What about the eye ball test? We played pretty physical against Stanford and Cal.GrantDuck wrote:Statistically it's not much improved over last year in the major metrics, save for run defense and takeaways(big thanks to the cal game). Pass defense quite a bit worse so far.UOducksTK1 wrote:Our defense looked really good against Cal. I know their QBs threw a couple bad balls, but just overall I was very impressed.
I feel like we have so many play makers right now, Dye, Winston, Jelks, Collins, Scott, Amadi, etc... That's not even including some of the up and coming young DBs we have (Holland, Graham, Lenoir, etc).
Is our D legit? Will we give Washington some problems in two weeks?
Long way to go, obviously.
How good is our defense?
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40733
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: How good is our defense?

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
-
GrandpaDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 3314
- Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm
Re: How good is our defense?
That's the thing about this defense going back to last year. They excel at the eyeball test with sacks and run stuffs and 3 and outs, but at the end of the day you look up at the scoreboard and where did all those points against come from?UOducksTK1 wrote:What about the eye ball test? We played pretty physical against Stanford and Cal.GrantDuck wrote:Statistically it's not much improved over last year in the major metrics, save for run defense and takeaways(big thanks to the cal game). Pass defense quite a bit worse so far.UOducksTK1 wrote:Our defense looked really good against Cal. I know their QBs threw a couple bad balls, but just overall I was very impressed.
I feel like we have so many play makers right now, Dye, Winston, Jelks, Collins, Scott, Amadi, etc... That's not even including some of the up and coming young DBs we have (Holland, Graham, Lenoir, etc).
Is our D legit? Will we give Washington some problems in two weeks?
Long way to go, obviously.
The replacements for Springs and Robinson have been a down grade but the front 7 is better, putting us right back to middle of the pack nationally in points against.
- nogerO
- Senior
- Posts: 4517
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:48 pm
- Location: Wyoming
Re: How good is our defense?
3 cupcakes and a decent Kal team later, I'd give them a 6 on a scale of 1-10.
"To give anything less than your best, is to sacrifice the gift." - Steve Prefontaine
-
wlduck
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1722
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:19 pm
Re: How good is our defense?
This is spot on.gogreen55 wrote:The defense has been pretty mediocre overall, but that isn't terribly surprising given the holes we have on that side of the ball. The Ducks are going to need at least a couple more top-notch recruiting classes in order to potentially fix these issues. That doesn't mean we can't still win a lot of games, and play defense at a high level for stretches, but you can't simply wave some magic wand and wish these holes away. As we all know, we have a 208 pound former walk-on starting at MIKE linebacker. We have an incredible lack of overall experience and quality depth in the secondary. Instead of the optimum number of players under scholarship on the defensive side of the ball, which would be 41 (you figure 41 on offense, 41 on defense and 3 on special teams), we have 31 (not counting Andrew Johnson and DJ Johnson since neither can play this season). When your numbers on the defensive side of the ball are 1/4th below where you would like them to be, that is going to cause some issues.
In summary, even though we have some really good individual players on defense, the overall picture isn't conducive to this unit ranking as one of the top in the country. The statistics reflect that.
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: How good is our defense?
The good:
Jordon Scott is a monster.
Drayton Carlberg has stepped up to give the DL depth.
We're relatively healthy through 5 games.
Our edges - Hollins and Jelks - are outstanding, and have potential to get better.
Holland is stepping up big time after a slow start.
I don't think I've yelled at the TV at all due to play-calling.
The meh:
Was hoping Austin Faoliu would make a big jump in year 2. He's been ok.
Similar to above, was hoping La'Mar Winston would make a bigger jump.
Nobody has taken Apelu's spot, though Apelu has improved over last year.
The bad:
Our corners contend with our WRs for being the worst unit on the field.
Opposite Holland, we don't have a second safety (assuming Amadi is nickel).
Together, the two points above mean we have 3 liabilities in 5 DB positions.
Dye hasn't been making the same impact as we've seen (he's also not bad, so this could be 'meh').
Jordon Scott is a monster.
Drayton Carlberg has stepped up to give the DL depth.
We're relatively healthy through 5 games.
Our edges - Hollins and Jelks - are outstanding, and have potential to get better.
Holland is stepping up big time after a slow start.
I don't think I've yelled at the TV at all due to play-calling.
The meh:
Was hoping Austin Faoliu would make a big jump in year 2. He's been ok.
Similar to above, was hoping La'Mar Winston would make a bigger jump.
Nobody has taken Apelu's spot, though Apelu has improved over last year.
The bad:
Our corners contend with our WRs for being the worst unit on the field.
Opposite Holland, we don't have a second safety (assuming Amadi is nickel).
Together, the two points above mean we have 3 liabilities in 5 DB positions.
Dye hasn't been making the same impact as we've seen (he's also not bad, so this could be 'meh').
-
GrandpaDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 3314
- Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm
Re: How good is our defense?
Apelu is easily the most improved player on the team. I held off pointing it out for the 3 non-conference games worrying he'd just get run over again in conference play, but he played well against Love and Stanford and held up against Cal too. His production this season is incredibly close to Dye's.StevensTechU wrote:The good:
Jordon Scott is a monster.
Drayton Carlberg has stepped up to give the DL depth.
We're relatively healthy through 5 games.
Our edges - Hollins and Jelks - are outstanding, and have potential to get better.
Holland is stepping up big time after a slow start.
I don't think I've yelled at the TV at all due to play-calling.
The meh:
Was hoping Austin Faoliu would make a big jump in year 2. He's been ok.
Similar to above, was hoping La'Mar Winston would make a bigger jump.
Nobody has taken Apelu's spot, though Apelu has improved over last year.
The bad:
Our corners contend with our WRs for being the worst unit on the field.
Opposite Holland, we don't have a second safety (assuming Amadi is nickel).
Together, the two points above mean we have 3 liabilities in 5 DB positions.
Dye hasn't been making the same impact as we've seen (he's also not bad, so this could be 'meh').
-
gogreen55
- Senior
- Posts: 2369
- Joined: Sat Apr 30, 2011 8:39 pm
Re: How good is our defense?
On many of the big runs Cal had, one thing that kept standing out was Apelu being swallowed up by a Cal offensive lineman. This happened over and over, so I don't know if we can really say he held up against Cal. I don't really have time to rewatch the game and focus just on him, so maybe I am not giving him enough credit for the things he did well (I do remember him making a couple nice plays).
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: How good is our defense?
Our run D gave up nearly 2 more yards per rush without Austin. I think you're selling him short. And Amadi is 100% a safety, he's not the nickel.StevensTechU wrote:The good:
Jordon Scott is a monster.
Drayton Carlberg has stepped up to give the DL depth.
We're relatively healthy through 5 games.
Our edges - Hollins and Jelks - are outstanding, and have potential to get better.
Holland is stepping up big time after a slow start.
I don't think I've yelled at the TV at all due to play-calling.
The meh:
Was hoping Austin Faoliu would make a big jump in year 2. He's been ok.
Similar to above, was hoping La'Mar Winston would make a bigger jump.
Nobody has taken Apelu's spot, though Apelu has improved over last year.
The bad:
Our corners contend with our WRs for being the worst unit on the field.
Opposite Holland, we don't have a second safety (assuming Amadi is nickel).
Together, the two points above mean we have 3 liabilities in 5 DB positions.
Dye hasn't been making the same impact as we've seen (he's also not bad, so this could be 'meh').
- UofDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 3970
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:51 pm
Re: How good is our defense?
Agree. Austin has be VERY solid
-
GrandpaDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 3314
- Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm
Re: How good is our defense?
He does get swallowed up sometimes by lineman. But watch Dye, he gets swallowed by them on occasion too. As does every linebacker that plays against a good zone blocking team. That's what they do. This year he is slipping and dodging more of those blocks, and isn't getting tread marks across his chest by every ball carrier he meets as he is largely putting them down.gogreen55 wrote:On many of the big runs Cal had, one thing that kept standing out was Apelu being swallowed up by a Cal offensive lineman. This happened over and over, so I don't know if we can really say he held up against Cal. I don't really have time to rewatch the game and focus just on him, so maybe I am not giving him enough credit for the things he did well (I do remember him making a couple nice plays).
He is second on the team to Dye in tackles, and has 4-1/2 tackles for loss to Dyes 1-1/2, 2 pass break-ups and 3 QB hurries. Last year he was non-existent on the stat sheet until he had a really good game going the game he got hurt and knocked out for the season.
I was his earliest and loudest critic on the board last year and called out Leavitt as a position coach for continuing to play him when he was producing nothing. So I have to give him his due this year. Most improved and a solid contributor to a better than average run defense.
-
maxduck
- Senior
- Posts: 3763
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:37 pm
Re: How good is our defense?
Question, in your opinion how much of the improvement is coaching and how much is the S&C program?GrandpaDuck wrote:He does get swallowed up sometimes by lineman. But watch Dye, he gets swallowed by them on occasion too. As does every linebacker that plays against a good zone blocking team. That's what they do. This year he is slipping and dodging more of those blocks, and isn't getting tread marks across his chest by every ball carrier he meets as he is largely putting them down.gogreen55 wrote:On many of the big runs Cal had, one thing that kept standing out was Apelu being swallowed up by a Cal offensive lineman. This happened over and over, so I don't know if we can really say he held up against Cal. I don't really have time to rewatch the game and focus just on him, so maybe I am not giving him enough credit for the things he did well (I do remember him making a couple nice plays).
He is second on the team to Dye in tackles, and has 4-1/2 tackles for loss to Dyes 1-1/2, 2 pass break-ups and 3 QB hurries. Last year he was non-existent on the stat sheet until he had a really good game going the game he got hurt and knocked out for the season.
I was his earliest and loudest critic on the board last year and called out Leavitt as a position coach for continuing to play him when he was producing nothing. So I have to give him his due this year. Most improved and a solid contributor to a better than average run defense.
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: How good is our defense?
Austin is definitely solid, but I'm comparing him to himself in '17, not comparing him to the next guy on the depth chart. He was good last year and I was hoping that year-over-year, he'd make an improvement that puts him in the conversation for all-league.
-
GrandpaDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 3314
- Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm
Re: How good is our defense?
Honestly, I don't know. There is so much improvement that there is credit to spread around to all. I do suspect though that a lot of it was getting his head right. He must have had it in him in practice last year or Coach Pepsi wouldn't have played him so much before he got hurt. And the game he got hurt he was playing a lot like he is playing this year. I think it took him awhile to learn how to adjust from his opponents practice thud intensity to their real game intensity. I am a believer in the new strength and conditioning philosophy that stresses football plays not beach body building. No amount of muscle building would allow Apelu to stand up and throw off a 300 pound lineman, He needs to use his speed and agility to make them miss.maxduck wrote:Question, in your opinion how much of the improvement is coaching and how much is the S&C program?GrandpaDuck wrote:He does get swallowed up sometimes by lineman. But watch Dye, he gets swallowed by them on occasion too. As does every linebacker that plays against a good zone blocking team. That's what they do. This year he is slipping and dodging more of those blocks, and isn't getting tread marks across his chest by every ball carrier he meets as he is largely putting them down.gogreen55 wrote:On many of the big runs Cal had, one thing that kept standing out was Apelu being swallowed up by a Cal offensive lineman. This happened over and over, so I don't know if we can really say he held up against Cal. I don't really have time to rewatch the game and focus just on him, so maybe I am not giving him enough credit for the things he did well (I do remember him making a couple nice plays).
He is second on the team to Dye in tackles, and has 4-1/2 tackles for loss to Dyes 1-1/2, 2 pass break-ups and 3 QB hurries. Last year he was non-existent on the stat sheet until he had a really good game going the game he got hurt and knocked out for the season.
I was his earliest and loudest critic on the board last year and called out Leavitt as a position coach for continuing to play him when he was producing nothing. So I have to give him his due this year. Most improved and a solid contributor to a better than average run defense.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: How good is our defense?
Being in your best shape allows you to feel very confident in yourself and what you can do. Being familiar on what's expected of you and what you're supposed to do within the defense also gives you a lot of confidence. They definitely go hand in hand but sometimes a player needs more time with the S&C and sometimes the player needs more IQ/Practice. We're not a finished product as a team or staff but all the pieces are there except the one thing we can't rush: time.maxduck wrote:Question, in your opinion how much of the improvement is coaching and how much is the S&C program?

-
wlduck
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1722
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:19 pm
Re: How good is our defense?
I keep thinking Thomas Graham is going to have a career that is a little better version of Aaron Gipsons. Thrown into starting as a true freshman because we didn't have anyone else and burned like toast. A little better as a sophomore, but still picked on. Solid as a junior and all league as a senior.