Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Post by buckmarkduck »

StevensTechU wrote:John Bates (Lebanon HS, Boise St) also just announced that he's leaving BSU to go pro.

I don't think Oregon puts out a ton of high level talent, but what annoys me is when Oregon kids who are clearly talented get discounted because they play in Oregon, and also when the overall quality of Oregon teams gets discounted as it compares to quality of play in other states (such as suggesting Mississippi small school ball is better than Oregon large school ball). In general, the best 6a team in the state in a given year is probably one of the top 150 teams in the country, give or take. They'll still get the doors blown off of them by Bishop Gorman and IMG Academy, but they compare well to the quality of play of most of the country.

A good friend of mine used to be the head football coach and track coach at Lebanon. He told me that TE was a crazy good athlete in HS, and he did everything he could to get OSu and UO to offer him, but neither did until late in the game. He also told me that if Keith Brown is a 4*, he doesn't know what a 4* is anymore. Meaning Keith is athletic but not a great football player. He's known Keith for years, and said if he had stayed with wrestling, he would have been an Olympic level wrestler.
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Post by GoDucksTroll »

buckmarkduck wrote:
GoDucksTroll wrote:
buckmarkduck wrote:Now do Utah, who has almost half as many people.
I don’t think Oregon producing great college players is a zero sum game where it means Utah isn’t better. But Utah high school football isn’t questioned as often as Oregon.

Demographic differences have to be accounted for. Utah has a large Polynesian community. Mississippi has a smaller population than Utah, and they produce significantly more top football players. Louisiana, about the same population as Oregon, is even more out of this world. In the last three years Louisiana has had 5 5-stars and 38 4-stars. Demographic and cultural differences.
I don’t think Oregon HS football is terrible. But I do think when you look around the country and compare it to just power 5 states. It probably produces the least D1 talent of any of those states.
Oregon doesn’t have a very high per capita production of football players (demographics), large population, or other things like weather or football culture - but it still is better than other states with a P-5, especially per capita. There are successful players that are late bloomers that don’t go to Pac-12 schools or Boise that we forget about. Like Tyrell Williams or Kevin Boss from WOU or the McQuistan brothers from Weber State.

Out of curiosity I looked it up and Massachusetts is your winner (or loser) in the worst talent producing P-5 state out of ones with more people than Oregon, nearly double the population with 1/3 less active NFL players. The only states with a smaller population and more current NFL players are Utah, Iowa, and Mississippi. Oklahoma with nearly the same population also has more.
User avatar
Phalanx
All Pac-12
Posts: 5293
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Post by Phalanx »

buckmarkduck wrote:

A good friend of mine used to be the head football coach and track coach at Lebanon. He told me that TE was a crazy good athlete in HS, and he did everything he could to get OSu and UO to offer him, but neither did until late in the game. He also told me that if Keith Brown is a 4*, he doesn't know what a 4* is anymore. Meaning Keith is athletic but not a great football player. He's known Keith for years, and said if he had stayed with wrestling, he would have been an Olympic level wrestler.
Unfortunately, I have heard the same about Brown. I still think Oregon should go after Oregon kids if they are D-1 type athletes.
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: Oregon HS Football is Garbage

Post by StevensTechU »

I have no inside info, but you can tell just by looking at Keith's tape that the football instincts aren't natural to him. He's a highly rated recruits because he went to a Dallas combine/camp and put up phenomenal numbers for a high school sophomore. Unfortunately, that's a major flaw in the raging system. If youre a muscle bound high schooler who looks the part at a camp, you're a 4-5 star recruit, even if you've been even all-league on the field.
Post Reply