Quarterback Situation
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Quarterback Situation
Feels like this deserves its own thread as it's hijacking many others.
I think Shough has arm talent. I bet he's the best guy in practice. Everyone makes boneheaded mistakes, especially in their first year starting. However, he gets rattled. Three games in a row, you can see when the camera zooms in on him that he's panicking. I hate to say it, but it's Lockie-esque.
Brown is a guy who likes to push the ball down-field and will mix in some INTs with his TDs as a byproduct. As we saw on some plays last night, guy has a calming influence and a look like he's got it all under control.
I think the staff should strongly encourage him to stay and be the guy in 2021, buying time for Butterfield and Thompson to vie for the spot in 2022 and become multi-year starters.
I think Shough has arm talent. I bet he's the best guy in practice. Everyone makes boneheaded mistakes, especially in their first year starting. However, he gets rattled. Three games in a row, you can see when the camera zooms in on him that he's panicking. I hate to say it, but it's Lockie-esque.
Brown is a guy who likes to push the ball down-field and will mix in some INTs with his TDs as a byproduct. As we saw on some plays last night, guy has a calming influence and a look like he's got it all under control.
I think the staff should strongly encourage him to stay and be the guy in 2021, buying time for Butterfield and Thompson to vie for the spot in 2022 and become multi-year starters.
-
jimmy12
- Senior
- Posts: 2823
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:38 am
Re: Quarterback Situation
StevensTechU wrote:Feels like this deserves its own thread as it's hijacking many others.
I think Shough has arm talent. I bet he's the best guy in practice. Everyone makes boneheaded mistakes, especially in their first year starting. However, he gets rattled. Three games in a row, you can see when the camera zooms in on him that he's panicking. I hate to say it, but it's Lockie-esque.
Brown is a guy who likes to push the ball down-field and will mix in some INTs with his TDs as a byproduct. As we saw on some plays last night, guy has a calming influence and a look like he's got it all under control.
I think the staff should strongly encourage him to stay and be the guy in 2021, buying time for Butterfield and Thompson to vie for the spot in 2022 and become multi-year starters.
Agreed. You could see in Tyler's eyes that we was rattled. The beautiful part about Herbs is that he had a very short memory from mistakes.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: Quarterback Situation
This is what I'm thinking. I hate to try and read too much into stuff that isn't concrete, but his body-language/face doesn't look great on the field when we need him to be that presence for the rest of the team in-game. Which leads to the hope that Brown can be that "calming influence." I do recall from practice reports that the Brown to Williams combo was strong from the start in practice so it might be worth it to push DW up too.StevensTechU wrote:Feels like this deserves its own thread as it's hijacking many others.
I think Shough has arm talent. I bet he's the best guy in practice. Everyone makes boneheaded mistakes, especially in their first year starting. However, he gets rattled. Three games in a row, you can see when the camera zooms in on him that he's panicking. I hate to say it, but it's Lockie-esque.
Brown is a guy who likes to push the ball down-field and will mix in some INTs with his TDs as a byproduct. As we saw on some plays last night, guy has a calming influence and a look like he's got it all under control.
I think the staff should strongly encourage him to stay and be the guy in 2021, buying time for Butterfield and Thompson to vie for the spot in 2022 and become multi-year starters.
The final part is also where I'm at today in my line of thinking for next-year except I'm crazy enough to think that if the coaches want to keep running the Pistol that Cale Millen might be the better choice than Butterfield (all based of course off the scientific method of watching ~4 minutes of HS highlights)

-
GoDucksIn09
- Senior
- Posts: 3086
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am
Re: Quarterback Situation
I know the coaches have confidence in Shough. I know Shough has said the right things about needing to be better and wanting some throws back. That is all fine and dandy but when you see him play his decision making does not back up his words. He continues to make the same mistakes over and over. At some point coaches have to make the tough decision. It took Cristobal a long time before he decided Lewis was not good as a field goal kicker. I hope with the quarterback he is a little more quicker to make the tough decision.
-
mrpd21
- Five Star Recruit
- Posts: 1177
- Joined: Mon Nov 02, 2009 6:04 am
Re: Quarterback Situation
I see people trying to compare his stats to guys like VA and Herbert. The on paper stats do not tell the story that we all see on the field. Kid looks rattled, uncertain and his vision and reads are just not there. Every QB makes mistakes but Shough's bad throws and INT's are sometimes on a major WTF scale. No hate on the kid from me but he is NOT the guy.
-
dthomas=ddixon
- Moderator

- Posts: 8818
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
- Location: McMinnville, Oregon
Re: Quarterback Situation
Seeing a young QB clearly regress during his first season as a starter is basically a death knell, IMO. That initial starting experience should bring leaps in progression, if the guy has a future at the position.

-
wepto
- Five Star Recruit
- Posts: 1074
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 11:07 pm
Re: Quarterback Situation
On the other hand, Dixon lost his confidence his junior year and looked bad. Some guys can turn it around mentally.dthomas=ddixon wrote:Seeing a young QB clearly regress during his first season as a starter is basically a death knell, IMO. That initial starting experience should bring leaps in progression, if the guy has a future at the position.
- GoDucksTroll
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1742
- Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am
Re: Quarterback Situation
Shough has time to turn it around, but I don’t think he should be our starter going forward.
* Can’t make the right choice on the read option consistently.!
* Gets rattled. As bad as any Duck QB ever.
* Arm talent is severely lacking.
* Adequate foot speed, lack of agility.
He’s tough, I’ll give Shough that. But I’d rather have poised and skilled.
If Brown is coming back next year then start Brown in the bowl game.
* Can’t make the right choice on the read option consistently.!
* Gets rattled. As bad as any Duck QB ever.
* Arm talent is severely lacking.
* Adequate foot speed, lack of agility.
He’s tough, I’ll give Shough that. But I’d rather have poised and skilled.
If Brown is coming back next year then start Brown in the bowl game.
- lukeyrid13
- All-American
- Posts: 10475
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
- GM: Portland TrailBlazers
Re: Quarterback Situation
I hope we see Brown start the bowl game. Shough just gets too antsy out there. He doesn’t play with poise.
As for next year, if Ty Thompson is who I think he is, I think it’s his job
As for next year, if Ty Thompson is who I think he is, I think it’s his job
-
GrantDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 2629
- Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm
Re: Quarterback Situation
Shough had 6 games and probably played the best 2 defenses last. He made the same boneheaded plays each game, those defenses simply punished him more.
I think "regressed" is incorrect, we just didn't see him improve much in a 1/2 season.
I think we likely see him start again next year, but if he doesn't improve, Thompson will be the guy midway through next year, because Thompson is already as good as Shough was this year.
I think "regressed" is incorrect, we just didn't see him improve much in a 1/2 season.
I think we likely see him start again next year, but if he doesn't improve, Thompson will be the guy midway through next year, because Thompson is already as good as Shough was this year.
Last edited by GrantDuck on Sat Dec 19, 2020 11:20 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
bellsduck
- Senior
- Posts: 3859
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:40 am
- GM: Utah Jazz
Re: Quarterback Situation
What's the deal with Millen? Where does he fit in?
-
gogreen55
- Senior
- Posts: 2369
- Joined: Sat Apr 30, 2011 8:39 pm
Re: Quarterback Situation
He is our new Steve Tasker.bellsduck wrote:What's the deal with Millen? Where does he fit in?
-
alxtw
- Freshman
- Posts: 1279
- Joined: Sun Dec 19, 2010 10:46 pm
Re: Quarterback Situation
There was one play in the USC game that pretty much sums up how easily he's rattled when pressured. I believe it was 3rd and long and USC was picking up momentum. We were pinned pretty close to our own endzone. Pocket was collapsing and Shough was running away from defenders and instead of just throwing it away, he tosses it up into an area with 2-3 USC defenders. We were extremely lucky it didn't get intercepted and our WRs not open.
- QuackininBama
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5736
- Joined: Sat Sep 10, 2011 8:55 am
Re: Quarterback Situation
That was the pass late in the 4th that he was just lucky it wasn't picked, because as good as our defensive line was playing their receivers are so good that would have been ball game.alxtw wrote:There was one play in the USC game that pretty much sums up how easily he's rattled when pressured. I believe it was 3rd and long and USC was picking up momentum. We were pinned pretty close to our own endzone. Pocket was collapsing and Shough was running away from defenders and instead of just throwing it away, he tosses it up into an area with 2-3 USC defenders. We were extremely lucky it didn't get intercepted and our WRs not open.
- justducky0
- Senior
- Posts: 2012
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:02 pm
- Location: The Real World
Re: Quarterback Situation
Should we go back and get the receipts of when Oregon was recruiting another QB this summer and so many people on this board were saying Shough should have the job no matter what.
Because that was absurd.
Because that was absurd.
