Jaynes Article on the Under-Utilization of Herbert
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
-
RanDux
- Senior
- Posts: 2840
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:19 pm
- Location: Happy Valley, OR
Jaynes Article on the Under-Utilization of Herbert
https://news.yahoo.com/justin-herbert-o ... 04893.html
In his article Jaynes argues that Herbert's success in the Chargers passing game is showing that he was under-utilized in the same at Oregon. He puts the blame on Cristobal's emphasis on the running game rather than on Arroyo's play-calling.
In his article Jaynes argues that Herbert's success in the Chargers passing game is showing that he was under-utilized in the same at Oregon. He puts the blame on Cristobal's emphasis on the running game rather than on Arroyo's play-calling.
- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6461
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: Jaynes Article on the Under-Utilization of Herbert
Interesting take. We'll see what happens this year.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: Jaynes Article on the Under-Utilization of Herbert
It's a bad, lazy take honestly. He ignores so many of the problems at WR by not talking about them and just saying the Coaches should have recruited better. The sheer absurdity of drops that Herbert suffered from in addition to just straight up bad WR play made a great deal of difference in both the efficacy of the Oregon Offense and how Justin was perceived. Yes, he missed throws at Oregon, but he had so many more plays that were left on the field that he now gets the benefit of the doubt of by throwing to Keenan Allen, Mike Williams, Hunter Henry and Austin Ekeler.
What makes it a truly bad take though is that with no basic off-season and training camp to prepare him that players have had the benefit of in the past, he has been a Stud QB period from the get-go. (Oregon's offensive coaches obv get ZERO credit for this)
So in order to believe Dwight I must believe that the Chargers coaches are entirely responsible for this sudden progression while at the same time showing offensive ineptitude at the same time. I just don't buy it.
I'll just go with the notion that Herbert was a Stud for us, we knew it from the first start against the poodles and despite the Taggart set-back, he and Cristobal have set the foundation for a very promising future.
What makes it a truly bad take though is that with no basic off-season and training camp to prepare him that players have had the benefit of in the past, he has been a Stud QB period from the get-go. (Oregon's offensive coaches obv get ZERO credit for this)
So in order to believe Dwight I must believe that the Chargers coaches are entirely responsible for this sudden progression while at the same time showing offensive ineptitude at the same time. I just don't buy it.
I'll just go with the notion that Herbert was a Stud for us, we knew it from the first start against the poodles and despite the Taggart set-back, he and Cristobal have set the foundation for a very promising future.

-
lmduck
Re: Jaynes Article on the Under-Utilization of Herbert
The fact that it's written by Jaynes says it all.
I normally don't have much reaction to the writer, I try to consider the point they are making. A good example is Canzano. I know he ruffles a lot of feathers but I honestly try to consider what he is saying. With Jaynes it's the opposite. The guy has simply been awful his entire career whether it was the Blazers, the Ducks, the Beavers etc. He just tries to hard to be relevant.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I normally don't have much reaction to the writer, I try to consider the point they are making. A good example is Canzano. I know he ruffles a lot of feathers but I honestly try to consider what he is saying. With Jaynes it's the opposite. The guy has simply been awful his entire career whether it was the Blazers, the Ducks, the Beavers etc. He just tries to hard to be relevant.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
- greenyellow
- Moderator

- Posts: 39368
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
- Location: Eugene, OR
Re: Jaynes Article on the Under-Utilization of Herbert
Jaynes is the worst with analysis. Sometimes that is best left to people who actually understand the game better.lmduck wrote:The fact that it's written by Jaynes says it all.
I normally don't have much reaction to the writer, I try to consider the point they are making. A good example is Canzano. I know he ruffles a lot of feathers but I honestly try to consider what he is saying. With Jaynes it's the opposite. The guy has simply been awful his entire career whether it was the Blazers, the Ducks, the Beavers etc. He just tries to hard to be relevant.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

- Boom
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5816
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:32 pm
- GM: Houston Rockets
Re: Jaynes Article on the Under-Utilization of Herbert
The skill position players during Herberts tenure was the least talented group I’ve seen at UofO. Did any of them make a NFL roster? Pittman and Breeland were the exception, but were often injured.
-
RanDux
- Senior
- Posts: 2840
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:19 pm
- Location: Happy Valley, OR
Re: Jaynes Article on the Under-Utilization of Herbert
Yeah, it is hard to trust the passing game when you don't have quality receivers. It will be interesting to see how things will be now that we are getting better receivers and now that we have a new OC.Boom wrote:The skill position players during Herberts tenure was the least talented group I’ve seen at UofO. Did any of them make a NFL roster? Pittman and Breeland were the exception, but were often injured.
- GoDucksTroll
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1742
- Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am
Re: Jaynes Article on the Under-Utilization of Herbert
I, like seemingly everyone, don’t care for Dwight’s takes. He was super nice to me 20+ years ago when I was a kid and emailed him to talk about the Blazers. But his takes are usually way off.
Jaynes gets some stuff wrong here. That Willie had a bevy of star WRs recruited. Yes in that they were 4-stars, but they haven’t been fantastic enough to have made a difference for Herbert. Out of all of those guys that recommitted (Thompson/Harrison/Lenzy/Ezeike/Battle) the best one has been Chase Cota who Taggart basically passed on for those guys.
I do agree with the premise: Herbert’s talents were underutilized. The offensive scheme has been a conservative don’t lose yards type. Arroyo’s play calling was not great. But all the coaching transitions left the skill player positions as bad as I have seen at Oregon. They adapted to win, and win they did. Who else has 21 wins and a big bowl victory over the last two years?
It sucks we didn’t get to see everything Herbert had to offer, but he had his own mistakes as well. I’m hoping we get a more dynamic offense with JoeMo, and I can keep watching play amazing in the NFL.
Jaynes gets some stuff wrong here. That Willie had a bevy of star WRs recruited. Yes in that they were 4-stars, but they haven’t been fantastic enough to have made a difference for Herbert. Out of all of those guys that recommitted (Thompson/Harrison/Lenzy/Ezeike/Battle) the best one has been Chase Cota who Taggart basically passed on for those guys.
I do agree with the premise: Herbert’s talents were underutilized. The offensive scheme has been a conservative don’t lose yards type. Arroyo’s play calling was not great. But all the coaching transitions left the skill player positions as bad as I have seen at Oregon. They adapted to win, and win they did. Who else has 21 wins and a big bowl victory over the last two years?
It sucks we didn’t get to see everything Herbert had to offer, but he had his own mistakes as well. I’m hoping we get a more dynamic offense with JoeMo, and I can keep watching play amazing in the NFL.
-
73duck
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 347
- Joined: Sun Jun 14, 2020 6:20 am
Re: Jaynes Article on the Under-Utilization of Herbert
There was a stretch of games earlier in Herbert's career where the offense was scoring 50 a game, and he got hurt and the team scored about 10 points a game. By the time Herbert was a senior, I think MC had decided not to needlessly expose Herbert to injury. It worked; the team won the PAC and the Rose Bowl, and nearly got into the CFP. In a sense it was the inability to recruit a reliable backup QB, not just WRs, that explains the play calling last year.
He has been taking a heck of a lot of shots with the Chargers, many after releasing the passes that Jaynes approves of. The Chargers are not necessarily being less protective; in fact, they have been fairly conservative. But they run it for a yard or two on first and second down, and then have to convert third and longs in tight games. Herbert has been unbelievably great in these situations, but takes shots on just about every one of those plays.
He has been taking a heck of a lot of shots with the Chargers, many after releasing the passes that Jaynes approves of. The Chargers are not necessarily being less protective; in fact, they have been fairly conservative. But they run it for a yard or two on first and second down, and then have to convert third and longs in tight games. Herbert has been unbelievably great in these situations, but takes shots on just about every one of those plays.
-
RanDux
- Senior
- Posts: 2840
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:19 pm
- Location: Happy Valley, OR
Re: Jaynes Article on the Under-Utilization of Herbert
The loss of Ekeler has really hurt the Chargers, not to mention all the other injuries they have had.73duck wrote:There was a stretch of games earlier in Herbert's career where the offense was scoring 50 a game, and he got hurt and the team scored about 10 points a game. By the time Herbert was a senior, I think MC had decided not to needlessly expose Herbert to injury. It worked; the team won the PAC and the Rose Bowl, and nearly got into the CFP. In a sense it was the inability to recruit a reliable backup QB, not just WRs, that explains the play calling last year.
He has been taking a heck of a lot of shots with the Chargers, many after releasing the passes that Jaynes approves of. The Chargers are not necessarily being less protective; in fact, they have been fairly conservative. But they run it for a yard or two on first and second down, and then have to convert third and longs in tight games. Herbert has been unbelievably great in these situations, but takes shots on just about every one of those plays.