Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Post Reply
User avatar
Phalanx
All Pac-12
Posts: 5294
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by Phalanx »

I keep reading here that people were calling for Shough over Herbert...does anyone have an example of this - like a serious example, not just a stupid in-game comment? I don't think this was actually ever a thing. I read quite a bit of criticism of Herbert, and lots here were casting doubt on his pro prospects, but nobody thought he was worse than Shough. The consensus was that Arroyo's offense and the lack of good receivers was the main problem.

In terms of ISU's purportedly physical play, I am sure that they are tough. On the other hand, this is always what Big 12 teams are crowing about before a bowl game with the Ducks. Colorado in the Fiesta Bowl, Oklahoma State in the Holiday Bowl, Kansas State in the Fiesta Bowl...all of them were saying they were the more physical team, and all of them found out differently. I personally don't think the Ducks have the same team this year as in those years, and it sounds like we will be depleted by more COVID protocols, so I'm not going to predict a big Duck win, but I do take the Big 12 bragging with a serious grain of salt based on history. The defense has looked a lot better lately. Here's hoping the Ducks show up and come out swinging.
droop10
Freshman
Posts: 1439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:07 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by droop10 »

pezsez1 wrote:I've never heard Brown described as an average QB who is prone to mistakes until now.

Shough isn't ready to be our starter. I'm sure he's great in practice, but whatever he does on the practice field doesn't translate to games. He repeatedly fails to read defenses, he regularly underthrows receivers, and his reads are inconsistent. It's not that he's a bad QB, but it's as if every game is the first time he's played and he keeps making the same mistakes. He really does remind me of Dakota Prukop or maybe a more talented version of Jeff Lockie. It seems like he SHOULD be better -- and he would have been had he grown throughout the season -- but he didn't, and he's not.

Anthony Brown, to me, wins the job if he simply takes better care of the football. Shough is an unassisted turnover waiting to happen and that could kill us on Saturday.

Now, to switch gears... I don't think we'll be *more* physical than Iowa State. That's a pretty physical group. But I absolutely believe we could be equally physical. The USC game looked so much like last season's Utah game (both for the Pac-12 title)... in each game, it was as if the defense completely came together and dudes stepped up who we hadn't really seen all season. (Last year it was Brady Breeze... this year it was Jamal Hill.) If I had to place a bet, I'd wager last season's trajectory will repeat itself this season, and that the D will come with brass knuckles for the Fiesta Bowl. The offensive side of the ball is more of a question mark, but if our QB (whoever it is) can limit mistakes then I really like our chances to score lots of points. I hope we see more of Sean Dollars... he reminds me of Ken Simonton, perhaps lacking elite speed but just really good at finding lanes and using his blockers -- SO MUCH BETTER than Verdell at that, based on what little we saw against USC.

Like we did against USC, Oregon wins the talent battle against Iowa State. If we can equalize the physicality then we should win the game.
I don't think I mentioned Brown being mistake prone, but has accuracy issues, which is evident in the fact that he's never completed 60% of his passes and has a career 55% completion percentage. Looking back, I'm not even sure we can consider Brown a bigger running threat. Shough rushed for more yards in his first 3 games than Brown ever rushed for in an entire season. I think this board is making a lot of assumptions about what Brown is capable of doing, with zero evidence that supports that argument. I think Brown is closer to Prukop than Shough.
User avatar
OregonFan4Life
All-American
Posts: 15429
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by OregonFan4Life »

Droop must be talking about me cause I created a thread basically saying the coaches should bench Herbert for a series or two when he's playing with 0 sense of urgency to light a fire under his ass. It was misinterpreted as me saying Shough was the better option which is not true at all, just during the ASU and OSU games last year felt like Herbert was going through the motions and playing with no motivation and the coaches needed to do something to fire him up and that's what I though could've motivated him. It was a half troll half serious thread, but that must be what Droop is referring to.

As for our expectations, what's wrong with having high expectations for a QB? Is it so wrong to expect a good QB after having Mariota, VA, and Herbert? Or should we just accept that's as good as it gets and accept average at best QB play? That's such a silly argument that makes 0 sense. Last I checked the coaches are working towards a national championship, not being a consistent middle of the road Pac-12 team. To win a national championship you need a good QB, one that is far better than how Shough has been playing. I understand there are growing pains but that's different than a deep regression and turning into a turnover machine. Every time Shough throws over 10 yards I feel like it's more likely to be a pick than a completion at this point. Nobody is saying Brown is the "answer", but while Shough is so clearly rattled, he may give the team a better chance at winning the Fiesta Bowl and winning is all that matters.

Too often coaches just stick with their guy and abandon trying anything else and it can be very costly. Chip stuck with Maldonado (cost us a national championship in 2012 and possibly 2011), Helf stuck with Lockie and Brenner in the Alamo Bowl, and Cristobal seems to just be sticking with Shough and also stuck with Camden Lewis too long (though eventually switched it up). We've seen it in the past, and we just don't want to see a coach stick with a guy when he's hurting the team; after all, it's not fair to the team.
Image
droop10
Freshman
Posts: 1439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:07 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by droop10 »

Phalanx wrote:I keep reading here that people were calling for Shough over Herbert...does anyone have an example of this - like a serious example, not just a stupid in-game comment? I don't think this was actually ever a thing. I read quite a bit of criticism of Herbert, and lots here were casting doubt on his pro prospects, but nobody thought he was worse than Shough. The consensus was that Arroyo's offense and the lack of good receivers was the main problem.

In terms of ISU's purportedly physical play, I am sure that they are tough. On the other hand, this is always what Big 12 teams are crowing about before a bowl game with the Ducks. Colorado in the Fiesta Bowl, Oklahoma State in the Holiday Bowl, Kansas State in the Fiesta Bowl...all of them were saying they were the more physical team, and all of them found out differently. I personally don't think the Ducks have the same team this year as in those years, and it sounds like we will be depleted by more COVID protocols, so I'm not going to predict a big Duck win, but I do take the Big 12 bragging with a serious grain of salt based on history. The defense has looked a lot better lately. Here's hoping the Ducks show up and come out swinging.
http://www.ducksattack.com/forum/viewto ... 2&start=30

This is only one example, and in fairness, many people were reasonable and shot it down, but there were certainly some on board with it. I tried searching by keyword, but it's not letting me click into the search box for the keyword search, and I don't feel like sifting through pages of the forum to find other examples. This was obviously an easier example to spot, because of the thread title. haha.
User avatar
Phalanx
All Pac-12
Posts: 5294
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by Phalanx »

droop10 wrote:
http://www.ducksattack.com/forum/viewto ... 2&start=30

This is only one example, and in fairness, many people were reasonable and shot it down, but there were certainly some on board with it. I tried searching by keyword, but it's not letting me click into the search box for the keyword search, and I don't feel like sifting through pages of the forum to find other examples. This was obviously an easier example to spot, because of the thread title. haha.
In fairness? In fairness, that thread was completely panned from the outset. Do you have another example? This one was not worth mentioning. To take that thread and say that 'this is the fan base that also called for Herbert to be benched for Shough last year' is patently ridiculous. That suggestion was met with overt ridicule and dismissal.

You should wash your own mouth out with soap and apologize to Oregon Duck fans everywhere.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by Duck07 »

Frankly none of the "Bench Herbert" talk, funny as it is, isn't relevant to the QB's we have or for potentially next year. One critique we can make of Mario is how he uses his QBs to give them reps as its clear now that Shough needed real reps, not just simple hand-offs last year. Looking at this year, its clear other QBs needed to play both for competitive and development reasons.

It's disingenuous to think that Anthony Brown's time at BC would be the exact same as it is with Moorhead and our offense. If you believe that one QB is capable of improvement you have to believe that all of them are with these coaches and system.

It's also a fools errand to think it has to be one or the other when we've got 5 on the team and with Thompson coming on board next year we won't be keeping 6 so some are going to transfer out with the rules.
Image
droop10
Freshman
Posts: 1439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:07 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by droop10 »

OregonFan4Life wrote:Droop must be talking about me cause I created a thread basically saying the coaches should bench Herbert for a series or two when he's playing with 0 sense of urgency to light a fire under his ass. It was misinterpreted as me saying Shough was the better option which is not true at all, just during the ASU and OSU games last year felt like Herbert was going through the motions and playing with no motivation and the coaches needed to do something to fire him up and that's what I though could've motivated him. It was a half troll half serious thread, but that must be what Droop is referring to.

As for our expectations, what's wrong with having high expectations for a QB? Is it so wrong to expect a good QB after having Mariota, VA, and Herbert? Or should we just accept that's as good as it gets and accept average at best QB play? That's such a silly argument that makes 0 sense. Last I checked the coaches are working towards a national championship, not being a consistent middle of the road Pac-12 team. To win a national championship you need a good QB, one that is far better than how Shough has been playing. I understand there are growing pains but that's different than a deep regression and turning into a turnover machine. Every time Shough throws over 10 yards I feel like it's more likely to be a pick than a completion at this point. Nobody is saying Brown is the "answer", but while Shough is so clearly rattled, he may give the team a better chance at winning the Fiesta Bowl and winning is all that matters.

Too often coaches just stick with their guy and abandon trying anything else and it can be very costly. Chip stuck with Maldonado (cost us a national championship in 2012 and possibly 2011), Helf stuck with Lockie and Brenner in the Alamo Bowl, and Cristobal seems to just be sticking with Shough and also stuck with Camden Lewis too long (though eventually switched it up). We've seen it in the past, and we just don't want to see a coach stick with a guy when he's hurting the team; after all, it's not fair to the team.
I did happen to link that before I saw this. Impressive that you remember that specific thread! That being said, that's not the only instance I recall seeing it, I'm just too lazy to sift through history to find every instance it was brought up. Also, I'm not stating that average at best QB play should be accepted. I'm saying 1) Brown isn't an upgrade, 2) Shough has the potential to be a good QB, 3) People's expectations of what is simply "good" QB play is skewed by historically great QBs, and 4) Not every QB is a polished player right out of the gate like Mariota, or a guy stepping in after 3 years as a starter (Adams).

I think a small sample size in a weird year is being used to judge Shough's potential going forward. Herbert had a 4-8 season with no pressure to learn and get up to speed. I also think calling Shough a turnover machine is a bit of a reach. He's averaged less than an interception a game (though I do hope he improves on his decision making and knocks that down a bit) and I believe has only turned the ball over more than once in one game (I can't find fumbles lost stats, and don't remember every potential fumble over the year so you can correct me if I'm wrong). Can he improve in that regard? Sure, but he's not as big a liability as he's made out to be.

My argument isn't even to stick with him through next year. If there's a guy on the roster that proves to be better, I'll support that guy. However, I think sitting him for Brown in this game doesn't help the team in any way for the future, but playing him at least allows for the potential for something to click with him and he could gain confidence going into next year. I think the Risk/Reward scenario benefits starting Shough over Brown, because there's very little to gain from starting Brown, and while starting Shough may not work out this game, it'll be more data to use in making a decision for next year. I know I've said it multiple times, so I'm sounding like a broken record, but I find this year's Fiesta Bowl to be meaningless, so I'm concerned about the long-term future of the team versus the short term benefit of winning a game that nobody will remember or care about a few months from now.
ducks5ever
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 936
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2017 12:15 pm

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by ducks5ever »

User avatar
OregonFan4Life
All-American
Posts: 15429
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by OregonFan4Life »

droop10 wrote:
OregonFan4Life wrote:Droop must be talking about me cause I created a thread basically saying the coaches should bench Herbert for a series or two when he's playing with 0 sense of urgency to light a fire under his ass. It was misinterpreted as me saying Shough was the better option which is not true at all, just during the ASU and OSU games last year felt like Herbert was going through the motions and playing with no motivation and the coaches needed to do something to fire him up and that's what I though could've motivated him. It was a half troll half serious thread, but that must be what Droop is referring to.

As for our expectations, what's wrong with having high expectations for a QB? Is it so wrong to expect a good QB after having Mariota, VA, and Herbert? Or should we just accept that's as good as it gets and accept average at best QB play? That's such a silly argument that makes 0 sense. Last I checked the coaches are working towards a national championship, not being a consistent middle of the road Pac-12 team. To win a national championship you need a good QB, one that is far better than how Shough has been playing. I understand there are growing pains but that's different than a deep regression and turning into a turnover machine. Every time Shough throws over 10 yards I feel like it's more likely to be a pick than a completion at this point. Nobody is saying Brown is the "answer", but while Shough is so clearly rattled, he may give the team a better chance at winning the Fiesta Bowl and winning is all that matters.

Too often coaches just stick with their guy and abandon trying anything else and it can be very costly. Chip stuck with Maldonado (cost us a national championship in 2012 and possibly 2011), Helf stuck with Lockie and Brenner in the Alamo Bowl, and Cristobal seems to just be sticking with Shough and also stuck with Camden Lewis too long (though eventually switched it up). We've seen it in the past, and we just don't want to see a coach stick with a guy when he's hurting the team; after all, it's not fair to the team.
I did happen to link that before I saw this. Impressive that you remember that specific thread! That being said, that's not the only instance I recall seeing it, I'm just too lazy to sift through history to find every instance it was brought up. Also, I'm not stating that average at best QB play should be accepted. I'm saying 1) Brown isn't an upgrade, 2) Shough has the potential to be a good QB, 3) People's expectations of what is simply "good" QB play is skewed by historically great QBs, and 4) Not every QB is a polished player right out of the gate like Mariota, or a guy stepping in after 3 years as a starter (Adams).

I think a small sample size in a weird year is being used to judge Shough's potential going forward. Herbert had a 4-8 season with no pressure to learn and get up to speed. I also think calling Shough a turnover machine is a bit of a reach. He's averaged less than an interception a game (though I do hope he improves on his decision making and knocks that down a bit) and I believe has only turned the ball over more than once in one game (I can't find fumbles lost stats, and don't remember every potential fumble over the year so you can correct me if I'm wrong). Can he improve in that regard? Sure, but he's not as big a liability as he's made out to be.

My argument isn't even to stick with him through next year. If there's a guy on the roster that proves to be better, I'll support that guy. However, I think sitting him for Brown in this game doesn't help the team in any way for the future, but playing him at least allows for the potential for something to click with him and he could gain confidence going into next year. I think the Risk/Reward scenario benefits starting Shough over Brown, because there's very little to gain from starting Brown, and while starting Shough may not work out this game, it'll be more data to use in making a decision for next year. I know I've said it multiple times, so I'm sounding like a broken record, but I find this year's Fiesta Bowl to be meaningless, so I'm concerned about the long-term future of the team versus the short term benefit of winning a game that nobody will remember or care about a few months from now.
I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree, I can't imagine Brown being a worse option than Shough over the last two games, but maybe he is. Just figured with how poorly Shough played Brown was worth a chance. I say let Shough start, but as soon as he looks rattled like he has the last few games, put Brown in.

As for this Fiesta Bowl, I find it to be very important cause for recruiting and national perception. A loss to Iowa State (who is a great team this year but historically is regarded very lowly) might hurt the perception of this team and therefore recruiting. Recruiting hasn't done as well lately the I believe a solid Fiesta Bowl win would give the coaches a good final push to land a top recruit.
Image
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by Duck07 »

ducks5ever wrote:Image

aight imma head out
Image
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39368
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by greenyellow »





Image
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by GoDucksTroll »

Every time I’ve rewatched a game and can get past the razzle dazzle of the play calling I have the same conclusion I had after the season opener:

Shough has very poor arm talent.

The throws he makes are ones every QB should be able to. Anything that requires velocity and accuracy is missing. I watched some 2009 highlights the other day and Masoli, who is generally regarded as the worst passer of the full time starters in the last 20+ years, is soooo much better at throwing the football than Shough. I’d even take Prukop now. Shough is just a rung above Braxton Burmeister, and he keeps getting worse- his confidence is shot.

I don’t think it’s that we’ve been spoiled by having elite QBs, dude just can’t throw well often enough. Part physical and part mental.

I looked back through the last few years, and they couldn’t close the deal on DJ Ukelele who would be perfect, but I would have loved Jayden Daniels. Or Indiana’s Mike Penix, who would be at Oregon if the offer we gave him was committable and we actually recruited him. Let’s hope Shough proves me wrong.
droop10
Freshman
Posts: 1439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:07 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by droop10 »

OregonFan4Life wrote: I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree, I can't imagine Brown being a worse option than Shough over the last two games, but maybe he is. Just figured with how poorly Shough played Brown was worth a chance. I say let Shough start, but as soon as he looks rattled like he has the last few games, put Brown in.

As for this Fiesta Bowl, I find it to be very important cause for recruiting and national perception. A loss to Iowa State (who is a great team this year but historically is regarded very lowly) might hurt the perception of this team and therefore recruiting. Recruiting hasn't done as well lately the I believe a solid Fiesta Bowl win would give the coaches a good final push to land a top recruit.

I dunno. I disagree that recruits care about the result of this Fiesta Bowl. How has recruiting not done as well lately? They just pulled in the highest rated class in the history of the program and have a shot to land a few others. They haven't had any recent commits, but that's because the class is essentially full, minus holding a few spots for a few select guys. If losing to Cal and Oregon St. in back-to-back weeks didn't deter recruits, why would losing to an Iowa St. team that was ranked top 10? I just don't think the NY6 bowls matter that much to recruits, but I could be wrong. If Brown ends up coming in and blowing the doors off, then good for him, but I just don't envision a scenario where that happens. I think the role they used him in last week is the ideal role for him.
Last edited by droop10 on Wed Dec 30, 2020 4:29 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by GoDucksTroll »

I don’t want to quote 20 replies (mods, is it possible to reduce how many posts are quoted or to collapse it to just one quote without manually deleting everything and potentially messing up the formatting?) but I have a take on why the Fiesta Bowl is important for both recruiting and program perception.

If Oregon finished 4-3 and unranked, with a loss to an less than prestigious opponent, it will have an impact on the 2022 class. We’re already in a bad spot because we haven’t had our summer SNL or any visits. The coaches made it work for 2021 - but most of those commits already visited in person. It’s the future classes more impacted by the shutdown.

The last thing we need is recruiting competition saying Cristobal just had some good years riding NFL stud Justin Herbert, etc. The narrative is much better with consecutive NY6 wins and it will be important considering how much recruiting is done before the summer even starts.

This Fiesta Bowl isn’t make or break. It’s a bigger deal to Iowa State than us. But it’s still very important.
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39368
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by greenyellow »

Image
Post Reply