Calling out those blaming Justin Herbert

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

GrantDuck
Senior
Posts: 2629
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm

Calling out those blaming Justin Herbert

Post by GrantDuck »

Those who know my posts know I don't sugar coat the negatives or make excuses.

People on here, on Twitter, etc. can go join the leg humper fan base with Softy, Ruth, and Co. IF you think Herbert is the reason for that loss, you don't know football, period.

He hit 16 of his last 18 throws and was our only offense after the 1st quarter. His accuracy last night was ridiculous on those quick pass plays and screens. He made 1 mistake(the fumble). The incompletions were the Hail Mary and that bogus grounding call with 2 guys in his face because our RB got lit the hell up in pass protection.

He was missing 4 of his top 5 pass targets. If you follow Dan Orlovsky on Twitter, you'll note that he counted "2" open Oregon WR's against man coverage. Outside of screen passes, we had like 20 total YAC last night. Breeland couldn't get 6 inches when we desperately needed it against a safety who he needs to outmuscle.

The "he doesn't win us games" is also completely bogus. He was clutch as hell against UW and ASU last season. Clutch as a freshman against Utah.

So please, I know the loss sucked and I'm bummed as any fan about it, but educate yourself before you blame Justin Herbert, who will go down as an Oregon legend and win us several games this year.
Last edited by GrantDuck on Mon Sep 02, 2019 12:49 pm, edited 1 time in total.
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: Calling out those blaming Justin Herbert

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

All valid points Grant, and while I agree he will win several games for Oregon. there is no escaping that as a senior on the rpo, he needs to hang on to the ball. He also needs to throw the hail mary where people can catch it and not 5 or 10 yards out of the end zone. I expect more from a guy who has been playing football a long time and been a starter at Oregon for 4 years. This is not a freshman or even a red shirt freshman. I think the criticism of Herbert is valid. That being said I would still put the loss on Arroyo as the second half was a joke. You combine that with the first half against WSU, Arizona, Utah, and now the second half of Auburn and we see a bad pattern developing. The common theme is they are all on the road.
duckfan96
Senior
Posts: 2717
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:58 pm

Re: Calling out those blaming Justin Herbert

Post by duckfan96 »

I would put this loss 85% on arroyo. 10% on Mitchell..woulda won with him playing(sarcasm) and the rest on injuries. Part of the game but another wr or two woulda helped.

On a side note anyone see schooler on sideline? Dudes been hitting the weight room
User avatar
nogerO
Senior
Posts: 4517
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:48 pm
Location: Wyoming

Re: Calling out those blaming Justin Herbert

Post by nogerO »

GrantDuck wrote:Those who know my posts know I don't sugar coat the negatives or make excuses.

People on here, on Twitter, etc. can go join the leg humper fan base with Softy, Ruth, and Co. IF you don't think Herbert is the reason for that loss, you don't know football, period.

He hit 16 of his last 18 throws and was our only offense after the 1st quarter. His accuracy last night was ridiculous on those quick pass plays and screens. He made 1 mistake(the fumble). The incompletions were the Hail Mary and that bogus grounding call with 2 guys in his face because our RB got lit the hell up in pass protection.

He was missing 4 of his top 5 pass targets. If you follow Dan Orlovsky on Twitter, you'll note that he counted "2" open Oregon WR's against man coverage. Outside of screen passes, we had like 20 total YAC last night. Breeland couldn't get 6 inches when we desperately needed it against a safety who he needs to outmuscle.

The "he doesn't win us games" is also completely bogus. He was clutch as hell against UW and ASU last season. Clutch as a freshman against Utah.

So please, I know the loss sucked and I'm bummed as any fan about it, but educate yourself before you blame Justin Herbert, who will go down as an Oregon legend and win us several games this year.
Agree totally. He was hamstrung the entire second half by questionable play calling. Arroyo with MC in his ear called the game to not lose, and we all know what happens when you do that. The one thing Chip KNEW...when you have your opponent down, step on their neck until they give up. We don't know that lesson yet...
"To give anything less than your best, is to sacrifice the gift." - Steve Prefontaine
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Calling out those blaming Justin Herbert

Post by Duck07 »

Might want to change that 2nd line based on your conclusion, lol
Image
droop10
Freshman
Posts: 1442
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:07 am

Re: Calling out those blaming Justin Herbert

Post by droop10 »

nogerO wrote:
GrantDuck wrote:Those who know my posts know I don't sugar coat the negatives or make excuses.

People on here, on Twitter, etc. can go join the leg humper fan base with Softy, Ruth, and Co. IF you don't think Herbert is the reason for that loss, you don't know football, period.

He hit 16 of his last 18 throws and was our only offense after the 1st quarter. His accuracy last night was ridiculous on those quick pass plays and screens. He made 1 mistake(the fumble). The incompletions were the Hail Mary and that bogus grounding call with 2 guys in his face because our RB got lit the hell up in pass protection.

He was missing 4 of his top 5 pass targets. If you follow Dan Orlovsky on Twitter, you'll note that he counted "2" open Oregon WR's against man coverage. Outside of screen passes, we had like 20 total YAC last night. Breeland couldn't get 6 inches when we desperately needed it against a safety who he needs to outmuscle.

The "he doesn't win us games" is also completely bogus. He was clutch as hell against UW and ASU last season. Clutch as a freshman against Utah.

So please, I know the loss sucked and I'm bummed as any fan about it, but educate yourself before you blame Justin Herbert, who will go down as an Oregon legend and win us several games this year.
Agree totally. He was hamstrung the entire second half by questionable play calling. Arroyo with MC in his ear called the game to not lose, and we all know what happens when you do that. The one thing Chip KNEW...when you have your opponent down, step on their neck until they give up. We don't know that lesson yet...
All I hear about is questionable play calling, but nobody actually brings up what they should have done differently. It’s easy to spout off PLAY CALLING with nothing to back it up. Here were the complaints last year:

1). Run, run, pass: I don’t have the stats in front of me, but I believe they passed more often on 1st down than they ran. If not, it was definitely a damn near equal distribution.

2). Only deep passes, nothing short or intermediate: lots of screens dialed up when they figured out it was the only way the receivers could get any space, and a good amount of intermediate passes. Now the argument was there weren’t enough deep passes! Funny how that works out. They did look to go deep multiple times, but nobody was open, so Herbert didn’t risk it. Then, Arroyo gets blamed for not going deep. What can ya do.

3). Too conservative!: the argument is still being made, and I’m not sure what to make of it. What defines too conservative? It seems like people don’t see a lot of points scored and automatically default to this argument. Or is it that Herbert didn’t take enough risks with the ball? Is it less conservative if he risks a jump ball into double coverage? Not enough trick plays? I’m not saying it was a perfectly called game, but it’s not as egregious as some make it out to be. My only qualms would be the 2 4th downs, although I understand the predicament of having your backup come in cold off the bench with little game experience, and expect him to make the biggest play of the game.
Last edited by droop10 on Mon Sep 02, 2019 8:14 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
FlDuckFan
All Pac-12
Posts: 5068
Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:45 am
GM: Orlando Magic GM
Location: Florida

Re: Calling out those blaming Justin Herbert

Post by FlDuckFan »

droop10 wrote:
nogerO wrote:
GrantDuck wrote:Those who know my posts know I don't sugar coat the negatives or make excuses.

People on here, on Twitter, etc. can go join the leg humper fan base with Softy, Ruth, and Co. IF you don't think Herbert is the reason for that loss, you don't know football, period.

He hit 16 of his last 18 throws and was our only offense after the 1st quarter. His accuracy last night was ridiculous on those quick pass plays and screens. He made 1 mistake(the fumble). The incompletions were the Hail Mary and that bogus grounding call with 2 guys in his face because our RB got lit the hell up in pass protection.

He was missing 4 of his top 5 pass targets. If you follow Dan Orlovsky on Twitter, you'll note that he counted "2" open Oregon WR's against man coverage. Outside of screen passes, we had like 20 total YAC last night. Breeland couldn't get 6 inches when we desperately needed it against a safety who he needs to outmuscle.

The "he doesn't win us games" is also completely bogus. He was clutch as hell against UW and ASU last season. Clutch as a freshman against Utah.

So please, I know the loss sucked and I'm bummed as any fan about it, but educate yourself before you blame Justin Herbert, who will go down as an Oregon legend and win us several games this year.
Agree totally. He was hamstrung the entire second half by questionable play calling. Arroyo with MC in his ear called the game to not lose, and we all know what happens when you do that. The one thing Chip KNEW...when you have your opponent down, step on their neck until they give up. We don't know that lesson yet...
All I hear about is questionable play calling, but nobody actually brings up what they should have done differently. It’s easy to spout off PLAY CALLING with nothing to back it up. Here were the complaints last year:

1). Run, run, pass: I don’t have the stats in front of me, but I believe they passed more often on 1st down than they ran. If not, it was definitely a damn near equal distribution.

2). Only deep passes, nothing short or intermediate: lots of screens dialed up when they figured out it was the only way the receivers could get any space, and a good amount of intermediate passes. Now the argument was there weren’t enough deep passes! Funny how that works out. They did look to go deep multiple times, but nobody was open, so Herbert didn’t risk it. Then, Arroyo gets blamed for not going deep. What can ya do.

3). Too conservative!: the argument is still being made, and I’m not sure what to make of it. What defines too conservative? It seems like people don’t see a lot of points scored and automatically default to this argument. Or is it that Herbert didn’t take enough risks with the call? Is it less conservative if he risks a jump ball into double coverage? Not enough trick plays? I’m not saying it was a perfectly called game, but it’s not as egregious as some make it out to be. My only qualms would be the 2 4th downs, although I understand the predicament of having your backup come in cold off the bench with little game experience, and expect him to make the biggest play of the game.

Well said
User avatar
nogerO
Senior
Posts: 4517
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:48 pm
Location: Wyoming

Re: Calling out those blaming Justin Herbert

Post by nogerO »

Duck07 wrote:Might want to change that 2nd line based on your conclusion, lol
LOL...
"To give anything less than your best, is to sacrifice the gift." - Steve Prefontaine
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: Calling out those blaming Justin Herbert

Post by buckmarkduck »

Am I misreading Grant line, to blame JH?

Anyways, here is the sad truth, we couldn't throw deep because no one was getting open beyond quick passes. Auburn owned our WRs after making adjustments. If you go back and watch the tape, Herbert made the right read every play. We lost this game, but it wasn't because of how JH played. .maybe it was Arroya play calling, or CMC going conservative. Maybe Auburn just realized we couldn't block 7 guys, and they could cover our guys man to man with no problems?

My biggest takeaway is we only have 1 true RB right now, and if he gets hurt the run game will suffer. Maybe Felix can become the 2nd guy, but baby Dye just isn't the guy you want taking 10+ carries a game vs good front 7. Against the beavs he will look great, but so would anyone who doesn't get touched for 10 yds. Also our OL run blocking, sucked for the most part. Warmack gets zero push, we need someone to step up and take his job over the next 2-3 games. Sewell on the othe hand, was killing guys, so much so that AU started putting 2-3 guys on him because he was dominating and man 1 on 1. Bottom line, we lost due to the OL bad run blocking, and lack of depth at RB, and lack of any of the WR able to get open down field.
maxduck
Senior
Posts: 3763
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:37 pm

Re: Calling out those blaming Justin Herbert

Post by maxduck »

I keep thinking of the throw to 6'6" 250 lb Spencer Webb who manhandled the DB. Think if 6'4" 230 lb Juwan Johnson had been available.
GrantDuck
Senior
Posts: 2629
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm

Re: Calling out those blaming Justin Herbert

Post by GrantDuck »

buckmarkduck wrote:Am I misreading Grant line, to blame JH?

Anyways, here is the sad truth, we couldn't throw deep because no one was getting open beyond quick passes. Auburn owned our WRs after making adjustments. If you go back and watch the tape, Herbert made the right read every play. We lost this game, but it wasn't because of how JH played. .maybe it was Arroya play calling, or CMC going conservative. Maybe Auburn just realized we couldn't block 7 guys, and they could cover our guys man to man with no problems?

My biggest takeaway is we only have 1 true RB right now, and if he gets hurt the run game will suffer. Maybe Felix can become the 2nd guy, but baby Dye just isn't the guy you want taking 10+ carries a game vs good front 7. Against the beavs he will look great, but so would anyone who doesn't get touched for 10 yds. Also our OL run blocking, sucked for the most part. Warmack gets zero push, we need someone to step up and take his job over the next 2-3 games. Sewell on the othe hand, was killing guys, so much so that AU started putting 2-3 guys on him because he was dominating and man 1 on 1. Bottom line, we lost due to the OL bad run blocking, and lack of depth at RB, and lack of any of the WR able to get open down field.
I just mistyped the second line. It's fixed now. Blaming JH is a very wrong conclusion.
GrantDuck
Senior
Posts: 2629
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm

Re: Calling out those blaming Justin Herbert

Post by GrantDuck »

Run plays are also about innovation. Would have loved to see some counter and misdirection plays in the run game.
Duckattack7
Five Star Recruit
Posts: 1106
Joined: Sun Jan 17, 2010 9:09 pm
Location: Lake Oswego

Re: Calling out those blaming Justin Herbert

Post by Duckattack7 »

Sadly that one mistake was inexcusable and completely changed the momentum. It’s not on all him but his completion rate being so high was also due to easy pitch and catches it’s not like he lit them up or anything. It’s honestly too bad we couldn’t have at least had Johnson ready to go otherwise I think we would have hung 40 on them. Oh well It’s part of the game.
Return Of the Quack!
User avatar
Alan
Senior
Posts: 4359
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Calling out those blaming Justin Herbert

Post by Alan »

Duckattack7 wrote:Sadly that one mistake was inexcusable and completely changed the momentum. It’s not on all him but his completion rate being so high was also due to easy pitch and catches it’s not like he lit them up or anything. It’s honestly too bad we couldn’t have at least had Johnson ready to go otherwise I think we would have hung 40 on them. Oh well It’s part of the game.

X2. We did not have the receiver core and his completions were mostly due to short pitch and catch throws. He is a very good QB and will rank highly in Ducks best....... but he has had a couple of big fumbled handoffs or bad snap connections in his career, but that Hail Mary attempt may have been one of the worst I have ever seen.
User avatar
UofDuck
Senior
Posts: 3970
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:51 pm

Re: Calling out those blaming Justin Herbert

Post by UofDuck »

GrantDuck wrote:Run plays are also about innovation. Would have loved to see some counter and misdirection plays in the run game.
And whatever happened to a quick pitch to get an RB to the edge faster? Just another wrinkle I’d like to see.
Post Reply