is if Alie was in fact concussed he is not allowed to be playing period and that's state law.greenyellow wrote: Could also have been a bit of gamesmanship by Taggart so it wasn't a completely obvious choice, forcing WSU to have to prepare for both. Don't think it would have mattered since they're both similar players except Alie has a tad more experience.

I agree with this. I’m not trying to rag on the kid but I didn’t see much positive from him yesterday. With Herbert coming back for at least another year and with Shough coming in along with more QB’s that Willie will recruit, I don’t see Braxton ever being a legit starter for us. I sure hope he proves me wrong though!buckmarkduck wrote:I know it's a snap judgement, and kids improve, but I'd have to bet he doesn't play another meaningful minute at Oregon again after this year. Unless we have a bunch of injuries again next year.karlhungis wrote:Well, he looked like a freshman. I am not impressed with his accuracy when throwing anything other than sideline screen passes. I am sure he will improve but it feels like it will be a while.

Duck07 wrote:The problem though is if Alie was in fact concussed he is not allowed to be playing period and that's state law.greenyellow wrote: Could also have been a bit of gamesmanship by Taggart so it wasn't a completely obvious choice, forcing WSU to have to prepare for both. Don't think it would have mattered since they're both similar players except Alie has a tad more experience.

I've always thought that going back to 9 months ago when we were recruiting him. He was a top 250 recruit in rating, but you could tell by his tape that he wasn't ever going to be a star let alone a starter in the PAC-12. I'm still happy we got him just for pure depth purposes, I mean imagine if we didn't have him last night...OregonFan4Life wrote:I agree with this. I’m not trying to rag on the kid but I didn’t see much positive from him yesterday. With Herbert coming back for at least another year and with Shough coming in along with more QB’s that Willie will recruit, I don’t see Braxton ever being a legit starter for us. I sure hope he proves me wrong though!buckmarkduck wrote:I know it's a snap judgement, and kids improve, but I'd have to bet he doesn't play another meaningful minute at Oregon again after this year. Unless we have a bunch of injuries again next year.karlhungis wrote:Well, he looked like a freshman. I am not impressed with his accuracy when throwing anything other than sideline screen passes. I am sure he will improve but it feels like it will be a while.