Phenom wrote:I bet that 4th down call was MC's.
So say MC did call 3-4 plays in the 2md half, Arroya still had a lot of plays that left a lot of meat on the bone
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
Phenom wrote:I bet that 4th down call was MC's.
I thought he was good considering the talent at his disposal. We definitely had WRs open, even if it was short gains. If you look at hythloday's review, he says Herbert left a lot on the bone. Doesn't trust WRs yet (and maybe for good reason). The playcalling was not the issue against Auburn (and tbh I thought Herbert was okay, too). Just don't have the playmakers.buckmarkduck wrote:Phenom wrote:I bet that 4th down call was MC's.
So say MC did call 3-4 plays in the 2md half, Arroya still had a lot of plays that left a lot of meat on the bone
Phenom wrote:I thought he was good considering the talent at his disposal. We definitely had WRs open, even if it was short gains. If you look at hythloday's review, he says Herbert left a lot on the bone. Doesn't trust WRs yet (and maybe for good reason). The playcalling was not the issue against Auburn (and tbh I thought Herbert was okay, too). Just don't have the playmakers.buckmarkduck wrote:Phenom wrote:I bet that 4th down call was MC's.
So say MC did call 3-4 plays in the 2md half, Arroya still had a lot of plays that left a lot of meat on the bone
I do agree that our offense isn't as good or explosive as it was under CK/MH but that might be by design (more "powerful" offense).
Phenom wrote:QB11 (former DUCK AND NFL QB) from ScoopDuck will do a live play by play analysis right now. Check it out.
https://m.twitch.tv/qb11sd/profile
Really!? lol that's what people were saying.buckmarkduck wrote:Phenom wrote:QB11 (former DUCK AND NFL QB) from ScoopDuck will do a live play by play analysis right now. Check it out.
https://m.twitch.tv/qb11sd/profile
I'm pretty sure neither of those two statements are true. But he did play college ball, and his dad is an NFL scout.
Former duck and NFL qb?Phenom wrote:QB11 (former DUCK AND NFL QB) from ScoopDuck will do a live play by play analysis right now. Check it out.
https://m.twitch.tv/qb11sd/profile
We know who this guy is? Sounds like he knew a bit more than the average guy but not a ton, still cool to see someone break it down a bit. If only the All22 was available.Phenom wrote:Really!? lol that's what people were saying.buckmarkduck wrote:Phenom wrote:QB11 (former DUCK AND NFL QB) from ScoopDuck will do a live play by play analysis right now. Check it out.
https://m.twitch.tv/qb11sd/profile
I'm pretty sure neither of those two statements are true. But he did play college ball, and his dad is an NFL scout.
Thanks for this analysis, free of vitriol; just substance.pezsez1 wrote:It's not even that Arroyo is completely predictable -- the problem is that he seems to play checkers while everyone else plays chess.
Auburn just trotted out a freshman QB -- talented, sure, but still a freshman -- and he beat us on the game's biggest plays. We trotted out a senior QB who could be playing in the NFL right now and... seemed afraid to really use him in the second half.
Herbert completed lots of passes, sure. But many of them came on safe reads that Auburn was letting him have.
And, for some reason, Arroyo seemed fine with settling for 2-3 yard passes on every first down, because golly that's what the defense was going to make easy.
Meanwhile, on the Auburn sideline, the coaches are using wheel routes & QB keepers to keep our defense off balance and get crucial first downs (and big chunks of yards). They didn't do anything groundbreaking -- don't think any of their trick plays ended up working too well -- but used ALL of their weapons to take us down.
Arroyo left a big weapon on the table. Why wasn't Herbert running more often?
Also, why can't our RBs be more involved in the passing game? Before the game, I read a commentary saying to expect Oregon's RBs to catch lots of passes coming out of the backfield, and I genuinely chuckled, because I've seen enough of Arroyo to know he's just not that forward-thinking.
I really WANT to like Arroyo. I keep telling myself the offense only sucks because we don't have the receivers we should have right now. Only problem is I can't really say that with a straight face.
I hope he works out. I hope something becomes a wake-up call and he starts coaching as if his job might someday depend on it.
Unless we magically have an injury-free season, we'll never win a natty or a Pac-12 title with this level of offensive coaching/playcalling.
Can you post specific examples of bad play calls?pezsez1 wrote:It's not even that Arroyo is completely predictable -- the problem is that he seems to play checkers while everyone else plays chess.
Auburn just trotted out a freshman QB -- talented, sure, but still a freshman -- and he beat us on the game's biggest plays. We trotted out a senior QB who could be playing in the NFL right now and... seemed afraid to really use him in the second half.
Herbert completed lots of passes, sure. But many of them came on safe reads that Auburn was letting him have.
And, for some reason, Arroyo seemed fine with settling for 2-3 yard passes on every first down, because golly that's what the defense was going to make easy.
Meanwhile, on the Auburn sideline, the coaches are using wheel routes & QB keepers to keep our defense off balance and get crucial first downs (and big chunks of yards). They didn't do anything groundbreaking -- don't think any of their trick plays ended up working too well -- but used ALL of their weapons to take us down.
Arroyo left a big weapon on the table. Why wasn't Herbert running more often?
Also, why can't our RBs be more involved in the passing game? Before the game, I read a commentary saying to expect Oregon's RBs to catch lots of passes coming out of the backfield, and I genuinely chuckled, because I've seen enough of Arroyo to know he's just not that forward-thinking.
I really WANT to like Arroyo. I keep telling myself the offense only sucks because we don't have the receivers we should have right now. Only problem is I can't really say that with a straight face.
I hope he works out. I hope something becomes a wake-up call and he starts coaching as if his job might someday depend on it.
Unless we magically have an injury-free season, we'll never win a natty or a Pac-12 title with this level of offensive coaching/playcalling.
