Willie leaving worse than chip leaving?
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
- lukeyrid13
- All-American
- Posts: 10475
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
- GM: Portland TrailBlazers
Willie leaving worse than chip leaving?
I think if Willie leaves it will decimate our team. Our recruiting class will totally fold, and I bet we see a ton of guys transfer out. Nothing we can do about it, but I think it would set us back even further than we were last year outside of Herbert.
-
Duckattack7
- Five Star Recruit
- Posts: 1106
- Joined: Sun Jan 17, 2010 9:09 pm
- Location: Lake Oswego
Re: Willie leaving worse than chip leaving?
Way way way way way worse. Chip left with a stacked roster and on a high not, Willie would be destroying an already broken program. (By destroying I mean setting us back and potentially destroying lol)
Return Of the Quack!
- UofO8
- Senior
- Posts: 2538
- Joined: Wed Nov 04, 2009 3:41 pm
-
wlduck
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1722
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:19 pm
Re: Willie leaving worse than chip leaving?
This is worse, but not as bad as some of you are saying. Make a good hire and keep the class ranking in the 25-30 range, maybe better. Soft schedule next year along with Herbert returning and still a good chance to win 9-10 games.
More pertinent question is: If Taggart leaves are we better off than we were when he came? I think we would be.
More pertinent question is: If Taggart leaves are we better off than we were when he came? I think we would be.
- lukeyrid13
- All-American
- Posts: 10475
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
- GM: Portland TrailBlazers
Re: Willie leaving worse than chip leaving?
I would say slightly better but he would have only had 11 months to build up anything. We got some good frosh from his class last year that will help us down the line, but the class coming in this year was what would have vaulted us forward.wlduck wrote:This is worse, but not as bad as some of you are saying. Make a good hire and keep the class ranking in the 25-30 range, maybe better. Soft schedule next year along with Herbert returning and still a good chance to win 9-10 games.
More pertinent question is: If Taggart leaves are we better off than we were when he came? I think we would be.
- Duckenstein
- Freshman
- Posts: 1433
- Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2016 7:43 pm
Re: Willie leaving worse than chip leaving?
Not sure. I think you could make a case that Willie leaving potentially kills the program for several years kind of like USC after sanctions.wlduck wrote:This is worse, but not as bad as some of you are saying. Make a good hire and keep the class ranking in the 25-30 range, maybe better. Soft schedule next year along with Herbert returning and still a good chance to win 9-10 games.
More pertinent question is: If Taggart leaves are we better off than we were when he came? I think we would be.
Team needs 30 odd recruits just to stay afloat in 2019/20. If this class gets shivved there will be some brutal years ahead post 2018
-
Groundswell
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 753
- Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm
Re: Willie leaving worse than chip leaving?
Totally.Duckenstein wrote:Not sure. I think you could make a case that Willie leaving potentially kills the program for several years kind of like USC after sanctions.wlduck wrote:This is worse, but not as bad as some of you are saying. Make a good hire and keep the class ranking in the 25-30 range, maybe better. Soft schedule next year along with Herbert returning and still a good chance to win 9-10 games.
More pertinent question is: If Taggart leaves are we better off than we were when he came? I think we would be.
Team needs 30 odd recruits just to stay afloat in 2019/20. If this class gets shivved there will be some brutal years ahead post 2018
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: Willie leaving worse than chip leaving?
Worse. 1 - Chip left for the NFL, not what he thought was a better college job which is precisely why WT is going to leave.
2 - Chip was here for 6 years and created one of the most memorable offenses in CFB history. When WT leaves, he's going to be known for just that - leaving.
2 - Chip was here for 6 years and created one of the most memorable offenses in CFB history. When WT leaves, he's going to be known for just that - leaving.

- Phalanx
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5323
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm
Re: Willie leaving worse than chip leaving?
I think the worst part about Taggart potentially leaving is losing a coach to Florida State as though that was a real gig and Oregon isn't. We are worried about a single recruiting class, but that would likely affect inroads the ducks have made in other regions for years to come. If Oregon wants to be perceived as a top team, they can't have coaches bailing whenever a 'destination job' opens up.
I don't think Taggart is an irreplaceable coach, I just think he has a lot of leverage at this moment because of the great recruiting class he has lined up, coupled with the fragile position the ducks are in in terms of national perception. This play he and his agent are making for more money is very shrewd, but it does have a cost down the road in terms of trust and connection with the fan base. College sports are more and more a business, but there is still a naive, romantic idea with fans that it is based on a community and connection around a school and a state. This fear-mongering might be great for getting a new contract, but at the same time, as it drags on, we are constantly being reminded that Willie isn't one of us, he isn't from here, and he has no loyalty to the program. Not a great message in the long run for a college football program.
Of course, Oregon more or less asked for this situation when they fired the hometown guy after one bad year. Loyalty is a two-way street, I guess.
I don't think Taggart is an irreplaceable coach, I just think he has a lot of leverage at this moment because of the great recruiting class he has lined up, coupled with the fragile position the ducks are in in terms of national perception. This play he and his agent are making for more money is very shrewd, but it does have a cost down the road in terms of trust and connection with the fan base. College sports are more and more a business, but there is still a naive, romantic idea with fans that it is based on a community and connection around a school and a state. This fear-mongering might be great for getting a new contract, but at the same time, as it drags on, we are constantly being reminded that Willie isn't one of us, he isn't from here, and he has no loyalty to the program. Not a great message in the long run for a college football program.
Of course, Oregon more or less asked for this situation when they fired the hometown guy after one bad year. Loyalty is a two-way street, I guess.
- Duckenstein
- Freshman
- Posts: 1433
- Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2016 7:43 pm
Re: Willie leaving worse than chip leaving?
I was with you until the last sentences. Helfrich got way too many years and enough rope to hang himself.Phalanx wrote:I think the worst part about Taggart potentially leaving is losing a coach to Florida State as though that was a real gig and Oregon isn't. We are worried about a single recruiting class, but that would likely affect inroads the ducks have made in other regions for years to come. If Oregon wants to be perceived as a top team, they can't have coaches bailing whenever a 'destination job' opens up.
I don't think Taggart is an irreplaceable coach, I just think he has a lot of leverage at this moment because of the great recruiting class he has lined up, coupled with the fragile position the ducks are in in terms of national perception. This play he and his agent are making for more money is very shrewd, but it does have a cost down the road in terms of trust and connection with the fan base. College sports are more and more a business, but there is still a naive, romantic idea with fans that it is based on a community and connection around a school and a state. This fear-mongering might be great for getting a new contract, but at the same time, as it drags on, we are constantly being reminded that Willie isn't one of us, he isn't from here, and he has no loyalty to the program. Not a great message in the long run for a college football program.
Of course, Oregon more or less asked for this situation when they fired the hometown guy after one bad year. Loyalty is a two-way street, I guess.
Remember Don Pellum and Brady Hoke? I don't see any of those guys coaching anywhere.
-
northbeachsf
- Freshman
- Posts: 1494
- Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 12:54 pm
Re: Willie leaving worse than chip leaving?
This is a very well thought out post and I agree with everything you said.Phalanx wrote:I think the worst part about Taggart potentially leaving is losing a coach to Florida State as though that was a real gig and Oregon isn't. We are worried about a single recruiting class, but that would likely affect inroads the ducks have made in other regions for years to come. If Oregon wants to be perceived as a top team, they can't have coaches bailing whenever a 'destination job' opens up.
I don't think Taggart is an irreplaceable coach, I just think he has a lot of leverage at this moment because of the great recruiting class he has lined up, coupled with the fragile position the ducks are in in terms of national perception. This play he and his agent are making for more money is very shrewd, but it does have a cost down the road in terms of trust and connection with the fan base. College sports are more and more a business, but there is still a naive, romantic idea with fans that it is based on a community and connection around a school and a state. This fear-mongering might be great for getting a new contract, but at the same time, as it drags on, we are constantly being reminded that Willie isn't one of us, he isn't from here, and he has no loyalty to the program. Not a great message in the long run for a college football program.
Of course, Oregon more or less asked for this situation when they fired the hometown guy after one bad year. Loyalty is a two-way street, I guess.
I will take it a step further. Up until yesterday I was upset about Taggart leaving. I am not anymore. Look what Jimbo and Sexton did to FSU for the last three consecutive years, a place the he supposedly loved and was supposed to stay for the rest of his career. Do you want that side show here every year? Because that is what I think we are going to get iif Willie stays. Let FSU have him for $7.5M/ year (rumored). Point of reference - Urban Meyer’s base salary is $6.9M
Also, after watching that press conference, I was totally unimpressed with how that was handled. He is standing there saying he is transparent and honest, yet all his answers are deceptive, his voice is nervous, and his body language is telling. If EVERYONE KNOWS YOU ARE LYING, JUST TELL THE DAMN TRUTH. Say “I grew up an FSU fan and I am from Florida. It was my dream job growing up. If the contact me, I have to listen to see if I still feel that way”
Grow some f$&&$ing balls.
-
Duck24
- Senior
- Posts: 4744
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
- Location: Portland, OR
Re: Willie leaving worse than chip leaving?
There’s not a chance in hell FSU is offering him $7.5M. That would be nearly $2M more than they were paying Jimbo and be 2.5X more than he’s making now.
-
maxduck
- Senior
- Posts: 3763
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:37 pm
Re: Willie leaving worse than chip leaving?
Outstanding posts! I can't imagine for a moment that Willie would tolerate that kind of evasive answer from one of his players.northbeachsf wrote:This is a very well thought out post and I agree with everything you said.Phalanx wrote:I think the worst part about Taggart potentially leaving is losing a coach to Florida State as though that was a real gig and Oregon isn't. We are worried about a single recruiting class, but that would likely affect inroads the ducks have made in other regions for years to come. If Oregon wants to be perceived as a top team, they can't have coaches bailing whenever a 'destination job' opens up.
I don't think Taggart is an irreplaceable coach, I just think he has a lot of leverage at this moment because of the great recruiting class he has lined up, coupled with the fragile position the ducks are in in terms of national perception. This play he and his agent are making for more money is very shrewd, but it does have a cost down the road in terms of trust and connection with the fan base. College sports are more and more a business, but there is still a naive, romantic idea with fans that it is based on a community and connection around a school and a state. This fear-mongering might be great for getting a new contract, but at the same time, as it drags on, we are constantly being reminded that Willie isn't one of us, he isn't from here, and he has no loyalty to the program. Not a great message in the long run for a college football program.
Of course, Oregon more or less asked for this situation when they fired the hometown guy after one bad year. Loyalty is a two-way street, I guess.
I will take it a step further. Up until yesterday I was upset about Taggart leaving. I am not anymore. Look what Jimbo and Sexton did to FSU for the last three consecutive years, a place the he supposedly loved and was supposed to stay for the rest of his career. Do you want that side show here every year? Because that is what I think we are going to get iif Willie stays. Let FSU have him for $7.5M/ year (rumored). Point of reference - Urban Meyer’s base salary is $6.9M
Also, after watching that press conference, I was totally unimpressed with how that was handled. He is standing there saying he is transparent and honest, yet all his answers are deceptive, his voice is nervous, and his body language is telling. If EVERYONE KNOWS YOU ARE LYING, JUST TELL THE DAMN TRUTH. Say “I grew up an FSU fan and I am from Florida. It was my dream job growing up. If the contact me, I have to listen to see if I still feel that way”
Grow some f$&&$ing balls.
- brich75
- Senior
- Posts: 4054
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:27 pm
Re: Willie leaving worse than chip leaving?
agree 100 percentmaxduck wrote:Outstanding posts! I can't imagine for a moment that Willie would tolerate that kind of evasive answer from one of his players.northbeachsf wrote:This is a very well thought out post and I agree with everything you said.Phalanx wrote:I think the worst part about Taggart potentially leaving is losing a coach to Florida State as though that was a real gig and Oregon isn't. We are worried about a single recruiting class, but that would likely affect inroads the ducks have made in other regions for years to come. If Oregon wants to be perceived as a top team, they can't have coaches bailing whenever a 'destination job' opens up.
I don't think Taggart is an irreplaceable coach, I just think he has a lot of leverage at this moment because of the great recruiting class he has lined up, coupled with the fragile position the ducks are in in terms of national perception. This play he and his agent are making for more money is very shrewd, but it does have a cost down the road in terms of trust and connection with the fan base. College sports are more and more a business, but there is still a naive, romantic idea with fans that it is based on a community and connection around a school and a state. This fear-mongering might be great for getting a new contract, but at the same time, as it drags on, we are constantly being reminded that Willie isn't one of us, he isn't from here, and he has no loyalty to the program. Not a great message in the long run for a college football program.
Of course, Oregon more or less asked for this situation when they fired the hometown guy after one bad year. Loyalty is a two-way street, I guess.
I will take it a step further. Up until yesterday I was upset about Taggart leaving. I am not anymore. Look what Jimbo and Sexton did to FSU for the last three consecutive years, a place the he supposedly loved and was supposed to stay for the rest of his career. Do you want that side show here every year? Because that is what I think we are going to get iif Willie stays. Let FSU have him for $7.5M/ year (rumored). Point of reference - Urban Meyer’s base salary is $6.9M
Also, after watching that press conference, I was totally unimpressed with how that was handled. He is standing there saying he is transparent and honest, yet all his answers are deceptive, his voice is nervous, and his body language is telling. If EVERYONE KNOWS YOU ARE LYING, JUST TELL THE DAMN TRUTH. Say “I grew up an FSU fan and I am from Florida. It was my dream job growing up. If the contact me, I have to listen to see if I still feel that way”
Grow some f$&&$ing balls.
- OregonFan4Life
- All-American
- Posts: 15430
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm
Re: Willie leaving worse than chip leaving?
Great posts in this thread! The more I’ve thought about it the more I’ve lost respect for Willie. Obviously what matters most to me is if he’s being honest to the recruits and players, but if he does leave, good, cause I wouldn’t want a coach with that character or lack thereof. But still, we’ll have to see what happens. If he stays for a reasonable price then I’m fine with it, he has been honest with recruits which matters. But if continues to use this to get overpaid from either school then it almost feels as if he’s using recruits to get more money, which is really lame.


