B1G20 wrote:
Curious what the PAC perspective would be on something like this? Bottom line, we're entering an era here where the only thing that matters is money and TV Ratings, the SEC is making a huge power grab with this UT/OU move, there needs to be a league to counter that. I think the above would be a proper response and while the SEC would remain the dominant conference of the south, the B20 would be the the only true national conference (coast to coast).
Notre Dame is probably the biggest reach above, but I suspect if there is an NCAA breakaway coming, they might see that access to a playoff (or at least favorable seeding) might depend on being in a major league.
Ultimately what's the point? If its simply to break away from the NCAA, these moves don't need to happen.
The moves are for TV revenue, ideally there would be a breakaway and a single TV agreement bargained for the top 64-96. In that circumstance you wouldn't see any of this realignment because it wouldn't matter that much and everything could just be based on geography.
I think eventually football and maybe mens basketball break away from all other sports, IMO. So the non-revenue sports won't matter as much in the future.
B1G, I tend to agree. The Pac-12 can either stay together and screw over the top schools and bleed out slowly, or the top schools can break away to try to form an association with greater appeal. It's shitty, if I'm being honest. All of this is shitty. One that that bothers me is Maryland and Rutgers getting into this super conference while much better properties like Arizona State and Arizona don't.
Regarding non-revenue sports, we may see no conference realignment there. I think about sports like wrestling, and the Pac-12 for that sports has included Cal-Fullerton and Bakersfield along with OSU and Stanford for years. You do what you gotta do.
B1G20 wrote:
Curious what the PAC perspective would be on something like this? Bottom line, we're entering an era here where the only thing that matters is money and TV Ratings, the SEC is making a huge power grab with this UT/OU move, there needs to be a league to counter that. I think the above would be a proper response and while the SEC would remain the dominant conference of the south, the B20 would be the the only true national conference (coast to coast).
Notre Dame is probably the biggest reach above, but I suspect if there is an NCAA breakaway coming, they might see that access to a playoff (or at least favorable seeding) might depend on being in a major league.
Ultimately what's the point? If its simply to break away from the NCAA, these moves don't need to happen.
When we put these new "conferences" into practice, is it really worth sending the Penn State Volleyball team to Pullman/Seattle and vice versa? Football and Basketball may make money, but those long-distance soccer games etc aren't doing anything for the Athletic Depts.
Does anyone in the P12 have D1 Hockey or aren't they all just club teams?
Could the increased revenue from these super conferences cover the increased expenses for the non-revenue sports and some? If not, couldn’t it be a situation where just football, basketball (men’s and women’s), baseball, and softball join these super conferences while the rest stay in the old conference alignment?
The B1G fan is right, these conferences have to do something with what the SEC is doing. I, as an Oregon fan, would LOVE it if Oregon joined the B1G, tired of Oregon being in the laughingstock conference of college football. I know the new commission may improve things but it might be too late, the damage of Larry Scott has already been done.
B1G20 wrote:
Curious what the PAC perspective would be on something like this? Bottom line, we're entering an era here where the only thing that matters is money and TV Ratings, the SEC is making a huge power grab with this UT/OU move, there needs to be a league to counter that. I think the above would be a proper response and while the SEC would remain the dominant conference of the south, the B20 would be the the only true national conference (coast to coast).
Notre Dame is probably the biggest reach above, but I suspect if there is an NCAA breakaway coming, they might see that access to a playoff (or at least favorable seeding) might depend on being in a major league.
Ultimately what's the point? If its simply to break away from the NCAA, these moves don't need to happen.
When we put these new "conferences" into practice, is it really worth sending the Penn State Volleyball team to Pullman/Seattle and vice versa? Football and Basketball may make money, but those long-distance soccer games etc aren't doing anything for the Athletic Depts.
Does anyone in the P12 have D1 Hockey or aren't they all just club teams?
Could the increased revenue from these super conferences cover the increased expenses for the non-revenue sports and some? If not, couldn’t it be a situation where just football, basketball (men’s and women’s), baseball, and softball join these super conferences while the rest stay in the old conference alignment?
The B1G fan is right, these conferences have to do something with what the SEC is doing. I, as an Oregon fan, would LOVE it if Oregon joined the B1G, tired of Oregon being in the laughingstock conference of college football. I know the new commission may improve things but it might be too late, the damage of Larry Scott has already been done.
Pac12 is the laughing stock? How long has that been? B1G is hardly more prestigious outside of recency bias.
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
I'm curious what people's thoughts are on the following:
If we were in the same conference as some Big 10 teams, wouldn't that make logistics even worse than it already is? I think the Pac-12 is already highly inefficient because it covers more geography than any other conference. This means higher travel expenses and logistical arrangements for schools and fans. I used to think more about this but I thought that just the geographical distance in the Pac-12 alone already put us at a competitive disadvantage in the CFB landscape.
As far as a super conference, there are probably 3 or 4 teams that have been consistently good over the last 2 decades. Dynasties come and go. What are you going to do once a school hits a rough patch and can't get out? Are we instead going all in where we assume in this case that the winners just keep winning just because we are a member of a super conference?
B1G20 wrote:
Curious what the PAC perspective would be on something like this? Bottom line, we're entering an era here where the only thing that matters is money and TV Ratings, the SEC is making a huge power grab with this UT/OU move, there needs to be a league to counter that. I think the above would be a proper response and while the SEC would remain the dominant conference of the south, the B20 would be the the only true national conference (coast to coast).
Notre Dame is probably the biggest reach above, but I suspect if there is an NCAA breakaway coming, they might see that access to a playoff (or at least favorable seeding) might depend on being in a major league.
Ultimately what's the point? If its simply to break away from the NCAA, these moves don't need to happen.
When we put these new "conferences" into practice, is it really worth sending the Penn State Volleyball team to Pullman/Seattle and vice versa? Football and Basketball may make money, but those long-distance soccer games etc aren't doing anything for the Athletic Depts.
Does anyone in the P12 have D1 Hockey or aren't they all just club teams?
Could the increased revenue from these super conferences cover the increased expenses for the non-revenue sports and some? If not, couldn’t it be a situation where just football, basketball (men’s and women’s), baseball, and softball join these super conferences while the rest stay in the old conference alignment?
The B1G fan is right, these conferences have to do something with what the SEC is doing. I, as an Oregon fan, would LOVE it if Oregon joined the B1G, tired of Oregon being in the laughingstock conference of college football. I know the new commission may improve things but it might be too late, the damage of Larry Scott has already been done.
Pac12 is the laughing stock? How long has that been? B1G is hardly more prestigious outside of recency bias.
You can't dismiss the current state of the world by calling it recency bias. Our conference has been lagging overall for years now.
A lot is unsettled about the future of what conferences are and what TV/broadcast deals will like.
It’s good that Larry Scott has been removed. I trust the Oregon shot callers and Rob Mullens to protect Oregon’s interests.
The problem is that options are limited. Hitching the wagon to the Big Ten is the best option in my opinion with the facts known. It’s still too early to predict how the dominos will fall. I liked the conferences best before the realignment a decade ago, but things change.
Nobody has yet to even state what the purpose of all of this is for? I get that some bring up TV revenue as if that solves all the other issues surrounding this kind of change but to me all of the other challenges in creating essentially a national league is a big issue to work out just to play more football. Further, at what point do the players of these games boycott when they see the schools and coaches getting massive pay increases. If you're a bunch of starters for Alabama, wouldn't you threaten to boycott a Playoff game if you don't get paid (especially when the NFL doesn't give a darn if you quit on your team in that situation) and have to play even more games as a result of these changes? Even if you work out some kind of NIL stipend it will vastly dwarf what the coaches and schools take in, so why wouldn't some NFL owner decide to create another league which pays those players even more?
What does winning this super-league get you? A higher slot in the playoff? If an expanded Playoff is all this is ultimately about then that is where the focus should be. Does Oklahoma really want to go 8-4/6-6 playing a murder's row every week or would they prefer to go 11-1 most every single year with an easier path to the playoff?
Instead, this to me reeks of the Euro Super League idea that was thrown out 2 months ago and what some of these ADs may not realize in their zest to kill the NCAA is that they could ruin their own operating model in the process.
Duck07 wrote:Nobody has yet to even state what the purpose of all of this is for? I get that some bring up TV revenue as if that solves all the other issues surrounding this kind of change but to me all of the other challenges in creating essentially a national league is a big issue to work out just to play more football. Further, at what point do the players of these games boycott when they see the schools and coaches getting massive pay increases. If you're a bunch of starters for Alabama, wouldn't you threaten to boycott a Playoff game if you don't get paid (especially when the NFL doesn't give a darn if you quit on your team in that situation) and have to play even more games as a result of these changes? Even if you work out some kind of NIL stipend it will vastly dwarf what the coaches and schools take in, so why wouldn't some NFL owner decide to create another league which pays those players even more?
What does winning this super-league get you? A higher slot in the playoff? If an expanded Playoff is all this is ultimately about then that is where the focus should be. Does Oklahoma really want to go 8-4/6-6 playing a murder's row every week or would they prefer to go 11-1 most every single year with an easier path to the playoff?
Instead, this to me reeks of the Euro Super League idea that was thrown out 2 months ago and what some of these ADs may not realize in their zest to kill the NCAA is that they could ruin their own operating model in the process.
The purpose is to get rid of the NCAA for good. The SEC is angling to not need anyone but themselves.
Duck07 wrote:Nobody has yet to even state what the purpose of all of this is for? I get that some bring up TV revenue as if that solves all the other issues surrounding this kind of change but to me all of the other challenges in creating essentially a national league is a big issue to work out just to play more football. Further, at what point do the players of these games boycott when they see the schools and coaches getting massive pay increases. If you're a bunch of starters for Alabama, wouldn't you threaten to boycott a Playoff game if you don't get paid (especially when the NFL doesn't give a darn if you quit on your team in that situation) and have to play even more games as a result of these changes? Even if you work out some kind of NIL stipend it will vastly dwarf what the coaches and schools take in, so why wouldn't some NFL owner decide to create another league which pays those players even more?
What does winning this super-league get you? A higher slot in the playoff? If an expanded Playoff is all this is ultimately about then that is where the focus should be. Does Oklahoma really want to go 8-4/6-6 playing a murder's row every week or would they prefer to go 11-1 most every single year with an easier path to the playoff?
Instead, this to me reeks of the Euro Super League idea that was thrown out 2 months ago and what some of these ADs may not realize in their zest to kill the NCAA is that they could ruin their own operating model in the process.
The purpose is to get rid of the NCAA for good. The SEC is angling to not need anyone but themselves.
The NCAA is also an ideal middle-man for the schools too even if they don't want to recognize that. Trying to take as many toys as you can and go play by yourself might seem like fun at first until you realize what you did. In many ways the system as it currently works favors the SEC so tearing that system down is probably a dumb move. But hey, CREAM right?
Duck07 wrote:Nobody has yet to even state what the purpose of all of this is for? I get that some bring up TV revenue as if that solves all the other issues surrounding this kind of change but to me all of the other challenges in creating essentially a national league is a big issue to work out just to play more football. Further, at what point do the players of these games boycott when they see the schools and coaches getting massive pay increases. If you're a bunch of starters for Alabama, wouldn't you threaten to boycott a Playoff game if you don't get paid (especially when the NFL doesn't give a darn if you quit on your team in that situation) and have to play even more games as a result of these changes? Even if you work out some kind of NIL stipend it will vastly dwarf what the coaches and schools take in, so why wouldn't some NFL owner decide to create another league which pays those players even more?
What does winning this super-league get you? A higher slot in the playoff? If an expanded Playoff is all this is ultimately about then that is where the focus should be. Does Oklahoma really want to go 8-4/6-6 playing a murder's row every week or would they prefer to go 11-1 most every single year with an easier path to the playoff?
Instead, this to me reeks of the Euro Super League idea that was thrown out 2 months ago and what some of these ADs may not realize in their zest to kill the NCAA is that they could ruin their own operating model in the process.
The purpose is to get rid of the NCAA for good. The SEC is angling to not need anyone but themselves.
The NCAA is also an ideal middle-man for the schools too even if they don't want to recognize that. Trying to take as many toys as you can and go play by yourself might seem like fun at first until you realize what you did. In many ways the system as it currently works favors the SEC so tearing that system down is probably a dumb move. But hey, CREAM right?
I agree. The NCAA has been less than perfect, and needs overhauled, but we need a middle man as you say. But the SEC being arrogant enough to think they can do a better job, is why this is happening.
As long as there are other conferences, the SEC will not be able to break away and claim a true recognized Natty, right? So what is their intent? What am I missing?
So if the SEC gets Texas, Oklahoma, Michigan and Ohio State they will pretty much have the Natty handed to that conference (Alabama) every year. Thank you Larry Scott for your tremendous management ability in relegating the Pac-12 to outsider status. San Francisco running anything is a dumpster fire...
"To give anything less than your best, is to sacrifice the gift." - Steve Prefontaine