Arroyo: Should he stay or go?

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

chapelhillduck
Senior
Posts: 2408
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 8:15 am

Re: Arroyo: Should he stay or go?

Post by chapelhillduck »

In the spirit of curiosity....would y'all be in favor of having Herbert take off and run more given his history and our backups?

That's one main reason why Chips team (and pretty much every high powered offense out there) are unstoppable


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
User avatar
Duckenstein
Freshman
Posts: 1433
Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2016 7:43 pm

Re: Arroyo: Should he stay or go?

Post by Duckenstein »

chapelhillduck wrote:In the spirit of curiosity....would y'all be in favor of having Herbert take off and run more given his history and our backups?

That's one main reason why Chips team (and pretty much every high powered offense out there) are unstoppable


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
No. Gotta be able to pass to open the run. Skip running the QB
User avatar
DuckMastaFunk
Five Star Recruit
Posts: 1044
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:07 pm

Re: Arroyo: Should he stay or go?

Post by DuckMastaFunk »

chapelhillduck wrote:In the spirit of curiosity....would y'all be in favor of having Herbert take off and run more given his history and our backups?

That's one main reason why Chips team (and pretty much every high powered offense out there) are unstoppable


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Hypothetically, you could save Herbert running for the big games. No need risking it against teams we should be able to move the ball on either way.
Everythingsducky
Senior
Posts: 2820
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 2:40 pm

Re: Arroyo: Should he stay or go?

Post by Everythingsducky »

chapelhillduck wrote:In the spirit of curiosity....would y'all be in favor of having Herbert take off and run more given his history and our backups?

That's one main reason why Chips team (and pretty much every high powered offense out there) are unstoppable


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I hate leaving your best club in the bag. Mariota at the time was at least given the option to run with plays designed for him to decide. Did the Ducks really have great options behind him if he got injured? Everyone is bitching about the crappy offense, and no imagination. Herbert opted to come back. I say, if he is good with it (zero knowledge if he is or isn’t), give him more options to run. He is a smart dude, and learned something from the Cal game. It just opens up the offense, and they wouldn’t be as freaking predictable. Open up the damn playbook.
User avatar
DuckMastaFunk
Five Star Recruit
Posts: 1044
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:07 pm

Re: Arroyo: Should he stay or go?

Post by DuckMastaFunk »

Everythingsducky wrote:
chapelhillduck wrote:In the spirit of curiosity....would y'all be in favor of having Herbert take off and run more given his history and our backups?

That's one main reason why Chips team (and pretty much every high powered offense out there) are unstoppable


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I hate leaving your best club in the bag. Mariota at the time was at least given the option to run with plays designed for him to decide. Did the Ducks really have great options behind him if he got injured? Everyone is bitching about the crappy offense, and no imagination. Herbert opted to come back. I say, if he is good with it (zero knowledge if he is or isn’t), give him more options to run. He is a smart dude, and learned something from the Cal game. It just opens up the offense, and they wouldn’t be as freaking predictable. Open up the damn playbook.
We had Bennett behind Mariota who might have won the job if he was going against nearly anyone except MM. Then we had Costa who looked pretty good in his limited appearances. (Of course we know now that was fools gold.)
I get what you’re saying about not leaving your best club in your bag, but running isn’t remotely closest to Herbert’s best club. Throwing is. Running is a “risky” club. Mostly beneficial but could also end disastrously. I still think you only use it when you have more to gain than lose. Now, if Herbert built like Masoli The risk factor goes way down and you can use him more in the run game.
Everythingsducky
Senior
Posts: 2820
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 2:40 pm

Re: Arroyo: Should he stay or go?

Post by Everythingsducky »

DuckMastaFunk wrote:
Everythingsducky wrote:
chapelhillduck wrote:In the spirit of curiosity....would y'all be in favor of having Herbert take off and run more given his history and our backups?

That's one main reason why Chips team (and pretty much every high powered offense out there) are unstoppable


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I hate leaving your best club in the bag. Mariota at the time was at least given the option to run with plays designed for him to decide. Did the Ducks really have great options behind him if he got injured? Everyone is bitching about the crappy offense, and no imagination. Herbert opted to come back. I say, if he is good with it (zero knowledge if he is or isn’t), give him more options to run. He is a smart dude, and learned something from the Cal game. It just opens up the offense, and they wouldn’t be as freaking predictable. Open up the damn playbook.
We had Bennett behind Mariota who might have won the job if he was going against nearly anyone except MM. Then we had Costa who looked pretty good in his limited appearances. (Of course we know now that was fools gold.)
I get what you’re saying about not leaving your best club in your bag, but running isn’t remotely closest to Herbert’s best club. Throwing is. Running is a “risky” club. Mostly beneficial but could also end disastrously. I still think you only use it when you have more to gain than lose. Now, if Herbert built like Masoli The risk factor goes way down and you can use him more in the run game.
Then it should lie where the coaches see improvement in the backups, if they feel better about their options. Hopefully the backups make leaps in their game, and they are more comfortable in playing them if needed. Running is always risky, but this is freaking football. Herbert is a very capable runner, and has speed. I get wanting to keep Herbert upright, but then you have to accept limitations to the offense. They are neither dynamic at the RB or WR spots, so where are you going to get the change? Got to do something different.
User avatar
Juice
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 685
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:19 am
Location: Seattle

Re: Arroyo: Should he stay or go?

Post by Juice »

DuckMastaFunk wrote:
chapelhillduck wrote:In the spirit of curiosity....would y'all be in favor of having Herbert take off and run more given his history and our backups?

That's one main reason why Chips team (and pretty much every high powered offense out there) are unstoppable


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Hypothetically, you could save Herbert running for the big games. No need risking it against teams we should be able to move the ball on either way.
Yes. Even if he pulls only 4-5 times a game just to keep them honest. He's gotta slide though :lol: I think it would open things up a lot more on O, but that's just me.
maxduck
Senior
Posts: 3763
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:37 pm

Re: Arroyo: Should he stay or go?

Post by maxduck »

Went back to the play by play against Stanford

1st possession 1 JH carry for 14 yards drive result TD
2nd possession 3 JH carries (4, 7, and 3 yds), plus a sack drive result TD
3rd possession 0 JH carries drive result TD
4th possession 3 JH carries (-1, 28, 0 yds) drive result FG

Herbert had 11 carries for the game including sacks. 8 of those carries were in the first 4 possessions and each possession ended with a score. Oregon had another 7 possessions with a total of 1 carry by Herbert. Only one of those possessions was successful. I think the threat of a QB carry had the Stanford defense off balance.
User avatar
DuckMastaFunk
Five Star Recruit
Posts: 1044
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:07 pm

Re: Arroyo: Should he stay or go?

Post by DuckMastaFunk »

maxduck wrote:Went back to the play by play against Stanford

1st possession 1 JH carry for 14 yards drive result TD
2nd possession 3 JH carries (4, 7, and 3 yds), plus a sack drive result TD
3rd possession 0 JH carries drive result TD
4th possession 3 JH carries (-1, 28, 0 yds) drive result FG

Herbert had 11 carries for the game including sacks. 8 of those carries were in the first 4 possessions and each possession ended with a score. Oregon had another 7 possessions with a total of 1 carry by Herbert. Only one of those possessions was successful. I think the threat of a QB carry had the Stanford defense off balance.
Good stat pulls Max!
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: Arroyo: Should he stay or go?

Post by buckmarkduck »

DuckMastaFunk wrote:
Everythingsducky wrote:
chapelhillduck wrote:In the spirit of curiosity....would y'all be in favor of having Herbert take off and run more given his history and our backups?

That's one main reason why Chips team (and pretty much every high powered offense out there) are unstoppable


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I hate leaving your best club in the bag. Mariota at the time was at least given the option to run with plays designed for him to decide. Did the Ducks really have great options behind him if he got injured? Everyone is bitching about the crappy offense, and no imagination. Herbert opted to come back. I say, if he is good with it (zero knowledge if he is or isn’t), give him more options to run. He is a smart dude, and learned something from the Cal game. It just opens up the offense, and they wouldn’t be as freaking predictable. Open up the damn playbook.
We had Bennett behind Mariota who might have won the job if he was going against nearly anyone except MM. Then we had Costa who looked pretty good in his limited appearances. (Of course we know now that was fools gold.)
I get what you’re saying about not leaving your best club in your bag, but running isn’t remotely closest to Herbert’s best club. Throwing is. Running is a “risky” club. Mostly beneficial but could also end disastrously. I still think you only use it when you have more to gain than lose. Now, if Herbert built like Masoli The risk factor goes way down and you can use him more in the run game.
Bennett wouldn't have beaten out any full time starter at UO over the last 20 years except DP.
Post Reply