Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Post Reply
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by GoDucksTroll »

Tray Dub wrote:Haven't researched the game but based on initial impression I'd move ISM down. Almost every time I noticed him he was doing something frustrating.
I’ve been preaching that ISM is not playing as bad as it looks. As the heart of the defense he winds up holding the bag for others mistakes. He does have four missed tackles, and they really stick out.

ISM is great in coverage, just a terrific coverage linebacker. Playing the run is not his speciality, but he’s really being let down by the DL and the edge LB or nickel at times, having to adjust and make the plays they missed. He also covers a lot of ground having to help the safeties.
GrandpaDuck
Senior
Posts: 3313
Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by GrandpaDuck »

I would like to see what would happen if ISM moved back to MLB, Sewel to Stud and Jackson to WIL to get more sideline to sideline run support. I know it wont happen especially since Jackson is questionable for the next game, but the D really looks like it could use an injection of speed at the second level.

That of course doesn't address the front and safeties.
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by GoDucksTroll »

Apparently I’m a glutton for punishment, as I rewatched more. The Jefferson 82 yard run to get the Beavs their first score.

The play is crazy, so much goes wrong and Jefferson just makes a great play. They could run that play a hundred more times and it probably doesn’t work quite like that ever again. Oregon’s defense read it perfectly.

What it was is a variant of the trap play everyone runs.

Oregon has KT, FatMac, Austin Faoliu, and Mase Funa on the line. ISM behind Faoliu and Sewell behind KT and FatMac. OSU has a TE on the line across from Funa, two WRs next to him. Pickett is pressing up as the Nickel, Lenoir is deep. McKinley and Bennett Williams as the safeties and Wright on the side side of the field.

The play design is that Jefferson get a handoff to the right. The left tackle runs straight ahead without even chipping KT since the play is going the other way and his job is to find Sewell. LG blocks Jordon Scott. C and RG double team Faoliu, TE tangle with Funa, RT slides into the LBs to block ISM. One WR runs off Lenoir, other blocks Pickett by the line.

ISM, Funa, KT, and Sewell read if instantly. Faoliu gets pushed back six yards on the double team before one disengages and goes back for Sewell who is screaming in. KT is trapped by Scott getting manhandled next to him.

This is where Jefferson sees there’s nothing. Can’t go outside right because Funa and Pickett are there. Can’t go up the middle because ISM and Sewell are there. So he cuts left. But KT is there so he cuts from left to middle. In the middle Pickett and Scott are going to close the gap while Faoliu is turning around with the grace of a 747.

Jefferson winds up in the middle of a diamond, it would be closed but Pickett is being held by the WR, hand in the arm hole pulling the jersey and slowing him by a fraction of a second. Then Scott falls down. He either plants a foot wrong or he’s pulled down by the hand by the LG blocking him, could be either. So he whiffs the tackle. He just falls. And blocks KT from having a chance. Pickett is right there and he just stops when FatMac does a fat face plant. Just freezes and does nothing. Faoliu has had his back turned for a while now and sees nothing. All the LBs are behind the play. VM3 takes a bad angle, and Bennett Williams does too - they were son eager to minimize the play that they missed stopping him to save a few yards.

And that’s that. Jermar Jefferson made a great play. Adjusted twice. Oregon players reacted both times and could have stopped the play.
Most blame: Faoliu, not for the double team six yards blasted back but for then being useless. FatMac for not just being useless but missing the tackle and taking both KT and Pickett out of the play. Pickett for not trying the tackle. Sewell and ISM for being over aggressive. McKinley and Williams for not doing the safety part of playing safety and letting a medium gain become a TD.
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by GoDucksTroll »

The moment where Jordon Scott either falls down or gets dragged down, I’d say fall. Pickett has broken free of a hold and then freezes like he expects Scott to make the tackle. Faoliu has just turned back around and has no idea where the ball is.

Photo link: https://photos.google.com/share/AF1QipO ... lEX2RLVll3
ducks5ever
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 936
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2017 12:15 pm

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by ducks5ever »

pudgejeff wrote:
ducks5ever wrote:You answered your own question - it's because they can move the ball but not consistently (ie. turnover or failed 3rd down conversion) so they struggle to see the endzone on longer drives. The endgame analysis gives the offense way too much credit. I highly doubt the plan was to leave the ballgame in the hands of the defense. Why not try to have the offense run out the clock? It's because they couldn't. I'm with you on this season - not going to get worked up over it but if we don't see much improvement on the offense this year, the Ohio State game next year won't be pretty.
You realize coming into the game they were at the top of the country in all those stats. Smh, keep saying the sky is falling, one day you’ll be actually right.
ThE OfFeNsE Is FiNe. We managed to put up fewer points than any of the other pac-12 teams that played against Cal. Frankly I no longer follow the logic of developing Shough for next year. Why not develop Brown for an actual run next year? I guess it's because he's really worse? I know the past two weeks have been a serious reality check for our aspirations but if we want to get somewhere, I didn't see it before the season began, and I still don't see it now that we're almost done with the season with Shough - why even bother developing him....
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by duck023 »

ducks5ever wrote:
pudgejeff wrote:
ducks5ever wrote:You answered your own question - it's because they can move the ball but not consistently (ie. turnover or failed 3rd down conversion) so they struggle to see the endzone on longer drives. The endgame analysis gives the offense way too much credit. I highly doubt the plan was to leave the ballgame in the hands of the defense. Why not try to have the offense run out the clock? It's because they couldn't. I'm with you on this season - not going to get worked up over it but if we don't see much improvement on the offense this year, the Ohio State game next year won't be pretty.
You realize coming into the game they were at the top of the country in all those stats. Smh, keep saying the sky is falling, one day you’ll be actually right.
ThE OfFeNsE Is FiNe. We managed to put up fewer points than any of the other pac-12 teams that played against Cal. Frankly I no longer follow the logic of developing Shough for next year. Why not develop Brown for an actual run next year? I guess it's because he's really worse? I know the past two weeks have been a serious reality check for our aspirations but if we want to get somewhere, I didn't see it before the season began, and I still don't see it now that we're almost done with the season with Shough - why even bother developing him....
Even if we get the best quarterback ever its going to take years for him to develop. I remember all of you Oregon fans wanted Kyler Murray but it took him 3 years and getting transferred before he was on the level a lot of Duck fans thought he was going to be on. That's a qb the ducks didn't get I don't even want to talk about Travis Jonson and Morgan Mahalak. Shough isn't that much worse than Herbert as a sophmore so I'd rather at least develop him as the only thing to look forward to next season. Who's Brown? I've at least seen Shough play great in garbage time before this year but I haven't seen Brown take a snap.
User avatar
OregonFan4Life
All-American
Posts: 15429
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by OregonFan4Life »

duck023 wrote:
ducks5ever wrote:
pudgejeff wrote:
ducks5ever wrote:You answered your own question - it's because they can move the ball but not consistently (ie. turnover or failed 3rd down conversion) so they struggle to see the endzone on longer drives. The endgame analysis gives the offense way too much credit. I highly doubt the plan was to leave the ballgame in the hands of the defense. Why not try to have the offense run out the clock? It's because they couldn't. I'm with you on this season - not going to get worked up over it but if we don't see much improvement on the offense this year, the Ohio State game next year won't be pretty.
You realize coming into the game they were at the top of the country in all those stats. Smh, keep saying the sky is falling, one day you’ll be actually right.
ThE OfFeNsE Is FiNe. We managed to put up fewer points than any of the other pac-12 teams that played against Cal. Frankly I no longer follow the logic of developing Shough for next year. Why not develop Brown for an actual run next year? I guess it's because he's really worse? I know the past two weeks have been a serious reality check for our aspirations but if we want to get somewhere, I didn't see it before the season began, and I still don't see it now that we're almost done with the season with Shough - why even bother developing him....
Even if we get the best quarterback ever its going to take years for him to develop. I remember all of you Oregon fans wanted Kyler Murray but it took him 3 years and getting transferred before he was on the level a lot of Duck fans thought he was going to be on. That's a qb the ducks didn't get I don't even want to talk about Travis Jonson and Morgan Mahalak. Shough isn't that much worse than Herbert as a sophmore so I'd rather at least develop him as the only thing to look forward to next season. Who's Brown? I've at least seen Shough play great in garbage time before this year but I haven't seen Brown take a snap.
You have to be a troll at this point.
Image
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by Duck07 »

duck023 wrote: Even if we get the best quarterback ever its going to take years for him to develop. I remember all of you Oregon fans wanted Kyler Murray but it took him 3 years and getting transferred before he was on the level a lot of Duck fans thought he was going to be on. That's a qb the ducks didn't get I don't even want to talk about Travis Jonson and Morgan Mahalak. Shough isn't that much worse than Herbert as a sophmore so I'd rather at least develop him as the only thing to look forward to next season. Who's Brown? I've at least seen Shough play great in garbage time before this year but I haven't seen Brown take a snap.
Image
Image
User avatar
UofDuck
Senior
Posts: 3970
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:51 pm

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by UofDuck »

duck023 wrote:
ducks5ever wrote:
pudgejeff wrote:
ducks5ever wrote:You answered your own question - it's because they can move the ball but not consistently (ie. turnover or failed 3rd down conversion) so they struggle to see the endzone on longer drives. The endgame analysis gives the offense way too much credit. I highly doubt the plan was to leave the ballgame in the hands of the defense. Why not try to have the offense run out the clock? It's because they couldn't. I'm with you on this season - not going to get worked up over it but if we don't see much improvement on the offense this year, the Ohio State game next year won't be pretty.
You realize coming into the game they were at the top of the country in all those stats. Smh, keep saying the sky is falling, one day you’ll be actually right.
ThE OfFeNsE Is FiNe. We managed to put up fewer points than any of the other pac-12 teams that played against Cal. Frankly I no longer follow the logic of developing Shough for next year. Why not develop Brown for an actual run next year? I guess it's because he's really worse? I know the past two weeks have been a serious reality check for our aspirations but if we want to get somewhere, I didn't see it before the season began, and I still don't see it now that we're almost done with the season with Shough - why even bother developing him....
Even if we get the best quarterback ever its going to take years for him to develop. I remember all of you Oregon fans wanted Kyler Murray but it took him 3 years and getting transferred before he was on the level a lot of Duck fans thought he was going to be on. That's a qb the ducks didn't get I don't even want to talk about Travis Jonson and Morgan Mahalak. Shough isn't that much worse than Herbert as a sophmore so I'd rather at least develop him as the only thing to look forward to next season. Who's Brown? I've at least seen Shough play great in garbage time before this year but I haven't seen Brown take a snap.
We knew it. Now you self incriminated.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39368
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by greenyellow »

I've had my suspicions as well.
Image
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40718
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by UOducksTK1 »

Better performance. Take out bad penalties, and I doubt Cal scores over 14 points.

At least our kicking game is AMAZING now.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by buckmarkduck »

UOducksTK1 wrote:Better performance. Take out bad penalties, and I doubt Cal scores over 14 points.

At least our kicking game is AMAZING now.

The PI call in the end zone was sooooo bad. If they call that, we should be seeing 10 PI flags a game. Bennett had his hand on him, the way DB are trained to to, but he didn't pull on him, or do anything that should warrant the PI.
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40718
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by UOducksTK1 »

buckmarkduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:Better performance. Take out bad penalties, and I doubt Cal scores over 14 points.

At least our kicking game is AMAZING now.

The PI call in the end zone was sooooo bad. If they call that, we should be seeing 10 PI flags a game. Bennett had his hand on him, the way DB are trained to to, but he didn't pull on him, or do anything that should warrant the PI.
Twas a bad call. And the 12 men on field on the 4th down punt made me cringe.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
User avatar
lukeyrid13
All-American
Posts: 10475
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
GM: Portland TrailBlazers

Re: Defense a massive disappointment through 3 games

Post by lukeyrid13 »

UOducksTK1 wrote:
buckmarkduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:Better performance. Take out bad penalties, and I doubt Cal scores over 14 points.

At least our kicking game is AMAZING now.

The PI call in the end zone was sooooo bad. If they call that, we should be seeing 10 PI flags a game. Bennett had his hand on him, the way DB are trained to to, but he didn't pull on him, or do anything that should warrant the PI.
Twas a bad call. And the 12 men on field on the 4th down punt made me cringe.
And the ticky tack (but still dumb) penalty by KT

Cal had a 6% chance of winning based on how the game played out.....all 3 of those plays were essentially turnovers as they changed possession back to Cal.

We shouldn't have even been close, but we did have a lot of bad breaks in that game.
Post Reply