Poll: Predictions on Herbert's NFL Career

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Post Reply

What's your best guess about Herbert's NFL career?

All-Pro/Elite Starter (e.g. Brady, Wilson, Mahomes)
1
2%
Strong Starter/Franchise Quarterback (e.g. Watson, Luck, Stafford)
18
33%
Average/Iffy Starter (e.g. Carr, Goff, Foles)
25
45%
Fringe Starter/Backup (e.g. Mariota :(, Trubisky, Fitzpatrick)
7
13%
Total Bust (Rosen, JP Losman, Jake Locker)
4
7%
 
Total votes: 55
User avatar
Tray Dub
Senior
Posts: 4994
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:31 pm

Poll: Predictions on Herbert's NFL Career

Post by Tray Dub »

Just curious what you guys see when you look into your crystal ball.

I know there's a lot of unknowns, like which team drafts him and whether he stays healthy. This is just your best guess.

And try not to yell at me if you disagree about the guys I give as examples in the polls. This topic is supposed to be about Herbert, not what tier Nick Foles belongs on.
Merganzer
Senior
Posts: 3656
Joined: Sat Apr 15, 2017 10:42 am

Re: Poll: Predictions on Herbert's NFL Career

Post by Merganzer »

Turns out I went with the other voter; average, iffy starter,seemed like a positive even if the first place doesn't turn out great. Or, like Goff, a new coach makes him a Super Bowl QB. I'm also voting that Herbert's measurables translate well in the NFL. I think he will be able to take charge in a huddle, won't be intimidated.
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: Poll: Predictions on Herbert's NFL Career

Post by SuperDuck »

There are so many things to consider. I voted iffy, too, but it really depends on the team he goes to, the coaching staff, particularly the QB coach, the system they run, how good the offense is, etc.

Will he have to start right away or will he be able to sit and learn for 1-2 years? If he's a first round pick it's almost certain that he'll be playing soon, if not starting right away.

Will he have good protection? If he's constantly getting sacked and pressured it's going to rattle him over time. (See: David Carr)

Will he have decent receivers to throw to? Will he have a decent running game that will give the team balance and not put all the pressure on him?

You could even go into how good is their defense, because if they suck then the offense will have to score more than average.

A lot of intangibles to consider.
John 3:36
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Poll: Predictions on Herbert's NFL Career

Post by GoDucksTroll »

As others have said, it will heavily depend on fit and franchise. You go to a dysfunctional team like Joey did with the Lions and people will label you a bust even though Joey was pretty decent in Miami and Atlanta.

I think Herbert is a hard worker and has the requisite skills (can make NFL throws, is lethal of Play Action) that he at least won’t be a mega bust. But he has potential to be in that great category. That’s the thing with drafting QBs - you never know.

I’m far from sold on Joe Burrow. If he played for us last year he would have been lucky to get Herbert numbers. Tua is also hard to gauge, spectacular but he’s also had first round picks catching and blocking for him his whole year. Weird dad, throws lefty when he’s a right hander, injury prone.
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: Poll: Predictions on Herbert's NFL Career

Post by SuperDuck »

GoDucksTroll wrote:As others have said, it will heavily depend on fit and franchise. You go to a dysfunctional team like Joey did with the Lions and people will label you a bust even though Joey was pretty decent in Miami and Atlanta.

I think Herbert is a hard worker and has the requisite skills (can make NFL throws, is lethal of Play Action) that he at least won’t be a mega bust. But he has potential to be in that great category. That’s the thing with drafting QBs - you never know.
Steve Mariucci ruined Harrington's confidence in Detroit. He didn't want him throwing deep. According to an article I read a few years ago, Joey went to Mariucci and asked him to let him throw downfield more, but the coach refused. I don't remember exactly why, but it affected him later in his career, too. In Miami someone gave him the nickname "check down, Joey" because he was hesitant to throw deep.

I just hope something like this doesn't happen with Herbert.
GoDucksTroll wrote:I’m far from sold on Joe Burrow. If he played for us last year he would have been lucky to get Herbert numbers. Tua is also hard to gauge, spectacular but he’s also had first round picks catching and blocking for him his whole year. Weird dad, throws lefty when he’s a right hander, injury prone.
I'm not sold on Burrow or Tua either. Yes, Tua was successful every year at Alabama, but as you pointed out, he was surrounded by a ton of talent.

Burrow had the greatest season in college football history for a QB, but the year before he was mediocre, at best. Also, besides being surrounded by talent at LSU, like Tua at Alabama, he played in a system that maximized his talents. Unless the team drafting him is setup to run that same system, I see him as being a risk at #1. If I were the Bengals I'd start seriously shopping that #1 pick to gauge what they might get for trading down. The could haul in a load of picks, players, etc, build for the future, and STILL get Herbert at #5.
John 3:36
User avatar
FlDuckFan
All Pac-12
Posts: 5068
Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:45 am
GM: Orlando Magic GM
Location: Florida

Re: Poll: Predictions on Herbert's NFL Career

Post by FlDuckFan »

I think he can be anywhere from an Andy Dalton to a Phillip Rivers type of career.
User avatar
Tray Dub
Senior
Posts: 4994
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:31 pm

Re: Poll: Predictions on Herbert's NFL Career

Post by Tray Dub »

If we had run this poll when Mariota was coming out I bet most would've said strong starter, and a handful would've said all-pro. Very different feel among the fanbase this time around.
User avatar
Alan
Senior
Posts: 4359
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Poll: Predictions on Herbert's NFL Career

Post by Alan »

Tray Dub wrote:If we had run this poll when Mariota was coming out I bet most would've said strong starter, and a handful would've said all-pro. Very different feel among the fanbase this time around.
I think by now a lot of us know after Joey and Marcus, the higher you are drafted the worse your chances are.
User avatar
DuckzRule
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 976
Joined: Sun Mar 22, 2020 3:30 pm

Re: Poll: Predictions on Herbert's NFL Career

Post by DuckzRule »

Yeh nowadays IDK if I even want on the Dolphins or Chargers (both teams finished with equal records last season) or have him fall so he gets drafted by the Tampa Bay Buccaneers or the New England Patriots.
User avatar
DuckzRule
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 976
Joined: Sun Mar 22, 2020 3:30 pm

Re: Poll: Predictions on Herbert's NFL Career

Post by DuckzRule »

Now that Herbert has been drafted by the L.A Chargers, I wonder, could he be as good as Dan Fouts who also played in Oregon (college career) and the Chargers (NFL career)?
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: Poll: Predictions on Herbert's NFL Career

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

The problem of being drafted high as a quarterback usually means are going to a team that has little or no offensive line. Joey was a great quarterback. If he would have protection from the line he would have a lot better numbers. They had pretty much zero running game for the same reason. It all starts and ends at the offensive line. I don't know how good the offensive line is at the chargers. If their offensive line can not protect the quarterback then it will not matter who they have back there. Steve Young once said about Detroit when Harrington was there that no quarterback would be any good there until they had a decent offensive line and he would never want to play behind that line. If look at any super bowl champions, they all have couple of guys up front that are all pro at their position. I think that speaks for itself.
GrantDuck
Senior
Posts: 2629
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm

Re: Poll: Predictions on Herbert's NFL Career

Post by GrantDuck »

Average/iffy starter. I will say LA Chargers currently is a pretty good franchise situation. They have good weapons, a really smart head coach, and a decent young defense. They also have low expectations because they are the "B" team in Los Angeles. The Chiefs will be tough for awhile with Mahomes, but LV/Denver don't have anything going for them right now. He also has Pep Hamilton as his guru, which also sets him up for success.

The limitations on him were more what we saw in college in terms of lack of consistency. You can't be inconsistent in the NFL or you are Nick Foles.


I DO think Marcus is going to get a real shot in LV. Gruden/Mayock love the guy going back to college and I actually think Marcus would be a good fit in a West Coast style offense with some modifications for him to run a bit.(Think Steve Young).
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8818
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Poll: Predictions on Herbert's NFL Career

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

I thought Herbert would have a good career as long as he had some decent coaching... then I watched a few film breakdowns on him and I'm not so sure now. Obviously I hope he has the greatest career ever but I don't think his struggles at Oregon were as simple as being in a bad offense. If anything, I think his extreme inconsistency forced Arroyo and staff to limit the offense.
Image
User avatar
Tray Dub
Senior
Posts: 4994
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:31 pm

Re: Poll: Predictions on Herbert's NFL Career

Post by Tray Dub »

dthomas=ddixon wrote:I thought Herbert would have a good career as long as he had some decent coaching... then I watched a few film breakdowns on him and I'm not so sure now. Obviously I hope he has the greatest career ever but I don't think his struggles at Oregon were as simple as being in a bad offense. If anything, I think his extreme inconsistency forced Arroyo and staff to limit the offense.
I agree 100%, I think most of us fans thought this during this past season, and I think there's been a lot of revisionist history in the lead-up to the draft as the fanbase circles the wagon around one of its own.

He could fix his problems, he does have potential. But many of his problems were his, not Arroyo's or the wide receivers or whatever. He'll need to make major strides to be a strong starter in the league.
User avatar
JIDuck97
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 998
Joined: Fri Sep 16, 2011 8:42 am

Re: Poll: Predictions on Herbert's NFL Career

Post by JIDuck97 »

GrantDuck wrote:Average/iffy starter. I will say LA Chargers currently is a pretty good franchise situation. They have good weapons, a really smart head coach, and a decent young defense. They also have low expectations because they are the "B" team in Los Angeles. The Chiefs will be tough for awhile with Mahomes, but LV/Denver don't have anything going for them right now. He also has Pep Hamilton as his guru, which also sets him up for success.

The limitations on him were more what we saw in college in terms of lack of consistency. You can't be inconsistent in the NFL or you are Nick Foles.


I DO think Marcus is going to get a real shot in LV. Gruden/Mayock love the guy going back to college and I actually think Marcus would be a good fit in a West Coast style offense with some modifications for him to run a bit.(Think Steve Young).
In all fairness though, doesn't Nick Foles have two super bowl rings?
Post Reply