X's and O's vs Recruiting
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
-
karlhungis
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7990
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:08 am
Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting
New guys learning a new system from a new coaching staff. There will be growing pains. The only coaching that I question is the O Line. The penalties seem so excessive, even when you take into account the new system.
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
- Phenom
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 9914
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:49 am
Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting
People have had the perception that our coaches were great recruiters but not x and o's guys since the beginning for some reason. The struggles last game just confirm their (false) perceptions.
Last edited by Phenom on Mon Oct 09, 2017 7:06 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- OregonFan4Life
- All-American
- Posts: 15435
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm
Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting
I’m no genius or even close to that, but even I could see all game long that WSU was loading the box to stop the run, and running an IZR with only 5 lineman puts the team at a numbers disadvantage. Not sure if like a previous poster said, this year the coaches are pushing a scheme into them or if they just lack creativity. I know you can’t blame Willie for injuries and that was devastating, but when the whole world knows you’re gonna run, running 5 on 7 won’t work very often.Phenom wrote:People have had the perception that our coaches were great recruiters but not x and o's guys since the beginning for some reason. The struggles last game just confirm what their (false) perceptions.

-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting
USC with far faster and better backs tried to go to the edges vs WSU, and they ended up with 45 more yards of offense. Maybe it's not our coaching, maybe it's that WSU has a great D?OregonFan4Life wrote:I’m no genius or even close to that, but even I could see all game long that WSU was loading the box to stop the run, and running an IZR with only 5 lineman puts the team at a numbers disadvantage. Not sure if like a previous poster said, this year the coaches are pushing a scheme into them or if they just lack creativity. I know you can’t blame Willie for injuries and that was devastating, but when the whole world knows you’re gonna run, running 5 on 7 won’t work very often.Phenom wrote:People have had the perception that our coaches were great recruiters but not x and o's guys since the beginning for some reason. The struggles last game just confirm what their (false) perceptions.
-
Handsome Dan
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 688
- Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 3:04 am
Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting
Wasn't USC missing three starting linemen? Also saying their backs are far faster and better seems like a little bit of an exaggeration.buckmarkduck wrote:USC with far faster and better backs tried to go to the edges vs WSU, and they ended up with 45 more yards of offense. Maybe it's not our coaching, maybe it's that WSU has a great D?OregonFan4Life wrote:I’m no genius or even close to that, but even I could see all game long that WSU was loading the box to stop the run, and running an IZR with only 5 lineman puts the team at a numbers disadvantage. Not sure if like a previous poster said, this year the coaches are pushing a scheme into them or if they just lack creativity. I know you can’t blame Willie for injuries and that was devastating, but when the whole world knows you’re gonna run, running 5 on 7 won’t work very often.Phenom wrote:People have had the perception that our coaches were great recruiters but not x and o's guys since the beginning for some reason. The struggles last game just confirm what their (false) perceptions.
- OregonFan4Life
- All-American
- Posts: 15435
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm
Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting
I’m not saying WSU doesn’t have a great D, I was very impressed by them and they simply are the better team, even if Herbert plays. However, no mattter who you are playing, running up the middle against a stacked box keying on the run with 5 lineman will never give you a numbers advantage. I’m just simply curious as to why the coaches are doing that. Not claiming to know more than them, but have noticed that and wondered why.buckmarkduck wrote:USC with far faster and better backs tried to go to the edges vs WSU, and they ended up with 45 more yards of offense. Maybe it's not our coaching, maybe it's that WSU has a great D?OregonFan4Life wrote:I’m no genius or even close to that, but even I could see all game long that WSU was loading the box to stop the run, and running an IZR with only 5 lineman puts the team at a numbers disadvantage. Not sure if like a previous poster said, this year the coaches are pushing a scheme into them or if they just lack creativity. I know you can’t blame Willie for injuries and that was devastating, but when the whole world knows you’re gonna run, running 5 on 7 won’t work very often.Phenom wrote:People have had the perception that our coaches were great recruiters but not x and o's guys since the beginning for some reason. The struggles last game just confirm what their (false) perceptions.

-
Handsome Dan
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 688
- Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 3:04 am
Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting
I don't think WSU would have won a fairly officiated game with Herbert playing, personally.OregonFan4Life wrote:I’m not saying WSU doesn’t have a great D, I was very impressed by them and they simply are the better team, even if Herbert plays. However, no mattter who you are playing, running up the middle against a stacked box keying on the run with 5 lineman will never give you a numbers advantage. I’m just simply curious as to why the coaches are doing that. Not claiming to know more than them, but have noticed that and wondered why.buckmarkduck wrote:USC with far faster and better backs tried to go to the edges vs WSU, and they ended up with 45 more yards of offense. Maybe it's not our coaching, maybe it's that WSU has a great D?OregonFan4Life wrote:I’m no genius or even close to that, but even I could see all game long that WSU was loading the box to stop the run, and running an IZR with only 5 lineman puts the team at a numbers disadvantage. Not sure if like a previous poster said, this year the coaches are pushing a scheme into them or if they just lack creativity. I know you can’t blame Willie for injuries and that was devastating, but when the whole world knows you’re gonna run, running 5 on 7 won’t work very often.Phenom wrote:People have had the perception that our coaches were great recruiters but not x and o's guys since the beginning for some reason. The struggles last game just confirm what their (false) perceptions.
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting
Carr would have at worst been our #2 back if we could have flipped him, and yes he's a 4.3s guy. Anyways WSU D is small and fast, so running right at them isn't necessarily the worst idea. And honestly Braxton had 3-4 times that he should have ran it, and he would have had 10-15 yds each time, one being the 4-1 that he gave to Royce. BB just didn't do a good job reading the D.OregonFan4Life wrote:I’m not saying WSU doesn’t have a great D, I was very impressed by them and they simply are the better team, even if Herbert plays. However, no mattter who you are playing, running up the middle against a stacked box keying on the run with 5 lineman will never give you a numbers advantage. I’m just simply curious as to why the coaches are doing that. Not claiming to know more than them, but have noticed that and wondered why.buckmarkduck wrote:USC with far faster and better backs tried to go to the edges vs WSU, and they ended up with 45 more yards of offense. Maybe it's not our coaching, maybe it's that WSU has a great D?OregonFan4Life wrote:I’m no genius or even close to that, but even I could see all game long that WSU was loading the box to stop the run, and running an IZR with only 5 lineman puts the team at a numbers disadvantage. Not sure if like a previous poster said, this year the coaches are pushing a scheme into them or if they just lack creativity. I know you can’t blame Willie for injuries and that was devastating, but when the whole world knows you’re gonna run, running 5 on 7 won’t work very often.Phenom wrote:People have had the perception that our coaches were great recruiters but not x and o's guys since the beginning for some reason. The struggles last game just confirm what their (false) perceptions.
-
Handsome Dan
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 688
- Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 3:04 am
Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting
Do you think Herbert correctly makes those reads?buckmarkduck wrote:Carr would have at worst been our #2 back if we could have flipped him, and yes he's a 4.3s guy. Anyways WSU D is small and fast, so running right at them isn't necessarily the worst idea. And honestly Braxton had 3-4 times that he should have ran it, and he would have had 10-15 yds each time, one being the 4-1 that he gave to Royce. BB just didn't do a good job reading the D.OregonFan4Life wrote:I’m not saying WSU doesn’t have a great D, I was very impressed by them and they simply are the better team, even if Herbert plays. However, no mattter who you are playing, running up the middle against a stacked box keying on the run with 5 lineman will never give you a numbers advantage. I’m just simply curious as to why the coaches are doing that. Not claiming to know more than them, but have noticed that and wondered why.buckmarkduck wrote:USC with far faster and better backs tried to go to the edges vs WSU, and they ended up with 45 more yards of offense. Maybe it's not our coaching, maybe it's that WSU has a great D?OregonFan4Life wrote:I’m no genius or even close to that, but even I could see all game long that WSU was loading the box to stop the run, and running an IZR with only 5 lineman puts the team at a numbers disadvantage. Not sure if like a previous poster said, this year the coaches are pushing a scheme into them or if they just lack creativity. I know you can’t blame Willie for injuries and that was devastating, but when the whole world knows you’re gonna run, running 5 on 7 won’t work very often.Phenom wrote:People have had the perception that our coaches were great recruiters but not x and o's guys since the beginning for some reason. The struggles last game just confirm what their (false) perceptions.
-
Duckattack7
- Five Star Recruit
- Posts: 1106
- Joined: Sun Jan 17, 2010 9:09 pm
- Location: Lake Oswego
Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting
I don't think you can always compare the 2 because the guys we usually label "Offensive Gurus" typically have the best classes or top 5 every year (Urban Myer, Dabo etc.) who's to say either of those guys could have had that much of a better game plan? If your players are just flat out better then everyone else's you will probably flat out be better then most. This isn't the NFL where everyone is pretty even for the most part obviously teams are better then others but....
Return Of the Quack!
-
Groundswell
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 753
- Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm
Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting
I'm going with growing pains as the main reasons the offense struggles at times. But here's a few things I find weird:
1. The jett sweep has not been run properly, nor has it been very effective, all year. The timing is a bit off. This becomes most evident on the "fake" motion play-action jett sweeps that are supposed to fool the defense into thinking sweep. The timing just isn't working. The defense isn't fooled, and you can tell it's not an actual sweep pretty easily and quickly. That is a time and rep and familiarity thing. Motion isn't really working period.
2. We have a hard time running a clean screen play. I'm talking the more traditional running back screen. We've had a couple work, but most of the time we can't even pull it off. Sure, the defense can sniff that play out and snuff it plenty. But we can't even seem to execute the play with any kind of consistency. And I'm not even going to start in on the WR bubble screens because that's just poor blocking.
3. We have no short pass game towards the middle of the field almost at all. I don't know why or what it means. I just know that this many games into the season I can't think of another team where I've seen almost nothing like this. Herbert or not.
4. Neither quarterback has run the ZR well. Herbert has actually been pretty bad at recognizing when he should run and some of the exchanges have been awkward at best.
5. Willie said "lethal simplicity" but I didn't expect "simplicity" to be this simple. We really haven't been running many different plays, especially with Herbert in there. Taggart may be too in love with Royce for the coach's own good. But I can understand that.
Now we've had some offensive success, but we've also been a bit Jeckyl and Hyde. That should all smooth out as coaches and players become more comfortable. I keep telling myself that the coaches are determined to impose their will in the run game, and believe that we can't win a championship without being able to do that. I also tell myself they believe we can't win big games unless Herbert can make the right reads and finesse the ball over the top. Basically, they are going to hammer this stuff until we can do it right. Run the ball straight ahead and throw over the top is so fundamental to what they want to do that they'e going all in. This year is a gift year for them, in many ways. Maybe they just want that foundation entrenched.
But that's just the story I tell myself. I really don't care what these coaches do this year, for the most part, but if "lethal simplicity" is costing us games next year, I'm going to start worrying.
1. The jett sweep has not been run properly, nor has it been very effective, all year. The timing is a bit off. This becomes most evident on the "fake" motion play-action jett sweeps that are supposed to fool the defense into thinking sweep. The timing just isn't working. The defense isn't fooled, and you can tell it's not an actual sweep pretty easily and quickly. That is a time and rep and familiarity thing. Motion isn't really working period.
2. We have a hard time running a clean screen play. I'm talking the more traditional running back screen. We've had a couple work, but most of the time we can't even pull it off. Sure, the defense can sniff that play out and snuff it plenty. But we can't even seem to execute the play with any kind of consistency. And I'm not even going to start in on the WR bubble screens because that's just poor blocking.
3. We have no short pass game towards the middle of the field almost at all. I don't know why or what it means. I just know that this many games into the season I can't think of another team where I've seen almost nothing like this. Herbert or not.
4. Neither quarterback has run the ZR well. Herbert has actually been pretty bad at recognizing when he should run and some of the exchanges have been awkward at best.
5. Willie said "lethal simplicity" but I didn't expect "simplicity" to be this simple. We really haven't been running many different plays, especially with Herbert in there. Taggart may be too in love with Royce for the coach's own good. But I can understand that.
Now we've had some offensive success, but we've also been a bit Jeckyl and Hyde. That should all smooth out as coaches and players become more comfortable. I keep telling myself that the coaches are determined to impose their will in the run game, and believe that we can't win a championship without being able to do that. I also tell myself they believe we can't win big games unless Herbert can make the right reads and finesse the ball over the top. Basically, they are going to hammer this stuff until we can do it right. Run the ball straight ahead and throw over the top is so fundamental to what they want to do that they'e going all in. This year is a gift year for them, in many ways. Maybe they just want that foundation entrenched.
But that's just the story I tell myself. I really don't care what these coaches do this year, for the most part, but if "lethal simplicity" is costing us games next year, I'm going to start worrying.
Last edited by Groundswell on Tue Oct 10, 2017 5:42 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
GoDucksIn09
- Senior
- Posts: 3086
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am
Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting
It has been mentioned a few times in this thread and I mentioned it in the Stanford thread, that if just going to run the ball straight up the middle when is 8 or 9 in the box it does not matter much who you are playing, the success rate will be very small. The whole stadium, people watching the game knew Oregon would run and opposing teams are going to stack the box until show can beat them with the pass. It is on the coaches to recognize what everyone already knows. You put your players in a place to make a play and succeed. Running straight up the middle when is 8 or 9 in box is not setting team up to succeed. I get the injury part. Injuries are part of football. If a team is going to keep doing what has failed to work so far then better expect to lose a lot of games. Coaches make adjustments at halftime. So far not seeing any adjustments at half.
-
lawduck
- Two Star Recruit
- Posts: 167
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:15 pm
Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting
Either of those things individually would have given us a chance. I can’t remember such a one-sided game from the officials. It was almost comical.Handsome Dan wrote:I don't think WSU would have won a fairly officiated game with Herbert playing, personally.OregonFan4Life wrote:I’m not saying WSU doesn’t have a great D, I was very impressed by them and they simply are the better team, even if Herbert plays. However, no mattter who you are playing, running up the middle against a stacked box keying on the run with 5 lineman will never give you a numbers advantage. I’m just simply curious as to why the coaches are doing that. Not claiming to know more than them, but have noticed that and wondered why.buckmarkduck wrote:USC with far faster and better backs tried to go to the edges vs WSU, and they ended up with 45 more yards of offense. Maybe it's not our coaching, maybe it's that WSU has a great D?OregonFan4Life wrote:I’m no genius or even close to that, but even I could see all game long that WSU was loading the box to stop the run, and running an IZR with only 5 lineman puts the team at a numbers disadvantage. Not sure if like a previous poster said, this year the coaches are pushing a scheme into them or if they just lack creativity. I know you can’t blame Willie for injuries and that was devastating, but when the whole world knows you’re gonna run, running 5 on 7 won’t work very often.Phenom wrote:People have had the perception that our coaches were great recruiters but not x and o's guys since the beginning for some reason. The struggles last game just confirm what their (false) perceptions.
-
jimmy12
- Senior
- Posts: 2823
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:38 am
Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting
The biggest concern for me is the regression of the O-line. They have played well in spurts but then awful in others.
- UofDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 3970
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:51 pm
Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting
Regression? They were not great last year either.jimmy12 wrote:The biggest concern for me is the regression of the O-line. They have played well in spurts but then awful in others.