Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

droop10
Freshman
Posts: 1439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:07 am

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Post by droop10 »

karlhungis wrote:
alxtw wrote:
OregonFan4Life wrote:
GoDucksIn09 wrote:The problem with Verdell has and always will be his health. He can not stay healthy. If you factor that with his lack of vision, I do not see any nfl teams taking him. It has been a long time since we have had a rb regarded as low as him that was a starter. I am not sure how far back would have to go to find our starting rb be as bad as Verdell. Nobody at this point strikes fear into an opposing defense as a running back have to stop. On offense it is probably our weakest unit. I know some might point at our offensive line, and while that might be true initially it is because of their lack of experience as a unit. I think when give them the experience they will become a strong unit by next year.
Sadly I agree, Verdell seems to have no place in the NFL. Only reason for his success and yards in big games were cause of Oline dominance. Against WSU and Utah they gave him huge holes to run through and even then sometimes he lacked the speed to keep the defense from catching up to him. Since Helf, the biggest step down in coaching positions has arguable been RB (except for OC with Arroyo). Hopefully the coaches can turn that around. Having a RB who can get yards even when the Oline breaks down can be very important to keep the offense in rhythm. With Verdell, it all falls on the Oline.
I think our RBs aren't awful, they're just very average now. We were spoiled with good and well coached RBs back when Campbell was heading that unit. Campbell was one of the top RB coaches in the country and that unit hasn't been the same since he retired.
I think it is worse than you make it out. I realize my perspective is skewed but I don't see any other programs that are at the level the Ducks play at where the RB's continually run straight into the pile, over and over again. The lack of vision and patience is so prevalent that it almost has to be by design.
I think you are all being very dramatic about the RB play, and I don't think it's warranted. I see complaints about Verdell's big play ability, yet he had the most 70+ yard runs in the country last year. Guess which team led the conference in yards per carry last year? Incredibly, despite apparently having average at best running backs and a QB that rarely scrambled, Oregon managed to have the most yards per carry and ranked 2nd in the conference in total rushing yards. Want to look at it individually? Dye and Verdell were ranked 2nd and 3rd in the conference in yards per carry (looking only at players that averaged at least 6 carries a game). You can't even make the argument that these came against non-conference patsies. For instance, Verdell averaged 6.8 yds/carry in the Pac-12 last season and saved his best performance for the Pac-12 championship game (where he happened to rush for more yards than anyone had against Utah since 2014).

It might not look at sexy as when LaMichael ran it, but it's still pretty damn effective. In fact, he averaged more yds/carry as a Soph than LaMichael did. The argument that all credit can be given to the offensive line is silly, as that's the same argument for every single RB. That's why the position is the most interchangeable one in the NFL. If you have a terrible OLine, it doesn't matter who your RB is, they won't do much damage. It's not like those OLines in the Kelly/Helfrich years lacked talent. If you're counting on a RB to consistently have to get yards when the OLine breaks down, you've got much bigger problems.

If there's an argument to be made in relation to Verdell, it's not talent but health. It seems he has to come out of nearly every game for multiple series at a time due to getting nicked up. He had multiple games where he never got going, because either he was dealing with a nagging injury from the start, or got knocked out after a few carries. Hopefully he can resolve that this year, though even with the injuries, he managed to rank 2nd in the Pac-12 in rushing yards (4th in yds/game, even with sharing more of the load than the other RBs ahead of him and missing parts of multiple games). I also think there could be an argument for scheme, as I think the Pistol offense is just garbage anyway. Hopefully, that will be phased out a bit more with Moorhead around. I just don't buy the talent argument. Do I think Verdell is as talented as LaMichael? No, but few college RBs are, and I don't think he's as bad as everyone in this thread is making him out to be. If anything, I think he's a bit underappreciated and definitely improved last year. He's only a junior, so I expect continued improvement from him. Anyway, I'll hop off my soapbox now.
User avatar
lukeyrid13
All-American
Posts: 10475
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
GM: Portland TrailBlazers

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Post by lukeyrid13 »

Verdell has struggled with keeping his knees high and not getting tripped up easily. He got a lot better with that as the season went on, but historically he goes down on too many arm tackles.
karlhungis
All Pac-12
Posts: 7990
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:08 am

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Post by karlhungis »

droop10 wrote:
karlhungis wrote:
alxtw wrote:
OregonFan4Life wrote:
GoDucksIn09 wrote:The problem with Verdell has and always will be his health. He can not stay healthy. If you factor that with his lack of vision, I do not see any nfl teams taking him. It has been a long time since we have had a rb regarded as low as him that was a starter. I am not sure how far back would have to go to find our starting rb be as bad as Verdell. Nobody at this point strikes fear into an opposing defense as a running back have to stop. On offense it is probably our weakest unit. I know some might point at our offensive line, and while that might be true initially it is because of their lack of experience as a unit. I think when give them the experience they will become a strong unit by next year.
Sadly I agree, Verdell seems to have no place in the NFL. Only reason for his success and yards in big games were cause of Oline dominance. Against WSU and Utah they gave him huge holes to run through and even then sometimes he lacked the speed to keep the defense from catching up to him. Since Helf, the biggest step down in coaching positions has arguable been RB (except for OC with Arroyo). Hopefully the coaches can turn that around. Having a RB who can get yards even when the Oline breaks down can be very important to keep the offense in rhythm. With Verdell, it all falls on the Oline.
I think our RBs aren't awful, they're just very average now. We were spoiled with good and well coached RBs back when Campbell was heading that unit. Campbell was one of the top RB coaches in the country and that unit hasn't been the same since he retired.
I think it is worse than you make it out. I realize my perspective is skewed but I don't see any other programs that are at the level the Ducks play at where the RB's continually run straight into the pile, over and over again. The lack of vision and patience is so prevalent that it almost has to be by design.
I think you are all being very dramatic about the RB play, and I don't think it's warranted. I see complaints about Verdell's big play ability, yet he had the most 70+ yard runs in the country last year. Guess which team led the conference in yards per carry last year? Incredibly, despite apparently having average at best running backs and a QB that rarely scrambled, Oregon managed to have the most yards per carry and ranked 2nd in the conference in total rushing yards. Want to look at it individually? Dye and Verdell were ranked 2nd and 3rd in the conference in yards per carry (looking only at players that averaged at least 6 carries a game). You can't even make the argument that these came against non-conference patsies. For instance, Verdell averaged 6.8 yds/carry in the Pac-12 last season and saved his best performance for the Pac-12 championship game (where he happened to rush for more yards than anyone had against Utah since 2014).

It might not look at sexy as when LaMichael ran it, but it's still pretty damn effective. In fact, he averaged more yds/carry as a Soph than LaMichael did. The argument that all credit can be given to the offensive line is silly, as that's the same argument for every single RB. That's why the position is the most interchangeable one in the NFL. If you have a terrible OLine, it doesn't matter who your RB is, they won't do much damage. It's not like those OLines in the Kelly/Helfrich years lacked talent. If you're counting on a RB to consistently have to get yards when the OLine breaks down, you've got much bigger problems.

If there's an argument to be made in relation to Verdell, it's not talent but health. It seems he has to come out of nearly every game for multiple series at a time due to getting nicked up. He had multiple games where he never got going, because either he was dealing with a nagging injury from the start, or got knocked out after a few carries. Hopefully he can resolve that this year, though even with the injuries, he managed to rank 2nd in the Pac-12 in rushing yards (4th in yds/game, even with sharing more of the load than the other RBs ahead of him and missing parts of multiple games). I also think there could be an argument for scheme, as I think the Pistol offense is just garbage anyway. Hopefully, that will be phased out a bit more with Moorhead around. I just don't buy the talent argument. Do I think Verdell is as talented as LaMichael? No, but few college RBs are, and I don't think he's as bad as everyone in this thread is making him out to be. If anything, I think he's a bit underappreciated and definitely improved last year. He's only a junior, so I expect continued improvement from him. Anyway, I'll hop off my soapbox now.
Excellent post and the data certainly doesn't back up what I see when I watch our running game. That said, my criticism was not so much of a shot at Verdell as it is a shot at Maestro. Watching our system, it looked like our coaches encouraged Dye and Verdell to just run as hard as they can towards where the play was supposed to go. This caused them to crash into the line instead of bouncing outside. They look like RB's that are not coached to run with patience or vision.
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
GrandpaDuck
Senior
Posts: 3313
Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Post by GrandpaDuck »

Phalanx wrote:Am I missing something? It seems like C.J. is being wildly underrated in this thread. The dude averaged 6.2 yards per carry last year. That's pretty much identical to Kenjon Barner's sophomore and junior seasons, and only slightly less than Jeremiah Johnson's sophomore and junior seasons. It also equals Jonathan Stewart's best season (junior). LaMichael only had one season better, his junior year, and Royce Freeman only his sophomore season.

Should I be looking at a different stat or something? I know Verdell doesn't get as many carries as some of those guys, but for the times he has the ball, it seems like he is doing pretty well.
I was going to look that stat up too. I thought his YPC was pretty good last year. I have mentioned before how he improved in the second half of each of his first 2 seasons and this year he seemed to be much better out of the gate.

In looking back over the last 3 years, I think he was too amped up at the beginning of the season and running eyes closed Kamikaze into the line. I think we all thought it was what Maestro wanted because why else was he out there. The answer maybe that in practice, he was opening his eyes and making cuts to daylight. In each of those two seasons he started doing that as the season went along. I also heard in an interview a couple of years ago Cristobal saying CJ just needed to calm down which would indicate that the coaches didn't want him blindly slamming into the line either.
User avatar
UofDuck
Senior
Posts: 3970
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:51 pm

Re: Now vs Then (2020 vs 2008)

Post by UofDuck »

I’ve said it before, but I think it’s Verdell’s style that a few don’t view as impressive, not his production. He runs a lot like Frank Gore. He would hit the hole (or not) super fast. If there was a crease, he’d be through it before it closed AND be at full speed when he got thru. Which is why I’m confused by the claims that he’s not explosive, or claims that he doesn’t have long runs, because he does. He also runs into the line often because he is not waiting for holes to open up. You can’t really do both.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Post Reply