X's and O's vs Recruiting

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

User avatar
DuckMastaFunk
Five Star Recruit
Posts: 1044
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:07 pm

X's and O's vs Recruiting

Post by DuckMastaFunk »

So far, it appears that our coaches are possibly the best recruiters in the nation (likely top 5, definitely top 10).

However, it seems that they are not X's and O's prodigies with the exception of Leavitt.

I know I am making assumptions based on a small sample size and minuscule operating knowledge, but luckily the bar is pretty low to get a message board log-in and start spouting opinions.

Assuming the pattern continues, would you be satisfied? We all loved how Chip out-schemed nearly everybody, but if the recruiting continues to be top-notch, I believe we can impose our will on better schemes and coaching.
Duck4Ever
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 217
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2017 2:44 pm

Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting

Post by Duck4Ever »

I've seen a few of USF games last season. Didn't seem like they had any trouble with play calling. Like I said in another thread, this team doesn't seem to know how to execute/run certain plays like the jet sweep. Whenever they run it, always minimal gains. USF has had pretty good success with that play along this year and the last.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting

Post by Duck07 »

Fortunately because Willie is a great recruiter and the Head Coach, he can surround himself with a "nerd" like I suggested in another thread.

Using his time at USF or WKU is apples and oranges because we're not competing against that level of talent to be able to win like that. While it is a new system for everyone, I'm willing to wait this year and see how the response is. Chip was a notorious student of the game constantly inviting coaches to practice and going to other places when he could. If Willie can act like a sponge in that regard, hell, just go make Chip the OC already and let him and Leavitt get into a Beer vs. Pepsi debate when they're aren't out scheming their opponents.
Image
Duck4Ever
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 217
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2017 2:44 pm

Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting

Post by Duck4Ever »

Duck07 wrote:Fortunately because Willie is a great recruiter and the Head Coach, he can surround himself with a "nerd" like I suggested in another thread.

Using his time at USF or WKU is apples and oranges because we're not competing against that level of talent to be able to win like that. While it is a new system for everyone, I'm willing to wait this year and see how the response is. Chip was a notorious student of the game constantly inviting coaches to practice and going to other places when he could. If Willie can act like a sponge in that regard, hell, just go make Chip the OC already and let him and Leavitt get into a Beer vs. Pepsi debate when they're aren't out scheming their opponents.
Haha drunk maybe? Have Pepsi instead. They can't run plays like the jet sweep correctly, what does the level of talent or conference have to do with it? Chip as OC has to be a joke, that would never happen.
User avatar
Phenom
All Pac-12
Posts: 9914
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:49 am

Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting

Post by Phenom »

Pretty sure we had the top O in the country not too long ago...
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting

Post by Duck07 »

Duck4Ever wrote:Haha drunk maybe? Have Pepsi instead. They can't run plays like the jet sweep correctly, what does the level of talent or conference have to do with it? Chip as OC has to be a joke, that would never happen.
The backups are struggling to run some of those plays, I recall Herbert and Nelson doing it just fine early in the season. For example, BB was said to have been too quiet with his cadence, which would certainly throw off a jet sweep.

Chip is going to coach football again, that he would only entertain offers of a HC position is foolish. The bigger question is whether his ego could fit in with everyone else.
Image
5$
Freshman
Posts: 1265
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:55 pm
Location: Eugene

Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting

Post by 5$ »

Hire Chip as the Practices Coach
Handsome Dan
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 688
Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 3:04 am

Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting

Post by Handsome Dan »

I don't think the egos would mesh properly, especially with Chip returning to a place where he used to be the heads coach, but on paper it looks like a great fit for him because he would have someone who is clearly very good at recruiting (and thus by extension gladhanding boosters) to the extent he probably wouldn't have to do much of it. We can all dream, I suppose.
User avatar
Phenom
All Pac-12
Posts: 9914
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:49 am

Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting

Post by Phenom »

Chip as an OC...almost as probably as Chip as OSU's HC...
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting

Post by buckmarkduck »

Phenom wrote:Pretty sure we had the top O in the country not too long ago...
We did, and there was warts while doing it. Namely our run blocking, which reared its ugly head again vs WSU. The interior of our OL hasn't been great all year. The biggest offenders I've noticed have been Pisarchick (sp) and Hanson, although I've wondered if Hanson hasn't been as good due to Jake being below average next to him.
Jesseisabeast
One Star Recruit
Posts: 97
Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 11:27 pm

Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting

Post by Jesseisabeast »

Last year Bama and others hired 'consultants' to help strategize behind the scenes....how crazy is it for someone to pay Chip or any other guru to help break down what they see?
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting

Post by buckmarkduck »

Jesseisabeast wrote:Last year Bama and others hired 'consultants' to help strategize behind the scenes....how crazy is it for someone to pay Chip or any other guru to help break down what they see?
Tedford was the one who turned UW O around. They were ready to fire Smith before Tedford came on board.

That said no O can look good without blocking and a QB.
User avatar
AutzenMember
Five Star Recruit
Posts: 1097
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:47 pm
Location: Hockinson, WA

Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting

Post by AutzenMember »

Execution almost always makes the play calling look good, and likewise, poor execution makes the play calling look bad. With today's offense, there are reads that a QB can act upon, or even check down to a different play based on what he sees. With a true freshman making these reads/calls, its understandable that there will be a lack of execution under these circumstances.

For example, on a zone read, the QB can either hand off, keep it, or throw it based on defensive alignments. He may see a mismatch on his pre-snap read and decide on a course of action, but then WSU shifts the entire defensive line which changes where the pressure is coming from and the pre-snap read is now headed straight into the teeth of the defensive alignment. He needed to check into a different play, or know that he is now going to a different option. Since WSU did this virtually every play, it falls on coaches to have a check-down system in place. However, with a true freshman at QB and only a week to prepare him, it's a tall order to make the necessary adjustments and also expect perfect execution.

BB needed to make better reads also. I will look at the positive side of things and feel good about a young future star getting good reps and good experience against a quality opponent. I'm not sure there was anything anyone could do to overcome all the obstacles facing the Ducks this past week. Play calling, or an understanding of X's and O's is not to blame...a lack of experience, health and talent is much more prevalent. At least the defense played well enough to keep them in it for a while...that is a true bright spot for this team!
User avatar
CanadianQuackers
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 143
Joined: Wed Jan 11, 2017 7:07 am

Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting

Post by CanadianQuackers »

The injuries hurt, there's no doubt about that but that is what happens in football (and any sport). First off, how can you compare something tangible with something that technically doesn't exist. Regardless of who the Ducks coaching staff gets on the recruiting trail you can't really comment on the success of it for two reasons:

1) The players won't play until next year. So you're comparing something that's in the early stages vs something that's already occurring. Recruiting is happening but unlike games there are no "legitimate" results until kids sign. Of course it's going to be easy to critique the play calling/on field production.

2) Are you implying you can measure recruiting success vs play calling? I would say it is possible but you'd have to wait until the entire roster is Taggart's team. Not because it will show that recruiting is more or less important but that any success or lack of success can be directory attributed to recruiting.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
User avatar
CanadianQuackers
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 143
Joined: Wed Jan 11, 2017 7:07 am

Re: X's and O's vs Recruiting

Post by CanadianQuackers »

buckmarkduck wrote:
Phenom wrote:Pretty sure we had the top O in the country not too long ago...
We did, and there was warts while doing it. Namely our run blocking, which reared its ugly head again vs WSU. The interior of our OL hasn't been great all year. The biggest offenders I've noticed have been Pisarchick (sp) and Hanson, although I've wondered if Hanson hasn't been as good due to Jake being below average next to him.
I agree, the run blocking has been atrocious. There's no doubt the concept switch has had an effect. Zone vs Man can be quite a huge change if you've only played with one, especially as a young player.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Post Reply