It is so frustrating to rectify what you see with your eyes happening in real-time vs. your pre-existing thoughts and how they conflict. Here is what I am struggling with as a fan. Bear in mind, this is through fan-eyes. I have always loved football because I never played it competitively. Most people on here know a helluva lot more about the X and O's of the game than I do. So here goes:
On one hand: Herbert is seemingly a lab-built NFL-ready QB, straight from central casting Qb/Honor Student/Citizen. Men want to be him and women want to be with him.
On the other: Taggart openly worried about Herbert's maturity and mental toughness last year and Justin has yet to show he can carry the team when he has to or mask warts the way Mariota did in '14 and the way VA did in 2015. Dude has broke out crying on several occasions, during or after games and practices.
On one hand: PFF seemingly loves our OLine grades. We recruit monsters. We have a great S & C staff. We bullied 'Furd and the Pups.
On the other: Smaller, quicker lines at San Jose, WSU and AZ have DESTROYED and DOMINATED us
On one hand: Cristobal is extremely competitive, energetic, tough as nails, a leader of men, he's highly intelligent and the guy clearly is on a mission to bring our program back to national prominence. Look at what he did with Florida International. Hell, most High Schools in Oregon have better facilities and structure than that place and he built them up and took them to a bowl. He actually developed a decent little coaching tree (call it a "sapling") under him at FIU as well.
On the other: Cristobal's style was forged by his time playing at Miami late 80's-90's and coaching OL at Alabama under Saban. Those teams recruited elite players that were simply bigger, better, faster, stronger athletes than every team they played. Line up with those athletes, put a hat on a hat and you are going to win most matchups. If that doesn't work at USC right now it's not going to work at Oregon. Notice how the "Stanford style" is starting to come back to earth for Stanford? I don't know what scheme is right for this team, I am not a football expert, however, I know that a scheme fitting personnel then tailored to the opponent matters to every team in every sport.
One on hand: Arroyo is organized, an elite recruiter, connects with kids, played QB at D1, has studied under some great offensive minds. The guy oozes intelligence & confidence when you see or read his interviews. OSU Cowboy fans were PISSED that he left to come to Taggart's staff. They thought very highly of him.
On the other: If you pull up Arroyo's coaching history when he has been an OC vs a position coach, it's mediocre at best. Like the average of averages or middling-to-poor. We have a QB that was thought of as a Heisman candidate, who has NFL scouts drooling and we have a veteran Oline, but unless we play a defense that is over-matched talent-wise (BG, PSU) or wants to meet us in the center of the ring and go toe-to-toe (Tree & Pups), our O has struggled to move the ball (Boise, SJSU, WSA, AZ).
TLDR version: These coaches clearly care, they obviously want to win, they know 1,000,000,0000 x more about football than I do, but all that isn't translating to what I see with my own untrained eyes. Maybe I need to be more patient.
On one hand, but then on the other - why I'm frustrated
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
-
bdkipe
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 544
- Joined: Fri Aug 30, 2013 4:09 pm
-
Merganzer
- Senior
- Posts: 3656
- Joined: Sat Apr 15, 2017 10:42 am
Re: On one hand, but then on the other - why I'm frustrated
I think it's fair to say that Herbert doesn't have the leadership traits that Mariota had. Of course these traits were seen as liabilities in Marcus according to some NFL Scouts during his draft evaluations. A part of that is because Mariota had a lot more to work with than does Herbert.
Herbert is smart. Being school smart doesn't necessarily translate to football smart. But, I think that Herbert understands that focusing almost entirely on Mitchell as a receiver is bad, but he's decided that its still better than any alternative.
Cristobal is coaching what he knows, and that is the "power" football. The coaching mantra is "wait until he gets his players'" Probably never before has that been more true than right here, right now. These players aren't suited to playing the way that Alabama does. It doesn't come to mind immediately, but some of Alabama's best players have been WR's. Julio Jones, Calvin Ridley...and the defense is even farther away. If the recruits will stay, Cristobal will have his players.
Herbert is smart. Being school smart doesn't necessarily translate to football smart. But, I think that Herbert understands that focusing almost entirely on Mitchell as a receiver is bad, but he's decided that its still better than any alternative.
Cristobal is coaching what he knows, and that is the "power" football. The coaching mantra is "wait until he gets his players'" Probably never before has that been more true than right here, right now. These players aren't suited to playing the way that Alabama does. It doesn't come to mind immediately, but some of Alabama's best players have been WR's. Julio Jones, Calvin Ridley...and the defense is even farther away. If the recruits will stay, Cristobal will have his players.
- dd10snoop28
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5046
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 12:06 am
- GM: New Jersey Nets GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: On one hand, but then on the other - why I'm frustrated
Good points except one.bdkipe wrote:It is so frustrating to rectify what you see with your eyes happening in real-time vs. your pre-existing thoughts and how they conflict. Here is what I am struggling with as a fan. Bear in mind, this is through fan-eyes. I have always loved football because I never played it competitively. Most people on here know a helluva lot more about the X and O's of the game than I do. So here goes:
On one hand: Herbert is seemingly a lab-built NFL-ready QB, straight from central casting Qb/Honor Student/Citizen. Men want to be him and women want to be with him.
On the other: Taggart openly worried about Herbert's maturity and mental toughness last year and Justin has yet to show he can carry the team when he has to or mask warts the way Mariota did in '14 and the way VA did in 2015. Dude has broke out crying on several occasions, during or after games and practices.
On one hand: PFF seemingly loves our OLine grades. We recruit monsters. We have a great S & C staff. We bullied 'Furd and the Pups.
On the other: Smaller, quicker lines at San Jose, WSU and AZ have DESTROYED and DOMINATED us
On one hand: Cristobal is extremely competitive, energetic, tough as nails, a leader of men, he's highly intelligent and the guy clearly is on a mission to bring our program back to national prominence. Look at what he did with Florida International. Hell, most High Schools in Oregon have better facilities and structure than that place and he built them up and took them to a bowl. He actually developed a decent little coaching tree (call it a "sapling") under him at FIU as well.
On the other: Cristobal's style was forged by his time playing at Miami late 80's-90's and coaching OL at Alabama under Saban. Those teams recruited elite players that were simply bigger, better, faster, stronger athletes than every team they played. Line up with those athletes, put a hat on a hat and you are going to win most matchups. If that doesn't work at USC right now it's not going to work at Oregon. Notice how the "Stanford style" is starting to come back to earth for Stanford? I don't know what scheme is right for this team, I am not a football expert, however, I know that a scheme fitting personnel then tailored to the opponent matters to every team in every sport.
One on hand: Arroyo is organized, an elite recruiter, connects with kids, played QB at D1, has studied under some great offensive minds. The guy oozes intelligence & confidence when you see or read his interviews. OSU Cowboy fans were PISSED that he left to come to Taggart's staff. They thought very highly of him.
On the other: If you pull up Arroyo's coaching history when he has been an OC vs a position coach, it's mediocre at best. Like the average of averages or middling-to-poor. We have a QB that was thought of as a Heisman candidate, who has NFL scouts drooling and we have a veteran Oline, but unless we play a defense that is over-matched talent-wise (BG, PSU) or wants to meet us in the center of the ring and go toe-to-toe (Tree & Pups), our O has struggled to move the ball (Boise, SJSU, WSA, AZ).
TLDR version: These coaches clearly care, they obviously want to win, they know 1,000,000,0000 x more about football than I do, but all that isn't translating to what I see with my own untrained eyes. Maybe I need to be more patient.
"Taggart openly worried about Herbert's maturity and mental toughness last year and Justin has yet to show he can carry the team when he has to or mask warts the way Mariota did in '14 and the way VA did in 2015. Dude has broke out crying on several occasions, during or after games and practices."
This is only partly true Those comments made by Taggart were made during Winter '17/Spring '17. During fall camp '17 he noted the vast improvement in leadership/communication by herbert and then during the season he lauded his leadership as well.
I haven't heard anything but good things regarding Herbert's leadership since Spring '17. And, i don't doubt that he did, but when did herbert cry?

-
bdkipe
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 544
- Joined: Fri Aug 30, 2013 4:09 pm
Re: On one hand, but then on the other - why I'm frustrated
I was more referencing his Freshman year, specifically after Cal interception in 2016 in Berkeley.
From the Fentress/Amaranthus article 2 days ago on NBC Sports Northwest:
"...During his freshman season, Herbert took losing and making mistakes so personal that they sometimes drove him to tears on the sideline. Don't mistake that for weakness, however. His emotions stem from a competitive fire that burns deep and drives him to succeed and not let him teammates down."
I can see your point about how his leadership has grown. I agree with that 100%.
I love Herbert. The kid is going to be a special player and he is already a special human being as a young man. I am bringing all this up because I think that there have been some head-scratching/WTF moments with him lately and I think it's because we ordained him as a Heisman Finalist and #1 pick before the season even started and in hindsight, we may have all got over our skis on expectations of him throwing for 300+ yards and 4 TD's every game.
From the Fentress/Amaranthus article 2 days ago on NBC Sports Northwest:
"...During his freshman season, Herbert took losing and making mistakes so personal that they sometimes drove him to tears on the sideline. Don't mistake that for weakness, however. His emotions stem from a competitive fire that burns deep and drives him to succeed and not let him teammates down."
I can see your point about how his leadership has grown. I agree with that 100%.
I love Herbert. The kid is going to be a special player and he is already a special human being as a young man. I am bringing all this up because I think that there have been some head-scratching/WTF moments with him lately and I think it's because we ordained him as a Heisman Finalist and #1 pick before the season even started and in hindsight, we may have all got over our skis on expectations of him throwing for 300+ yards and 4 TD's every game.