Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Post Reply
ducks5ever
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 936
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2017 12:15 pm

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by ducks5ever »

Just to be clear, did the 4th quarter happen more or less as usual this year or was it largely on the players themselves to stay in shape, ie. you could be anywhere and there's no accountability. I was under the impression the 4th quarter program still happened - as in facilities were open and Feld was able to physically meet/train people
ducks5ever
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 936
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2017 12:15 pm

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by ducks5ever »

Also what sucks this year is that it's not just older players playing poorly... it's more like the entire rotation of DL players. In a normal world, you'd bench the starters and let the players who actually try get some playing time but it appears these are our best options.... yay

11 scholarship DE/DT outside KT and another 4 guys who can play stud. Anyone.... anyone???
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by duck023 »

I want Nick Aliotti back this guy Avalos had one great season but it seems like he is going to rest on that.
lmduck

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by lmduck »

OregonFan4Life wrote:That’s quite the contact you got there giving you some golden inside info, they’re disappointed they loss? Offseason conditioning is important to them? Wow! Big time info!
I guess on.par with you seeing Chip’s signature on that contract to return six years ago. Maybe someday you will learn to be less rude.

There’s an old axiom that says it's better to remain silent and let people think you are a fool than to.open your mouth and remove all doubt. You effectively removed all doubt.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
lmduck

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by lmduck »

ducks5ever wrote:Just to be clear, did the 4th quarter happen more or less as usual this year or was it largely on the players themselves to stay in shape, ie. you could be anywhere and there's no accountability. I was under the impression the 4th quarter program still happened - as in facilities were open and Feld was able to physically meet/train people
The facility were closed for quite sometime. They were not able to.do the full regimen.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by duck023 »

ducks5ever wrote:Also what sucks this year is that it's not just older players playing poorly... it's more like the entire rotation of DL players. In a normal world, you'd bench the starters and let the players who actually try get some playing time but it appears these are our best options.... yay

11 scholarship DE/DT outside KT and another 4 guys who can play stud. Anyone.... anyone???
That is what I'm wondering. I just don't think Oregon will ever have what it takes to compete with Big Ten and SEC teams in power no matter how good the recruiting is. I almost think Oregon needs to go back to recruiting like they used to with Chip Kelly. Instead of getting the fattest and laziest 5 star athlete get the best 3 star athlete that wants to win. Oregon needs to go back to being a gimmick team maybe see if UCLA wants to trade coaches. The power game just isn't working.
Last edited by duck023 on Sun Nov 29, 2020 2:47 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by GoDucksTroll »

duck023 wrote:The defense was disgraceful. All of last year I bit my tongue about how badly they choked their chance at a national title away because I thought the defense looked better then ever and Oregon was changing. Now I realize it was a fluke, Oregon is the same old terrible defense and that was Oregon's best chance to win a title.
The defense was disgraceful.

But how were you biting your tongue at last year’s defense blowing a chance at a title? Finished 9th in scoring defense and were the main reason Oregon even won 12 games. It sure as hell wasn’t the offense, which sputtered on a regular basis.

Giving up 27 to Auburn and 31 to Arizona State isn’t exactly blowing it, and the offense was culpable for giving up some of those points. Against Auburn they had a dropped TD pass in the end zone by Addison which led to a missed field goal by Lewis. They also fumbled inside the 10, set up by an 80 yard Holland return, which Auburn took back a million yards. I blame that game on Arroyo as much as anyone, that was some uninspired play calling. Not having Juwan, Pittman, and even Schooler also hurt. Against Arizona State the offense went scoreless on 7 straight possessions, and Herbert’s two interception in his own territory led to a TD and a field goal for them. Back-to-back interceptions in your own territory are just not how you win games.
lmduck

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by lmduck »

Duck07 wrote:
OregonFan4Life wrote:That’s quite the contact you got there giving you some golden inside info, they’re disappointed they loss? Offseason conditioning is important to them? Wow! Big time info!
Don't be that guy
Only thing he knows.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by duck023 »

GoDucksTroll wrote:
duck023 wrote:The defense was disgraceful. All of last year I bit my tongue about how badly they choked their chance at a national title away because I thought the defense looked better then ever and Oregon was changing. Now I realize it was a fluke, Oregon is the same old terrible defense and that was Oregon's best chance to win a title.
The defense was disgraceful.

But how were you biting your tongue at last year’s defense blowing a chance at a title? Finished 9th in scoring defense and were the main reason Oregon even won 12 games. It sure as hell wasn’t the offense, which sputtered on a regular basis.

Giving up 27 to Auburn and 31 to Arizona State isn’t exactly blowing it, and the offense was culpable for giving up some of those points. Against Auburn they had a dropped TD pass in the end zone by Addison which led to a missed field goal by Lewis. They also fumbled inside the 10, set up by an 80 yard Holland return, which Auburn took back a million yards. I blame that game on Arroyo as much as anyone, that was some uninspired play calling. Not having Juwan, Pittman, and even Schooler also hurt. Against Arizona State the offense went scoreless on 7 straight possessions, and Herbert’s two interception in his own territory led to a TD and a field goal for them. Back-to-back interceptions in your own territory are just not how you win games.
You misunderstood, I meant I was nice about the offense being choke artists because I thought Oregon was transforming into LSU. I had a feeling that was the best defense Oregon will ever have and Herbert blew it. Yes I'm glad the Eugene QB got his Rose Bowl but the defense was ranked above LSU so the main difference was Herbert and the offense underperformed compared to LSU's offense. If Oregon was going to become a defensive team I could understand the offense underperforming like that did. However now that I see the Offense is back to scoring 40 points a game and the defense sucks again I can admit the offense choked last year.
Last edited by duck023 on Sun Nov 29, 2020 3:09 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by GoDucksTroll »

duck023 wrote:
ducks5ever wrote:Also what sucks this year is that it's not just older players playing poorly... it's more like the entire rotation of DL players. In a normal world, you'd bench the starters and let the players who actually try get some playing time but it appears these are our best options.... yay

11 scholarship DE/DT outside KT and another 4 guys who can play stud. Anyone.... anyone???
That is what I'm wondering. I just don't think Oregon will ever have what it takes to compete with Big Ten and SEC teams in power no matter how good the recruiting is. I almost think Oregon needs to go back to recruiting like they used to with Chip Kelly. Instead of getting the fattest and laziest 5 star athlete get the best 3 star athlete that wants to win. Oregon needs to go back to being a gimmick team maybe see if UCLA wants to trade coaches. The power game just isn't working.
It’s not the highly rated recruits who are blowing it. It’s mostly the three stars. Happle, both Faolius, Bennett Williams, Jordon, Forsyth, interior OL, Verdell the last two games. Out of the top recruits Funa has become a liability but most of the teams best players were 4-star recruits. Redd, Devon Williams, Lenoir, Kayvon, Mykael Wright, Noah Sewell.

We probably wouldn’t even be having this conversation and instead complaining about playoff rankings if 4-stars like Penei, Graham, Holland, and Breeze were playing.
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by duck023 »

GoDucksTroll wrote:
duck023 wrote:
ducks5ever wrote:Also what sucks this year is that it's not just older players playing poorly... it's more like the entire rotation of DL players. In a normal world, you'd bench the starters and let the players who actually try get some playing time but it appears these are our best options.... yay

11 scholarship DE/DT outside KT and another 4 guys who can play stud. Anyone.... anyone???
That is what I'm wondering. I just don't think Oregon will ever have what it takes to compete with Big Ten and SEC teams in power no matter how good the recruiting is. I almost think Oregon needs to go back to recruiting like they used to with Chip Kelly. Instead of getting the fattest and laziest 5 star athlete get the best 3 star athlete that wants to win. Oregon needs to go back to being a gimmick team maybe see if UCLA wants to trade coaches. The power game just isn't working.
It’s not the highly rated recruits who are blowing it. It’s mostly the three stars. Happle, both Faolius, Bennett Williams, Jordon, Forsyth, interior OL, Verdell the last two games. Out of the top recruits Funa has become a liability but most of the teams best players were 4-star recruits. Redd, Devon Williams, Lenoir, Kayvon, Mykael Wright, Noah Sewell.

We probably wouldn’t even be having this conversation and instead complaining about playoff rankings if 4-stars like Penei, Graham, Holland, and Breeze were playing.
Why are so many 3 stars playing when Oregon's recruiting has been so good. I remember Chip Kelly having back up 4 stars even when Oregon was ranked 20th in recruiting. How does Oregon recruit a bunch of 4 stars and play 3 stars? That might be another coaching issue. Also don't get me started on the guy's that opted out. Being a 4 star recruit but being afraid to play football sort of makes my point. I don't think Chip recruits guys who are afraid to play football. Chip recruits guy's that stop school shootings.
droop10
Freshman
Posts: 1439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:07 am

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by droop10 »

duck023 wrote:
GoDucksTroll wrote:
duck023 wrote:
ducks5ever wrote:Also what sucks this year is that it's not just older players playing poorly... it's more like the entire rotation of DL players. In a normal world, you'd bench the starters and let the players who actually try get some playing time but it appears these are our best options.... yay

11 scholarship DE/DT outside KT and another 4 guys who can play stud. Anyone.... anyone???
That is what I'm wondering. I just don't think Oregon will ever have what it takes to compete with Big Ten and SEC teams in power no matter how good the recruiting is. I almost think Oregon needs to go back to recruiting like they used to with Chip Kelly. Instead of getting the fattest and laziest 5 star athlete get the best 3 star athlete that wants to win. Oregon needs to go back to being a gimmick team maybe see if UCLA wants to trade coaches. The power game just isn't working.
It’s not the highly rated recruits who are blowing it. It’s mostly the three stars. Happle, both Faolius, Bennett Williams, Jordon, Forsyth, interior OL, Verdell the last two games. Out of the top recruits Funa has become a liability but most of the teams best players were 4-star recruits. Redd, Devon Williams, Lenoir, Kayvon, Mykael Wright, Noah Sewell.

We probably wouldn’t even be having this conversation and instead complaining about playoff rankings if 4-stars like Penei, Graham, Holland, and Breeze were playing.
Why are so many 3 stars playing when Oregon's recruiting has been so good. I remember Chip Kelly having back up 4 stars even when Oregon was ranked 20th in recruiting. How does Oregon recruit a bunch of 4 stars and play 3 stars? That might be another coaching issue. Also don't get me started on the guy's that opted out. Being a 4 star recruit but being afraid to play football sort of makes my point. I don't think Chip recruits guys who are afraid to play football. Chip recruits guy's that stop school shootings.
Goodness, what a take. 3 stars are starting, because despite what everyone here seems to think, even 4/5 star players don’t show up on campus as finished products. The upper classmen are the guys from the Taggart class and the cobbled together class the year Taggart left. The stars are generally based on the potential of a player, but people here seem to think 5 stars should be superstars the second they hit campus. I constantly people suggesting 4 star guys should consider transferring because they didn’t see much PT by their sophomore year. People are so quick to give up on guys rather than give them some time to actually develop.
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by duck023 »

droop10 wrote:
duck023 wrote:
GoDucksTroll wrote:
duck023 wrote:
ducks5ever wrote:Also what sucks this year is that it's not just older players playing poorly... it's more like the entire rotation of DL players. In a normal world, you'd bench the starters and let the players who actually try get some playing time but it appears these are our best options.... yay

11 scholarship DE/DT outside KT and another 4 guys who can play stud. Anyone.... anyone???
That is what I'm wondering. I just don't think Oregon will ever have what it takes to compete with Big Ten and SEC teams in power no matter how good the recruiting is. I almost think Oregon needs to go back to recruiting like they used to with Chip Kelly. Instead of getting the fattest and laziest 5 star athlete get the best 3 star athlete that wants to win. Oregon needs to go back to being a gimmick team maybe see if UCLA wants to trade coaches. The power game just isn't working.
It’s not the highly rated recruits who are blowing it. It’s mostly the three stars. Happle, both Faolius, Bennett Williams, Jordon, Forsyth, interior OL, Verdell the last two games. Out of the top recruits Funa has become a liability but most of the teams best players were 4-star recruits. Redd, Devon Williams, Lenoir, Kayvon, Mykael Wright, Noah Sewell.

We probably wouldn’t even be having this conversation and instead complaining about playoff rankings if 4-stars like Penei, Graham, Holland, and Breeze were playing.
Why are so many 3 stars playing when Oregon's recruiting has been so good. I remember Chip Kelly having back up 4 stars even when Oregon was ranked 20th in recruiting. How does Oregon recruit a bunch of 4 stars and play 3 stars? That might be another coaching issue. Also don't get me started on the guy's that opted out. Being a 4 star recruit but being afraid to play football sort of makes my point. I don't think Chip recruits guys who are afraid to play football. Chip recruits guy's that stop school shootings.
Goodness, what a take. 3 stars are starting, because despite what everyone here seems to think, even 4/5 star players don’t show up on campus as finished products. The upper classmen are the guys from the Taggart class and the cobbled together class the year Taggart left. The stars are generally based on the potential of a player, but people here seem to think 5 stars should be superstars the second they hit campus. I constantly people suggesting 4 star guys should consider transferring because they didn’t see much PT by their sophomore year. People are so quick to give up on guys rather than give them some time to actually develop.
LSU and Alabama could play only their recruits and beat Oregon State. They seem to have no problem replacing a senior with a freshmen and getting the same results. When will Alabama ever be a young team? I thought Oregon was closing in on their level but maybe Oregon is closer to the USC teams that were really talented but would lose to Chip Kelly.
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by GoDucksTroll »

023 - Chip’s teams never had this many 4-star recruits, not even close. But the bulk of the roster is still 3-stars like it is for almost every school that’s outside the perennial top-10/15 recruiters, which Oregon has just joined the last few years.

Oregon has four 5-stars, 33 4-stars, and 47 3-stars. USC is the nearly the same with 33 4-stars but one more 5-star. There are only ~350 4-stars recruits per year.

One of the 5-stars is injured, and four 4-stars opted out. So instead of 37 blue chips you have 32. Three of them are QBs, and you can only play one at a time, so it’s effectively 30. Webb and Patrick Herbert have been out all year, so it’s 28. Eight of them are WRs, and you can only play so many of those, and some are busts. If you play five WRs per game you have 23 4-stars left.
droop10
Freshman
Posts: 1439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:07 am

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by droop10 »

duck023 wrote:
droop10 wrote:
duck023 wrote:
GoDucksTroll wrote:
duck023 wrote:
ducks5ever wrote:Also what sucks this year is that it's not just older players playing poorly... it's more like the entire rotation of DL players. In a normal world, you'd bench the starters and let the players who actually try get some playing time but it appears these are our best options.... yay

11 scholarship DE/DT outside KT and another 4 guys who can play stud. Anyone.... anyone???
That is what I'm wondering. I just don't think Oregon will ever have what it takes to compete with Big Ten and SEC teams in power no matter how good the recruiting is. I almost think Oregon needs to go back to recruiting like they used to with Chip Kelly. Instead of getting the fattest and laziest 5 star athlete get the best 3 star athlete that wants to win. Oregon needs to go back to being a gimmick team maybe see if UCLA wants to trade coaches. The power game just isn't working.
It’s not the highly rated recruits who are blowing it. It’s mostly the three stars. Happle, both Faolius, Bennett Williams, Jordon, Forsyth, interior OL, Verdell the last two games. Out of the top recruits Funa has become a liability but most of the teams best players were 4-star recruits. Redd, Devon Williams, Lenoir, Kayvon, Mykael Wright, Noah Sewell.

We probably wouldn’t even be having this conversation and instead complaining about playoff rankings if 4-stars like Penei, Graham, Holland, and Breeze were playing.
Why are so many 3 stars playing when Oregon's recruiting has been so good. I remember Chip Kelly having back up 4 stars even when Oregon was ranked 20th in recruiting. How does Oregon recruit a bunch of 4 stars and play 3 stars? That might be another coaching issue. Also don't get me started on the guy's that opted out. Being a 4 star recruit but being afraid to play football sort of makes my point. I don't think Chip recruits guys who are afraid to play football. Chip recruits guy's that stop school shootings.
Goodness, what a take. 3 stars are starting, because despite what everyone here seems to think, even 4/5 star players don’t show up on campus as finished products. The upper classmen are the guys from the Taggart class and the cobbled together class the year Taggart left. The stars are generally based on the potential of a player, but people here seem to think 5 stars should be superstars the second they hit campus. I constantly people suggesting 4 star guys should consider transferring because they didn’t see much PT by their sophomore year. People are so quick to give up on guys rather than give them some time to actually develop.
LSU and Alabama could play only their recruits and beat Oregon State. They seem to have no problem replacing a senior with a freshmen and getting the same results. When will Alabama ever be a young team? I thought Oregon was closing in on their level but maybe Oregon is closer to the USC teams that were really talented but would lose to Chip Kelly.
Show me all of the Bama freshmen replacing seniors. I think you’re just guessing that happens rather than actually having any facts, unless you also happen to be an Alabama football historian. I’m not saying it has never happened, but I am suggesting it’s not as frequent as you believe. They have a top 3 class every year, which allows you the luxury of having 4/5 star guys lined up that don’t start until their junior/senior year. You need 3-4 years of top recruiting classes to build that kind of depth. Right now guys are being thrust into important starting roles that aren’t ready yet, hence the struggles.
Post Reply