#19 Oregon @ #24 Cal (Sept. 29, Sat 7:35 PM FS1)

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39373
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: #19 Oregon @ #24 Cal (Sept. 29, Sat 7:35 PM FS1)

Post by greenyellow »

Image
Handsome Dan
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 688
Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 3:04 am

Re: #19 Oregon @ #24 Cal (Sept. 29, Sat 7:35 PM FS1)

Post by Handsome Dan »

To the people saying that fans need to adjust from the Chip-era to ball control type offense:

The issue is that the conservative play calling isn't having the effect of securing wins, which is the entire justification for it. Conversely, as we saw both this week and last week, it jeopardizes the outcome of games where Oregon is completely in the driver's seat. Why should they change the play calling to "control" the game when the play calling they were using up to that point was already controlling it? At the end of the day, controlling a game is always the primary goal, and putting it out of reach psychologically halfway through the third quarter is always a better form of control than slowly massaging out the final 20-25 minutes with passive and predictable play calling that hinders the offense to the point it is ineffective.

It's frustrating to see because it is reflective of the immensely dumb SEC-esque mentality of "we're up so now we're just going to run it down your throat without trying to fool you." That approach is only effective if you have a massive talent advantage in the running game (OL/RB vs. DL/LB/SS) or in general on defense - if you don't, the opposing team will shut down your running game by stacking the box, which shuts down your offense, which exposes your defense and demoralizes them because they can no longer trust the offense to bail them out of their mistakes. Alabama traditionally enjoys those advantages, but Oregon doesn't. The biggest talent advantage Oregon enjoys is the same one that they enjoyed in 2012: a quarterback that rarely makes stupid decisions with the football while possessing the arm talent and athleticism to execute every component of an offense that attacks all of the field. Chip slowed down the offense a bit that year, but it was also pretty objectively the most effective/reliable offense he had in his four years as HC. (Remember how we all complained that Marcus wasn't getting enough Heisman hype because he was getting pulled at halftime or early in the third quarter and not accruing the gaudy stats necessary to warrant attention as a freshman in the Pac-12?) This offense displays a similar level of reliability to the 2012 offense, and that means the coaches should be putting a similar level of trust in it to execute the normal balanced play calling to the point the game is out of reach. They either don't trust the players, don't trust their own ability to continue calling the right plays of a well-balanced spread offense in the second half, or are too afraid in general of losing a big lead and making suboptimal decisions because of it.

You win a game by pressing your advantages, and when your advantage is an offense that exerts an untenable amount of scoring pressure on the defense because its quarterback's reliability, the only way you are going to really lose a game where you have a large lead in the third quarter is if you shut down that offense yourself. That is what the coaching staff is doing with their current playcalling approach in the third quarter, and it is something that needs to stop if we don't want to see the Washington game be a repeat of Stanford. I am very glad that there is a bye week this week because I think the coaches are competent and self-aware enough to potentially solve the issue with the extra time they have to prepare.
User avatar
duckduckgoose
Five Star Recruit
Posts: 1117
Joined: Mon Feb 23, 2009 6:45 pm

Re: #19 Oregon @ #24 Cal (Sept. 29, Sat 7:35 PM FS1)

Post by duckduckgoose »

Duck24 wrote:So who do we hope has the #1 pick in the NFL draft? Giants? Chargers? Who else needs a QB and will be in position to pick Herbie at #1? Marcus was a better college QB but Herbert’s skills translate better to the NFL IMO.
I think that Herbert is a much better passer than Marcus, but Marcus is the better dual threat by far. I always anticipated Marcus in the end zone when he pulled the ball on the zone read. With Herbie I anticipate a good run for a first down.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
User avatar
nogerO
Senior
Posts: 4517
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:48 pm
Location: Wyoming

Re: #19 Oregon @ #24 Cal (Sept. 29, Sat 7:35 PM FS1)

Post by nogerO »

Handsome Dan wrote:To the people saying that fans need to adjust from the Chip-era to ball control type offense:

The issue is that the conservative play calling isn't having the effect of securing wins, which is the entire justification for it. Conversely, as we saw both this week and last week, it jeopardizes the outcome of games where Oregon is completely in the driver's seat. Why should they change the play calling to "control" the game when the play calling they were using up to that point was already controlling it? At the end of the day, controlling a game is always the primary goal, and putting it out of reach psychologically halfway through the third quarter is always a better form of control than slowly massaging out the final 20-25 minutes with passive and predictable play calling that hinders the offense to the point it is ineffective.

It's frustrating to see because it is reflective of the immensely dumb SEC-esque mentality of "we're up so now we're just going to run it down your throat without trying to fool you." That approach is only effective if you have a massive talent advantage in the running game (OL/RB vs. DL/LB/SS) or in general on defense - if you don't, the opposing team will shut down your running game by stacking the box, which shuts down your offense, which exposes your defense and demoralizes them because they can no longer trust the offense to bail them out of their mistakes. Alabama traditionally enjoys those advantages, but Oregon doesn't. The biggest talent advantage Oregon enjoys is the same one that they enjoyed in 2012: a quarterback that rarely makes stupid decisions with the football while possessing the arm talent and athleticism to execute every component of an offense that attacks all of the field. Chip slowed down the offense a bit that year, but it was also pretty objectively the most effective/reliable offense he had in his four years as HC. (Remember how we all complained that Marcus wasn't getting enough Heisman hype because he was getting pulled at halftime or early in the third quarter and not accruing the gaudy stats necessary to warrant attention as a freshman in the Pac-12?) This offense displays a similar level of reliability to the 2012 offense, and that means the coaches should be putting a similar level of trust in it to execute the normal balanced play calling to the point the game is out of reach. They either don't trust the players, don't trust their own ability to continue calling the right plays of a well-balanced spread offense in the second half, or are too afraid in general of losing a big lead and making suboptimal decisions because of it.

You win a game by pressing your advantages, and when your advantage is an offense that exerts an untenable amount of scoring pressure on the defense because its quarterback's reliability, the only way you are going to really lose a game where you have a large lead in the third quarter is if you shut down that offense yourself. That is what the coaching staff is doing with their current playcalling approach in the third quarter, and it is something that needs to stop if we don't want to see the Washington game be a repeat of Stanford. I am very glad that there is a bye week this week because I think the coaches are competent and self-aware enough to potentially solve the issue with the extra time they have to prepare.
Exactamundo!
"To give anything less than your best, is to sacrifice the gift." - Steve Prefontaine
User avatar
Alan
Senior
Posts: 4359
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: #19 Oregon @ #24 Cal (Sept. 29, Sat 7:35 PM FS1)

Post by Alan »

Handsome Dan wrote:To the people saying that fans need to adjust from the Chip-era to ball control type offense:

The issue is that the conservative play calling isn't having the effect of securing wins, which is the entire justification for it. Conversely, as we saw both this week and last week, it jeopardizes the outcome of games where Oregon is completely in the driver's seat. Why should they change the play calling to "control" the game when the play calling they were using up to that point was already controlling it? At the end of the day, controlling a game is always the primary goal, and putting it out of reach psychologically halfway through the third quarter is always a better form of control than slowly massaging out the final 20-25 minutes with passive and predictable play calling that hinders the offense to the point it is ineffective.

It's frustrating to see because it is reflective of the immensely dumb SEC-esque mentality of "we're up so now we're just going to run it down your throat without trying to fool you." That approach is only effective if you have a massive talent advantage in the running game (OL/RB vs. DL/LB/SS) or in general on defense - if you don't, the opposing team will shut down your running game by stacking the box, which shuts down your offense, which exposes your defense and demoralizes them because they can no longer trust the offense to bail them out of their mistakes. Alabama traditionally enjoys those advantages, but Oregon doesn't. The biggest talent advantage Oregon enjoys is the same one that they enjoyed in 2012: a quarterback that rarely makes stupid decisions with the football while possessing the arm talent and athleticism to execute every component of an offense that attacks all of the field. Chip slowed down the offense a bit that year, but it was also pretty objectively the most effective/reliable offense he had in his four years as HC. (Remember how we all complained that Marcus wasn't getting enough Heisman hype because he was getting pulled at halftime or early in the third quarter and not accruing the gaudy stats necessary to warrant attention as a freshman in the Pac-12?) This offense displays a similar level of reliability to the 2012 offense, and that means the coaches should be putting a similar level of trust in it to execute the normal balanced play calling to the point the game is out of reach. They either don't trust the players, don't trust their own ability to continue calling the right plays of a well-balanced spread offense in the second half, or are too afraid in general of losing a big lead and making suboptimal decisions because of it.

You win a game by pressing your advantages, and when your advantage is an offense that exerts an untenable amount of scoring pressure on the defense because its quarterback's reliability, the only way you are going to really lose a game where you have a large lead in the third quarter is if you shut down that offense yourself. That is what the coaching staff is doing with their current playcalling approach in the third quarter, and it is something that needs to stop if we don't want to see the Washington game be a repeat of Stanford. I am very glad that there is a bye week this week because I think the coaches are competent and self-aware enough to potentially solve the issue with the extra time they have to prepare.
You are correct........ but while we had the nations best dual threat QB at the helm in those days Chips system stumbled without Mario, we still had a very good team just not beat you by 50. Also and more to the point of the Cristobal era, even with Mariota, and the Ducks were a nationally elite team, we still get beat consistently by one type of team. The top notch smash mouth, control the line, control the clock teams. Stanford was always a struggle, Ohio State, and to a degree Auburn.

I stated I feel Mario is still learning, in the Stanford game I think he made a big mistake which contributed as much to the loss as any bad snap or fumble. Aliotti explained the situation best last week on a sports radio show, he wasn't criticizing Cristobal at all he was just explaining the take a knee seniro. According to Aliotti, with 42 or 43 seconds to go Stanford had one timeout. If we would have taken a knee then punted the ball away, Stanford would had to had used their final timeout during the series, they would have gotten the ball back with about 6 seconds and somewhere one their own side of the field, no timeouts. They still could have pulled off the Hail Mary....... but it was another option. In hindsight I think I would have liked that option better, but its only hindsight. We played very well against Stanford, just beat the number 24 team on the road, let's see how we preform against the Huskies in two weeks after the bye.
ducksrock
Senior
Posts: 2739
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 8:08 am

Re: #19 Oregon @ #24 Cal (Sept. 29, Sat 7:35 PM FS1)

Post by ducksrock »

It seems that everyone that is weighing in has the same opinions as to the Ducks conservatism play calling situations... From watching Stanford dismantle the Ducks in past years (often 2nd half comebacks), I watched last weeks game with horror, hoping the outcome would be different..It wasnt... Same bs... I recall a 28 point plus Stanford comeback years back and it still haunts me...Now, I have something to replace that nightmare with... Hopefully, the coaching staff will get their act together and right this slightly listing ship...
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: #19 Oregon @ #24 Cal (Sept. 29, Sat 7:35 PM FS1)

Post by StevensTechU »

This is more criticism than an 18 point road victory over a ranked team deserves. Especially one that followed a massive emotional letdown. Anybody remember the ducks in Arizona a handful of years ago? Yea, that didn’t happen here.
Last edited by StevensTechU on Sun Sep 30, 2018 8:42 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Juice
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 685
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:19 am
Location: Seattle

Re: #19 Oregon @ #24 Cal (Sept. 29, Sat 7:35 PM FS1)

Post by Juice »

Cristobal said Verdell tweaked his MCL a little bit, but they don't think it's serious. Hopefully it's not.
User avatar
Alan
Senior
Posts: 4359
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: #19 Oregon @ #24 Cal (Sept. 29, Sat 7:35 PM FS1)

Post by Alan »

Juice wrote:Cristobal said Verdell tweaked his MCL a little bit, but they don't think it's serious. Hopefully it's not.
Thanks for the info on Verdell, he also said TBJ was healthy enough to return kicks, but they didn't want to use him a single a regular RB with the repeated hits yet. Good time for a Bye week.
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: #19 Oregon @ #24 Cal (Sept. 29, Sat 7:35 PM FS1)

Post by buckmarkduck »

Mario's style will work, but right now the D doesn't have the horses to shut down top 25 teams in the 2nd half of games. In ancouple years, we'll have the LBs and DBs to shut a team like Cal down, while playing ball control.
Duck24
Senior
Posts: 4744
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: #19 Oregon @ #24 Cal (Sept. 29, Sat 7:35 PM FS1)

Post by Duck24 »

StevensTechU wrote:This is more criticism than an 18 point road victory over a ranked team deserves. Especially one that followed a massive emotional letdown. Anybody remember the ducks in Arizona a handful of years ago? Yea, that didn’t happen here.
Some of the criticism is absolutely warranted. Yes, the game was an impressive rebound from the Stanford game, especially given Cal's first drive, but they got sloppy in the second half and very much benefitted from Cal having no legit passing options at QB. The second half 'letdowns' are a concern. You have a guy who is arguably the best QB in the country. When it comes time to put the game to bed, put the ball in his hands and let him work.
Duck24
Senior
Posts: 4744
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: #19 Oregon @ #24 Cal (Sept. 29, Sat 7:35 PM FS1)

Post by Duck24 »

Handsome Dan wrote:To the people saying that fans need to adjust from the Chip-era to ball control type offense:

The issue is that the conservative play calling isn't having the effect of securing wins, which is the entire justification for it. Conversely, as we saw both this week and last week, it jeopardizes the outcome of games where Oregon is completely in the driver's seat. Why should they change the play calling to "control" the game when the play calling they were using up to that point was already controlling it? At the end of the day, controlling a game is always the primary goal, and putting it out of reach psychologically halfway through the third quarter is always a better form of control than slowly massaging out the final 20-25 minutes with passive and predictable play calling that hinders the offense to the point it is ineffective.

It's frustrating to see because it is reflective of the immensely dumb SEC-esque mentality of "we're up so now we're just going to run it down your throat without trying to fool you." That approach is only effective if you have a massive talent advantage in the running game (OL/RB vs. DL/LB/SS) or in general on defense - if you don't, the opposing team will shut down your running game by stacking the box, which shuts down your offense, which exposes your defense and demoralizes them because they can no longer trust the offense to bail them out of their mistakes. Alabama traditionally enjoys those advantages, but Oregon doesn't. The biggest talent advantage Oregon enjoys is the same one that they enjoyed in 2012: a quarterback that rarely makes stupid decisions with the football while possessing the arm talent and athleticism to execute every component of an offense that attacks all of the field. Chip slowed down the offense a bit that year, but it was also pretty objectively the most effective/reliable offense he had in his four years as HC. (Remember how we all complained that Marcus wasn't getting enough Heisman hype because he was getting pulled at halftime or early in the third quarter and not accruing the gaudy stats necessary to warrant attention as a freshman in the Pac-12?) This offense displays a similar level of reliability to the 2012 offense, and that means the coaches should be putting a similar level of trust in it to execute the normal balanced play calling to the point the game is out of reach. They either don't trust the players, don't trust their own ability to continue calling the right plays of a well-balanced spread offense in the second half, or are too afraid in general of losing a big lead and making suboptimal decisions because of it.

You win a game by pressing your advantages, and when your advantage is an offense that exerts an untenable amount of scoring pressure on the defense because its quarterback's reliability, the only way you are going to really lose a game where you have a large lead in the third quarter is if you shut down that offense yourself. That is what the coaching staff is doing with their current playcalling approach in the third quarter, and it is something that needs to stop if we don't want to see the Washington game be a repeat of Stanford. I am very glad that there is a bye week this week because I think the coaches are competent and self-aware enough to potentially solve the issue with the extra time they have to prepare.
That last paragraph pretty much sums up my thoughts to a T. Well said.
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39373
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: #19 Oregon @ #24 Cal (Sept. 29, Sat 7:35 PM FS1)

Post by greenyellow »

Image
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: #19 Oregon @ #24 Cal (Sept. 29, Sat 7:35 PM FS1)

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

I will only say one thing in regards to the play calling the second half. We all remember last year and how the team looked without Herbert. Maybe the play calling is to try to limit the hits their qb takes. When the qb's we have behind him do not get us excited about the future I think we need to be glad they are thinking about that. The defense struggled in the second half. They knew what was coming and still did not execute. I have no problems with the philosophy of keeping Herbert healthy if this was what was going on in the second half. I think Oregon was comfortable with the lead and knew they could turn Herbert loose anytime if needed to.
User avatar
OregonFan4Life
All-American
Posts: 15429
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm

Re: #19 Oregon @ #24 Cal (Sept. 29, Sat 7:35 PM FS1)

Post by OregonFan4Life »

GoDucksIn09 wrote:I will only say one thing in regards to the play calling the second half. We all remember last year and how the team looked without Herbert. Maybe the play calling is to try to limit the hits their qb takes. When the qb's we have behind him do not get us excited about the future I think we need to be glad they are thinking about that. The defense struggled in the second half. They knew what was coming and still did not execute. I have no problems with the philosophy of keeping Herbert healthy if this was what was going on in the second half. I think Oregon was comfortable with the lead and knew they could turn Herbert loose anytime if needed to.
I hear you, but I think the best way to keep a player healthy is by putting him on the bench, and you can only do that when the game is out of reach for the opponent. Look at Marcus on week 1 again the Dolphins, he was injured on a handoff. As long as a player is on the field there is always a risk of injury.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Image
Post Reply