Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
- greenyellow
- Moderator

- Posts: 39368
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
- Location: Eugene, OR
-
duck023
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm
Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)
I hope Cristobal and the Ducks use this season as fuel for next season. Ohio State wanted revenge on Clemson and I feel Oregon should want revenge on everyone after this season. They need to own the fact that they played pretty badly all year except for the Stanford and USC game. They need to use the fact that most people are going to count them out after a season like they just had.greenyellow wrote:
-
OrTDuck
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 291
- Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2020 6:39 pm
Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)
droop10 wrote:Tray Dub wrote:
My profession is as an analyst, so I am trained to remove emotion and strictly look at the numbers. The irrational part for me is that all numbers suggest Shough is the better QB, and nothing Brown did today outside of a drive and a half, suddenly can erase 3 years of data that suggests otherwise. The stats showed Brown has accuracy issues and today played that out. It was a mix of a few good throws, some open misses and receivers needing to make adjustments to make plays. Does Shough make some head scratching plays? Absolutely, but he’s a young QB that’s learning with an o-line that can’t protect him consistently. We’ll see what happens. I’m skeptical after the way they handled him tonight that Shough will start again, but the QBs in the pipeline aren’t ideal fits for the offense (minus Thompson, but it’s not good to rely on a true freshman to start) and there’s no guarantee Brown wants to spend a 6th year in college.
This analysis appears to depend a bit much on raw BC numbers.
First of all, his "skill" talent guys (and OL) recruiting ratings at BC were Cal, Arizona, and Oregon State level. Playing with more talent around him might not help his numbers? Second, he had two seasons ended with leg injuries. Third, completion percentage depends a lot on the types of throws an offense requires. A "pro style" offense isn't going to rely as much on short to gimmy throws like a West Coast offense, basic spread, run and shoot, or air raid offense.
I'm not watching a ton of BC but I believe they historically have been a more tradition "pro style" offense. Their team completion % historically have been:
2011 53%
2012 54%
2013 61%
2014 56%
2015 44%
2016 51%
2017 54%
2018 58%
2019 53%
So, 55% seems in line with their offense.
When Oregon ran a more traditional down field pro style offense, its QBs had career passing percentage of:
Akili Smith 57%
AJ Feeley 53%
Joey Harrington 55%
Kellen Clemens 61%
Brady Leaf 54%
Dennis Dixon 62% (before CK)
Dennis Dixon 68% (after CK)
Jeremiah Masoli 57%
Darron Thomas 61%
Marcus Mariota 67%
Vernon Adams 65%
Justin Herbert 64%
See the percentages going up as the offenses changed? Akili, Feeley, and Harrington were all inaccurate? Good enough for college and apparently ok for the NFL (as those 3 combined for 16 seasons there) for 55% passers.
Gardener Mishnew (71%), Kyler Murray (67%), Baker Mayfield (69%), Slovis (70%), Rattler (67%). Which kinds of offense here?
On video, AB doesn't show any crazy accuracy issues and probably more arm than TS. He miss occasional throws? It happens. As well, maybe a reason not to wait and throw him in for his first major non-goal line action trailing in the 2nd quarter of your NY6 bowl game. Maybe let him get some of those throws out of the way back in early November? And again, no one is expecting Marriota or Adams, or Spencer Rattler or Baker Mayfield to walk through the door, just someone who can run the thing.
AB highlights (BC):
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=QtW51BF2B5
-
Everythingsducky
- Senior
- Posts: 2818
- Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 2:40 pm
Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)
Odds on Brown even coming back next year? This is all for naught if he doesn’t. If Shough doesn’t transfer, does he want another QB competition?
-
droop10
- Freshman
- Posts: 1439
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:07 am
Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)
I appreciate you bringing data into it, and I hear you on some of the points. I do agree that the spread allows for higher completion percentage in general. I still contend that anything below 60% is still a concern regardless of offensive system (BC was a pretty run heavy offense similar to Stanford’s, so QB wasn’t relied on to do much). I think the passing game has evolved significantly from the times Harrington, etc., so it’s not fair to compare numbers in that era, but I understand what you’re getting at. I still wouldn’t point to them as rousing NFL successes (though that doesn’t need to be argued, because it doesn’t impact the Brown argument).OrTDuck wrote:droop10 wrote:Tray Dub wrote:
My profession is as an analyst, so I am trained to remove emotion and strictly look at the numbers. The irrational part for me is that all numbers suggest Shough is the better QB, and nothing Brown did today outside of a drive and a half, suddenly can erase 3 years of data that suggests otherwise. The stats showed Brown has accuracy issues and today played that out. It was a mix of a few good throws, some open misses and receivers needing to make adjustments to make plays. Does Shough make some head scratching plays? Absolutely, but he’s a young QB that’s learning with an o-line that can’t protect him consistently. We’ll see what happens. I’m skeptical after the way they handled him tonight that Shough will start again, but the QBs in the pipeline aren’t ideal fits for the offense (minus Thompson, but it’s not good to rely on a true freshman to start) and there’s no guarantee Brown wants to spend a 6th year in college.
This analysis appears to depend a bit much on raw BC numbers.
First of all, his "skill" talent guys (and OL) recruiting ratings at BC were Cal, Arizona, and Oregon State level. Playing with more talent around him might not help his numbers? Second, he had two seasons ended with leg injuries. Third, completion percentage depends a lot on the types of throws an offense requires. A "pro style" offense isn't going to rely as much on short to gimmy throws like a West Coast offense, basic spread, run and shoot, or air raid offense.
I'm not watching a ton of BC but I believe they historically have been a more tradition "pro style" offense. Their team completion % historically have been:
2011 53%
2012 54%
2013 61%
2014 56%
2015 44%
2016 51%
2017 54%
2018 58%
2019 53%
So, 55% seems in line with their offense.
When Oregon ran a more traditional down field pro style offense, its QBs had career passing percentage of:
Akili Smith 57%
AJ Feeley 53%
Joey Harrington 55%
Kellen Clemens 61%
Brady Leaf 54%
Dennis Dixon 62% (before CK)
Dennis Dixon 68% (after CK)
Jeremiah Masoli 57%
Darron Thomas 61%
Marcus Mariota 67%
Vernon Adams 65%
Justin Herbert 64%
See the percentages going up as the offenses changed? Akili, Feeley, and Harrington were all inaccurate? Good enough for college and apparently ok for the NFL (as those 3 combined for 16 seasons there) for 55% passers.
Gardener Mishnew (71%), Kyler Murray (67%), Baker Mayfield (69%), Slovis (70%), Rattler (67%). Which kinds of offense here?
On video, AB doesn't show any crazy accuracy issues and probably more arm than TS. He miss occasional throws? It happens. As well, maybe a reason not to wait and throw him in for his first major non-goal line action trailing in the 2nd quarter of your NY6 bowl game. Maybe let him get some of those throws out of the way back in early November? And again, no one is expecting Marriota or Adams, or Spencer Rattler or Baker Mayfield to walk through the door, just someone who can run the thing.
AB highlights (BC):
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=QtW51BF2B5
I’ll still remain skeptical that he’ll be better than Shough long-term, but it’s obvious that I have more belief that Shough can figure it out than anyone else here. Given a real offseason to get familiar with the offense and a more seasoned line, I think he’d figure it out, but after how they used him to end the year, I’m not sure that’ll happen here.. I think he has the higher ceiling, while Brown has the higher floor, if that makes sense.
Oh well. Pointless to continue to argue it. We’ll see what happens this offseason. Maybe we’ll get a surprise from one of the backups. I forget about Ashford at times, because I just always kind of assumed he’d have a tough climb to get ahead of Butterfield or Shough, but this offense is probably more suited to his strengths, unless Butterfield has more agility than I expect.
-
OrTDuck
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 291
- Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2020 6:39 pm
Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)
Fair enough. Another way to make the point would be if TS was at Boston College in 2019 and played all season, I'd be surprised to see him improve upon AB's 55% (meaning I don't see the number as confirming "accuracy" either way).
