Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6483
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo

Post by pezsez1 »

If our receivers are unable to get separation running the kinds of routes Arroyo repeatedly asks them to run, then it's past time to teach the receivers to run different kinds of routes, or to take pressure off of them by finding other ways to open up the passing game.

Arroyo, so far, seems really bad at thinking outside the box regarding how to help his players get open. We barely saw runningbacks get involved in the passing game. We barely saw any creative running plays. We only saw ONE quarterback keeper. We only saw one or two option plays to stretch that D.

I don't understand the point of the pistol, especially if the QB is never going to keep the ball. Why don't we want that advantage of the defense needing to account for a running QB?

I just don't understand how our offense as currently run is designed to give us any specific advantage over any defense.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo

Post by StevensTechU »

This is the saltiest I've ever seen this forum. It sucks, but reputationally (aka- ego), because I never had illusions of a national title this year anyway.

I thought playcalling wasn't bad (on par with our opponent). Game management was pretty bad. Herbert played well (good but not great; I was perhaps more annoyed with him tucking the ball and not making it bad to the line of scrimmage than anything). It seemed like the wide receivers were the worst unit on the field, but since they're not always in the frame, it's hard to be certain of that. Troy Dye allowing the wheel route and then the tight end to get downfield drove me bonkers. Dye had a crap game in coverage. I still have the image of Pickett taking the worst line to tackle Nix stuck in my head. The defensive line didn't put pressure on Nix on far too many plays. So anyway, lots of things.

Onto Nevada. If we went 12-1 with wins again the huskies and USC, I'd still call it a very good season.
Last edited by StevensTechU on Tue Sep 03, 2019 9:27 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
OregonFan4Life
All-American
Posts: 15429
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm

Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo

Post by OregonFan4Life »

pezsez1 wrote:If our receivers are unable to get separation running the kinds of routes Arroyo repeatedly asks them to run, then it's past time to teach the receivers to run different kinds of routes, or to take pressure off of them by finding other ways to open up the passing game.

Arroyo, so far, seems really bad at thinking outside the box regarding how to help his players get open. We barely saw runningbacks get involved in the passing game. We barely saw any creative running plays. We only saw ONE quarterback keeper. We only saw one or two option plays to stretch that D.

I don't understand the point of the pistol, especially if the QB is never going to keep the ball. Why don't we want that advantage of the defense needing to account for a running QB?

I just don't understand how our offense as currently run is designed to give us any specific advantage over any defense.
I could not agree with this more! Feels like the offense hasn't been able to gain an identity since Cristobal took over. It just feels like the coaching staff needs someone whose sole focus is offensive identity/playcalling. Maybe instead of firing Arroyo Cristobal should find a new role for him as I'm sure he can help the offense a lot in certain ways, just not sure being the primary playcaller is suited for him. Just feels like the coaching staff could really benefit from a Mark Helfrich type that would stay away from recruiting and would only focus on offensive identity/innovation.
Image
Duckattack7
Five Star Recruit
Posts: 1106
Joined: Sun Jan 17, 2010 9:09 pm
Location: Lake Oswego

Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo

Post by Duckattack7 »

OregonFan4Life wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:If our receivers are unable to get separation running the kinds of routes Arroyo repeatedly asks them to run, then it's past time to teach the receivers to run different kinds of routes, or to take pressure off of them by finding other ways to open up the passing game.

Arroyo, so far, seems really bad at thinking outside the box regarding how to help his players get open. We barely saw runningbacks get involved in the passing game. We barely saw any creative running plays. We only saw ONE quarterback keeper. We only saw one or two option plays to stretch that D.

I don't understand the point of the pistol, especially if the QB is never going to keep the ball. Why don't we want that advantage of the defense needing to account for a running QB?

I just don't understand how our offense as currently run is designed to give us any specific advantage over any defense.
I could not agree with this more! Feels like the offense hasn't been able to gain an identity since Cristobal took over. It just feels like the coaching staff needs someone whose sole focus is offensive identity/playcalling. Maybe instead of firing Arroyo Cristobal should find a new role for him as I'm sure he can help the offense a lot in certain ways, just not sure being the primary playcaller is suited for him. Just feels like the coaching staff could really benefit from a Mark Helfrich type that would stay away from recruiting and would only focus on offensive identity/innovation.
You know I've defended Arroyo and put a lot of blame on the players execution but I also believe we could do a lot better in that department. Its too bad this year has to be another test/what if with him but I honestly hope for the best. Now if we get healthy at WR and its still looking like nothing has improved them ill for sure be the first to admit to being wrong. Id rather have Helf back at OC then chip but the chances of either of those is very slim. I also think Mario needs some blame for the second half play calling it just doesn't make sense that he would go so conservative unless someone was in his ear but I don't have proof on that front.
Return Of the Quack!
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8818
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

StevensTechU wrote:This is the saltiest I've ever seen this forum. It sucks, but reputationally (aka- ego), because I never had illusions of a national title this year anyway.

I thought playcalling wasn't bad (on par with our opponent). Game management was pretty bad. Herbert played well (good but not great; I was perhaps more annoyed with him tucking the ball and not making it bad to the line of scrimmage than anything). It seemed like the wide receivers were the worst unit on the field, but since they're not always in the frame, it's hard to be certain of that. Troy Dye allowing the wheel route and then the tight end to get downfield drove me bonkers. Dye had a crap game in coverage. I still have the image of Pickett taking the worst line to tackle Nix stuck in my head. The defensive line didn't put pressure on Nix on far too many plays. So anyway, lots of things.

Onto Nevada. If we went 12-1 with wins again the huskies and USC, I'd still call it a very good season.
This is more along the lines of how I feel. I’m not an Arroyo fan but he’s become the catch-all scapegoat for all Duck struggles and it gets a bit tiring. Especially because most of it is mindless criticism that lacks any real analysis, and ignores all the other just as significant flaws.

That said, I agree with Pez’s critique above. In the Chip years we usually had very average receiving corps yet they were perpetually wide open due to great scheming by the staff. Our current offensive staff seems utterly dependent on player ability. When our guys can’t consistently beat the guy opposite them we’re out of luck.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Image
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo

Post by buckmarkduck »

Imho CMC is only as good as his assistants. He needs to hire a dynamic OC, and get out of his way. Mario just needs to do what he does best, recruit and inspire the players.
GrantDuck
Senior
Posts: 2629
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm

Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo

Post by GrantDuck »

dthomas=ddixon wrote:
StevensTechU wrote:This is the saltiest I've ever seen this forum. It sucks, but reputationally (aka- ego), because I never had illusions of a national title this year anyway.

I thought playcalling wasn't bad (on par with our opponent). Game management was pretty bad. Herbert played well (good but not great; I was perhaps more annoyed with him tucking the ball and not making it bad to the line of scrimmage than anything). It seemed like the wide receivers were the worst unit on the field, but since they're not always in the frame, it's hard to be certain of that. Troy Dye allowing the wheel route and then the tight end to get downfield drove me bonkers. Dye had a crap game in coverage. I still have the image of Pickett taking the worst line to tackle Nix stuck in my head. The defensive line didn't put pressure on Nix on far too many plays. So anyway, lots of things.

Onto Nevada. If we went 12-1 with wins again the huskies and USC, I'd still call it a very good season.
This is more along the lines of how I feel. I’m not an Arroyo fan but he’s become the catch-all scapegoat for all Duck struggles and it gets a bit tiring. Especially because most of it is mindless criticism that lacks any real analysis, and ignores all the other just as significant flaws.

That said, I agree with Pez’s critique above. In the Chip years we usually had very average receiving corps yet they were perpetually wide open due to great scheming by the staff. Our current offensive staff seems utterly dependent on player ability. When our guys can’t consistently beat the guy opposite them we’re out of luck.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Exactly how I feel too re: last paragraph. We had 2 plays where I thought scheme got our guys really open. 1. The Big JJIII play on our first drive. 2. The dropped TD by Addison.(that play was super well schemed). There are scheme things you can do against man2man defense. Rub routes, bunch routes, etc. Also what Malzahn did where he put Canella in the backfield and wheeled him out against a linebacker. That kind of scheme stuff.
User avatar
nogerO
Senior
Posts: 4517
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:48 pm
Location: Wyoming

Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo

Post by nogerO »

Duckattack7 wrote:
OregonFan4Life wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:If our receivers are unable to get separation running the kinds of routes Arroyo repeatedly asks them to run, then it's past time to teach the receivers to run different kinds of routes, or to take pressure off of them by finding other ways to open up the passing game.

Arroyo, so far, seems really bad at thinking outside the box regarding how to help his players get open. We barely saw runningbacks get involved in the passing game. We barely saw any creative running plays. We only saw ONE quarterback keeper. We only saw one or two option plays to stretch that D.

I don't understand the point of the pistol, especially if the QB is never going to keep the ball. Why don't we want that advantage of the defense needing to account for a running QB?

I just don't understand how our offense as currently run is designed to give us any specific advantage over any defense.
I could not agree with this more! Feels like the offense hasn't been able to gain an identity since Cristobal took over. It just feels like the coaching staff needs someone whose sole focus is offensive identity/playcalling. Maybe instead of firing Arroyo Cristobal should find a new role for him as I'm sure he can help the offense a lot in certain ways, just not sure being the primary playcaller is suited for him. Just feels like the coaching staff could really benefit from a Mark Helfrich type that would stay away from recruiting and would only focus on offensive identity/innovation.
You know I've defended Arroyo and put a lot of blame on the players execution but I also believe we could do a lot better in that department. Its too bad this year has to be another test/what if with him but I honestly hope for the best. Now if we get healthy at WR and its still looking like nothing has improved them ill for sure be the first to admit to being wrong. Id rather have Helf back at OC then chip but the chances of either of those is very slim. I also think Mario needs some blame for the second half play calling it just doesn't make sense that he would go so conservative unless someone was in his ear but I don't have proof on that front.
Agreed. Let's see how the wind blows after this weekend. Let's see how much better the team and the coaches execute against Nevada...
"To give anything less than your best, is to sacrifice the gift." - Steve Prefontaine
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6483
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Don't be so quick to jump on Arroyo

Post by pezsez1 »

Agreed. Let's see how the wind blows after this weekend. Let's see how much better the team and the coaches execute against Nevada...
Just one thing about this mindset...

Oregon is likely to look great against Nevada. We should be able to roll over them with our running game, and Herbert should have lots of nice one-on-one matchups downfield against a secondary without Auburn's speed.

In other words, we'll likely learn nothing of Arroyo's evolution (if there is any) from the Nevada game.

Also, to anyone who perceives folks here as "jumping all over Arroyo" after just one game, keep in mind this has been going on for more than a year now and it isn't just one game. It's a trend, and we have lots of observational data to draw from.

I want to see this team take Nevada to the woodshed -- that would be a good sign of the team's focus, and focus is definitely a result of great coaching.

Beyond that, a blowout win by any margin won't do anything to validate the offensive playcalling of this coaching staff -- unless Herbert, Verdell, and a couple of linemen all go down with injuries early in the first quarter and we still win by 30.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
Post Reply