Continued Conference Realignment
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
- DuckzRule
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 976
- Joined: Sun Mar 22, 2020 3:30 pm
Re: Continued Conference Realignment
I bet Oklahoma and Texas literally wanted to destroy the whole NCAA in their own and it looks like they will succeed.
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: Continued Conference Realignment
At this point I think the best move for UO, is to the big. I don’t love it, but financially and for the future of the program, it seems like the only real move. I’d be we see UCLA, SC, UO and UW move. Unless the pac 12 and Big can figure out something else, like we just combine. But why would they want to carry all the schools who don’t bring much fans or money like OS, WSU, ASU, Cal.
-
wepto
- Five Star Recruit
- Posts: 1074
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 11:07 pm
Re: Continued Conference Realignment
Even the Big10 only makes sense if Ohio State and Michigan stay. If they go to the SEC, we better hope the super conference wants to expand to the west.buckmarkduck wrote:At this point I think the best move for UO, is to the big. I don’t love it, but financially and for the future of the program, it seems like the only real move. I’d be we see UCLA, SC, UO and UW move. Unless the pac 12 and Big can figure out something else, like we just combine. But why would they want to carry all the schools who don’t bring much fans or money like OS, WSU, ASU, Cal.
- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40713
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: Continued Conference Realignment
Yeah combining Big10 with Pac-12 and SEC with some of Big 12 would create two super power conferences.wepto wrote:Even the Big10 only makes sense if Ohio State and Michigan stay. If they go to the SEC, we better hope the super conference wants to expand to the west.buckmarkduck wrote:At this point I think the best move for UO, is to the big. I don’t love it, but financially and for the future of the program, it seems like the only real move. I’d be we see UCLA, SC, UO and UW move. Unless the pac 12 and Big can figure out something else, like we just combine. But why would they want to carry all the schools who don’t bring much fans or money like OS, WSU, ASU, Cal.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: Continued Conference Realignment
So what network is paying for this super conference and what does that leave for the runner up networks?
Say Fox and CBS get left out to ABC/ESPN, there's a lot of tv coverage being lost for all those schools that were left out.
Easiest solution is quit scheduling the schools from the little sisters of the poor in favor of the big leagues.
Say Fox and CBS get left out to ABC/ESPN, there's a lot of tv coverage being lost for all those schools that were left out.
Easiest solution is quit scheduling the schools from the little sisters of the poor in favor of the big leagues.

- greenyellow
- Moderator

- Posts: 39365
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
- Location: Eugene, OR
Re: Continued Conference Realignment
This whole thing wouldn't be an issue if SEC Commissioner Sankey and ESPN weren't hellbent on getting rich and controlling everything about CFB just to stick it to the NCAA. What CFB and college athletics needs right now is for every other league commissioner and school president to not be so concerned about squeezing every dollar they can out of athletics at the cost of long-term viability of collegiate sports.

-
northbeachsf
- Freshman
- Posts: 1494
- Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 12:54 pm
Re: Continued Conference Realignment
I saw that too. I think this is probably more of "you better do something now B1G to counter the SEC move" then "we are actually considering leaving"JIDuck97 wrote:And now rumors that the SEC is talking to Ohio State and Michigan.
I know the general thought process is this is all about football. But AAU status brings in 10X the amount of revenue in grants then football brings in each year. There is NO way OSU and Michigan presidents are voting to leave a conference full of AAU schools to join the SEC. Not happening.
I think it is much more likely that this is a move by OSU and Michigan to try to push the B1G to raid the top half of the PAC. I like the idea that the B1G poster presented, but there is no chance that ND makes that move, as they are tied to the ACC until 2036. Plus the B1G presidents would crawl over broken glass to get Stanford and Cal (two of the top research schools in the world) for research dollars and prestige.
If the B1G raids the Pac, they will take Oregon, Washington, Cal, Stanford, USC, and UCLA.
Just my $.02
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: Continued Conference Realignment
Northbeach, could you elaborate on the AAU~dollars relationship? I'm specifically wondering why the research status of another institution in the same sports conference would impact access to grants for a specific university? Are the dollars divvied out at a conference level, ala TV deal money?
-
northbeachsf
- Freshman
- Posts: 1494
- Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 12:54 pm
Re: Continued Conference Realignment
You are correct in that they don't share research dollars between institutions. However, the most straightforward explanation I have read is that schools within the Big Ten (or more specifically their academic arm, the CIC) work together closely towards the goal of gaining research grants / dollars in a more organized way than other conferences (Pac-12 is probably similar, but not as focused as the B1G). As a result, the individual schools within the conference benefit from this approach. If you have Stanford, Cal, UCLA, Washington, USC, and Oregon at that table, that only strengthens that position.
When you start talking about research dollars, you start talking billions instead of millions. Therefore, IMO it makes some sense that they would only consider schools with a high research standing, and AAU membership as a marker of that standing. I believe the B1G came out a couple of days ago and confirmed they will not consider schools that are not AAU members, which was not shocking.
There are possibly teams in play from the PAC that strengthen both the B1G's athletics and AAU status. Oklahoma got the cold shoulder from the B1G once already. If they are not willing to entertain Oklahoma, there is not another non-AAU team that is getting in.
On a side note, Nebraska lost their AAU membership few years ago. If I was Nebraska, I would be very concerned right now.
Again...just my opinion on this.
When you start talking about research dollars, you start talking billions instead of millions. Therefore, IMO it makes some sense that they would only consider schools with a high research standing, and AAU membership as a marker of that standing. I believe the B1G came out a couple of days ago and confirmed they will not consider schools that are not AAU members, which was not shocking.
There are possibly teams in play from the PAC that strengthen both the B1G's athletics and AAU status. Oklahoma got the cold shoulder from the B1G once already. If they are not willing to entertain Oklahoma, there is not another non-AAU team that is getting in.
On a side note, Nebraska lost their AAU membership few years ago. If I was Nebraska, I would be very concerned right now.
Again...just my opinion on this.
- Phalanx
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5289
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm
Re: Continued Conference Realignment
Iowa State, Colorado, and Utah are all AAU members. I wonder why they are not being mentioned more since they are much closer in proximity to the Big 10 schools. I know Oregon has a bigger brand, but if prowess on the gridiron is the measure, there really hasn't been that big of a disparity the last few years.
I dunno, none of this is making sense to me. The travel already puts Pac 12 teams at a disadvantage. How is doubling the distance to travel going to help? The conference clearly has problems, but I think they are more internal - like some schools need to get more serious about football. If we could just keep our own top recruits west of the Rockies, that would be a start. I think that the West is just not as into football as they are in the South and Midwest, and the TV contracts are just reflecting that.
I dunno, none of this is making sense to me. The travel already puts Pac 12 teams at a disadvantage. How is doubling the distance to travel going to help? The conference clearly has problems, but I think they are more internal - like some schools need to get more serious about football. If we could just keep our own top recruits west of the Rockies, that would be a start. I think that the West is just not as into football as they are in the South and Midwest, and the TV contracts are just reflecting that.
- lukeyrid13
- All-American
- Posts: 10475
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
- GM: Portland TrailBlazers
Re: Continued Conference Realignment
Not to mention the tradition as well.Phalanx wrote:Iowa State, Colorado, and Utah are all AAU members. I wonder why they are not being mentioned more since they are much closer in proximity to the Big 10 schools. I know Oregon has a bigger brand, but if prowess on the gridiron is the measure, there really hasn't been that big of a disparity the last few years.
I dunno, none of this is making sense to me. The travel already puts Pac 12 teams at a disadvantage. How is doubling the distance to travel going to help? The conference clearly has problems, but I think they are more internal - like some schools need to get more serious about football. If we could just keep our own top recruits west of the Rockies, that would be a start.
Going from playing: Stanford, Wazzu, OSU, USC, UW each week to....Maryland, Purdue and Rutgers in back to back weeks just doesn't sound nearly as fun or exciting.
- Phalanx
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5289
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:50 pm
Re: Continued Conference Realignment
Totally agree: this is the argument that gets missed here. We are talking about selling out the soul of the PAC - a conference whose tradition and identity stacks up as well as anyone's in the country. Why give that up, especially when we know that the recruits from this region are enough to sustain football in the West? The PAC teams need to start following the Oregon model of recruiting. Go all over the country. Steal recruits from Texas and even further South and East. Lock down Hawaii and the Pacific Islands and all of those awesome Poly players. Get better coaches who build more sustainable programs.lukeyrid13 wrote:
Not to mention the tradition as well.
Going from playing: Stanford, Wazzu, OSU, USC, UW each week to....Maryland, Purdue and Rutgers in back to back weeks just doesn't sound nearly as fun or exciting.
I think we should be looking to poach teams from other conferences right now, rather than a few teams at the top getting all excited that some conference in the east wants them and being willing to sell out and abandon the rest of the traditional rivals. Hopefully the vanity wears off and schools start thinking more long term. Use the wooing from the Big 10 as leverage within the conference against teams less serious about football if you want to, but don't sell out the soul and tradition of a proud conference. These 8 schools on the West Coast have been together all these decades for a reason.
Sorry if I sounded a little too Bill Walton-esque there.
- OregonFan4Life
- All-American
- Posts: 15429
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm
Re: Continued Conference Realignment
I’m regards to traveling, if 4-6 teams from the PAC-12 including Oregon join, then they’ll all be in the same division and most of Oregon’s conference games will be the same distance as before anyways.
In an ideal world, the Big Ten adds the 4 CA schools and Oregon and Washington, SEC finds another 4 teams, then each team has 20 teams total with 8 conference games, an agreement between the conferences that each team will have a non conference games against each other (round robin style, all 20 SEC teams vs all 20 Big Ten teams), and Oregon has an annual end of season non-conference game against the Beavs. 2 other non-conference games can be random including a warm up game against an FCS team. That’s not asking too much is it?
In an ideal world, the Big Ten adds the 4 CA schools and Oregon and Washington, SEC finds another 4 teams, then each team has 20 teams total with 8 conference games, an agreement between the conferences that each team will have a non conference games against each other (round robin style, all 20 SEC teams vs all 20 Big Ten teams), and Oregon has an annual end of season non-conference game against the Beavs. 2 other non-conference games can be random including a warm up game against an FCS team. That’s not asking too much is it?

-
northbeachsf
- Freshman
- Posts: 1494
- Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 12:54 pm
Re: Continued Conference Realignment
Good discussion!! I think Iowa State, Kansas, and Colorado give you AAU status, but not national branding in athletics. Why settle for 1/2 of the pie, when you can have the whole thing? I did a little research and I think you can make the argument for Utah. If you are between Colorado and Cal, you take Cal based on potential and the fact that it is a Top 5 research school in the world. Plus it would make the other CA schools happy.Phalanx wrote:Iowa State, Colorado, and Utah are all AAU members. I wonder why they are not being mentioned more since they are much closer in proximity to the Big 10 schools. I know Oregon has a bigger brand, but if prowess on the gridiron is the measure, there really hasn't been that big of a disparity the last few years.
Here are the TV viewer ratings by school. I was surprised to see how far ahead Oregon is over USC:
Oregon - 47.7M
USC - 23.6M
Utah - 21.9M
Washington - 19.8M
Arizona State - 14.9M
Washington State - 12.4M
UCLA - 11.8M
Stanford - 11.75M
Colorado - 10.1M
Arizona - 7.7M
Cal - 7.3M
Oregon State - 1.9M
-
northbeachsf
- Freshman
- Posts: 1494
- Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 12:54 pm
Re: Continued Conference Realignment
I think this is the main issue with Texas and Oklahoma going to the SEC. The Pac-12 is already losing West Coast kids to the SEC and B1G. In addition, I think we can all agree that Texas and Oklahoma joining the SEC is likely going to have a negative impact on West Coast schools recruiting in the state of Texas. Everything snowballs from there....TV contract money, NIL deals, etc.Phalanx wrote: If we could just keep our own top recruits west of the Rockies, that would be a start. I think that the West is just not as into football as they are in the South and Midwest, and the TV contracts are just reflecting that.
Adding those two schools to the SEC is just going to increase the narrative by ESPN and the media that the SEC is "big time" and everyone else is garbage. It makes me sick. I can see it now....In five years , Paul Finebaum is probably going to be arguing on ESPN that a five loss South Carolina team should be in the payoff over a 1-loss Pac-12 team because they had play Alabama, LSU, Texas, Oklahoma, etc.
I don't want to see the Pac-12 fall apart, but sitting back and doing nothing right now is probably not the right answer.