Running with the QB
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
- Quietduck
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 623
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:43 pm
Running with the QB
I believe that one of the primary reasons that we didn't do RPO's and a lot of option style runs is that we could not in any way allow Herbert to get injured. The coaches seem to know that if he went down so did our whole season. Now that we have a back up that actually seem able to complete a pass and run the offense will we open up the options part of the playbook again?
By the way, I have gone back and watched our offense during the golden years and while I agree it was powerful I believe we are looking through green and gold glasses to think bringing it back will solve all our offenses problems. Take a look at the bowl game vs Texas for an example. Our best QB ever and some of our great receivers and we still would likely lose the game if the defense hadn't scored as it did. Any offense can be great or bad depending on the coach and the players.
Quiet duck
By the way, I have gone back and watched our offense during the golden years and while I agree it was powerful I believe we are looking through green and gold glasses to think bringing it back will solve all our offenses problems. Take a look at the bowl game vs Texas for an example. Our best QB ever and some of our great receivers and we still would likely lose the game if the defense hadn't scored as it did. Any offense can be great or bad depending on the coach and the players.
Quiet duck
- lukeyrid13
- All-American
- Posts: 10475
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
- GM: Portland TrailBlazers
Re: Running with the QB
We are transitioning to an offense similar to what Bama ran from about 08-17. They obviously had a ton of success over that time. If we continue to get too 5 classes we will win most of our games.
In our games last season where we had more talent, we scored a ton of points and had no problem moving the ball. We still had an above average roster last year and couldn’t dominate like we would have liked.
I don’t see is getting 750 yards in a game again but we can still dominate in other ways. I do think we need to run occasional RPO to keep the defense honest and use the edge more
In our games last season where we had more talent, we scored a ton of points and had no problem moving the ball. We still had an above average roster last year and couldn’t dominate like we would have liked.
I don’t see is getting 750 yards in a game again but we can still dominate in other ways. I do think we need to run occasional RPO to keep the defense honest and use the edge more
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: Running with the QB
"We're transitioning to an offense that a team abandoned because they recognized that it was less successful than others nationwide."
"We're transitioning to an offense that was schematically inferior and success only due to talent differential."
"We're transitioning to a decent offense, but not a good one."
"We're transitioning to an offense that was schematically inferior and success only due to talent differential."
"We're transitioning to a decent offense, but not a good one."
-
huckthefuskies
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 290
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:55 pm
Re: Running with the QB
Almost feels like the man in charge has an offensive lineman mentality that we can impose our will upfront and always get positive yardage and stay ahead of the chains 3 yards at a time. Pretty exciting football. SarcasmStevensTechU wrote:"We're transitioning to an offense that a team abandoned because they recognized that it was less successful than others nationwide."
"We're transitioning to an offense that was schematically inferior and success only due to talent differential."
"We're transitioning to a decent offense, but not a good one."
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: Running with the QB
As far as the topic - running with the QB - there are big differences in this. My spectrum of 'offenses with a running QB' is something like
GaTech/Wing T --> Houston --> Ohio State/Nebraska/Oregon under Chip --> Oregon under Helfrich.
All have had success, and the latter two groupings were very successful against high level competition. Helf moved further away from running Marcus than Chip's offense would have because of the injuries sustained seemed to signal that what you get in additional potency, you lose in injuries. Ohio State has been able to pull it off because they've frequently gone 2-3 deep in extremely talented QBs. Most other schools (all?) don't have that luxury. This is why I'm a big fan of the Oregon offense under Helf. It achieved being unpredictable, but still kept the QB healthy.
GaTech/Wing T --> Houston --> Ohio State/Nebraska/Oregon under Chip --> Oregon under Helfrich.
All have had success, and the latter two groupings were very successful against high level competition. Helf moved further away from running Marcus than Chip's offense would have because of the injuries sustained seemed to signal that what you get in additional potency, you lose in injuries. Ohio State has been able to pull it off because they've frequently gone 2-3 deep in extremely talented QBs. Most other schools (all?) don't have that luxury. This is why I'm a big fan of the Oregon offense under Helf. It achieved being unpredictable, but still kept the QB healthy.
- lukeyrid13
- All-American
- Posts: 10475
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
- GM: Portland TrailBlazers
Re: Running with the QB
^ I'm going to disagree with you actually. Mariota ran it 135 times in 2014. Right around 10x a game under Helfrich.
Darron Thomas ran it 93 times in 2010, 7x a game & 56 times in 2011. We led the conference in rushing all years and DT ran a 4.8 40, I bet Herbert runs at least a 4.7 in a few months and is much bigger and stronger.
Helf actually ran the QB more.
The main difference, was defenses would never know when DT was going to pull it and run off the edge. Say 2 of those runs were scrambles, those 5x that he kept it in the zone read was enough to keep the defenses honest. Running RPO or read option 5x a game will keep the defense honest in all facets: read option, edge rushing, play action etc
Darron Thomas ran it 93 times in 2010, 7x a game & 56 times in 2011. We led the conference in rushing all years and DT ran a 4.8 40, I bet Herbert runs at least a 4.7 in a few months and is much bigger and stronger.
Helf actually ran the QB more.
The main difference, was defenses would never know when DT was going to pull it and run off the edge. Say 2 of those runs were scrambles, those 5x that he kept it in the zone read was enough to keep the defenses honest. Running RPO or read option 5x a game will keep the defense honest in all facets: read option, edge rushing, play action etc
-
Everythingsducky
- Senior
- Posts: 2820
- Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 2:40 pm
Re: Running with the QB
Just don’t think it fits the offensive mentality of the current staff. I would love to see the RPO more to loosen up the defense. You are basically asking the coaching staff if they are good to possibly hand over the keys of the O to Shough right now if necessary.The question is, do they coach for today, or do they protect Herbert being that he came back for his senior year, and throw risk to the wind? I’m sure Herbert gives them the green light on either, but...?
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: Running with the QB
Those numbers are very misleading, as the number of designed runs was far lower than the 135 that includes sacks and scrambles captured in what you're referring to. The difference is apparent when you look at the average yards per run in 2014 (5.7) compared to 2013 (7.4) and 2012 (7.1). The coaching staff deliberately removed designed runs in 2014 after Marcus' injuries in 2013.lukeyrid13 wrote:^ I'm going to disagree with you actually. Mariota ran it 135 times in 2014. Right around 10x a game under Helfrich.
Darron Thomas ran it 93 times in 2010, 7x a game & 56 times in 2011. We led the conference in rushing all years and DT ran a 4.8 40, I bet Herbert runs at least a 4.7 in a few months and is much bigger and stronger.
Helf actually ran the QB more.
The main difference, was defenses would never know when DT was going to pull it and run off the edge. Say 2 of those runs were scrambles, those 5x that he kept it in the zone read was enough to keep the defenses honest. Running RPO or read option 5x a game will keep the defense honest in all facets: read option, edge rushing, play action etc
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: Running with the QB
The bigger issue is this: You can't use the pistol to its full effect if you don't run the QB from it So whether it was a decision due to lack of depth behind him or from his prior injury, we can't continue to trot it out if we don't let him rip off a few runs to simply force the defense to respect it. Plus he can practice his baseball slide because we can trust him to know when to run and keep himself safe. It doesn't need to be a staple, just something to take advantage of to keep the defense honest.
