Last time I checked, it was 2021. I wouldn't put much weight on the teams that Chip had up until this past year, he's been rebuilding the disaster that he inherited.
jBeavertonduck wrote:
Last time I checked, it was 2021. I wouldn't put much weight on the teams that Chip had up until this past year, he's been rebuilding the disaster that he inherited.
People keep repeating that Mora left him a disaster but that just isn't the case. The recruiting classes were trending up and Top 25 consistently. I posted their cumulative Win records for their 4 years. It's absurd to think that Chip inherited a disaster. It was a decent program needing to take the next step for an AD that had no patience/
I think we're talking semantics re: the state of UCLA football when Chip took over. It may not be fair to blame the exodus of players on Jim Mora... maybe the players left after him, not *because* of him. That's fair.
That said, UCLA had just 57 scholarship players during Chip's first season. Might as well just toss those results out the window because that's a dumpster fire no matter who is in charge. Second season, he had 70 scholarship players -- which is better, but still a massive uphill battle. Then came 2020 -- still not a full roster -- but, again, that year didn't really count for anyone.
Then, last season -- first time with a full 85 scholarship players -- Chip wins eight games.
I think the best argument against Chip so far is his UCLA record against winning teams. However, for the reasons stated above, the only real apples-to-apples comparison worth making is this last season in which 0-4 was 6 pts away from 2-2.
Jim Mora may not have ignited the dumpster fire, but the UCLA football program was a dumpster fire when Chip took over. Not only did he not have momentum, but the program was suddenly in freefall, and the recruiting successes of the previous few years were completely neutralized. Chip would have the opportunity to take over here and salvage the roster and recruiting class and go into next year with the momentum of a playoff contender -- a far different situation than his start at UCLA.
pezsez1 wrote:I think we're talking semantics re: the state of UCLA football when Chip took over. It may not be fair to blame the exodus of players on Jim Mora... maybe the players left after him, not *because* of him. That's fair.
That said, UCLA had just 57 scholarship players during Chip's first season. Might as well just toss those results out the window because that's a dumpster fire no matter who is in charge. Second season, he had 70 scholarship players -- which is better, but still a massive uphill battle. Then came 2020 -- still not a full roster -- but, again, that year didn't really count for anyone.
Then, last season -- first time with a full 85 scholarship players -- Chip wins eight games.
I think the best argument against Chip so far is his UCLA record against winning teams. However, for the reasons stated above, the only real apples-to-apples comparison worth making is this last season in which 0-4 was 6 pts away from 2-2.
Jim Mora may not have ignited the dumpster fire, but the UCLA football program was a dumpster fire when Chip took over. Not only did he not have momentum, but the program was suddenly in freefall, and the recruiting successes of the previous few years were completely neutralized. Chip would have the opportunity to take over here and salvage the roster and recruiting class and go into next year with the momentum of a playoff contender -- a far different situation than his start at UCLA.
If I remember correctly there was a mass exodus when Chip was announced. Chip's image was considerable tarnished by the time he got to LA. The argument that we can't judge his first few years when it is apparent that he and his staff did not do enough to stop the bleeding does not give me confidence.
I feel like something changed after Chip was fired from Philly, like he suddenly lost the fire he had in him at Oregon and Philly. I feel like whenever I see him on the sidelines at UCLA he just doesn’t seem to be the same Chip, same when he was at San Fran. Maybe he’s just older now but remember Chip jumping on the sidelines and pointing at a loose ball? Just feel like I don’t see that anymore. Maybe Oregon could bring that fire back but I doubt it.
Here is a good read on "The Chip Kelly Purge" and why it happened. From reading this -- which has some good player interviews -- it looks like the problem is a combination of Chip's hardass coaching style combined with the transfer portal. If players can bail and have it easier playing for another school, then why not do it?
This is definitely concerning and it's something Chip would need to address in the interview. His style of play really commands excellence, but he also needs depth and he can't be effective if players are jumping ship for gentler pastures.
Oregon is hiring both Chip Kelly and Justin Wilcox. One for offense and one for defense, a dual head coach system where Kelly will have seniority on in game coaching decisions IE clock management, downs, etc. A third coach will be in charge of special teams and recruiting. The hold up is that Chip Kelly is insisting that be Jerry Azzinaro.
The positions will be endowed, similar to the way that Stanford’s head coach is the Bradford M. Freeman Director of Football and their defensive coordinator is the Willie Shaw Director of Defense. Charles Kelly becomes the first Philip Hampson Knight Administrator of Offense, and Justin Draper Wilcox will be the Patrick N. Kilkenny Chairman of Defense.
GoDucksTroll wrote:Oregon is hiring both Chip Kelly and Justin Wilcox. One for offense and one for defense, a dual head coach system where Kelly will have seniority on in game coaching decisions IE clock management, downs, etc. A third coach will be in charge of special teams and recruiting. The hold up is that Chip Kelly is insisting that be Jerry Azzinaro.
The positions will be endowed, similar to the way that Stanford’s head coach is the Bradford M. Freeman Director of Football and their defensive coordinator is the Willie Shaw Director of Defense. Charles Kelly becomes the first Philip Hampson Knight Administrator of Offense, and Justin Draper Wilcox will be the Patrick N. Kilkenny Chairman of Defense.
This reminds me of The Office when both Jim and Michael were co-managers.
'Twas the night before signing day, when all thro' the house,
Not a coach was stirring, not even a mouse;
The phat contracts were hung by the chimney with care,
In hopes that a Meyer soon would be there;
The fans were nestled all snug in their beds,
While visions of nattys danc'd in their heads,
A quick run through of all the major news sites..........crickets. No updates yet guys
woundedknees wrote:Chip has been fiercely loyal to some former Oregon assistants some of us would prefer not to see on the Duck sideline again.
If he is the choice, I'm hoping for a fresh, aggressive, proven staff.
He likes to surround himself with people he's comfortable with. He did the same thing when he went to Philly. He took some of the staff and also brought in some of players (Barner, Huff, etc).
I wouldn't be opposed to him having a few familiar faces come with him, but he also needs to focus on the best coaches and recruiters available in order to help him thrive.
Defense and recruiting MUST be addressed - period.
If we just want a good offensive minded guy then let the new HC bring in a great OC, not hire the head coach because he's great with Xs and Os. That doesn't make sense to me. The entire program must be in capable hands at each position.