Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

rockthief
Senior
Posts: 4867
Joined: Sun Nov 27, 2011 11:52 am
Location: Stand By Me

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by rockthief »

Shough has coach speak down just so.
droop10
Freshman
Posts: 1439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:07 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by droop10 »

Tray Dub wrote:
It's fine to go out on a limb and argue against the majority, but you sound really pompous when you act like everyone who disagrees is part of an irrational hivemind. I've watched Shough all year and he's inconsistent, fails to make plays, and seems to wilt when things start going wrong. We haven't seen much of Brown, and no one says he's Joey Harrington, but he's moved the ball more consistently and made some nice plays. We've seen enough from Shough to lose confidence, and Brown was exciting in limited action. Simple as that.
Sorry if it comes off pompous, and I’m sure in text it sounds worse than intended, but I do find some of the takes on here and the level of disdain for Shough to be a little irrational. I did state that I was aware that’s a part of fandom, and I’m by no means immune to it.

My profession is as an analyst, so I am trained to remove emotion and strictly look at the numbers. The irrational part for me is that all numbers suggest Shough is the better QB, and nothing Brown did today outside of a drive and a half, suddenly can erase 3 years of data that suggests otherwise. The stats showed Brown has accuracy issues and today played that out. It was a mix of a few good throws, some open misses and receivers needing to make adjustments to make plays. Does Shough make some head scratching plays? Absolutely, but he’s a young QB that’s learning with an o-line that can’t protect him consistently. We’ll see what happens. I’m skeptical after the way they handled him tonight that Shough will start again, but the QBs in the pipeline aren’t ideal fits for the offense (minus Thompson, but it’s not good to rely on a true freshman to start) and there’s no guarantee Brown wants to spend a 6th year in college.
droop10
Freshman
Posts: 1439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:07 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by droop10 »

duck023 wrote:
Nevermind I got him confused with a TE with a similar name. I was going to say everyone is talking about how young Oregon is and the only good player being a senior would have sucked. At least Oregon finally has a kicker.
Doesn’t make it any better. Stop being so dramatic with “the only good player” line. There is plenty of talent on the team to Build on. We don’t even have enough evidence to say Katleman is a good kicker. He’s done great in the few instances he’s been called upon, and I definitely hope he continues to do so, but it’s been 3-4 kicks? The expectations are so low for the kickers, that it makes what he’s done so far seem exemplary.
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by duck023 »

droop10 wrote:
duck023 wrote:
Nevermind I got him confused with a TE with a similar name. I was going to say everyone is talking about how young Oregon is and the only good player being a senior would have sucked. At least Oregon finally has a kicker.
Doesn’t make it any better. Stop being so dramatic with “the only good player” line. There is plenty of talent on the team to Build on. We don’t even have enough evidence to say Katleman is a good kicker. He’s done great in the few instances he’s been called upon, and I definitely hope he continues to do so, but it’s been 3-4 kicks? The expectations are so low for the kickers, that it makes what he’s done so far seem exemplary.
You are right. My expectations of Oregon kickers are extremely low. Don't get me wrong I'm not saying he is as good as Schneider at this point but he can at least kick from the hash marks and make it in which is more than most of the Oregon kickers of the past could do. I'm being dramatic because that was an awful performance but I do have hope that the Duck's can some how get it together by next season.
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by GoDucksTroll »

Anyone ever heard of this Rob guy?

Seriously, starting to suspect that someone here is a troll that doesn’t have the word troll in their username.
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by GoDucksTroll »

Agreed with the commenters saying Cristobal coaches scared. He does. Not even up for debate. This is the type of strategy we would mock when it was used by Big Ten and SEC teams - and guess what? Saban doesn’t even coach that way anymore. Ryan Day certainly doesn’t. Even Kirby Smart, the most conservative coach out of the playoff contenders doesn’t mind taking a risk.

The two QB system I talked about before the game as being expected - That is another sign of hedging your bets. Pick one and stick with it. Ducks had a bad drive when Brown’s pass was dropped by Jaylon Redd and we go back to Shuck. I don’t even know how Moorhead is okay with this.

Y’all remember when Slim Reaper Roper was the opening day starter and got hurt so we rolled with Masoli after Roper could play?Even though Roper was like 3-0 as a starter? That’s what a good coach does. You have potentially one more year of Anthony Brown and...

Is there anyone who thinks that Tyler Shough is better than Anthony Brown? Not calling you out, just genuinely curious. I was the guy after a few games defending Shough and saying Brown isn’t a better runner, and the coaches would be playing him if he could run the offense better. I admit I was very wrong. Anyone else feel like me?
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by Duck07 »

GoDucksTroll wrote:Anyone ever heard of this Rob guy?

Seriously, starting to suspect that someone here is a troll that doesn’t have the word troll in their username.
Are you seriously talking about Rob Moseley as a troll?
Image
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by duck023 »

GoDucksTroll wrote:Anyone ever heard of this Rob guy?

Seriously, starting to suspect that someone here is a troll that doesn’t have the word troll in their username.
Am I supposed to memorize every Duck reporter? After I read one article from Canzano I gave up on Oregon reporters.
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39368
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by greenyellow »

Duck07 wrote:
GoDucksTroll wrote:Anyone ever heard of this Rob guy?

Seriously, starting to suspect that someone here is a troll that doesn’t have the word troll in their username.
Are you seriously talking about Rob Moseley as a troll?
With how down and/or manic some posters get after losses, it's not surprising people lost their heads a bit. I've been cleaning things up reduce the frenzied, unhinged nature of some of the post-game posts.
Image
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by duck023 »

GoDucksTroll wrote:Agreed with the commenters saying Cristobal coaches scared. He does. Not even up for debate. This is the type of strategy we would mock when it was used by Big Ten and SEC teams - and guess what? Saban doesn’t even coach that way anymore. Ryan Day certainly doesn’t. Even Kirby Smart, the most conservative coach out of the playoff contenders doesn’t mind taking a risk.

The two QB system I talked about before the game as being expected - That is another sign of hedging your bets. Pick one and stick with it. Ducks had a bad drive when Brown’s pass was dropped by Jaylon Redd and we go back to Shuck. I don’t even know how Moorhead is okay with this.

Y’all remember when Slim Reaper Roper was the opening day starter and got hurt so we rolled with Masoli after Roper could play?Even though Roper was like 3-0 as a starter? That’s what a good coach does. You have potentially one more year of Anthony Brown and...

Is there anyone who thinks that Tyler Shough is better than Anthony Brown? Not calling you out, just genuinely curious. I was the guy after a few games defending Shough and saying Brown isn’t a better runner, and the coaches would be playing him if he could run the offense better. I admit I was very wrong. Anyone else feel like me?
I trust Cristobal even though I'm really upset at his performance. I just wished he would trust his offense and not rely on his defense so much.
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39368
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by greenyellow »

duck023 wrote:
GoDucksTroll wrote:Anyone ever heard of this Rob guy?

Seriously, starting to suspect that someone here is a troll that doesn’t have the word troll in their username.
Am I supposed to memorize every Duck reporter? After I read one article from Canzano I gave up on Oregon reporters.
It'd certainly help to remember a few so you don't look so uninformed.
Image
OrTDuck
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 291
Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2020 6:39 pm

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by OrTDuck »

Kickers tend to be "either/or", especially in difficult spots (not entirely unlike QBs).

A kid who can walk out and put a 40 then a 47 yarder right down the middle, coming in midseason, in a pair of big games, early in his career is a great sign. I don't know what "stats" might or might say, but if you've watched Duck football many years, it is a great sign passing the "eyeball" test. Kind of like the anti-Alejandro Maldonado.

In 1998, Nathan Villegas started his Duck career 20-22 on FGs. It can happen. Over 20 years ago, but still...
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by GoDucksTroll »

Duck07 wrote:
GoDucksTroll wrote:Anyone ever heard of this Rob guy?

Seriously, starting to suspect that someone here is a troll that doesn’t have the word troll in their username.
Are you seriously talking about Rob Moseley as a troll?
I’m talking about the guy who has no idea who Rob is. The one who is clearly here to troll, and I’m amazed hasn’t been banned yet considering his transparency.
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by duck023 »

GoDucksTroll wrote:Agreed with the commenters saying Cristobal coaches scared. He does. Not even up for debate. This is the type of strategy we would mock when it was used by Big Ten and SEC teams - and guess what? Saban doesn’t even coach that way anymore. Ryan Day certainly doesn’t. Even Kirby Smart, the most conservative coach out of the playoff contenders doesn’t mind taking a risk.

The two QB system I talked about before the game as being expected - That is another sign of hedging your bets. Pick one and stick with it. Ducks had a bad drive when Brown’s pass was dropped by Jaylon Redd and we go back to Shuck. I don’t even know how Moorhead is okay with this.

Y’all remember when Slim Reaper Roper was the opening day starter and got hurt so we rolled with Masoli after Roper could play?Even though Roper was like 3-0 as a starter? That’s what a good coach does. You have potentially one more year of Anthony Brown and...

Is there anyone who thinks that Tyler Shough is better than Anthony Brown? Not calling you out, just genuinely curious. I was the guy after a few games defending Shough and saying Brown isn’t a better runner, and the coaches would be playing him if he could run the offense better. I admit I was very wrong. Anyone else feel like me?
I trust Cristobal even though I'm really upset at his performance. I just wished he would trust his offense and not rely on his defense so much.
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by duck023 »

GoDucksTroll wrote:
Duck07 wrote:
GoDucksTroll wrote:Anyone ever heard of this Rob guy?

Seriously, starting to suspect that someone here is a troll that doesn’t have the word troll in their username.
Are you seriously talking about Rob Moseley as a troll?
I’m talking about the guy who has no idea who Rob is. The one who is clearly here to troll, and I’m amazed hasn’t been banned yet considering his transparency.
This is my tough love not trolling. Trolling is when I tell Clemson fans that IU should have had their playoff spot. I'm mad and sad at the way the Ducks played. I don't even know who to point the finger at. I like the direction Cristobal is taking this team and I like the talent. I don't even know who to be mad at but I know I'm mad.
Post Reply