squintsdd wrote:Holy crap, all the complaining. It's almost like you would think Oregon is a veteran team of all seniors that's been playing together for 5 years. There's a brand new OC, new starting QB, the whole O-line is new, and 3 starting DBs opted out. This isn't a bad team. It's a young and very inexperienced team in one of the most awkward college football seasons ever played.
Excuses again. Good teams reload.
Only really 3 teams reload - Alabama, Clemson and Ohio State. All other go through some rebuilding/“down” years.
LSU was an older team than Oregon last year and rebuilt themselves much faster. Even though they weren't great they showed as much promise as Oregon did this year.
Thank you for making my point.
That doesn't make your point. LSU was actually rebuilding while Oregon had the same excuse of being a young team last year. I even heard that after the ASU game. No LSU fan last year was under the delusion that was a young team. LSU with a brand new team would have went unbeaten with Oregon's schedule. So if you are happy with being as good as LSU on a bad year I guess I made your point.
Your response is very confusing, but let me clarify.
1. Oregon wasn’t a young team last year. They are the youngest this year.
2. LSU didn’t rebuild last year - they won the championship! They are rebuilding this year.
3. You have issues with the Pac 12 - so do I. Oregon is in a NY6 game this year and LSU isn’t. What does that have to do with my original statement that only 3 teams don’t go through rebuilding? If you want to add LSU to that group of 3, then my point that most teams go through rebuilding every few years still stands.
4. Happy with being as good as LSU? Not sure your point, but yes I’d like Oregon to be spoken in the same sentence as LSU. Bad year being in a NY6 game - I’ll take that. I’m frustrated just as much as many here, but anything positive out of this year is gravy and valuable experience for a young team.
Brown was down. It was not a fumble. He played a pretty good game. Had drops from Pittman and Redd that slowed drives. Tough breaks because both Mycah and Redd have great hands. Shough doesn’t have it mentally. Hopeful Brown returns next year and Thompson can battle for a position. Tough game. Reminiscent of BYU (2006). Cristobal needs to learn when to go for it and when to punt. I’m losing my patience with in game coaching from Mario. Love his o line coaching, recruiting and hires but he needs to take more chances.
I came into this game with a bit of confidence but mostly low expectations-
The reward was:
* 2 fumbles, although one was iffy but it still came on a player fighting for extra yards.
* 2 botched kicks: kick off and punt return.
* 2 QBs although it’s clear that Brown is a million times better.
* -5 turnover margin.
* 8 minutes of possession in the first half, and that was the good half.
* Inability to tackle consistently.
* AND THE WORST CRIME of all in punting it down two scores on 4th and 2 from the 50. WTF Cristobal? You don’t deserve to win when you do that.
Embarrassing. Just as bad as I’ve felt about Oregon football in a while. Vegas Bowl with Willie bouncing beforehand is probably the last time I had this feeling.
Tray Dub wrote:Citing this year's LSU as an example of a reload is honestly hilarious
That is how low my standards are and Oregon is still not meeting them. I don't want Oregon to be as good as LSU last year. I think Oregon would lose to LSU this year and by 20.
Maybe it's time for you to just not call yourself an Oregon fan, since clearly you don't like them
ducks5ever wrote:The QB rotation is so bizarre. This is what happens when we've been knowingly playing the 2nd best QB on the team for the majority of the season.
Lol, incredible how moist everyone here has gotten over Brown’s one good drive, after Shough effortlessly moved down the field on the exact same defense the first drive. Brown has looked alright, but he’s fumbled the ball away and missed a wide open TD pass, but he’s clearly better than Shough because he had that one good drive. Brown showed a few flashes, but they’re still in trouble if he’s starting next year.
Spoke too soon
Eh. He made just as many mistakes as Brown this game. Still funny how certain people are that Brown is clearly better, despite no historical evidence that proves such.
Are you related to Shough?
Haha, nah. I just like arguing against the irrational, which I understand is what fandom is all about. I don’t mind not going against the hive mentality against players. I will stick to Shough being a better option that Brown. I’ve repeatedly said that if Butterfield, Millen, or Thompson (Millen or Thompson is unlikely) beat him out next year, I’m all for it. Just cracked me up how everyone here latched onto Brown after one solid drive, when Shough had similar moments early on the year. Brown has just been less exposed. It’s hypocritical how it took a couple of bad weeks for people to seem Shough a bad QB, but they can choose to ignore 3 years of mediocre play by Brown.
It's fine to go out on a limb and argue against the majority, but you sound really pompous when you act like everyone who disagrees is part of an irrational hivemind. I've watched Shough all year and he's inconsistent, fails to make plays, and seems to wilt when things start going wrong. We haven't seen much of Brown, and no one says he's Joey Harrington, but he's moved the ball more consistently and made some nice plays. We've seen enough from Shough to lose confidence, and Brown was exciting in limited action. Simple as that.
Last edited by Tray Dub on Sat Jan 02, 2021 5:50 pm, edited 1 time in total.
GoDucksTroll wrote:I came into this game with a bit of confidence but mostly low expectations-
The reward was:
* 2 fumbles, although one was iffy but it still came on a player fighting for extra yards.
* 2 botched kicks: kick off and punt return.
* 2 QBs although it’s clear that Brown is a million times better.
* -5 turnover margin.
* 8 minutes of possession in the first half, and that was the good half.
* Inability to tackle consistently.
* AND THE WORST CRIME of all in punting it down two scores on 4th and 2 from the 50. WTF Cristobal? You don’t deserve to win when you do that.
Embarrassing. Just as bad as I’ve felt about Oregon football in a while. Vegas Bowl with Willie bouncing beforehand is probably the last time I had this feeling.
Tray Dub wrote:Citing this year's LSU as an example of a reload is honestly hilarious
That is how low my standards are and Oregon is still not meeting them. I don't want Oregon to be as good as LSU last year. I think Oregon would lose to LSU this year and by 20.
Maybe it's time for you to just not call yourself an Oregon fan, since clearly you don't like them
I'll always be an Oregon fan. I wished I could be an Oregon hater they seem to have a lot more fun and are usually right. I wished Oregon with their great recruits could hang with the teams that I dislike but that isn't the case. The teams I dislike will always be on top.
Sucks to finish on a sour note but at least our team got to get their feet wet this season. Best wishes to each and every one of you all, regardless of your views on Shough/Dye
See you all around, stay safe, and take care. I'm sure there's going to be some serious debate/controversy this off season!!
Well, that was special. Cut out unforced errors and I'm convinced we win that pretty easily.
That said, here's what killed our chances for a comeback:
- QB rotation. Brown is better. Should have just stuck with him.
- 3rd-down playcalling. Just bad. I get it that Iowa State played some good D, but we completely screwed the pooch on at least two 3rd-and-short situations. That just can't happen.
Brown should start next year unless Thompson wins the job. We also need an upgrade at RB.
Loved our D in the second half. We easily matched Iowa State's physicality. Just can't make so many dumb mistakes while also gimping ourselves offensively.
I think there are a few basic things you look for in an FBS QB. Look composed, handle pressure, sit in the pocket or comfortably move around the pocket, see the field, complete passes 7+ yards down field, and show some consistency in making decisions. Basically show some composure and that the game isn't going a million miles an hour for you nearly every down.
One guy at least shows a pulse. The ball to Pittman taken away by the penalty and even the freaking overthrow of Williams were light years of anything "QB like" we saw from TS today. At least on the overthrow he sat in the pocket and found the right guy. 12-19 for 147 and 4 rushes for 36 yards rushing in the time he had isnt horrible. The fumble was unfortunate but was at least an effort play.
One QB is maybe Jeramiah Maoli having an off day. The other has regressed and is Braxton Burmeister. All it takes is eyeballs.
GoDucksTroll wrote:I came into this game with a bit of confidence but mostly low expectations-
The reward was:
* 2 fumbles, although one was iffy but it still came on a player fighting for extra yards.
* 2 botched kicks: kick off and punt return.
* 2 QBs although it’s clear that Brown is a million times better.
* -5 turnover margin.
* 8 minutes of possession in the first half, and that was the good half.
* Inability to tackle consistently.
* AND THE WORST CRIME of all in punting it down two scores on 4th and 2 from the 50. WTF Cristobal? You don’t deserve to win when you do that.
Embarrassing. Just as bad as I’ve felt about Oregon football in a while. Vegas Bowl with Willie bouncing beforehand is probably the last time I had this feeling.
Are you me? I agree with everything you said.
My girlfriend also agrees with both of us, but she also added that they tried hard. Sigh.
GoDucksTroll wrote:I came into this game with a bit of confidence but mostly low expectations-
The reward was:
* 2 fumbles, although one was iffy but it still came on a player fighting for extra yards.
* 2 botched kicks: kick off and punt return.
* 2 QBs although it’s clear that Brown is a million times better.
* -5 turnover margin.
* 8 minutes of possession in the first half, and that was the good half.
* Inability to tackle consistently.
* AND THE WORST CRIME of all in punting it down two scores on 4th and 2 from the 50. WTF Cristobal? You don’t deserve to win when you do that.
Embarrassing. Just as bad as I’ve felt about Oregon football in a while. Vegas Bowl with Willie bouncing beforehand is probably the last time I had this feeling.
When the Ducks couldn’t even produce any first downs off of any 3rd downs, I get Mario’s rationale. However, this wasn’t the Natty, he really didn’t have much to lose. He did play scared. Guess you play scared when you can’t pick, and stick with a QB you have any amount of confidence in. This situation pretty much confirms the adage that if you have to play two, you don’t have one.
ducks5ever wrote:Sucks to finish on a sour note but at least our team got to get their feet wet this season. Best wishes to each and every one of you all, regardless of your views on Shough/Dye
See you all around, stay safe, and take care. I'm sure there's going to be some serious debate/controversy this off season!!
Best Wishes to you too. I feel negative right now but all these great recruiting classes have to pay off at some point. Although right now I feel down in the dumps I have a feeling there are high school kids that will soon show these Ducks what competing is all about and some jobs are going to be taken right way. Just as KT took over at DE.
GoDucksTroll wrote:I came into this game with a bit of confidence but mostly low expectations-
The reward was:
* 2 fumbles, although one was iffy but it still came on a player fighting for extra yards.
* 2 botched kicks: kick off and punt return.
* 2 QBs although it’s clear that Brown is a million times better.
* -5 turnover margin.
* 8 minutes of possession in the first half, and that was the good half.
* Inability to tackle consistently.
* AND THE WORST CRIME of all in punting it down two scores on 4th and 2 from the 50. WTF Cristobal? You don’t deserve to win when you do that.
Embarrassing. Just as bad as I’ve felt about Oregon football in a while. Vegas Bowl with Willie bouncing beforehand is probably the last time I had this feeling.
When the Ducks couldn’t even produce any first downs off of any 3rd downs, I get Mario’s rationale. However, this wasn’t the Natty, he really didn’t have much to lose. He did play scared. Guess you play scared when you can’t pick, and stick with a QB you have any amount of confidence in. This situation pretty much confirms the adage that if you have to play two, you don’t have one.
Cristobal has always coached scared. That is why my one hope is that Oregon's talent is so overwhelming that coaching doesn't matter as much (which is sort of like LSU who I brought up) Chip Kelly never had this type of talent and I sort of get why. Chip didn't like the prima donna stuff and they played like some prima donna's today!!!