Killer Mentality

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Post Reply
whosyourwally
Freshman
Posts: 1320
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 10:52 am
Location: Columbus, Ohio

Killer Mentality

Post by whosyourwally »

Great coaches/coordinators have it. Good ones don’t.

We’ve won some close games against good teams, and I think that shows we’ve got some very good coaches on this team. I’m very high on Avalos, and I think he might have it. But we need an offense with an identity they impose on other teams. One that gets them on their heals and then buries them.

Kelly had it. Meyer had it. Carroll had it. Harbaugh had it at Stanford. Sweeney has finally instilled it at Clemson. Saban keeps finding coordinators that have it. Sometimes Leach as it. Hell, Altman has it, and I believe it will win us a basketball championship if he sticks around long enough.

Ritch couldn’t find it. Peterson seemed to have it as BSU but luckily hasn’t consistently found it at UW yet. Lots of coaches had it and lost it when their coordinators moved on or the league adjusted (Carr, Brown, Miles).

Good coaches can win big games and, with the right breaks across a season, occasionally win a title. Great coaches can lose games, but more often than not, see a 14pt first half lead as a chance to break a team, not a lead to defend.

Cristobal has this year to decide if Arroyo can be his guy. If not, Cristobal’s next hire will define his legacy as a head coach. We know Cristobal is not an X’s and O’s coach, so he needs strong coordinators and position coaches. So far, I’ve loved his hires and his willingness to push out weaker links. Here’s to hoping he has the same eye for offensive coordinators.

Thanks all. Hang in there everyone.




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
alxtw
Freshman
Posts: 1279
Joined: Sun Dec 19, 2010 10:46 pm

Re: Killer Mentality

Post by alxtw »

Its too early to tell, but for this first game, we saw that the DC hire looks promising. Its great he was able to deter from the comfortable and popular hire of Heyward and went for the best DC from a pure performance standpoint. I hope he can make the change if our offense doesn't improve this year.
jimmy12
Senior
Posts: 2823
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:38 am

Re: Killer Mentality

Post by jimmy12 »

To be totally fair, I think Arroyo called a great first half. So, good that we should have had two more TDs and a FG (which obviously was missed). He struggles when he gets conservative. The Ducks also do not have a Whitemore. A bell-cow back that can lead the team with pure power and determination. I think Arroyo deserves a partial pass for yesterday. Some keys to this game that ended up killing the Ducks. (Death by 1000 cuts)

1) Drop in the end zone
2) Missed FG
3) Fumble at the 2
4) Miscommunication that led to their TD. While they were in the RZ, the Ducks were playing stout. That miscommunication led to an easy TD (their first)
5) The QB grounding call (Total BS)
6) The last first down by on the QB scramble. I would give Dye the advantage every time. We had our best tackler and a frosh QB 1:1 in open space and somehow he slipped past.

Let's be very clear, the Ducks are really really good. I actually think they may go up in the polls. The season is just beginning. They now have no room for error. They win out, they get through, BUT they have to play a lot of games. The WRs played much better. Javon Holland is the real deal. Our D is really really good. (Just go look at all the NFL players tweeting about the Ducks D), Our OL is AMAZING. We had a lot of key offensive guys out McCormick, juwan Johnson, Mycah pittman, JR Waters etc. This is disruptive to the offense. This was also an AWAY game! (where we sucked last year) Should we have done better to mitigate the offensive injuries, YES. Should we have been able to win this game, YES. We beat ourselves. Every point they got, except lthe last TD, was due to a mistake. We are bigger, faster and better than we have been in the past 5-6 years.

I went to bed at 4:30, because I live in London, and I usually wake up devastated. Today, I am encouraged. It's early, we're better and we showed it, and I love our chances against anyone in the Pac.
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: Killer Mentality

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

I think our coaches are pretty darn good. The killer instinct on offense is lacking though and that stems from the OC. We didn't have it last year and we see it again this game. You have to keep attacking in games against good teams. There is a saying in football that you play to win the game. If you get conservative to early are playing to lose. This is what we saw in the second half from our OC. He is being paid 6 figures and I am not seeing anything that indicates on the field he is worth it. Arroyo does not attack and put the foot on the pedal when have a team down. He needs to go because he is the weak link. This is the same thing we saw last year. Score 7 points in a half. That by itself will lose you a lot of games.
User avatar
Phalanx
All Pac-12
Posts: 5318
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm

Re: Killer Mentality

Post by Phalanx »

jimmy12 wrote:To be totally fair, I think Arroyo called a great first half. So, good that we should have had two more TDs and a FG (which obviously was missed). He struggles when he gets conservative. The Ducks also do not have a Whitemore. A bell-cow back that can lead the team with pure power and determination. I think Arroyo deserves a partial pass for yesterday. Some keys to this game that ended up killing the Ducks. (Death by 1000 cuts)

1) Drop in the end zone
2) Missed FG
3) Fumble at the 2
4) Miscommunication that led to their TD. While they were in the RZ, the Ducks were playing stout. That miscommunication led to an easy TD (their first)
5) The QB grounding call (Total BS)
6) The last first down by on the QB scramble. I would give Dye the advantage every time. We had our best tackler and a frosh QB 1:1 in open space and somehow he slipped past.
I would also add whatever the heck that was with the two timeouts and still having to take Herbert out and go for it on 4th down with Shough in there. I'm still not sure what happened there, and I don't think Cristobal ever did know what he was doing in that situation. It looked like he called the last timeout before the clock had even started from the second one. ANd then the play they ran was total garbage. So frustrating.
User avatar
Phalanx
All Pac-12
Posts: 5318
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm

Re: Killer Mentality

Post by Phalanx »

Just came across a pretty damning article on Cristobal's decision on yahoo.

https://www.yahoo.com/sports/on-the-clo ... 17917.html

"Simply put, the Stanford game last year and the Auburn game this year have left Cristobal branded as one of the worst game managers in all of the Power Five. This is simple and true. And he needs to realize that quickly, as his own inability to navigate late-game situations has already cost his program dearly."

Ouch
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Killer Mentality

Post by GoDucksTroll »

Let’s be honest: Cristobal is not a good in game coach, and Arroyo is a bad play caller. We didn’t lose this game because of a talent disparity, we lost it because of coaching.
User avatar
Alan
Senior
Posts: 4359
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Killer Mentality

Post by Alan »

I wish I could disagree with Cristobol’s The management ability. I agree with the previous poster about those two timeouts To try to get Hebert back into the game was poor judgment, as a head coach he should’ve known the rules or someone on his staff should have. I also think he’s pretty quick to pull the trigger on time outs, He seems to call him early and often
User avatar
FlDuckFan
All Pac-12
Posts: 5068
Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:45 am
GM: Orlando Magic GM
Location: Florida

Re: Killer Mentality

Post by FlDuckFan »

Alan wrote:I wish I could disagree with Cristobol’s The management ability. I agree with the previous poster about those two timeouts To try to get Hebert back into the game was poor judgment, as a head coach he should’ve known the rules or someone on his staff should have. I also think he’s pretty quick to pull the trigger on time outs, He seems to call him early and often
Rewatch that part of them game, Cristobal calls a timeout and then goes to referee and asks him something. the guy shakes his head yes and then Mario sends in Justin. Wasting 1 timeout there to get Justin in would have a good call but he got bad information from an official. He should have taken the penalty and then punted but hindsight is 20/20.
Merganzer
Senior
Posts: 3656
Joined: Sat Apr 15, 2017 10:42 am

Re: Killer Mentality

Post by Merganzer »

Alan wrote:I wish I could disagree with Cristobol’s The management ability. I agree with the previous poster about those two timeouts To try to get Hebert back into the game was poor judgment, as a head coach he should’ve known the rules or someone on his staff should have. I also think he’s pretty quick to pull the trigger on time outs, He seems to call him early and often
It's not even just calling time outs and end of the game situations. It's been pointed out here and other forums, that the Ducks were calling plays with a lot of time left. IF, Oregon had used more time from the start of the game, there would have been less time for Auburn at the end.
GrantDuck
Senior
Posts: 2629
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm

Re: Killer Mentality

Post by GrantDuck »

2 things:

1. Cristobal managed the game against Stanford last year 100% correctly. Statistically, was 100% the right move. Sometimes the right play doesn't work. Verdell fumbled, out defense fell apart.

2. The timeouts had pretty much zero affect on the outcome of the game. Yeah, he should know the rule, but what did it affect in the game? Absolutely nothing.


As far as the original topic. The play call was trash(Their DC slanted like 10 guys to our left side, it was ridiculous), I'll give you that and I think we got soft in that 2nd half. The conservative mentality isn't it in modern college football. This also isn't Madden 95 where you call the same stupid 3 plays over and over again. When the defense expects something, you outsmart them. Run a bootleg there and Shough is still running up the tunnel like Forrest freaking Gump if he wants to. Chip Kelly or any offensive coach worth a damn would never run that play there.

Why don't we have a QB sneak package for 4th and short?!
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Killer Mentality

Post by GoDucksTroll »

GrantDuck wrote:2 things:

1. Cristobal managed the game against Stanford last year 100% correctly. Statistically, was 100% the right move. Sometimes the right play doesn't work. Verdell fumbled, out defense fell apart.

2. The timeouts had pretty much zero affect on the outcome of the game. Yeah, he should know the rule, but what did it affect in the game? Absolutely nothing.


As far as the original topic. The play call was trash(Their DC slanted like 10 guys to our left side, it was ridiculous), I'll give you that and I think we got soft in that 2nd half. The conservative mentality isn't it in modern college football. This also isn't Madden 95 where you call the same stupid 3 plays over and over again. When the defense expects something, you outsmart them. Run a bootleg there and Shough is still running up the tunnel like Forrest freaking Gump if he wants to. Chip Kelly or any offensive coach worth a damn would never run that play there.

Why don't we have a QB sneak package for 4th and short?!
Those timeouts were not a game changer - but - you’re giving the defense an extra minute plus to regroup and catch a breath. Not what you want when the play is telegraphed. Everyone knew we were running it to that side. Either hurry up and try to get it on the ground, run something creative, or give them a long field.

I’m over it now, but it hurts to see so many what-ifs left out there.
User avatar
dd10snoop28
All Pac-12
Posts: 5046
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 12:06 am
GM: New Jersey Nets GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Killer Mentality

Post by dd10snoop28 »

I agree with this. Killer mentality wasn't there in the 2nd half in all aspects of the game:

1) Missed opporunitites on play-calling (3rd & 8) and 4&1 to put the game away.

2) Herbert had multiple chances to take over the game but went conservative in his decisions. ESPECIALLY on that 3&12 in the 4th quarter when he threw a checkdown to the receiver. No pressure. He should have taken a shot.

3) Defense (they played great!) couldn't come up with a stop on the final drive and the drive where Whitlow ran all over us.

I think we played a good game overall, but I agree with you Wally. Where I disagree is where that "killer mentalitiy" is lacking. I think it showed up on defense, Herbert, and a little bit on play-calling.... not just playcalling.
Image
User avatar
nogerO
Senior
Posts: 4517
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:48 pm
Location: Wyoming

Re: Killer Mentality

Post by nogerO »

Phalanx wrote:Just came across a pretty damning article on Cristobal's decision on yahoo.

https://www.yahoo.com/sports/on-the-clo ... 17917.html

"Simply put, the Stanford game last year and the Auburn game this year have left Cristobal branded as one of the worst game managers in all of the Power Five. This is simple and true. And he needs to realize that quickly, as his own inability to navigate late-game situations has already cost his program dearly."

Ouch
Ouch indeed. Great recruiter. Great line coach. Not sure but I think he’s a great motivator. Coaching under pressure? Making in game adjustments? Game management? So far, He grades out to a B. Hopefully he learns from stepping on his dick.
"To give anything less than your best, is to sacrifice the gift." - Steve Prefontaine
alxtw
Freshman
Posts: 1279
Joined: Sun Dec 19, 2010 10:46 pm

Re: Killer Mentality

Post by alxtw »

CMC is great at those things and should just leave all of the play calling to the OC. I feel like its kind of blurred who's calling the plays between him and arroyo. This way if the play calling is still bad, you can come to the conclusion that its all arroyo and then get a new playcalling OC.
Post Reply